sunny.png
Tuesday May 18th, 2021 10:16AM

Trump talks up his rule-cutting, but courts saying otherwise

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump is positioning himself as a champion regulation-cutter in the leadup to the Nov. 3 election, but in between his showy red-tape-cutting events, his deregulatory agenda is taking a beating in the courts.

One day, he’s hailing a massive rollback to one of the nation’s most important environmental laws, which he hopes will speed up gas pipelines and all kinds of other big projects. Another, he’s holding forth between two pickup trucks being used as props on the South Lawn of the White House — a blue one piled with weights identified as government regulations and a red one, of course, that has been unburdened.

“No other administration has done anywhere near,” Trump declared.

But there’s a sharp disconnect between the president's muscular rhetoric and the many courtroom battles he's lost.

Trump's deregulatory victories have been shrinking in number as courts uphold many of the lawsuits filed by states, environmental groups and others in response to his administration's sometimes hastily engineered rollbacks.

Just hours before Trump's South Lawn event, for example, a federal judge reinstated an Obama-era rule that required oil and gas companies operating on public lands to take reasonable measures to stop climate-damaging methane emissions.

The judge described the Trump administration’s legal groundwork to justify the rollback as “wholly inadequate” and “backwards." “An agency cannot flip-flop regulations on the whims of each new administration,″ she wrote.

The defeat was the administration's third major loss in federal courts in just one week.

“Those were three really huge major decisions all across the span ... where the Trump administration was rebuked across the board," said Vickie Patton, general counsel of the Environmental Defense Fund, who had a role in all three cases.

Bethany Davis Noll, director of New York University’s Institute for Policy Integrity, estimates the administration has emerged victorious in 15 percent of the regulatory lawsuits. Previous administrations generally won about 70 percent, she said.

To be sure, the president has had a few wins, and many important cases are not yet resolved.

Among the administration's victories: It scrapped an Obama-era regulation that imposed tougher restrictions on hydraulic “fracking” operations. Trump also signed 15 resolutions of disapproval that passed a Republican-led Congress, overturning an array of rules issued by federal agencies in the final months of Barack Obama’s presidency.

But where Trump has really made his mark is throttling back new regulations, said Cary Coglianese, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School and director of the Penn Program on Regulation.

“There’s just been much less new regulation of great consequence during the last three and a half years,” Coglianese said.

With respect to peeling back existing regulations, Coglianese finds Trump efforts to be limited and mostly aimed at undoing the work of his predecessor. That includes throwing out Obama's legacy efforts to moderate climate change by mandating far more fuel-efficient vehicles and setting the first limits on carbon pollution from U.S. power plants.

Other administration efforts would greatly weaken the scope of two laws that have served as the foundation for a half-century of public health and environmental regulation, removing federal protections for millions of miles of waterways and wetlands and reining in environmental reviews and public input for major projects.

Among modern-day presidents, Coglianese said, Democrat Jimmy Carter was probably the most impactful, deregulating the airline, trucking and railroad industries. Democrat Bill Clinton systematically got rid of outdated regulations through a reinventing government initiative.

With Trump, “there’s a lot more smoke-and-mirrors to the deregulatory picture than the administration paints,” Coglianese said. “It’s certainly not at all the driver of economic growth during the pre-COVID period of the administration and it’s certainly not enough to take us out of the economic troubles we find ourselves in.”

The president early in his administration directed agencies to scrap two regulations for every new one they create. The White House said this month that it has taken seven deregulatory actions for every significant new rule.

But even the White House’s own records reflect that many of those rule-cutting measures were minor. The ratio falls to 2 to 1 over the past two years when only significant rules are considered.

The president's pose between the two pickups was designed as a reminder to supporters — not as an overture to win over new ones — that if you distrust regulations, Trump is still your guy, said Daniel Bosch, who tracks regulatory policy at the conservative American Action Forum.

“Those folks that are driven and motivated by deregulation know that the president is committed to that,” Bosch said.

Trump also sees the regulatory issue as a chance to tie Vice President Joe Biden to the progressive wing of the Democratic Party. He argues that Biden's support for the Paris climate accord and other policies would lead to higher energy bills and job cuts.

If he wins, Biden pledges to do to Trump's regulatory record what Trump did to Obama's: obliterate it.

“We're not just going to tinker around the edges,” Biden said in recent weeks. He pledged to "reverse Trump’s rollbacks of ... public health and environmental rules and then forge a path to greater ambition.”

Trump's regulatory legacy will be greatly shaped in coming months by court rulings in lawsuits challenging some of his most potentially consequential rollbacks.

“He needs to win reelection in order to defend those rules in court, and even then I think it’s going to be a longshot to win some of those,” Noll said.

Both sides know the end game for many of the rollbacks may be in the Supreme Court — and Trump may have a chance to name more justices to the court if he wins a second term.

If it comes to that, said Patton, the environmental group lawyer, then regulatory litigation could be “generation-defining.”

—-

Knickmeyer reported from Oklahoma City. Will Weissert contributed from Washington.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Baker wins debut, Astros top M's in 1st game post sign scam
Dusty Baker posted a win in his debut as Houston’s manager and the Astros, playing for the first time since their sign-stealing scandal rocked baseball, opened the season by beating the Seattle Mariners 8-2
12:31AM ( 11 minutes ago )
In a future bomber force, old and ugly beats new and snazzy
In the topsy-turvy world of U.S. strategic bombers, older and uglier beats newer and snazzier
12:26AM ( 16 minutes ago )
South Korea reports case spike, US states tighten controls
South Korea has reported more than 100 new coronavirus cases for the first time in four months as more American states tightened anti-disease controls in response to rising infections
12:24AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
A coronavirus hot spot, South Texas braces for Hanna's rain
South Texas is bracing for Tropical Storm Hanna, which is expected to strengthen into a hurricane before making landfall
11:41PM ( 1 hour ago )
US sued over expulsion of migrant children detained in hotel
Legal groups sued the U.S. government Friday in an attempt to prevent the rapid expulsion of children that the Trump administration detained in hotel rooms under an emergency declaration citing the coronavirus
10:33PM ( 2 hours ago )
Blue Jays to play in Buffalo minor league park amid pandemic
The displaced Toronto Blue Jays will play in Buffalo, New York, this year amid the pandemic
10:31PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Judge denies Oregon's request to stop arrests by US agents
A U.S. judge denied an order sought by Oregon’s top law enforcement officer to stop federal agents from arresting people during nightly protests in Portland that have roiled the progressive city and pitted local officials against the Trump administration
6:43PM ( 6 hours ago )
Former Trump lawyer Michael Cohen released from prison again
President Donald Trump's former lawyer has been released from prison after a federal judge ruled that a move to revoke his home confinement was retaliatory
6:12PM ( 6 hours ago )
At 88, former Sheriff Joe Arpaio makes 2nd comeback bid
Joe Arpaio is trying to win back the sheriff’s post in metro Phoenix that he held for 24 years
5:47PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
The Latest: S Korea has 100+ cases for 1st time in 4 months
South Korea has reported 113 newly confirmed cases of COVID-19 over the past 24 hours — its first daily jump above 100 in nearly four months
9:53PM ( 2 hours ago )
Police: Fire at Arizona Democratic headquarters was arson
Authorities say a fire that destroyed part of the Arizona and Maricopa County Democratic Party headquarters was an act of arson
8:53PM ( 3 hours ago )
Gov't: New foreign students can't enter US if courses online
Federal immigration officials say new foreign students will be barred from entering the United States if they plan to take their classes entirely online this fall
8:43PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Montana's U.S. House race brings partisan divide to the fore
In the race for Montana’s lone U.S. House seat, Democrat Kathleen Williams is making a second attempt at retaking a seat held by Republicans since 1997
3:47PM ( 8 hours ago )
Barred presidential candidate flees Belarus, fearing arrest
An opposition candidate who planned to challenge Belarus’ longtime authoritarian leader in next month’s presidential election says he has left the country with his children, fearing arrest
1:08PM ( 11 hours ago )
In VP search, Biden has a known quantity in Susan Rice
Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden is in the final stages of selecting his running mate
12:37PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Elections
Obama blasts Trump, praises Biden in new 2020 campaign video
Joe Biden and Barack Obama are stepping up their attacks on President Donald Trump and defending their time in the White House in a new video
2:03PM ( 1 day ago )
White House scrambles on nursing homes as COVID-19 surges
President Donald Trump says his administration will provide another $5 billion to help nursing homes battle COVID-19
9:03PM ( 2 days ago )
The Latest: Trump cites protests, bars, travel in virus rise
President Donald Trump is casting wide blame for a nationwide surge in coronavirus cases, pointing to racial justice protests, travelers from Mexico and young bar-goers
6:57PM ( 2 days ago )
General Election News
Belarus: Leader threatens to expel media over election news
The longtime leader of Belarus has warned that Western media could be expelled from the country over what he described as their “tendentious” coverage of the presidential election next month in which he is seeking a sixth term
10:45AM ( 1 day ago )
Biden, Obama pair in socially distanced video to decry Trump
Joe Biden and Barack Obama are stepping up their attacks on President Donald Trump and defending their own time in the White House in a new video
10:22AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: 2 White House campus cafeterias closed by virus
Two White House campus cafeterias have been closed after a person involved in food service tested positive for the coronavirus
10:11AM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
Camps set to open after NFL, players' union reach agreement
NFL training camps are set to open after the league and the players’ union reached agreement on several issues
8:47PM ( 3 hours ago )
Vikings sign Zimmer to 3-year contract extension through '23
The Minnesota Vikings have signed head coach Mike Zimmer to a three-year contract extension through the 2023 season
7:23PM ( 5 hours ago )
Minneapolis council shifts police media duties to city staff
The Minneapolis City Council has voted to shift police media duties away from the Police Department to city communications staff
6:54PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business
With no deal to curb drug costs, Trump tries his own changes
President Donald Trump has been unable to land the big deal with Congress to curb drug costs
3:30PM ( 9 hours ago )
Q&A: What charges might longest serving US speaker face?
Federal prosecutors recently made clear that Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan is a subject of a criminal investigation into influence peddling to benefit an energy utility
2:18PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Detroit students test positive at summer school
At least two Detroit students attending summer school have tested positive for the coronavirus after a judge ordered tests as a condition for attendance in the voluntary classes
12:59PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
S&P 500 has biggest loss in nearly 4 weeks as tech stumbles
Wall Street stumbled Thursday, undercut in part by a discouraging report showing that layoffs are picking up across the country with coronavirus counts
5:01PM ( 1 day ago )
Wall Street slumps after rise in layoffs, tech weakness
Wall Street stumbled Thursday, undercut in part by a discouraging report showing that layoffs are picking up across the country with coronavirus counts
4:08PM ( 1 day ago )
Ex-utility exec pleads guilty to $1B fraud in South Carolina
An executive in charge of building two nuclear reactors in South Carolina that never generated a watt of power has pleaded guilty to fraud
1:00PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Baker wins debut, Astros top M's in 1st game post sign scam
Dusty Baker posted a win in his debut as Houston’s manager and the Astros, playing for the first time since their sign-stealing scandal rocked baseball, opened the season by beating the Seattle Mariners 8-2
12:31AM ( 12 minutes ago )
In a future bomber force, old and ugly beats new and snazzy
In the topsy-turvy world of U.S. strategic bombers, older and uglier beats newer and snazzier
12:26AM ( 17 minutes ago )
South Korea reports case spike, US states tighten controls
South Korea has reported more than 100 new coronavirus cases for the first time in four months as more American states tightened anti-disease controls in response to rising infections
12:24AM ( 19 minutes ago )
With no new law to curb drug costs, Trump tries own changes
President Donald Trump has been unable to land the big deal he sought with Congress to curb drug costs
12:18AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Inside Texas: Rangers open new park in 1-0 win over Rockies
The Texas Rangers went inside for a home game and got a 1-0 win over the Colorado Rockies
12:15AM ( 28 minutes ago )