sunny.png
Tuesday September 22nd, 2020 7:50PM

Meghan fights to keep friends anonymous in newspaper lawsuit

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LONDON (AP) — Lawyers for the Duchess of Sussex asked a judge at a London court on Wednesday to keep the names of five of her friends out of the public domain as she wages a privacy-infringement battle against a British newspaper.

Meghan's attorney said the female friends, who defended her in anonymous magazine interviews last year, are innocent parties who fear intrusion if their names come out. The target of her lawsuit, Associated Newspapers Ltd., argues that the principle of open justice — the public’s right to know — means the friends should be identified.

The former Meghan Markle is suing the publisher of the Mail on Sunday newspaper and the MailOnline website at Britain’s High Court over five articles that published portions of a handwritten letter she wrote to her estranged father, Thomas Markle, after her marriage to Prince Harry in 2018.

Meghan, 38, is seeking damages from the publisher for alleged misuse of private information, copyright infringement and data protection breaches. Her lawyers say publishing the letter was “a flagrant and unjustified intrusion into her private and family life.” Associated Newspapers says it will strongly contest the claim.

At a half-day pretrial hearing, Meghan’s lawyers asked judge Mark Warby to prohibit publishing the personal details of the friends who spoke to People magazine in early 2019 to condemn alleged bullying of the duchess by the U.K. press.

The women's names are included in a confidential court document, but they have been identified in public only as A to E.

Meghan's attorney, Justin Rushbrooke, argued that the court had a duty to “protect the identity of confidential journalistic sources.”

He said that with the full high-profile libel trial yet to begin, the court should be cautious and protect "the innocent party who fears intrusion.”

But the Mail's lawyer, Antony White, said granting anonymity would undermine the “vitally important open justice principle.”

“The friends are important potential witnesses on a key issue," White said in a written argument. He said removing their names "would be a heavy curtailment of the media’s and the defendant’s entitlement to report this case and the public’s right to know about it.”

Associated Newspapers says it was Meghan’s friends who brought the letter to Thomas Markle into the public domain by describing it in the People article. It argues that details of the letter in that article must have come “directly or indirectly” from the duchess.

But Rushbrooke said Meghan did not know at the time that her friends were speaking to the magazine. He said the anonymous interviews were arranged by one of the five friends, who was concerned about the toll media criticism was taking on the duchess, pregnant at the time with her first child.

In a witness statement submitted in the case, the duchess said “each of these women is a private citizen, young mother, and each has a basic right to privacy.”

“These five women are not on trial, and nor am I,” she wrote. “The publisher of the Mail on Sunday is the one on trial. It is this publisher that acted unlawfully and is attempting to evade accountability; to create a circus and distract from the point of this case -- that the Mail on Sunday unlawfully published my private letter.”

American actress Meghan Markle, former star of the TV legal drama “Suits,” married Queen Elizabeth II's grandson Harry in a lavish ceremony at Windsor Castle in May 2018. Their son Archie was born the following year,

In January the couple announced they were quitting royal duties and moving to North America, citing what they said was unbearable intrusion from the British media.

Neither Harry nor Meghan was in court for Wednesday's hearing. The judge said he would give his ruling “as soon as I can."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Entertainment, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Very different, symbolic hajj in Saudi Arabia amid virus
Muslim pilgrims wearing face masks and moving in small groups after days in isolation have begun arriving at Islam's holiest site in Mecca for the start of a unique and scaled-down hajj experience reshaped by the coronavirus pandemic
8:38AM ( 5 minutes ago )
The Latest: European Commission signs deal for virus drug
The European Commission says it signed a 63 million euro ($72 million) deal to secure thousands of doses of remdesavir, the only licensed experimental drug to treat people with severe COVID-19
8:24AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Troubles abound, Boeing losses bloom to $2.4 billion in 2Q
Boeing is reporting losses of $2.4 billion for the second quarter, and it's taking a more downbeat view about the airplane market because of the coronavirus outbreak
8:14AM ( 29 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Israeli artist takes aim at Netanyahu with life-size statue
Residents in the Israeli city of Tel Aviv have woken up to a jarring site: a massive installation depicting Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu enjoying a lavish meal all by himself at a sprawling 10-meter table in a mock re-enactment of the Last Supper
6:31AM ( 2 hours ago )
'Appalled' Cuomo to investigate crowded Chainsmokers concert
New York’s governor says he is “appalled” by videos showing crowds standing close together at a Hamptons concert featuring electronic music duo The Chainsmokers over the weekend
11:41PM ( 9 hours ago )
Pharrell, Beastie Boys, RZA, halftime show score Emmy nods
Grammy-winners including Pharrell Williams, the Beastie Boys and Nine Inch Nails’ Trent Reznor have a chance of winning their first-ever honors at the Emmy Awards
10:37PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Depp lawyer says Amber Heard lied during tabloid libel case
Johnny Depp’s libel case against a British tabloid that accused him of assaulting ex-wife Amber Heard has wrapped up, with Depp's lawyer claiming Heard is a “compulsive liar” who concocted allegations of abuse
2:38PM ( 18 hours ago )
Dystopian series 'Watchmen' leads all Emmy nominees with 26
HBO's limited series “Watchmen” is the leading Emmy nominee with 26 nods
2:34PM ( 18 hours ago )
'Watchmen' leads all Emmy nominees with 26
“HBO's” limited series “Watchmen” is the leading Emmy nominee with 26 nods
11:54AM ( 20 hours ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
World markets lack direction as investors await Fed
World shares are mixed as investors look to the U.S. Federal Reserve for clues about the economic outlook
7:36AM ( 1 hour ago )
Source: US, Oregon in talks about pulling agents in Portland
A senior White House official says the Trump administration has started talks with the Oregon governor’s office and indicated that it would begin to draw down the presence of federal agents in Portland if the state steps up its own enforcement
7:28AM ( 1 hour ago )
Can I get a job? Wife tries it all for nursing home reunion
When her husband's Jacksonville nursing home went on lockdown in March, Mary Daniel didn’t think it would last long
7:17AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Very different, symbolic hajj in Saudi Arabia amid virus
Muslim pilgrims wearing face masks and moving in small groups after days in isolation have begun arriving at Islam's holiest site in Mecca for the start of a unique and scaled-down hajj experience reshaped by the coronavirus pandemic
8:38AM ( 5 minutes ago )
The Latest: European Commission signs deal for virus drug
The European Commission says it signed a 63 million euro ($72 million) deal to secure thousands of doses of remdesavir, the only licensed experimental drug to treat people with severe COVID-19
8:24AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Troubles abound, Boeing losses bloom to $2.4 billion in 2Q
Boeing is reporting losses of $2.4 billion for the second quarter, and it's taking a more downbeat view about the airplane market because of the coronavirus outbreak
8:14AM ( 29 minutes ago )
The Latest: Colombian riders sent home because of virus
Three riders competing at the Vuelta a Burgos cycling race in Spain have been dropped from the event after being in contact with someone with the coronavirus
8:14AM ( 30 minutes ago )
Plant closings send GM to 2Q loss, but signs of improvement
Even though General Motors was able to reopen its U.S. factories for the last half of the second quarter, the company still lost $806 million from April through June
8:01AM ( 43 minutes ago )