Tuesday October 20th, 2020 5:14AM

Who's a hypocrite? GOP, Dems debate past comments on court

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The “H” word — hypocrisy — is suddenly in vogue at the Capitol as lawmakers debate how quickly to fill a vacancy on the Supreme Court following the death of liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has vowed that President Donald Trump’s as-yet unnamed nominee will receive a vote on the Senate floor “this year," but has been careful not to say exactly when that will happen.

Democrats accuse the Kentucky Republican of blatant hypocrisy after McConnell refused to consider President Barack Obama’s Supreme Court nominee, Judge Merrick Garland, eight months before the 2016 election.

Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer took to the Senate floor Monday to remind McConnell of his own words hours after the February 2016 death of conservative Justice Antonin Scalia. “The American people,'' McConnell said then, "should have a voice in the selection of their next Supreme Court justice.'' The vacancy created by Scalia's death should not be filled until the election of a new president, he added.

"No amount of sophistry can change what McConnell said then, and it applies even more so now — so much closer we are to an election,'' Schumer said Monday.

But McConnell said it is Democrats who are being hypocritical. What Republicans did in 2016 — blocking a nominee of the opposing party — was "precisely what Democrats had indicated they would do themselves'' when they were in the majority, McConnell said in his own floor speech Monday. He and other Republicans cited a 1992 speech by then-Sen. Joe Biden — now the Democratic nominee for president — indicating that a vacancy occurring in an election year should not be filled.

Biden, Schumer and other Democrats flip-flopped in 2016, in McConnell's telling, because they urged the Senate to act on Obama's nominee.


McConnell stunned the political world in 2016 with his declaration that the Senate would not consider a replacement for Scalia until after the presidential election nearly nine months away. While daring, McConnell said his action was justified by history.

“Remember that the Senate has not filled a vacancy arising in an election year when there was divided government since 1888, almost 130 years ago,'' he declared again and again that year, frequently citing what Republicans called the “Biden Rule.” That so-called rule — never adopted in any formal sense by the Senate — urged the Senate to delay action on a Supreme Court vacancy until after the presidential election.

“President Obama was asking Senate Republicans for an unusual favor that had last been granted nearly 130 years prior. But voters had explicitly elected our majority to check and balance the end of his presidency. So we stuck with the historical norm," McConnell said Monday as he recounted past fights over the Supreme Court.

McConnell's statement, while accurate, omitted a more recent vote when the Democratic-controlled Senate approved President Ronald Reagan's nomination of Anthony Kennedy in February 1988. Kennedy was named to fill a vacancy that arose in 1987, after two failed nominations.


By 2019, with Trump in office and a continued GOP Senate majority, McConnell said Senate action on a court opening close to the election would not be an issue. Asked at a May 2019 appearance in his home state what he would do if a Supreme Court justice died the next year, creating a vacancy on the nine-member court, McConnell responded immediately: “Oh, we’d fill it.”

The main difference? Unlike 2016, when the White House and Senate were controlled by different parties, both are now under Republican control, McConnell said.

“I’d also remind everybody what I just told you, which is the Senate is of the same party as the president of the United States,'' McConnell told Fox News in February of this year. "And in that situation we would confirm” a new justice.

Schumer wasn't buying it. He cited a 2016 op-ed co-written by McConnell imploring that the American people be given the opportunity to "weigh in on whom they trust to nominate the next person for a lifetime appointment to the Supreme Court.''

“Now these words don’t apply?” Schumer asked. "It doesn’t pass the smell test in any way. No wonder Leader McConnell was so defensive in his comments.''

Schumer and other Democrats urged McConnell to abide by his own standard. "What’s fair is fair. A senator's word must count for something,'' Schumer said.

But McConnell, in his speech, said that at a time when "the American people have elected a Senate majority to work closely with the sitting president, the historical record is even more overwhelming — in favor of confirmation.''

Eight times in the nation’s history vacancies have arisen during an election year when the White House and Senate were controlled by the same party. Seven of those times the justice was confirmed. The sole exception was in 1968, when President Lyndon Johnson tried to elevate Justice Abe Fortas to become chief justice. The nomination faced a filibuster due in part to ethics problems that later led Fortas to resign from the court.

“Apart from that one strange exception, no Senate has failed to confirm a nominee in the circumstances that face us now,'' McConnell said.

“The American people reelected our majority in 2016 and strengthened it further in 2018 because we pledged to work with President Trump on the most critical issues facing our country. The federal judiciary was right at the top of that list,'' he said.

On that final point — the importance of the judiciary — Schumer agreed.

“That's what this (fight) is all about,'' he said. “All the rights enshrined in our Constitution that are supposed to be protected by the Supreme Court of the United States” are at stake.

"The right to join a union, marry who you love, freely exercise your right to vote ... (and) proper health care. If you care about these things and the kind of country we live in, this election — and this vacancy — mean everything,'' Schumer said.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Political Conventions
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Biggest unknown with Beta is how much rain it will bring
Tropical Storm Beta made landfall on the upper Texas coast on Monday night
12:52AM ( 3 minutes ago )
Who's a hypocrite? GOP, Dems debate past comments on court
Democrats are accusing Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell of blatant hypocrisy after he pledged a Senate vote on President Donald Trump’s nominee to the Supreme Court
12:36AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Athletics clinch first AL West title since 2013
The Oakland Athletics clinched their first AL West title since 2013 on Monday night with an assist from the rival Houston Astros
12:27AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump interviews Barrett while weighing a high court nominee
President Donald Trump has met with the conservative appeals court judge, Amy Coney Barrett, who is considered the favorite to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
12:04AM ( 50 minutes ago )
Enormous California wildfire threatens desert homes near LA
An enormous wildfire that churned through mountains northeast of Los Angeles and into the Mojave Desert is continuing to threaten homes after destroying or damaging 29 buildings
11:46PM ( 1 hour ago )
China uproots ethnic minority villages in anti-poverty fight
The ruling Communist Party says its initiatives have helped to lift millions of people out of poverty
9:45PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
Born to prevent war, UN at 75 faces a deeply polarized world
The United Nations is marking its 75th anniversary with its chief urging leaders of an increasingly polarized, go-it-alone world to work together and preserve the organization’s most important success since its founding
9:42PM ( 3 hours ago )
Former Wisconsin police chief to review Jacob Blake shooting
Wisconsin’s attorney general has selected a former Madison police chief to serve as an independent consultant for prosecutors weighing whether to file charges against the officer who shot Jacob Blake, a Black man who was left paralyzed from the waist down
9:15PM ( 3 hours ago )
Barrett emerges as court favorite; Trump to pick by weekend
President Donald Trump met Monday with Amy Coney Barrett at the White House as the conservative judge emerged as an early favorite for the Supreme Court
8:53PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Top contenders for Ginsburg's seat on Supreme Court
President Donald Trump says he will nominate a woman to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who was a champion of gender equality
12:05AM ( 49 minutes ago )
The Latest: Hollywood unions announce pandemic agreement
Hollywood’s unions have announced that they have reached an agreement on pandemic protocols with major studios that will allow the broad resumption of production of films and television after six months of stagnant sets and widespread unemployment
10:37PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Connecticut forms advisory groups on vaccines
Gov. Ned Lamont says Connecticut is forming an advisory group to validate the safety of any coronavirus vaccines and how to distribute them to the public
7:54PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Ginsburg's death exposes fragility of health law protection
COVID-19 is the newest preexisting medical condition, and the Obama-era health law that protects Americans from insurance discrimination is more fragile following the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
5:44PM ( 7 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump says he's vetting 5 women for court pick
President Donald Trump says five women are being carefully vetted to become his nominee for the Supreme Court to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
5:01PM ( 7 hours ago )
Cuban-American judge from Florida on Trump high court list
Barbara Lagoa is the daughter of Cuban exiles who grew up in a heavily Hispanic suburb of Miami and has had a swift rise as a lawyer and judge — and she is on President Donald Trump’s short list to replace Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the U.S. Supreme Court
5:01PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Supreme Court fight could elevate Kamala Harris' profile
Kamala Harris is poised to become a leading figure in the Democratic opposition to President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court pick
1:13PM ( 11 hours ago )
2020 Watch: Is this suddenly a new election?
The October surprise of 2020 came a month early
12:59PM ( 11 hours ago )
The Latest: Schiff says Trump hit new low in Ginsburg claim
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff says President Donald Trump has reached a “new low” for suggesting Democrats were behind a report that the late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's wish was not to be replaced until a new president is inaugurated
12:20PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
The Latest: White House urges governors to help on vaccines
The White House is urging U.S. governors to put politics aside and help the Trump administration promote future coronavirus vaccines as safe and effective
5:17PM ( 7 hours ago )
Ohio, GOP defend limit on ballot drop boxes to 1 per county
Ohio and Republican groups including the Trump campaign are defending a GOP election chief’s directive limiting ballot drop boxes in the critical presidential battleground to one per county
5:12PM ( 7 hours ago )
Judge: Postal Service must process election mail on time
For the second time in a week, a federal judge has ordered the U.S. Postal Service to live up to its responsibilities to process election mail in a timely fashion
4:46PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Elections
The Latest: WH leaves it to McConnell to decide vote timing
The White House says President Donald Trump will announce his pick to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in the “near future” but declined to say whether the president will push for a Senate confirmation vote before Election Day
2:30PM ( 1 day ago )
GOP hopeful Supreme Court battle will help shift election
Four years ago, the allure of conservative Supreme Court appointments helped persuade skeptical Republicans to support Donald Trump for president
2:26PM ( 1 day ago )
2nd GOP senator a 'no' to filling court seat before election
A second Republican senator has come out in opposition to filling a vacant Supreme Court seat before the Nov. 3 election
1:56PM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
How Ginsburg's death could reshape the presidential campaign
A presidential campaign that was already tugging at the nation’s most searing divides has been jolted by the death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
6:49PM ( 2 days ago )
GOP senators confront past comments on Supreme Court vote
Republican senators face questions about their own past comments as they weigh what to do about the vacancy on the Supreme Court
6:35PM ( 2 days ago )
Q&A: What does banning TikTok and WeChat mean for users?
The U.S. government is cracking down on the Chinese apps TikTok and WeChat, starting by barring them from app stores on Sunday
6:21PM ( 2 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
McConnell pledges quick vote on next justice; Biden says no
The death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on Friday has cast an immediate spotlight on the vacancy on the high court, with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell vowing to bring President Donald Trump’s nominee to a vote with just over six weeks before the election
10:48PM ( 3 days ago )
After Ginsburg: McConnell pledges quick vote on successor
The death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on Friday has cast an immediate spotlight on the vacancy on the high court, with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell vowing to bring President Donald Trump’s nominee to a vote with just over six weeks before the election
9:47PM ( 3 days ago )
Trump and Biden hit unlikely battleground state of Minnesota
Donald Trump and Joe Biden both campaigned in Minnesota on Friday, though the state has voted for Democrats for president for a half century
8:08PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Elections - Political Conventions
Athletics clinch first AL West title since 2013
The Oakland Athletics clinched their first AL West title since 2013 on Monday night with an assist from the rival Houston Astros
12:27AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Raiders open Las Vegas stadium with 34-24 win vs Saints
Derek Carr threw three touchdown passes and the Raiders gave their new fans in Las Vegas plenty to celebrate even if they weren’t allowed in the stadium by beating the New Orleans Saints 34-24
12:21AM ( 34 minutes ago )
Third parties could play a lesser role in 2020 campaign
Third-party candidates could play a lesser role in 2020 than in years past
12:15AM ( 40 minutes ago )
Black voters in Detroit key for Biden, but are they engaged?
Black voters across Michigan will be pivotal in deciding who will win the battleground state in November
12:13AM ( 42 minutes ago )
Trump aims to use UN address to send strong message to China
President Donald Trump prefers speaking to boisterous crowds, but because of the coronavirus, he'll be giving a prerecorded address to the U.N. General Assembly on Tuesday
12:11AM ( 43 minutes ago )