clearn.png
Thursday December 2nd, 2021 8:56PM

Supreme Court questions controversial Texas abortion law

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — A majority of the Supreme Court signaled Monday they would allow abortion providers to pursue a court challenge to the controversial Texas law that has virtually ended abortion in the nation’s second-largest state after six weeks of pregnancy.

But it was unclear how quickly the court would rule and whether it would issue an order blocking the law that has been in effect for two months, or require providers to ask a lower court to put the law on hold.

Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett, two conservative appointees of former President Donald Trump, voted in September to allow the law to take effect, but they raised questions Monday about its novel structure. The law, written to make it difficult to mount legal challenges, subjects clinics, doctors and any others who facilitate abortions to large financial penalties.

“Millions and millions retroactively imposed, even though the activity was perfectly lawful under all court orders and precedent at the time it was undertaken, right?" Kavanaugh asked, one of several skeptical questions he put to Judd E. Stone II, representing Texas.

Barrett, too, pressed Stone about provisions of the law that force providers to fight lawsuits one by one and, she said, don't allow their constitutional rights to be “fully aired.”

The justices heard three hours of arguments Monday in two cases over whether abortion providers or the Justice Department can mount federal court challenges to the law, which has an unusual enforcement scheme its defenders argue shields it from federal court review.

The Biden administration filed its lawsuit after the justices voted 5-4 to refuse a request by providers to keep the law on hold. Justice Neil Gorsuch, also a Trump appointee, and two other conservative justices joined Barrett and Kavanaugh in the majority to let the law take effect. Chief Justice John Roberts joined the court’s three liberal justices in dissent.

The justices sounded less convinced that the Justice Department lawsuit should go forward, and Justice Elena Kagan suggested that a ruling instead in favor of the providers would allow the court to avoid difficult issues of federal power.

In neither case argued Monday is the right to an abortion directly at issue. But the motivation for the lawsuits is that the Texas law conflicts with landmark Supreme Court rulings that prevent a state from banning abortion early in pregnancy.

Arguing for the United States, Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar told the justices that Texas’ law was enacted in “open defiance” of Supreme Court precedent. “It enacted a law that clearly violates this court’s precedents,” she said.

Under the Supreme Court's 1973 Roe v. Wade decision and 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey decision, states are prevented from banning abortion before viability, the point at which a fetus can survive outside the womb, around 24 weeks of pregnancy.

The justices will hear a separate challenge to those decisions in a case over Mississippi's ban on abortion after 15 weeks. Those arguments are set for Dec. 1.

The most direct reference to the Mississippi case came from Justice Samuel Alito, who asked if the decision by providers to stop doing abortions in Texas “is attributable to the fear of liability if Roe or Casey is altered?”

But most questions focused on the Texas law and how it has altered abortion in the state even before the high court has made any change in abortion law. Kagan told Stone that until Texas passed its law, "no state dreamed" of trying to make an end-run around Supreme Court precedent in the same way.

If the Supreme Court doesn't do anything about that, she said, it would be inviting states to try to flout precedent: “Guns. Same-sex marriage. Religious rights. Whatever you don't like: go ahead,” she said. Kagan, who disagreed with her colleagues' decision to let the law take effect, said Texas' law has prevented women in Texas “from exercising a constitutional right.”

Kavanaugh also raised concerns about laws that might affect other constitutional rights.

The Texas law has been in effect since September when the Supreme Court declined to intervene, except for a 48-hour period in early October when it was blocked by a lower court. The high court got involved again less than two weeks ago, moving at extraordinary speed. The court offered no explanation for its decision to hear the cases so quickly.

If the court allows the providers to continue their lawsuit, it would still take a separate order from the justices or a lower court to put the law on hold.

Amy Hagstrom Miller, chief executive of Whole Woman's Health, said her four clinics would resume abortion services if they get a favorable court order.

The Texas ban, signed into law by Gov. Greg Abbott in May, prohibits abortion after cardiac activity is detected in a fetus, usually around six weeks and before some women know they are pregnant.

The law makes exceptions for medical emergencies but not for rape or incest.

A study published by researchers at the University of Texas found that the number of abortions statewide fell by 50% after the law took effect in September, compared to the same month in 2020. The study was based on data from 19 of the state’s 24 abortion clinics, according to the Texas Policy Evaluation Project.

At least 12 other states have enacted bans early in pregnancy, but all have been blocked from going into effect.

Rather than have state officials enforce the law, Texas deputizes private citizens to sue anyone who performs or aids and abets an abortion. If someone bringing suit is successful, they are entitled to at least $10,000. Women who obtain abortions can’t be sued under the law.

During arguments Monday, Roberts at one point asked whether the law could be challenged if Texas had made the entitlement much higher, $1 million. Texas' lawyer told him no.

The structure of the law threatens abortion providers with huge financial penalties if they violate it. Clinics throughout the state have stopped performing abortions once cardiac activity is found.

The result, both the providers and the Biden administration said, is that women who are financially able have traveled to other states and those without the means must either continue their pregnancies against their will or find other, potentially dangerous ways to end them.

Stone and Jonathan Mitchell, an architect of the law who also argued Monday, defended the law and its unusual structure. They said both the providers and the Justice Department lack the right to go into federal court, and should be asking Congress, not the justices, to expand court access.

___

Corrects 2nd paragraph, restoring missing “to.”

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Military weighs penalties for those who refuse COVID vaccine
As deadlines loom for military and defense civilians to get mandated COVID-19 vaccines, senior leaders are wrestling with the fate of tens of thousands who flatly refuse the shots or are seeking exemptions, and how to make sure they are treated fairly and equally
7:33PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Jury selection underway at Kyle Rittenhouse homicide trial
The trial of Kyle Rittenhouse has begun with the challenging task of seating jurors who haven't already made up their minds about the man who shot three people, killing two, during a violent night of protests last summer
7:22PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Supreme Court questions controversial Texas abortion law
A majority of the Supreme Court are signaling that they would allow abortion providers to pursue a court challenge to a Texas law that has virtually ended abortion in the nation’s second-largest state after six weeks of pregnancy
7:20PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Astros' Baker appreciates bench; Bregman to stay in 7-spot
Houston Astros manager Dusty Baker appreciates his star players
6:51PM ( 55 minutes ago )
Robert Durst indicted in 1982 murder of wife Kathie Durst
Prosecutors say millionaire real estate scion Robert Durst has been indicted on a murder charge in the death of Kathie Durst, his first wife who disappeared nearly four decades ago
6:37PM ( 1 hour ago )
Police: Chicago-area Halloween party shooting gang-related
Police say a shooting at a suburban Chicago Halloween party that left two people dead appears to be gang related
6:36PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
COVID vaccine for younger kids already being packed, shipped
The White House says the Biden administration is already assembling and shipping millions of doses of the COVID-19 vaccine for children ages 5-11
4:43PM ( 3 hours ago )
Manchin wavers on Biden's plan, rebuffs progressives
Sen. Joe Manchin is wavering over supporting President Joe Biden's $1.75 trillion policy package
4:35PM ( 3 hours ago )
Americans sour on economy amid inflation woes: AP-NORC Poll
Americans’ opinions on the U.S. economy have soured noticeably in the past month, a new poll finds
4:24PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Tight Virginia race becomes referendum on Biden presidency
A Virginia governor’s race that appears deadlocked between Democrat Terry McAuliffe and Republican Glenn Youngkin has entered its final hours
6:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
Judge limits new California law protecting vaccination sites
A federal judge has thrown out California’s new 30-foot buffer zone designed to restrict protests at coronavirus vaccination sites
5:37PM ( 2 hours ago )
Officials: Damaged US Navy sub struck underwater mountain
Defense officials say the U.S. Navy has determined that a submarine damaged in a collision in early October struck a seamount, or underwater mountain
5:23PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Supreme Court won't hear case involving transgender rights
The Supreme Court is declining to wade into a case involving transgender rights and leaving in place a lower court decision against a Catholic hospital that wouldn’t allow a transgender man to have a hysterectomy there
10:09AM ( 9 hours ago )
Supreme Court declines to block Maine vaccine mandate
The Supreme Court has rejected an emergency appeal from health care workers in Maine to block a vaccine mandate that went into effect Friday
12:11AM ( 2 days ago )
Oklahoma executes inmate who dies vomiting and convulsing
Oklahoma has executed a man who stabbed a prison cafeteria worker to death in 1998 in the state’s first lethal injection following a six-year moratorium
9:36PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Indonesia first to greenlight Novavax COVID-19 vaccine
Biotechnology company Novavax says that Indonesia has given the world’s first emergency use authorization for its COVID-19 vaccine, which uses a different technology than current shots
11:38AM ( 8 hours ago )
'Nothing else here': Why it's so hard for world to quit coal
Efforts to fight climate change are being held back in part because coal, the biggest single source of climate-changing gases, provides cheap electricity and supports millions of jobs
6:18AM ( 13 hours ago )
Shanghai Disneyland tests 33K, closes 2 days over 1 contact
Fireworks boomed as visitors at Shanghai Disneyland waited for COVID-19 test results, surrounded by health care workers dressed from head to toe in white protective suits
6:09AM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Health
NHL defends disciplinary decisions in Blackhawks scandal
Commissioner Gary Bettman is defending the NHL’s handling of disciplinary matters following an investigation into the Chicago Blackhawks over sexual assault allegations in 2010
7:01PM ( 46 minutes ago )
The Latest: $1.7 billion pledged for Indigenous communities
A coalition of governments and private funders announced plans at COP26 Monday to invest $1.7 billion to aid Indigenous communities and protect biodiverse tropical forests in the next four years
6:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
Union seeks Biden admin's help in Charleston port dispute
The union representing dockworkers at South Carolina’s ports tells The Associated Press it's calling on the Biden administration for help in a dispute related to a new shipping terminal
6:27PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Texas abortion law shutting down court avenue for teens
The latest restrictions in Texas that essentially ban abortion past the six-week pregnancy mark have made it nearly impossible for teenagers to get an abortion without parental consent
12:50AM ( 2 weeks ago )
Texas women drive hours for abortions after new law
The nation's most restrictive abortion law is driving many women from Texas to seek services as far away as Oklahoma and Kansas
9:32AM ( 2 weeks ago )
'We have to be heard': Texas women travel to seek abortions
The nation's most restrictive abortion law is driving many women from Texas to seek services as far away as Oklahoma and Kansas
4:39PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Military weighs penalties for those who refuse COVID vaccine
As deadlines loom for military and defense civilians to get mandated COVID-19 vaccines, senior leaders are wrestling with the fate of tens of thousands who flatly refuse the shots or are seeking exemptions, and how to make sure they are treated fairly and equally
7:33PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Jury selection underway at Kyle Rittenhouse homicide trial
The trial of Kyle Rittenhouse has begun with the challenging task of seating jurors who haven't already made up their minds about the man who shot three people, killing two, during a violent night of protests last summer
7:22PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Braves' Fried tries to win World Series
The Atlanta Braves lead the World Series three games to two and will try to win the championship Tuesday night when Max Fried starts against the Astros in Houston
7:19PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Judge: No new trial for Texas death row inmate Rodney Reed
A judge has recommended no new trial for Texas death row inmate Rodney Reed
7:09PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Judge starts Rittenhouse trial with trivia and lectures
The Wisconsin judge presiding over Kyle Rittenhouse’s homicide trial opened jury selection with a round of “Jeopardy!”
7:08PM ( 39 minutes ago )