mcloudy.png
Wednesday June 23rd, 2021 2:29PM

Judge sanctions Mountaire in Delaware wastewater lawsuit

By The Associated Press

DOVER, Del. (AP) — A Superior Court judge has ordered an Arkansas poultry processing company and two Delaware subsidiaries to pay more than $28,000 in sanctions for repeatedly refusing to provide information to plaintiffs suing the company over wastewater violations in southern Delaware.

The judge this week ordered Mountaire Corp. and the subsidiaries to pay $18,000 in attorneys fees to the plaintiffs and more than $10,300 for the plaintiffs’ share of billings from a special master appointed by the court to help manage the case.

Judge Craig Karsnitz noted that he had repeatedly warned attorneys on both sides about “the lack of civility which permeated the case.”

“My urging to civility has fallen on deaf ears,” Karsnitz wrote.

The ruling came in a lawsuit filed by Millsboro-area residents against Mountaire Corp., Mountaire Farms Inc. and Mountaire Farms of Delaware Inc.

The plaintiffs claim they have suffered both property damage and personal injury from wastewater discharges at Mountaire facilities in Sussex County.

The plaintiffs also have intervened in a federal lawsuit involving a proposed consent decree between Mountaire and Delaware’s Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control. The consent decree is aimed at resolving spray irrigation and land application permit violations cited by DNREC in 2017 involving Mountaire’s Millsboro facility.

Area residents argue that the consent decree is not fair, reasonable or consistent with federal environmental laws. They are seeking permission from a federal judge to obtain information about the settlement negotiations between DNREC and Mountaire.

Meanwhile, Mountaire agreed in December to pay a $420,000 penalty and upgrade its wastewater system as part of the proposed consent decree. The company also agreed to pay a $230,000 administrative penalty regarding violations at its Selbyville facility and other violations in Millsboro that are not related to the 2017 wastewater treatment system failure.

In his sanctions ruling, Karsnitz pointed to a February 2019 court decision that allowed limited information sharing in the state lawsuit to determine whether his court had jurisdiction over Mountaire Corp., and whether the plaintiffs had met the requirements for a class-action proceeding.

The two sides could not agree, however, on what information the plaintiffs were entitled to receive, including minutes of Mountaire Corp. board meetings and shareholder meetings. The special master subsequently ordered Mountaire to produce minutes from such meetings that involve the formation and operations of its facilities in Delaware.

The plaintiffs later complained of “extensive redactions” by Mountaire in documents it had provided. Mountaire was then ordered to produce unredacted copies of several documents, including meeting minutes. After seeing the unredacted documents, the plaintiffs asked for sanctions.

Karsnitz noted that “even a cursory examination” of the documents shows that they contained information that “clearly and obviously” covered relevant issues and had direct bearing on the jurisdictional issue.

“The redactions were intentional, and ... without any legal basis,” Karsnitz wrote, noting that five separate orders required Mountaire to produce the documents requested.

A spokeswoman for Mountaire Farms Inc. declined to comment on the ruling, citing a gag order that has been issued in the case.

The sanctions decision is the second ruling by Karsnitz in recent months involving a lack of information sharing in the lawsuit.

In April, the judge scolded state environmental regulators for withholding information subpoenaed by the plaintiffs’ attorneys. He rejected arguments by the Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control that the information being sought could be withheld under Delaware’s Freedom of Information Act as “investigatory files.”

DNREC also had argued that the information was subject to attorney-client privilege and was protected because it was part of settlement discussions, and that having to provide it would unduly burden the agency.

“A statutory obligation cannot be an undue burden,” the judge noted.

The information sought from DNREC included documents gathered in its investigation of Mountaire’s environmental violations and information from settlement discussions between DNREC and Mountaire.

Karsnitz noted that DNREC had an obligation under Delaware law to provide the public with information about environmental inspections, violations and enforcement actions.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Agriculture, AP Business - Poultry & Egg
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Coronavirus concerns freeze Vanilla Ice show
Vanilla Ice has indefinitely postponed a Texas concert that was drawing fierce criticism because of the coronavirus pandemic
1:55PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Epstein friend accused of recruiting girls for sex arrested
The FBI says a British socialite has been arrested on charges she helped recruit three girls to have sex with financier Jeffrey Epstein
1:48PM ( 20 minutes ago )
From big cities to backyards, July 4 not usual blowout bash
The Fourth of July was always a time for communities to come together
1:46PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Intel chiefs brief congressional leaders on Russia bounties
U.S. intelligence chiefs are conducting classified briefings for congressional leaders who have demanded more answers about an intelligence assessment that Russia offered bounties for killing U.S. troops in Afghanistan
1:01PM ( 1 hour ago )
American and 4 other airlines reach loan agreements with US
Five airlines including American Airlines have reached tentative agreements for new loans from the government to help them survive the virus pandemic
12:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
China, pro-Beijing activists condemn 'meddling' in Hong Kong
China's government and pro-Beijing activists in Hong Kong are condemning what they call foreign meddling in the territory's affairs, as countries move to offer Hong Kongers refuge and impose sanctions on China over a new security law
12:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Biden team putting together list of Black female court picks
Joe Biden says his team is putting together a list of potential options for his first Supreme Court nominee, which he has already pledged will be a Black woman
3:22PM ( 1 day ago )
Supreme Court lifts ban on state aid to religious schooling
The Supreme Court has ruled that states can’t cut religious schools out of programs that send public money to private education
1:10PM ( 2 days ago )
Supreme Court's abortion ruling raises stakes for election
Supporters of abortion rights were elated, and foes of abortion dismayed, after the Supreme Court issued its first major abortion ruling since President Donald Trump took office
10:54AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
US tries to seize Iranian gas heading toward Venezuela
U.S. federal prosecutors are seeking to seize four tankers they say are sailing toward Venezuela with 1.1 million barrels of gasoline supplied by Iran
1:17PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Analysts: Fire at Iran nuclear site hit centrifuge facility
U.S.-based analysts have told The Associated Press that they believe a fire at an Iran nuclear site struck a new centrifuge production facility
1:17PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Alaska Airlines secures loans; casinos in NJ reopening
Alaska Airlines has secured nearly $1.2 billion in private loans to further secure its financial stability
12:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Analysts: Fire at Iran nuke site hit new centrifuge facility
U.S.-based analysts have told The Associated Press that they believe a fire at an Iran nuclear site struck a new centrifuge production facility
11:06AM ( 3 hours ago )
Tesla 2Q deliveries rise over 1Q despite factory shutdown
Tesla says it delivered more electric vehicles worldwide in the second quarter than it did in the first
9:36AM ( 4 hours ago )
Fire damages building at Iran nuclear enrichment site
A fire has burned a building above Iran’s underground Natanz nuclear enrichment facility, though officials say it did not affect its centrifuge operation or cause any release of radiation
9:08AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Stocks rally on strong job gains, S&P nears week-long sweep
Wall Street is rallying Thursday after a report showed the U.S. job market continues to climb from the crater created by the coronavirus pandemic in the spring
11:00AM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump: Economy 'roaring back' after jobs report
President Donald Trump says the positive jobs report shows the U.S. economy is “roaring back” from the coronavirus
10:04AM ( 4 hours ago )
US trade deficit rises 9.7% in May to $54.6 billion
The U.S. trade deficit rose for the third straight month in May
9:27AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
The Latest: Lockdown returns to English city of Leicester
The British government has reimposed lockdown restrictions in the English city of Leicester after a spike in coronavirus infections, including the closure of shops that don’t sell essential goods and schools
4:42PM ( 2 days ago )
The Latest: Jacksonville enacts mandatory mask requirement
The city of Jacksonville, where President Trump is expected to accept the Republican nomination, enacted a mandatory mask requirement for public and indoor locations, and “in other situations where individuals cannot socially distance.”
2:41PM ( 2 days ago )
The Latest: Partial lockdown extended in German district
Authorities have extended by a week a partial lockdown in a western German district hit by a big coronavirus outbreak at a slaughterhouse
10:28AM ( 3 days ago )
AP Business - Agriculture
Families of 3 deceased workers sue Tyson over Iowa outbreak
The families of three workers who died after contracting coronavirus in an Iowa meat plant outbreak are suing Tyson Foods and its top executives, saying the company knowingly put employees at risk and lied to keep them on the job
6:38PM ( 6 days ago )
The Latest: SKorea continues upward trend in new infections
South Korea has reported 51 additional cases of the coronavirus over the past 24 hours, a continuation of an upward trend in new infections
10:23PM ( 1 week ago )
The Latest: Australia records first COVID-19 death in month
Australia has recorded its first death from COVID-19 in a month, increasing the national toll from the new coronavirus to 103
9:44PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Business - Poultry & Egg
Study: World's pile of electronic waste grows ever higher
The world’s mountain of discarded flat-screen TVs, cellphones and other electronic goods grew to a record high last year
2:02PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Coronavirus concerns freeze Vanilla Ice show
Vanilla Ice has indefinitely postponed a Texas concert that was drawing fierce criticism because of the coronavirus pandemic
1:55PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Epstein friend accused of recruiting girls for sex arrested
The FBI says a British socialite has been arrested on charges she helped recruit three girls to have sex with financier Jeffrey Epstein
1:48PM ( 21 minutes ago )
From big cities to backyards, July 4 not usual blowout bash
The Fourth of July was always a time for communities to come together
1:46PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Stocks rise on jobs data, S&P 500 nears week-long sweep
The stock market got a boost Thursday from a report showing the U.S. job market continues to climb out of the crater created by the coronavirus pandemic in the spring
1:46PM ( 22 minutes ago )