Wednesday July 15th, 2020 12:15AM

Split high court throws out Louisiana abortion clinic limit

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — A divided Supreme Court on Monday struck down a Louisiana law regulating abortion clinics, reasserting a commitment to abortion rights over fierce opposition from dissenting conservative justices in the first big abortion case of the Trump era.

Chief Justice John Roberts and his four more liberal colleagues ruled that a law that requires doctors who perform abortions must have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals violates abortion rights the court first announced in the landmark Roe v. Wade decision in 1973.

The outcome is far from the last word on the decades-long fight over abortion with dozens of state-imposed restrictions winding their way through the courts. But the decision was a surprising defeat for abortion opponents, who thought that a new conservative majority with two of President Donald Trump's appointees on board would start chipping away at abortion access.

The key vote belonged to Roberts, who had always voted against abortion rights before, including in a 2016 case in which the court struck down a Texas law that was virtually identical to the one in Louisiana.

The chief justice explained that he continues to think the Texas case was wrongly decided, but believes it’s important for the court to stand by its prior decisions.

“The result in this case is controlled by our decision four years ago invalidating a nearly identical Texas law,” Roberts wrote. He did not join the opinion written by Justice Stephen Breyer for the other liberals in Monday's decision, and his position left abortion-rights supporters more relieved than elated.

The case was t he third in two weeks in which Roberts, a George W. Bush appointee, joined the court’s liberals in the majority. One of the earlier decisions preserved the legal protections and work authorization for 650,000 immigrants who were brought to the U.S. as children. The other extended federal employment-discrimination protections to LGBT Americans, a decision that Justice Neil Gorsuch also joined and wrote.

In dissent on Monday, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote, “Today a majority of the Court perpetuates its ill-founded abortion jurisprudence by enjoining a perfectly legitimate state law and doing so without jurisdiction.”

Trump’s two high-court picks, Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, were in dissent, along with Samuel Alito. The presence of the new justices is what had fueled hopes among abortion opponents, and fears on the other side, that the Supreme Court would be more likely to uphold restrictions.

The Trump administration had sided with Louisiana in urging the court to uphold the law. White House Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany criticized the decision. “In an unfortunate ruling today, the Supreme Court devalued both the health of mothers and the lives of unborn children by gutting Louisiana’s policy that required all abortion procedures be performed by individuals with admitting privileges at a nearby hospital," McEnany said.

Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of the anti-abortion Susan B. Anthony List, said, “Today’s ruling is a bitter disappointment. It demonstrates once again the failure of the Supreme Court to allow the American people to protect the well-being of women from the tentacles of a brutal and profit-seeking abortion industry.”

On the other side, support for the decision mixed with a wariness that the future of abortion rights appears to rest with Roberts.

Nancy Northup, president and CEO of the Center for Reproductive Rights, said Monday's decision by no means ends the struggle over abortion rights in legislatures and the courts.

“We’re relieved that the Louisiana law has been blocked today but we’re concerned about tomorrow. With this win, the clinics in Louisiana can stay open to serve the one million women of reproductive age in the state. But the Court’s decision could embolden states to pass even more restrictive laws when clarity is needed if abortion rights are to be protected," Northup said.

In his reasoning, Roberts “signaled a willingness to lessen the legal protections for abortion," University of Michigan law professor Leah Litman wrote on the Take Care blog. However, she also acknowledged that Roberts' “emphasis on the importance of adhering to the Court’s prior decisions does not sound like the thinking of a person who is inclined to overrule Roe v. Wade."

A trial judge had said the law would not provide health benefits to women and would leave only one clinic open in Louisiana, in New Orleans. That would make it too hard for women to get abortions, in violation of the Constitution, the judge ruled.

But the appeals court in New Orleans rejected the judge’s findings and upheld the law in 2018, doubting that any clinics would have to close and saying that doctors had not tried hard enough to establish relationships with local hospitals.

The clinics filed an emergency appeal at the Supreme Court, asking that the law be blocked while the justices evaluated the case.

Early last year, Roberts joined with the four liberal members of the court to grant that request and keep the law on hold.

Roberts’ vote was a bit of a surprise because of his earlier vote n the Texas case. It may have reflected his new role since Justice Anthony Kennedy’s retirement as the court’s swing justice, his concern about the court being perceived as a partisan institution and his respect for a prior decision of the court, even one he disagreed with. Roberts didn’t write anything explaining his position at the time of the Texas case.

The regulations at issue in Louisiana are distinct from other state laws making their way through court challenges that would ban abortions early in a pregnancy. Those include bans on abortion once a fetal heartbeat is detected, as early as 6 weeks, and the almost total ban passed in Alabama.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Split high court throws out Louisiana abortion clinic limit
The Supreme Court has reasserted a commitment to abortion rights over fierce opposition from dissenting conservative justices in the first big abortion case of the Trump era
5:33PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Administration skips hearing on violence against protesters
The head of the U.S. Park Police has refused to appear to answer lawmakers’ questions on violence against demonstrators and journalists outside the White House
5:31PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Dr. Dre’s wife of 24 years Nicole Young files for divorce
Dr. Dre’s wife of 24 years Nicole Young has filed for divorce
5:25PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
McConnell: 'No stigma' in wearing masks for virus
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has become the highest ranking Republican in Congress to encourage Americans to wear a facial mask
4:50PM ( 59 minutes ago )
The Latest: Lockdown returns to English city of Leicester
The British government has reimposed lockdown restrictions in the English city of Leicester after a spike in coronavirus infections, including the closure of shops that don’t sell essential goods and schools
4:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
US bars defense exports to Hong Kong, says new rules coming
The Trump administration is barring defense exports to Hong Kong and will soon require licenses for the sale of items that have both civilian and military uses
4:40PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Biden campaign says 36% of senior staff are people of color
Joe Biden’s campaign says more than a third of its senior staff are people of color
8:06PM ( 1 day ago )
Appeals court: Trump wrongly diverted $2.5B for border wall
A federal appeals court has ruled against the Trump administration in its transfer of military money to build sections of the U.S. border wall with Mexico
5:56PM ( 2 days ago )
SUPREME COURT NOTEBOOK: Election-year retirement unlikely
The last time a Supreme Court justice announced his retirement in a presidential election year, most of the current justices were too young to vote
11:00AM ( 3 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
France, Germany push for rapid EU recovery plan agreement
The leaders of Germany and France say they will use their influence as European Union powerhouses to help negotiate a rapid agreement on a coronavirus recovery package for the 27-nation bloc that leaves no country behind
2:44PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Jacksonville enacts mandatory mask requirement
The city of Jacksonville, where President Trump is expected to accept the Republican nomination, enacted a mandatory mask requirement for public and indoor locations, and “in other situations where individuals cannot socially distance.”
2:41PM ( 3 hours ago )
Macron pledges billions for climate after Greens make gains
French President Emmanuel Macron, who once declared “Make The Planet Great Again” but whose climate agenda got knocked off course by persistent street protests, is under new pressure to fight climate change after the Green Party did well in Sunday’s local elections
2:09PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Health
The Latest: Giants prospect Bishop tests positive for virus
San Francisco Giants president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi says minor league center fielder Hunter Bishop has tested positive for the coronavirus
4:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
Wall Street stocks claw back a chunk of last week's losses
Stocks closed higher on Wall Street Monday, clawing back half of their losses from last week
4:43PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Marlins player without symptoms tests positive
Miami Marlins president of baseball operations Michael Hill says a player who was asymptomatic has tested positive for the coronavirus
4:39PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
U.S. officials change virus risk groups, add pregnant women
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has revamped its list of which Americans are at higher risk for severe illness from the coronavirus
5:12PM ( 4 days ago )
The Latest: WHO says outbreaks add to childbirth death risk
The head of the World Health Organization says officials are worried about the coronavirus pandemic's disproportionate toll on certain populations, including women at “heightened risk” of dying in childbirth
12:27PM ( 2 weeks ago )
The Latest: South Korea urges vulnerable people to stay home
South Korea’s top infectious disease expert has pleaded people over 65, pregnant women and other medically vulnerable individuals to stay at home as officials struggle to trace and stem the spread of the coronavirus amid increased public activity
4:19AM ( 4 weeks ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Administration skips hearing on violence against protesters
The head of the U.S. Park Police has refused to appear to answer lawmakers’ questions on violence against demonstrators and journalists outside the White House
5:31PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Dr. Dre’s wife of 24 years Nicole Young files for divorce
Dr. Dre’s wife of 24 years Nicole Young has filed for divorce
5:25PM ( 25 minutes ago )
White House: Trump not briefed on 'unverified' bounties
The White House says President Donald Trump wasn’t briefed on U.S. intelligence assessments that Russia secretly offered bounties to Taliban-linked militants for killing American troops in Afghanistan
5:22PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Dems push campaign-season health care bill through House
Democrats have pushed an election-year package expanding “Obamacare” coverage through the House
5:20PM ( 30 minutes ago )
Judge warns of possible move of trial in George Floyd death
A Minnesota judge is warning that he's likely to move the trials of four former police officers charged in George Floyd's death out of Minneapolis if public officials and attorneys continue speaking out about the case
5:15PM ( 35 minutes ago )