clearn.png
Friday November 26th, 2021 6:30PM

EXPLAINER: What instructions did jury get in Arbery death?

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

ATLANTA (AP) — Before jurors in the trial of the three men charged in the killing of Ahmaud Arbery retired to the jury room to begin their deliberations, the judge read them specific instructions on the law that's applicable to this case.

The jury instructions, also called the jury charge, were carefully put together with input from the lawyers for the defense and prosecution, each side trying to make sure instructions on the parts of the law that support its case were included. The disproportionately white jury began deliberating Tuesday after hearing 10 days of testimony.

After seeing Arbery running in their neighborhood near the Georgia port city of Brunswick in February 2020, father and son Greg and Travis McMichael armed themselves, jumped in a pickup truck and pursued the 25-year-old Black man. A neighbor, William “Roddie” Bryan, joined the pursuit and recorded video on his cellphone video, capturing the moments when Travis McMichael shot Arbery with a shotgun. All three defendants are white.

WHERE DO THE JURY INSTRUCTIONS COME FROM?

Georgia court rules provide instructions that address most situations and serve as a template that the lawyers and judge work from to create a set of jury instructions tailored to a particular case.

The lawyers on each side are expected to have their proposed jury instructions ready on the first day of trial, and then they come together with the judge after trial testimony is done to determine the exact wording of the instructions in the case.

“It’s the most important part of the trial,” said Andrew Fleischman, an appellate lawyer in Atlanta who's not involved in this case. “Lawyers don’t give it enough attention, and the public doesn’t, but that is where we hammer out what the law is and what the actual elements of the crime are going to be.”

WHAT GOES INTO THE JURY INSTRUCTIONS?

The instructions include the law that applies to the facts of the case as well as the definitions of relevant legal terms and concepts.

During the course of the trial, lawyers on each side try to admit evidence that supports their theory of the case and the law they believe is applicable. There must be at least some evidence admitted during the trial that supports the applicability of a given law for it to be included in the jury instructions.

During a charge conference Friday, the lawyers worked with Superior Court Judge Timothy Walmsley to come up with the final instructions before closing arguments were delivered.

“By the time the lawyers are giving their closings, they know what the instructions are going to be,” Fleischman said. “That’s a super important part of a good close, telling the jury what the instructions mean in relation to this case.”

HOW DOES THE JURY RECEIVE THE INSTRUCTIONS?

After the closing arguments in the case are delivered, the judge charges the jury by reading the instructions out loud.

The instructions in this case were lengthy; it took Walmsley 42 minutes to read them to the jurors. It is up to the judge to decide whether to give the jurors a hard copy of the instructions to consult while they're deliberating. Walmsley did give the jurors a copy.

WHAT WERE SOME OF THE KEY INSTRUCTIONS IN THIS CASE?

Walmsley defined each of the charges: malice murder, felony murder, aggravated assault, false imprisonment and criminal attempt to commit false imprisonment.

He also explained that for Bryan, the jury may consider lesser offenses — simple assault, reckless conduct and reckless driving — in place of an aggravated assault charge.

The judge explained the law governing criminal trespass and burglary, which are relevant because the McMichaels' lawyers argued their clients believed Arbery had been inside a house under construction and was responsible for burglaries. The McMichaels were trying to carry out a citizen's arrest, and Travis McMichael shot Arbery when he fought back, their lawyers said

In defining citizen’s arrest for the jury, the judge spelled out the conditions that must be present to motivate that arrest. He also noted that a person making a lawful citizen’s arrest can’t use “excessive force or an unlawful degree of force.” And he instructed the jury that a person who’s the target of an unjustified citizen’s arrest “has the right to resist the arrest with such force as is reasonably necessary.”

Self-defense cannot be used as a defense if the person is the aggressor in a confrontation and excessive force cannot be used in self-defense, the judge said.

He also told the jury that with defenses of citizen’s arrest and self-defense, the prosecution must disprove those defenses beyond a reasonable doubt.

CAN THE JURORS ASK QUESTIONS WHILE DELIBERATING?

Jurors can send a note out when they have questions during deliberations. When that happens, the judge and lawyers work together to craft an appropriate response.

WHAT HAPPENS IF THE INSTRUCTIONS ARE WRONG?

Jury instructions are meant to inform the jury on the applicable law. If there is an error in the jury instructions, it can lead to the reversal of a conviction.

“Jury charges are where the best appeals happen because a jury charge issue, if the judge is wrong, is the most likely to lead to a reversible error," Fleischman said.

The defense attorneys repeatedly objected to parts of the jury instructions, which allows them to preserve that issue for appeal.

____

Associated Press writer Russ Bynum in Brunswick, Georgia, contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online - Georgia News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Fighting gas prices, US to release 50 million barrels of oil
President Joe Biden is ordering 50 million barrels of oil released from America's strategic reserve to help bring down energy costs
2:49PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Conviction overturned in 1981 rape of author Alice Sebold
A 39-year-old rape conviction at the center of a memoir by award-winning author Alice Sebold has been overturned because of what authorities determined were serious flaws with the prosecution
2:47PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Tennessee judge vacates 2 death sentences for inmate
A Tennessee judge has vacated two death sentences for a prison inmate convicted of fatally stabbing a mother and daughter more than 30 years ago
2:42PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Vaccines making Thanksgiving easier, but hot spots remain
The U.S. is in better shape approaching its second Thanksgiving of the pandemic, thanks to the vaccine
2:04PM ( 51 minutes ago )
'Glue me back together': Online pleas to aid parade victims
Friends and families of the roughly 50 people hit by an SUV that sped through a Christmas parade in a suburban Milwaukee downtown say they suffered life-threatening injuries, with some clinging to life
2:03PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Biden administration asks court to allow vaccine mandate
The Biden administration is asking a federal court to let it move ahead with a workplace rule that would require employees at larger companies to be vaccinated against COVID-19 or face weekly testing
1:59PM ( 56 minutes ago )
AP National News
Texas congressman joins GOP race for attorney general
U.S. Rep. Louie Gohmert has joined the crowded field of Republicans mounting primary challenges against Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
12:25PM ( 2 hours ago )
Social distancing mandatory as Dutch COVID infections spike
The Dutch government is making social distancing mandatory again for all adults after coronavirus infection numbers hit a new weekly record
11:12AM ( 3 hours ago )
Dutch COVID infections hit weekly record; Hospitals stressed
Dutch coronavirus infection numbers have hit a new weekly record, climbing 39% while hospital and intensive care unit admissions also rose sharply
10:08AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
House Jan. 6 panel subpoenas Alex Jones and Roger Stone
A committee investigating the Jan. 6 U.S. Capitol insurrection has issued subpoenas to five more individuals, including former President Donald Trump’s ally Roger Stone and conspiracy theorist Alex Jones
5:43PM ( 21 hours ago )
How Ohio's new US congressional map sprinted into law
Ohio's final congressional map sprinted through the Legislature last week and was signed by Republican Gov. Mike DeWine over the weekend, all in less than five days
5:04PM ( 21 hours ago )
Tennessee gov backs signing bill aide said violates US law
Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee is defending a new law assigning sprawling limits on COVID-19 restrictions, despite his office’s warning that it would violate federal disability law
4:48PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Bus crashes, catches fire in Bulgaria; at least 45 dead
Authorities say a bus carrying tourists back to North Macedonia crashed and caught fire in western Bulgaria, killing at least 45 people, including a dozen children
2:50PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Fighting gas prices, US to release 50 million barrels of oil
President Joe Biden is ordering 50 million barrels of oil released from America's strategic reserve to help bring down energy costs
2:49PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Conviction overturned in 1981 rape of author Alice Sebold
A 39-year-old rape conviction at the center of a memoir by award-winning author Alice Sebold has been overturned because of what authorities determined were serious flaws with the prosecution
2:47PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Tennessee judge vacates 2 death sentences for inmate
A Tennessee judge has vacated two death sentences for a prison inmate convicted of fatally stabbing a mother and daughter more than 30 years ago
2:42PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Jury holds pharmacies responsible for role in opioid crisis
A federal jury says CVS, Walgreens and Walmart pharmacies didn’t do enough to stop the flow of opioid pills into two Ohio counties
2:40PM ( 17 minutes ago )