sunny.png
Sunday May 16th, 2021 11:58AM

Still too soon to try altering human embryo DNA, panel says

By The Associated Press

It’s still too soon to try to make genetically edited babies because the science isn’t advanced enough to ensure safety, says an international panel of experts who also mapped a pathway for any countries that want to consider it.

Thursday’s report comes nearly two years after a Chinese scientist shocked the world by revealing he’d helped make the first gene-edited babies using a tool called CRISPR, which enables DNA changes or “edits” that can pass to future generations. He Jianqui did this to three babies when they were embryos to try to make them resistant to infection with the AIDS virus and described it in exclusive interviews with The Associated Press.

Mainstream scientists condemned his experiment as unethical, and He was sentenced to three years in prison for violating Chinese laws. The experts commission was formed in the aftermath by the U.S. National Academy of Medicine, U.S. National Academy of Sciences and the United Kingdom’s Royal Society.

The group doesn’t take a stance on whether editing embryos is ethical, just whether it’s ready scientifically -- and deems that it’s not. A separate panel formed by the World Health Organization is to report on ethics issues later this year.

The commission does say that if a country allows this, it should be limited to cases where people have no or very poor options for having a child without the disease. Initial attempts should be for serious diseases caused by a single gene, such as muscular dystrophy, cystic fibrosis, the blood disorder beta thalassemia and Tay-Sachs, a neurological disease, the report says.

Altering genes to try to enhance traits such as muscle mass or height is not endorsed.

It gives “much better clarity about what it would take to go forward and that now is not the time,” said Jeffrey Kahn, bioethics chief at Johns Hopkins University and a member of the panel.

Whether editing is acceptable from an ethics and societal perspective “needs to be answered country by country,” he said. “You’re modifying a future human. It’s a big step.”

The panel recommended that:

-- Pregnancy with edited embryos should not be attempted unless it’s clearly possible to make only the intended gene changes and not any unintended ones, which can’t be done now.

-- Extensive public discussions should be held before any country decides to allow editing embryos, eggs or sperm. A regulatory system needs to be in place to ensure oversight and publication of results, and to prevent bias or discrimination.

-- Initial uses should be limited to cases meeting four criteria: a serious disease caused by a single gene; editing is limited to changing a problem DNA sequence to one that is known to be safe in the general population; no embryos without the problem gene are edited, and parents lack a good way to have a child without the disease because of fertility problems or other issues.

-- Edited embryos should be studied in the lab to ensure they’re developing normally, and tests should be done to verify that all cells were altered as intended, before they’re used to attempt pregnancy.

-- An international scientific advisory panel should be formed to give regular updates on science advances, assess if requirements have been met for embryo editing, review results from any cases and help any countries seeking advice.

“Our group was very concerned about the potential for rogue scientists” to proceed on their own, and included advice that there needs to be a way for whistleblowers to report unethical work, said Richard Lifton, president of the Rockefeller University in New York and co-leader of the panel.

Some scientists not connected with the work expressed surprise at the panel’s inclusion of diseases such as sickle cell and cystic fibrosis, which have a wide range of severity and existing treatments.

If drugs or gene therapy after birth can treat a disease, “then it doesn’t make sense to me to layer the additional medical and ethical risks” of editing embryos to try to prevent it, said David Liu, Harvard University professor and co-founder of several gene editing companies. He is paid by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, which also supports AP’s Health & Science Department.

Jennifer Doudna, a gene editing pioneer from the University of California, Berkeley, said she also was struck by the inclusion of cystic fibrosis.

"It’s a disease that can be managed in some cases,” she said.

Gene editing of blood cells after birth seems a potential cure for sickle cell, and “there’s already been success with one patient” using CRISPR, she noted.

Kahn said not every case would meet all of the criteria the panel set, and if gene therapy turns out to work, "I think we have a different conversation” about editing's risks and benefits.

Regardless, the report shows that editing embryos, eggs or sperm should not be done yet because “the technology is too early stage,” Doudna said.

“If there ever was confusion or if anyone in the past could say it wasn’t clear ... it’s now very clear” that it’s taboo, she said. Gene editing is a powerful technology and should be pursued with international standards and full transparency, “not having it happening in the shadows.”

___

The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute’s Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Health, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
NYC's new sex crimes chief has a background in nursing
The new head of New York City’s sex crimes unit is a veteran investigator and forensic nurse who has conducted the physical exams and evidence collection that are vital to solving such cases
8:31AM ( 1 hour ago )
Black man killed by Rochester police is remembered as loving
The aunt of a Black man who suffocated after police in New York’s third-largest city put a “spit hood” over his head says he was the loving father of five adult children and had just arrived in Rochester for a visit with his brother
8:20AM ( 2 hours ago )
Facebook moves to target misinformation before election
With just two months left until the U_S_ presidential election, Facebook says it is taking additional steps to encourage voting, minimize misinformation and reduce the likelihood of post-election “civil unrest.”
7:04AM ( 3 hours ago )
U.S. News
Russia: Germany has provided no proof of Navalny poisoning
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s spokesman has brushed off allegations of involvement in the poisoning of the Kremlin’s most determined critic, accusing Germany of not providing Moscow with any evidence
10:14AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Tyson Foods to open medical clinics at some meat plants
Tyson Foods says it is planning to open medical clinics at several of its U.S. plants to improve the health of its workers and better protect them from the coronavirus
10:02AM ( 21 minutes ago )
U.S. productivity rises a record 10.1% in second quarter
U.S. productivity rose at a 10.1% rate in the second quarter as the number of hours worked declined by the largest amount since the government started compiling the data more than 70 years ago
10:01AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Jobless claims fall to 881,000 but layoffs remain elevated
The number of laid-off Americans applying for unemployment benefits fell to a still-elevated 881,000 last week, evidence that the viral pandemic keeps forcing many businesses to slash jobs
9:29AM ( 54 minutes ago )
UK public tribunal to probe Uighur 'genocide' claims
A prominent British human rights lawyer is convening an independent tribunal in London to investigate whether the Chinese government’s alleged rights abuses against Uighur Muslims in the far western Xinjiang region constitute genocide or crimes against humanity
9:24AM ( 1 hour ago )
Hurricane Nana hits Belize, drives across Guatemala
Hurricane Nana has made landfall in Belize and it-s now pushing across Guatemala
8:29AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
NYC's new sex crimes chief has a background in nursing
The new head of New York City’s sex crimes unit is a veteran investigator and forensic nurse who has conducted the physical exams and evidence collection that are vital to solving such cases
8:31AM ( 1 hour ago )
Black man killed by Rochester police is remembered as loving
The aunt of a Black man who suffocated after police in New York’s third-largest city put a “spit hood” over his head says he was the loving father of five adult children and had just arrived in Rochester for a visit with his brother
8:20AM ( 2 hours ago )
Facebook moves to target misinformation before election
With just two months left until the U_S_ presidential election, Facebook says it is taking additional steps to encourage voting, minimize misinformation and reduce the likelihood of post-election “civil unrest.”
7:04AM ( 3 hours ago )
Can I get the coronavirus twice?
Can I get the coronavirus twice
3:04AM ( 7 hours ago )
Experts: Cohen may profit from criminal exploits in tell-all
Legal experts say so-called Son of Sam laws won't prevent former Donald Trump attorney Michael Cohen from cashing in on his criminal exploits in a new memoir
1:06AM ( 9 hours ago )