mcloudyn.png
Friday August 14th, 2020 6:41AM

US officials seek limits on "habitat" for imperiled species

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) — The Trump administration is moving to restrict what land and water areas can be declared as “habitat” for imperiled plants and animals — potentially excluding locations that species could use in the future as climate change upends ecosystems.

An administration proposal obtained in advance by The Associated Press and publicly released Friday would for the first time define “habitat” for purposes of enforcing the Endangered Species Act, the landmark law that has dictated species protections efforts in the U.S. since 1973.

A final decision is expected by year's end, with broad implications for how lands are managed and how far the government must go in protecting plants and animals that could be sliding toward extinction.

Democratic lawmakers and wildlife advocates said the proposal ignores shifting threats to wildlife and plants due to climate change and habitat loss.

It follows other steps under Trump to scale back or alter endangered species rules, including lifting blanket protections for animals newly listed as threatened and setting cost estimates for saving species.

Legal observers said the Republican administration's two-sentence definition of habitat would limit what areas the government can designate as critical to a species' survival.

Its declaration that habitat includes areas with “existing attributes" appears to rule out land or water needing restoration work or sites that could become suitable in the future as climate change forces species to relocate, said J.B. Ruhl with Vanderbilt University Law School.

“To me, they are clearly trying to rule out restoration and climate change,” Ruhl said.

He added that a court would likely agree that the government's definition was reasonable, even though he does not think it is good policy for dealing with climate change.

Jonathan Wood with the Pacific Legal Foundation, which represents landowners opposed to having species protections forced upon them, said the government's proposal would rightly restrict what areas could be designated as habitat.

He said that would force the government to concentrate on sites more suitable for conservation work, instead of infringing on private property rights.

Others warned that it would seriously hobble restoration efforts, by confining struggling species to small patches of pristine land and blocking restoration work that could expand their range.

The northern spotted owl of the Pacific Northwest, which depends on old growth forests, offers a prime example, said Noah Greenwald with the Center for Biological Diversity.

Much of the bird’s historic habitat was logged. “But it will become old growth forest again one day if we protect it. So does that not count as habitat?” Greenwald asked.

“If we want to recover species, we have to restore them to more larger portions of their historic range,” he said.

Friday’s proposal from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries Service comes in response to a 2018 U.S. Supreme Court ruling involving a highly endangered Southern frog — the dusky gopher frog.

Trump administration officials said the proposal would apply to relatively few cases and provide “more consistency" and “more transparency” for private landowners, companies and states.

They would not specify what types of land or how much could be excluded under the definition, or give immediate details on which species could be impacted.

“The Supreme Court recently held that an area must be ‘habitat’ in order to be designated as ‘critical habitat’, and we are now seeking public comment on how best to define that overarching term,” said wildlife service assistant director Gary Frazer.

In the gopher frog case, a unanimous court said the government had to decide what constitutes suitable habitat for the 3 ½-inch-long (8.9-centimeter-long) frogs before it could designate some of those areas as “critical habitat” for the species, which survives in just a few ponds in Mississippi.

The dispute arose after the Fish and Wildlife Service designated 1,500-acres (607-hectares) of land and ponds in neighboring Louisiana as critical habitat for the frog even though none lived there.

Attorneys for the landowner, timber company Weyerhaeuser Co., called that an unjust land grab. But environmentalists said designating the land as critical was necessary to keeping the frog from disappearing.

The proposed definition says habitat includes “places that a species depend upon to carry out one or more life processes,” such as breeding or eating.

If the definition had been in place prior to the dispute over the gopher frog, the government might have been forced to limit its critical habitat designation to the ponds only, and not the surrounding land, said Wood.

“It gives a standard which we’ve been lacking for the past 45 years to guide critical habitat designations,” he said. “You won’t have the free-roaming critical habitat designations like you would have in the Weyerhaeuser case.”

The Trump administration ultimately withdrew the Louisiana critical habitat designation in a settlement.

Arizona Rep. Raul Grijalva, a Democrat, said if the Friday’s proposal had been in place decades ago, iconic species such as the bald eagle would not have recovered widely, and instead would be limited to scattered patches of land.

“The purpose of the Endangered Species Act is to help endangered species flourish and expand back into their former habitat.” said Grijalva, chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee.

___

Follow Matthew Brown on twitter: @matthewbrownap

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
UK's Johnson names brother and Brexiteers to House of Lords
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has named 36 new members to Parliament’s unelected House of Lords
1:54PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Wall Street slips as worries overshadow Big Tech strength
Big Tech continues to steamroll through the pandemic, but much of the rest of Wall Street is struggling on Friday, leaving stock indexes mostly lower
1:48PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Fauci optimistic COVID-19 vaccine will be widely available
Dr. Anthony Fauci has told lawmakers that once a coronavirus vaccine is approved as safe and effective, Americans should have widespread access within a reasonable time
1:44PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Oklahoma murder suspect escapes 12th floor cell using sheets
Authorities say they're seeking an escapee from the Oklahoma County jail in Oklahoma City who used sheets tied together to climb down the outside of the building from a 12th floor cell
1:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Dr. Fauci dismisses Trump tweet on virus cases
Dr. Anthony Fauci dismissed a tweet by President Donald Trump claiming the global lead in coronavirus cases is because of increased testing in the United States
1:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
Summer road trip? Quarantines are crimping some US travelers
Families trying to get in a last-minute vacation before school starts better do some homework on COVID-19 restrictions before loading up the minivan
12:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Cardinals-Brewers game postponed after 2 St. Louis positives
Friday’s game between St. Louis and Milwaukee was postponed after two Cardinals employees tested positive for the coronavirus
11:59AM ( 2 hours ago )
Judge bans lawyers from identifying Epstein abuse victims
A federal judge says lawyers for a British socialite can't publicly identify women who accuse her of participating in Jeffrey Epstein's abuse of teenagers
11:12AM ( 2 hours ago )
Portland protest scene relatively calm after US drawdown
The first nightly protest in Portland after a deal was struck for federal agents to withdraw from the city was largely peaceful after state troopers took over patrolling duties outside a federal courthouse
10:55AM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
UK's Johnson names brother and Brexiteers to House of Lords
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has named 36 new members to Parliament’s unelected House of Lords
1:54PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Wall Street slips as worries overshadow Big Tech strength
Big Tech continues to steamroll through the pandemic, but much of the rest of Wall Street is struggling on Friday, leaving stock indexes mostly lower
1:48PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Fauci optimistic COVID-19 vaccine will be widely available
Dr. Anthony Fauci has told lawmakers that once a coronavirus vaccine is approved as safe and effective, Americans should have widespread access within a reasonable time
1:44PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Harvey Updyke, 'Bama fan who poisoned trees at Auburn, dies
An overzealous University of Alabama football fan who poisoned landmark oak trees at archrival Auburn University has died
1:42PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Sleepy lions, empty bars, lost jobs: A world without tourism
A new world without mass tourism is seeing lions sleep undisturbed in South Africa, quiet at the Louvre but agonizing pain and worry for millions around the world who depend on the global industry shattered by the coronavirus
1:40PM ( 29 minutes ago )