cloudyn.png
Thursday January 20th, 2022 8:29PM

GOP-majority court chosen to consider Biden vaccine mandate

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Challenges to President Joe Biden's COVID-19 vaccine mandate for private employers will be consolidated in the U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals, a panel dominated by judges appointed by Republicans.

The Cincinnati-based court was selected Tuesday in a random drawing using ping-pong balls, a process employed when challenges to certain federal agency actions are filed in multiple courts.

The selection could be good news for those challenging the administration's vaccine requirement, which includes officials in 27 Republican-led states, employers and several conservative and business organizations. They argue the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration does not have the authority to impose the mandate.

The challenges, along with some from unions that said the vaccine mandate didn't go far enough, were made this month in 12 circuit courts. Under an arcane system, it was up to the clerk of the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict litigation to select a ping-pong ball from a bin to choose where the cases would be heard.

It was a favorable outcome for Republicans. Eleven of the 16 full-time judges in the 6th Circuit were appointed by Republican presidents. Accounting for one of the Republican-appointed judges, Helene White, who often sides with judges appointed by Democrats and adding senior judges who are semi-retired but still hear cases, the split is 19-9 in favor of Republicans. Six of the full-time judges were appointed by former President Donald Trump.

Another court where a majority of judges were nominated by Republicans, the New Orleans-based 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, issued a ruling that put the mandate on hold.

It's not clear whether the court that will hear the case will act as the 5th Circuit did and side quickly with the Republican challengers. But legal experts have become increasingly concerned in recent years about the politicization of both federal and state courts, raising questions about whether justice is fairly administered or dispensed through a partisan lens.

Allison Orr Larsen, a professor at William & Mary Law School, coauthored a study published this year that found growing partisanship in federal judicial decisions. For decades, the study found that rulings on cases in which all judges in a circuit weighed in generally were not decided along party lines based on the presidents who appointed the judges.

“We did see a concerning spike starting in 2018 that led us to wring our hands,” Larsen said in an interview.

The increasing partisanship in a branch of government that is supposed to be blind to partisan politics was seen in judges appointed by presidents of both parties, but Larsen said it's not clear why that was or whether it will last.

Some of the federal courts moved to the right when Donald Trump was president and Republicans controlled the U.S. Senate, which confirms judicial nominees. Trump appointed 54 judges to the circuit courts, which are one step below the U.S. Supreme Court, including filling one seat twice. That represents nearly 30% of the seats on the circuit courts, where cases are most often considered by three-judge panels.

Trump's appointees flipped the 11th Circuit in the South to Republican control and expanded the GOP-appointed majorities in the 5th, 6th and 8th Circuits in the Midwest and South. Biden's three appointees switched the New York-based 2nd Circuit to Democratic control.

Republican state attorneys general and conservative groups mostly filed their challenges in circuit courts dominated by conservative judges, while the unions went to circuits with more judges nominated by Democratic presidents.

In all, 34 objections have been filed in all 11 regional circuits plus the one for the District of Columbia. That’s where the ping-pong balls came in to play.

Under federal law, cases challenging federal agency actions get consolidated upon the agency's request if they are filed in multiple circuit courts. Each circuit where a challenge is filed within the first 10 days of the agency taking action has an equal chance of being selected.

It was up to the judicial panel's clerk, John W. Nichols, to select a ping-pong ball from a bin, according to a Tuesday court filing by the panel. The office denied a request by The Associated Press to allow media access to the drawing.

Previously this year, the lottery had been used to assign just two cases. One involved fallout from a National Labor Relations Board ruling on an anti-union Twitter message by Tesla founder Elon Musk where objectors filed in two circuits. The other was over orders from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission in which objectors filed in three.

The employer vaccine mandate is higher profile and further reaching. It calls for businesses with more than 100 workers to require employees to be vaccinated by Jan. 4 or wear masks and be tested weekly for COVID-19. Exemptions are provided for religious reasons and for those who work at home or only outdoors.

Because it's an unusual rule from the workplace safety agency, there is no consensus among lawyers on how the challenges will go. OSHA has issued just 10 emergency rules in the half century since it was formed. Of the six challenged in court, only one survived intact.

The Biden administration has insisted it’s on strong legal footing. It also has the backing of the American Medical Association, which filed papers in support of the mandate.

“The AMA’s extensive review of the medical literature demonstrates that COVID-19 vaccines authorized or approved by FDA are safe and effective, and the widespread use of those vaccines is the best way to keep COVID-19 from spreading within workplaces,” the group said in its filing.

Among those challenging the rule is a consortium of construction contractors. They say they want their workers vaccinated, but that a requirement only on larger companies is just pushing vaccine-hesitant workers to take jobs with companies that have fewer than 100 employees.

“Crafting an unworkable rule that will do little to get construction workers vaccinated is an approach that is not only wrong, but likely counterproductive,” said Scott Casabona, president of Signatory Wall and Ceiling Contractors Alliance.

Officials with the workplace safety agency say they’re considering extending the mandate to smaller employers.

A three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit extended the stay of the OSHA rule in an opinion released last Friday, expressing skepticism that the agency had authority to implement the vaccine requirement. The 6th Circuit could modify, revoke or extend the stay.

It had not yet been determined which judges from the 6th Circuit will be on a three-judge panel to hear the case or whether it will be considered by all the judges.

The U.S. Department of Justice declined to comment on the selection of the court.

___

Mulvihill reported from Cherry Hill, New Jersey. Associated Press writer Mark Sherman in Washington, D.C., contributed to this article.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2022 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
GOP-majority court chosen to consider Biden vaccine mandate
A ping-pong ball may have bounced in Republicans' favor as a GOP-dominated court was selected at random to consider the fate of President Joe Biden's mandate that larger employers require workers to be vaccinated
5:37PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Prosecution rests in trial of men who chased Ahmaud Arbery
Prosecutors have rested their case in the trial of three white men charged with chasing and killing Ahmaud Arbery as the Black man ran in their neighborhood
5:28PM ( 11 minutes ago )
CDC panel to discuss expanding COVID booster shots Friday
An influential U.S. advisory panel will discuss expanding eligibility for COVID-19 vaccine booster shots to all adults Friday, a move that could make the shots available as early as this weekend
5:06PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Pfizer agrees to let other companies make its COVID-19 pill
Drugmaker Pfizer Inc. has signed a deal with a U.N.-backed group to allow other manufacturers to make its experimental COVID-19 pill
5:00PM ( 39 minutes ago )
AP source: House to vote on censuring Gosar over video
Republican Rep. Paul Gosar of Arizona is facing censure in the House over a violent video he posted online
4:57PM ( 42 minutes ago )
Leahy retirement sets off scramble in Vermont for successor
Democrat Patrick Leahy’s announcement that he will retire after eight terms in the Senate has set off a scramble in Vermont over the rare opening in the state’s tiny congressional delegation
4:43PM ( 57 minutes ago )
AP National News
US journalist jailed for months in Myanmar lands in New York
American journalist Danny Fenster, who spent nearly six months in jail in military-ruled Myanmar, has arrived in the United States
3:04PM ( 2 hours ago )
Infrastructure bill unleashes funding to address risky dams
States will soon be flooded with federal money they can use to repair, improve or remove thousands of aging dams across the U.S. The funding is included in the $1 trillion infrastructure bill signed by President Joe Biden
2:57PM ( 2 hours ago )
Nearly 50K still have no power after Washington state storm
Officials say about 50,000 electrical customers in Washington state still have no power after a storm that dumped rain for days caused floods and mudslides
1:32PM ( 4 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Richardson adds to diplomatic wins with journalist's release
Bill Richardson’s success in helping secure the release of journalist Danny Fenster from a Myanmar prison is the latest demonstration of the former New Mexico governor’s knack for flying into some the most closed societies on earth and persuading those in charge to do Washington a favor
4:55PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Scion of Polish nobility jailed in property restitution case
A Warsaw court has confirmed the arrest order for a Polish businessman who is a descendent of one of Poland’s aristocratic families
4:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
Envoy: US ready to confront attempts to tear Bosnia apart
A senior U.S. official says Washington remains committed to maintaining peace and stability in Bosnia despite recent challenges by some of its Serb nationalist leaders to the U.S.-brokered Dayton peace agreement
3:28PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Vermont Democratic Sen. Leahy, 81, is retiring after 8 terms
Democratic Sen. Patrick Leahy of Vermont says he won’t seek reelection next year to the seat he's held since 1975
6:33PM ( 23 hours ago )
Biden boosts crime fighting efforts on Native American lands
President Joe Biden has ordered several Cabinet departments to work together to combat human trafficking and crime on Native American lands, where violent crime rates are more than double the national average
5:28PM ( 1 day ago )
Bannon indicted on contempt charges for defying 1/6 subpoena
Steve Bannon, a longtime ally to former President Donald Trump, has been indicted on two counts of criminal contempt of Congress after he defied a subpoena from the House committee investigating the Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol
10:26AM ( 3 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
'Red Notice,' 'Squid Game' top Netflix hours-watched metric
Netflix on Tuesday rolled out a new website that measures its most-watched films and series by the amount of hours users spend watching them
4:24PM ( 1 hour ago )
Stocks rise on Wall Street after retail sales post big gain
Stocks closed higher on Wall Street Tuesday as investors reviewed solid earnings reports from retailers and an encouraging update on consumer spending
4:07PM ( 1 hour ago )
Russia rejects accusations of endangering ISS astronauts
Russian officials are rejecting accusations that they endangered astronauts aboard the International Space Station by conducting a weapons test that created more than 1,500 pieces of space junk
3:21PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
US industrial production rebounded 1.6% in October
U.S. industrial production rebounded in October as auto production, which has been hurt by supply chain problems, posted a strong increase and the adverse effects from Hurricane Ida faded
10:28AM ( 7 hours ago )
Americans ramped up retail spending a strong 1.7% last month
Americans sharply boosted their spending last month, pushing up retail sales and giving the economy a lift
9:13AM ( 8 hours ago )
Home Depot sales continue to surge in hot housing market
Home Depot’s sales continued to climb through third quarter with the U.S. housing market red hot
8:40AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Defying inflation, Americans ramped up spending last month
Many Americans have taken a darker view of the economy as inflation has worsened
1:08PM ( 4 hours ago )
'We don’t deserve this': Inflation hits Turkish people hard
Many people in Turkey are facing increased hardship as prices of food and other goods have soared
10:01AM ( 7 hours ago )
German agency suspends approval process for Russia pipeline
Germany’s network regulator says it's suspended its procedure to certify the operator of a new pipeline that would bring Russian gas to the country under the Baltic Sea
9:45AM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Venezuelans crossing into Colombia for coronavirus vaccines
Hundreds of Venezuelans have been traveling to Colombia recently for coronavirus shots, as Venezuela struggles to get enough doses for its people
5:56PM ( 2 days ago )
Sinema's shift: 'Prada socialist' to corporate donor magnet
Twenty years ago, when Kyrsten Sinema was a Green Party activist running for the Phoenix City Council, she likened the practice of raising campaign cash to “bribery.”
11:43AM ( 3 days ago )
Alzheimer's drug cited as Medicare premium jumps by $21.60
Medicare’s “Part B” outpatient premium will jump by $21.60 a month in 2022, one of the largest increases ever
9:43PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Prosecution rests in trial of men who chased Ahmaud Arbery
Prosecutors have rested their case in the trial of three white men charged with chasing and killing Ahmaud Arbery as the Black man ran in their neighborhood
5:28PM ( 12 minutes ago )
CDC panel to discuss expanding COVID booster shots Friday
An influential U.S. advisory panel will discuss expanding eligibility for COVID-19 vaccine booster shots to all adults Friday, a move that could make the shots available as early as this weekend
5:06PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Pfizer agrees to let other companies make its COVID-19 pill
Drugmaker Pfizer Inc. has signed a deal with a U.N.-backed group to allow other manufacturers to make its experimental COVID-19 pill
5:00PM ( 40 minutes ago )
AP source: House to vote on censuring Gosar over video
Republican Rep. Paul Gosar of Arizona is facing censure in the House over a violent video he posted online
4:57PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Richardson adds to diplomatic wins with journalist's release
Bill Richardson’s success in helping secure the release of journalist Danny Fenster from a Myanmar prison is the latest demonstration of the former New Mexico governor’s knack for flying into some the most closed societies on earth and persuading those in charge to do Washington a favor
4:55PM ( 45 minutes ago )