clearn.png
Thursday February 25th, 2021 8:49PM

Supreme Court wrestles with Georgia college free speech case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Tuesday wrestled with whether to revive a lawsuit brought by a Georgia college student who sued school officials after being prevented from distributing Christian literature on campus.

The school, Georgia Gwinnett College, has since changed its policies and the student has graduated. A lower court dismissed the case as moot and an appeals court agreed, but the student, Chike Uzuegbunam, is urging the justices to allow the case to move forward. He's seeking just $1 and says he wants the Lawrenceville, Georgia, school to be held accountable for its past policies.

Groups across the political spectrum including the ACLU say the case is important to ensuring that people whose constitutional rights were violated can continue their cases even when governments repeal the policies they were challenging.

During arguments the justices heard by phone because of the coronavirus pandemic, both conservative and liberal justices expressed some concerns with Uzuegbunam's argument. Chief Justice John Roberts suggested to Uzuegbunam’s attorney, Kristen Waggoner of the group Alliance Defending Freedom, that it was problematic that “the only redress you're asking for is a declaration that you're right.” And Justice Elena Kagan noted that “people can't bring a suit for pure vindication alone ... for the psychic satisfaction that it gives to hear a court say that.”

Kagan, however, also brought up what she said was the most famous case she could think of where someone had sought a symbolic $1 in a lawsuit. In that case, former radio DJ David Mueller sued singer-songwriter Taylor Swift after she accused him of groping her, saying he was falsely accused and lost his job as a result of the allegation. She countersued for $1 alleging sexual assault.

“ That's what happened. The jury gave her $1,” Kagan said, later adding: “Why isn't that the same as this? The petitioner here says he was harmed. He wasn't able to speak when he should have been able to speak...He's just asking for $1 to redress that harm.”

Justice Brett Kavanaugh also told Georgia Solicitor General Andrew Pinson, the lawyer representing Georgia Gwinnett College officials, that it “seems that there are a number of things working against you here.” But Kavanaugh also sought to explain why the case has continued.

“I'm trying to, again, figure out what's really at stake here. This is not about the $1, I wouldn't think," he said at one point, adding that it was his “strong suspicion that attorneys fees is what's driving all this on both sides.”

Georgia Gwinnett College for years had a restrictive policy that limited where students could make speeches and distribute written materials to two “free speech expression areas.” Students had to get permission to demonstrate, march or pass out leaflets in other areas. The school has approximately 12,000 students.

In 2016, Uzuegbunam was distributing Christian pamphlets and talking to students on campus when a security guard told him he'd need to make a reservation and distribute the literature in one of the college's two speech zones. But when Uzuegbunam did, he was approached again and told that there had been complaints and that he'd need to stop.

Uzuegbunam and another student, Joseph Bradford, sued, and the college changed its policy in 2017. Students can now demonstrate or distribute literature anywhere and at any time on campus without having to first obtain a permit. The only time a group needs a permit is if it expects 30 or more people to participate. The college has said it won't go back to its old policy.

Uzuegbunam has the support of the Trump administration as well as a host of religious groups.

A decision in Uzuegbunam v. Preczewski, 19-968, is expected by the end of June.

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, Local/State News, Associated Press (AP), AP Entertainment, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Online - Georgia News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
House races to oust Trump as he says effort angers nation
Impeachment ahead, the House will first try Tuesday to push the vice president and Cabinet to act even more quickly to remove President Donald Trump from office
2:36PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Supreme Court wrestles with Georgia college free speech case
The Supreme Court is weighing whether to revive a lawsuit brought by a Georgia college student who sued school officials after being prevented from distributing Christian literature on campus
2:33PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Michigan plans to charge ex-Gov. Snyder in Flint water probe
The Associated Press has learned that former Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder, his health director and other ex-officials have been told they’re being charged after a new investigation of the Flint water scandal
2:33PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Her past: Billie Eilish photo book coming in May
At age 19, Billie Eilish is already looking back
2:19PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Her past: Book of Billie Elish photos coming in May
At age 19, Billie Eilish is already looking back
2:12PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Sundance adds Coogler-produced ‘Judas and the Black Messiah’
The Ryan Coogler-produced Fred Hampton film “Judas and the Black Messiah” will have its premiere at the Sundance Film Festival
1:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Entertainment
The Latest: Louisiana expands vaccine delivery to elderly
Louisiana is boosting its distribution of coronavirus vaccines to the elderly
5:37PM ( 21 hours ago )
The Latest: Gorillas in San Diego test positive for COVID-19
Several gorillas at the San Diego Zoo Safari Park have tested positive for the coronavirus in what is believed to be the first cases among such primates in captivity
3:50PM ( 23 hours ago )
The Latest: Jordan receives first shipment of Pfizer vaccine
Jordan has received its first shipment of the Pfizer coronavirus vaccine before its vaccination drive kicks off this week
3:10PM ( 23 hours ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Bills sign RB Freeman to practice squad, place Moss on IR
The Buffalo Bills have signed running back Devonta Freeman to their practice squad to add veteran depth after placing rookie Zack Moss on injured reserve
1:28PM ( 1 hour ago )
Masters plans for a limited number of spectators in April
Augusta National plans to have cheers, but maybe not roars at the Masters in April
11:53AM ( 2 hours ago )
Bernice King: Don't 'fuel the fires' ignited by Capitol mob
The daughter of the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. says Americans angered by the mob attack on the U.S. Capitol should refrain from responses that feed the divisive message of extremists
11:41AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online - Georgia News
House races to oust Trump as he says effort angers nation
Impeachment ahead, the House will first try Tuesday to push the vice president and Cabinet to act even more quickly to remove President Donald Trump from office
2:36PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Michigan plans to charge ex-Gov. Snyder in Flint water probe
The Associated Press has learned that former Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder, his health director and other ex-officials have been told they’re being charged after a new investigation of the Flint water scandal
2:33PM ( 18 minutes ago )
US shifts to speed COVID shots as cases and deaths rise
Barely a month into a mass vaccination campaign to stop the COVID-19 pandemic, the Trump administration has unexpectedly shifted gears to speed the delivery of shots
2:32PM ( 19 minutes ago )
EXPLAINER: Who's been charged in the deadly Capitol siege?
Prosecutors have brought dozens of cases after the deadly attack at the U
2:31PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Sage grouse review done, but scant time for Trump's changes
The Trump administration has completed a review of plans to ease protections for a struggling bird species in seven states in the U.S. West, but there’s little time to put them into action before President-elect Joe Biden takes office
2:28PM ( 23 minutes ago )