cloudyn.png
Wednesday November 25th, 2020 11:05PM

Justices rule states can bind presidential electors' votes

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — In a decision flavored with references to “Hamilton” and “Veep,” the Supreme Court ruled unanimously Monday that states can require presidential electors to back their states’ popular vote winner in the Electoral College.

The ruling, in cases in Washington state and Colorado just under four months before the 2020 election, leaves in place laws in 32 states and the District of Columbia that bind electors to vote for the popular-vote winner, as electors almost always do anyway.

So-called faithless electors have not been critical to the outcome of a presidential election, but that could change in a race decided by just a few electoral votes. It takes 270 electoral votes to win the presidency.

A state may instruct “electors that they have no ground for reversing the vote of millions of its citizens," Justice Elena Kagan wrote in her majority opinion that walked through American political and constitutional history with an occasional nod to pop culture.

Such an order by a state "accords with the Constitution — as well as with the trust of a Nation that here, We the People rule,” Kagan wrote.

President Donald Trump has been both a critic and fan of the Electoral College.

In 2012, he tweeted, “The electoral college is a disaster for a democracy.” But in November 2016 after he won he presidency despite losing the popular vote to Hillary Clinton, he tweeted, “The Electoral College is actually genius in that it brings all states, including the smaller ones, into play.”

Monday's ruling was not about the legitimacy of the Electoral College or an ongoing effort to effectively eliminate it by having states commit to support the national popular vote winner. That proposal, sure to be challenged in the courts, wouldn't take effect unless states constituting a majority of electoral votes endorsed it.

The court acted on another issue, whether electors are free agents regardless of what voters in their states decide. The justices scheduled arguments for last spring so they could resolve the issue before this year's presidential election rather than amid a potential political crisis after the country votes.

Kagan recounted how the Constitution’s original rules for presidential electors sowed confusion because there was no distinction between votes for president and vice president. She noted that the results of the 1796 election gave President John Adams his political rival, Thomas Jefferson, as vice president, a situation Kagan called “fodder for a new season of Veep.”

Things got worse four years later when Jefferson and Aaron Burr finished in an Electoral College tie, sending the election to the House of Representatives. It took 36 ballots and the influence of Alexander Hamilton to elect Jefferson as president, Kagan wrote.

“Alexander Hamilton secured his place on the Broadway stage—but possibly in the cemetery too—by lobbying Federalists in the House to tip the election to Jefferson, whom he loathed but viewed as less of an existential threat to the Republic,” she said.

Those two elections led to the adoption of the Twelfth Amendment, which produced the Electoral College rules in use today, with separate ballots for president and vice president. “By then, everyone had had enough of the Electoral College’s original voting rules,” Kagan wrote.

The closest Electoral College margin in recent years was in 2000, when Republican George W. Bush received 271 votes to 266 for Democrat Al Gore. One elector from Washington, D.C., left her ballot blank.

When the court heard arguments by telephone in May because of the coronavirus outbreak, justices invoked fears of bribery and chaos if electors could cast their ballots regardless of the popular vote outcome in their states.

The issue arose in lawsuits filed by three Hillary Clinton electors in Washington state and one in Colorado who refused to vote for her despite her popular vote win in both states in 2016. In so doing, they hoped to persuade enough electors in states won by Trump to choose someone else and deny him the presidency.

The federal appeals court in Denver ruled that electors can vote as they please, rejecting arguments that they must choose the popular-vote winner. In Washington, the state Supreme Court upheld $1,000 fines against the three electors and rejected their claims.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Washington decision and reversed the ruling from Colorado.

In all, there were 10 faithless electors in 2016, including a fourth in Washington, a Democratic elector in Hawaii and two Republican electors in Texas. In addition, Democratic electors who said they would not vote for Clinton were replaced in Maine and Minnesota.

The closest Electoral College margin in recent years was in 2000, when Republican George W. Bush received 271 votes to 266 for Democrat Al Gore. One elector from Washington, D.C., left her ballot blank.

The Supreme Court played a decisive role in that election, ending a recount in Florida, where Bush held a 537-vote margin out of 6 million ballots cast.

The justices scheduled separate arguments in the Washington and Colorado cases after Justice Sonia Sotomayor belatedly removed herself from the Colorado case because she knows one of the plaintiffs.

In asking the Supreme Court to rule that states can require electors to vote for the state winner, Colorado had urged the justices not to wait until “the heat of a close presidential election.”

Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser, who argued his state's case at the Supreme Court, called the outcome “a win for orderly elections and our constitutional democracy.”

Reacting to the decision Monday, the lawyer for the electors who challenged the state rules said he's glad the court acted now. “Obviously, we don’t believe the Court has interpreted the Constitution correctly. But we are happy that we have achieved our primary objective — this uncertainty has been removed. That is progress,” lawyer Lawrence Lessig said.

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, U.S. News, Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, General House Election News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Coast Guard alters training for incoming class due to virus
New cadets arrive at the Coast Guard Academy this week for the basic training known as Swab Summer
10:35AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Judge orders Dakota Access pipeline shut down pending review
A federal judge has ordered the Dakota Access pipeline to shut down until more environmental review is done
10:33AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Justices rule states can bind presidential electors' votes
The Supreme Court has ruled unanimously that states can require presidential electors to back their states’ popular vote winner in the Electoral College
10:18AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
$10,000 reward offered in Atlanta killing of 8-year-old girl
The shooting death of an 8-year-old girl has prompted a $10,000 reward for information as authorities in Atlanta search for at least two people who opened fire on the car she was riding in
9:20AM ( 1 hour ago )
No more delays: What to know about the July 15 deadline
Tax procrastinators, your time is running out
8:59AM ( 1 hour ago )
Broadway veteran Nick Cordero dies from virus complications
Tributes have come pouring in for Tony Award-nominated stage actor Nick Cordero, who died of severe medical complications after contracting the coroavirus
7:30AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
Czech volunteers develop functioning lung ventilator in days
A group volunteers in the Czech Republic was working round the clock to prevent critical shortage of ventilators for COVID-19 patients, something that happened in northern Italy
4:22AM ( 6 hours ago )
'Lift Every Voice and Sing' hymn ignites hope across nation
“Lift Every Voice and Sing” was created more than a century ago
3:49AM ( 6 hours ago )
Frederick Douglass statue vandalized in Rochester park
A statue of abolitionist Frederick Douglass has been ripped from its base in Rochester on the anniversary of one of his most famous speeches
3:41AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Croatia's opposition leader stepping down after vote defeat
The leader of Croatia’s main liberal opposition party announced his resignation a day after a crushing defeat in the country’s parliamentary election held amid a coronavirus spike
8:34AM ( 2 hours ago )
US diplomat in Hong Kong says security law use a 'tragedy'
The top American diplomat in Hong Kong says it's a “tragedy” to use the semi-autonomous Chinese territory’s new national security law to chip away at “fundamental freedoms” in the Asian financial hub and create an “atmosphere of coercion and self-censorship.”
5:02AM ( 5 hours ago )
Trump to hold outdoor campaign rally in Portsmouth, N.H.
President Donald Trump is set to hold an outdoor campaign rally Saturday in Portsmouth, New Hampshire
10:29PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Dominican Republic chooses leader amid rising COVID-19 cases
The Dominican Republic is holding presidential elections that had already been delayed by the pandemic, even as the count of new infections continues to rise
7:54PM ( 14 hours ago )
The Latest: Fearing outbreak, Spain locks down county of 71K
Authorities in northwestern Spain have ordered the lockdown of a county with a population of 71,000 for fears of a coronavirus outbreak
3:39PM ( 19 hours ago )
The Latest: Mexican town residents block road to US border
Residents of the Mexican town of Sonoyta, across from Lukeville, Arizona, briefly blocked the main road leading south from the U.S. border over the weekend over fears of coronavirus outbreaks
2:37PM ( 20 hours ago )
AP Elections
Buttigieg, South Carolina mayor teaming up on COVID effort
Former South Bend, Indiana, mayor and presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg has teamed up with the mayor of South Carolina’s capital city to help municipalities stem the spread of the coronavirus
3:51PM ( 3 days ago )
LeBron James' group touts sports venues as mega-voting sites
If basketball icon LeBron James gets his way, NBA arenas and other sports venues around the country will be mega polling sites for the November general election
3:49PM ( 4 days ago )
Trump: I'll veto defense bill to keep Confederate base names
President Donald Trump is vowing to veto a massive defense bill to keep military bases such as Fort Bragg named after Confederate officers
3:33PM ( 4 days ago )
General Election News
The Latest: Pence in Florida as new virus cases hit record
Vice President Mike Pence met with Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis to discuss the coronavirus situation on the same day state health officials reported a new single-day record total of 10,000 new cases
6:01PM ( 3 days ago )
Florida felons seeking voting rights back face court setback
A federal appellate court has delivered a setback to Florida felons seeking to have their voting rights restored
7:34PM ( 4 days ago )
McGrath raises Russia bounty issue in Kentucky Senate race
Democratic Senate nominee Amy McGrath has gone on the offensive after her narrow primary win
6:13PM ( 4 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
Coast Guard alters training for incoming class due to virus
New cadets arrive at the Coast Guard Academy this week for the basic training known as Swab Summer
10:35AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Judge orders Dakota Access pipeline shut down pending review
A federal judge has ordered the Dakota Access pipeline to shut down until more environmental review is done
10:33AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Supreme Court upholds cellphone robocall ban
The Supreme Court has upheld a 1991 law that bars robocalls to cellphones
10:32AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Trump lashes out at NASCAR, Bubba Wallace over flag, rope
President Donald Trump is criticizing NASCAR for banning the Confederate flag at its races and is going after its only Black driver
10:09AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Wall Street rises again, joins worldwide upturn for markets
Stocks are pushing higher in early Monday trading on Wall Street, joining a worldwide upturn headlined by the best day for Chinese stocks in nearly five years
10:05AM ( 35 minutes ago )