mcloudy.png
Sunday May 16th, 2021 2:55PM

Nevada church resumes court battle over COVID-19 rules

By The Associated Press

RENO, Nev. (AP) — A rural Nevada church is trying again to persuade the 9th U.S. Circuit of Appeals that the state's 50-person cap on religious gatherings is unconstitutional.

Lawyers for Calvary Chapel Dayton Valley filed new briefs with the San Francisco-based appellate court on Wednesday after the Supreme Court narrowly refused in July to grant an emergency order suspending Nevada's COVID-19 church cap.

They're emphasizing the three dissenting opinions from the high court's 5-4 decision in their latest bid to prove that parishioners' religious freedoms are being violated partly because casinos and other secular businesses are allowed to operate at 50% capacity.

The Lyon County church wants to allow as many as 90 people to attend services at the same time — with masks required, spaced 6-feet apart — at the sanctuary east of Reno with a capacity of 200.

Its lawyers say Gov. Steve Sisolak’s claim that the hard cap on churches is needed to guard against the spread of COVID-19 “defies reason.”

“A casino entertaining 1,000 gamblers has no impact on public health while Calvary Chapel increasing its service size from 50 people to 90 would cripple the state’s health effort?" they asked in Wednesday's filing accusing the state of putting profits ahead of the First Amendment.

“It has everything to do with Nevada’s person-based tourism economy,” they said.

The high court’s decision followed the 9th Circuit’s refusal to grant temporary injunctive relief after a federal judge in Reno upheld the state policy in May and again in June.

“Calvary and its counsel should not be allowed to continually second-guess Nevada’s efforts to protect public health against a novel, highly contagious virus,” Deputy Solicitor General Craig Newby wrote in mid-August.

But the church argues the landscape has changed.

“This is not just a 14-day or 30-day temporary, emergency measure,” it said. “Restricting religious gatherings for more than five months, with no end in sight, is not a rapidly changing, temporary measure that deserves substantial deference. It is government overreach in clear violation of constitutional principles.”

Other Nevada businesses allowed to operate at half capacity include gyms, hair salons, bowling alleys and water parks.

Sisolak, a Democrat, insists the policy is legal because it doesn’t target religious establishments or attempt to regulate speech based on ideology or opinion.

“No preference has been provided for commercial speech versus religious speech in public areas," his lawyers said.

Consistent with White House guidelines, Sisolak “has implemented directives to slowly reopen Nevada to ensure the curve stays flat and that there is no need to completely revert back to earlier phases that require further sacrifices from all Nevadans to remain safe,” they said.

They maintain casinos are different because they're licensed by the state and subject to restrictions beyond the virus guidelines.

“Choosing to reopen a highly regulated industry, that is subject to significant regulatory control that allows for a rapid shutdown if a second COVID-19 outbreak arises, makes sense," the state says.

Nevada's case is the only one the Supreme Court has considered since it upheld restrictions on religious gatherings in California in May.

Chief Justice John Roberts sided with the liberal majority in denying Cavalry Chapel's request without explanation. Justices Brett Kavanaugh, Neil Gorsuch and Samuel Alito each wrote their own dissent, the latter joined by Kavanaugh and Clarence Thomas.

“That Nevada would discriminate in favor of the powerful gaming industry and its employees may not come as a surprise, but this Court’s willingness to allow such discrimination is disappointing,” Alito wrote July 25.

“There are certain constitutional red lines that a state may not cross even in a crisis,” Kavanaugh added in his own dissent.

Gorsuch said: “There is no world in which the Constitution permits Nevada to favor Caesars Palace over Calvary Chapel."

The church said Wednesday federal courts have an obligation “to stop unconstitutional actions by state officials.”

"And this court has a monopoly on the legal power to do so since the governor will not relent.”

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Business
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Portland protests set up clash between journalists, police
Journalists have been covering protests in Portland, Oregon, for three months
3:42PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Brown U. rebuts 'conspiracy' in fight over women's sports
Brown University is rebutting what the Ivy League school calls “spurious conspiracy claims" as it responds to an allegation that is is failing to comply with a 1998 agreement ensuring gender equity in sports
3:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
White House faces skepticism over prospects for a vaccine
Could the U.S. really see a coronavirus vaccine before Election Day
3:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
U.S. News
NATO says Turkey, Greece agree to talks; Athens denies deal
NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg says Greece and Turkey have agreed to start “technical talks” aimed at helping to reduce the risks of military incidents and accidents in the eastern Mediterranean
4:16PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Tech rout sends stock market to its biggest loss since June
Stocks fell sharply on Wall Street Thursday as high-flying technology companies took a tumble after months of spectacular gains
4:09PM ( 11 minutes ago )
The Latest: Jacob Blake speaks by phone with Joe Biden
Former Vice President Joe Biden has spoken with Jacob Blake on the phone for 15 minutes during a visit to Wisconsin
4:05PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Biden meets Jacob Blake's family in trip to Wisconsin
Joe Biden met Thursday with the family of Jacob Blake, as the Democratic presidential nominee began a day of events in Wisconsin
3:46PM ( 34 minutes ago )
A month on, signal in Beirut rubble raises hope for survivor
A pulsing signal has been detected from under the rubble of a Beirut building that collapsed during the horrific port explosion in the Lebanese capital last month, raising hopes there may be a survivor still buried there
3:21PM ( 59 minutes ago )
Stocks drop sharply as tech sector stumbles; Apple down 7.1%
Technology stocks took a tumble on Wall Street Thursday, giving back some of their spectacular gains over the past several months and dragging the rest of the market down with them
3:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
NYC's new sex crimes chief has a background in nursing
The new head of New York City’s sex crimes unit is a veteran investigator and forensic nurse who has conducted the physical exams and evidence collection that are vital to solving such cases
10:57AM ( 5 hours ago )
Facebook moves to target misinformation before election
With just two months left until the U_S_ presidential election, Facebook says it is taking additional steps to encourage voting, minimize misinformation and reduce the likelihood of post-election “civil unrest.”
9:40AM ( 6 hours ago )
Can I get the coronavirus twice?
Can I get the coronavirus twice
3:04AM ( 13 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Pelosi, Mnuchin agree on plan to avoid government shutdown
Democrats and the Trump administration are taking a key step toward avoiding a government shutdown in September
3:44PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Leaders of Kosovo, Serbia at White House for economic talks
The U.S. is mediating talks between Serbia and Kosovo in hopes of normalizing economic relations and possibly paving the way toward resolving thorny political disputes
3:34PM ( 46 minutes ago )
The Latest: Milwaukee's health commissioner steps down
Milwaukee’s health commissioner is quitting to take a new job, citing partisan battles management of the coronavirus
3:25PM ( 54 minutes ago )
AP Business
Portland protests set up clash between journalists, police
Journalists have been covering protests in Portland, Oregon, for three months
3:42PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Brown U. rebuts 'conspiracy' in fight over women's sports
Brown University is rebutting what the Ivy League school calls “spurious conspiracy claims" as it responds to an allegation that is is failing to comply with a 1998 agreement ensuring gender equity in sports
3:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
White House faces skepticism over prospects for a vaccine
Could the U.S. really see a coronavirus vaccine before Election Day
3:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
Black jogger who was mistakenly jailed in Texas speaks out
A Black jogger who spent nearly two days in jail after mistakenly being arrested by San Antonio police because he fit the description of an assault suspect says it was a traumatic experience that no one should have to experience
3:08PM ( 1 hour ago )
Black man killed by Rochester police is remembered as loving
The aunt of a Black man who suffocated after police in New York’s third-largest city put a “spit hood” over his head says he was the loving father of five adult children and had just arrived in Rochester for a visit with his brother
2:54PM ( 1 hour ago )