clearn.png
Saturday July 11th, 2020 10:45PM

SUPREME COURT NOTEBOOK: Election-year retirement unlikely

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — The last time a Supreme Court justice announced his retirement in a presidential election year, most of the current justices were too young to vote.

It was 1968, and things didn't work out as planned. The nomination to replace Chief Justice Earl Warren failed in that turbulent year, and no justice has retired in an election year since.

The pattern is not likely to be broken in 2020, despite persistent chatter that Justice Clarence Thomas could give President Donald Trump a seat to fill before the election.

Retirements have tended to be announced in June, as Justice Anthony Kennedy did in 2018. But the conservative Thomas has made clear to anyone who has asked, including an interviewer last year, that he has no plans to retire.

“Let’s fast forward to 20 years from now. Twenty years from now, at your retirement party,” his interviewer, Pepperdine University law professor James Gash, began.

“I’m not retiring,” Thomas broke in to say.

“Twenty years?” Gash said.

“No,” Thomas said.

“Thirty years?” Gash followed.

“No,” Thomas said.

The 72-year-old Georgia native is the longest-serving justice on the current court. If he serves another eight years, he would eclipse the service of record-holding Justice William O. Douglas, whose tenure lasted 36 years and nearly 8 months.

If Thomas does stay that long, he'll only be 80 — younger than Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer are today.

In 1968, Warren announced his retirement, but it didn't take effect until the Senate confirmed his successor. President Lyndon Johnson quickly named Justice Abe Fortas for the job. The president also nominated a federal judge and friend from Texas, Homer Thornberry, for Fortas' seat.

It didn't go well for Fortas, whose nomination was blocked by Republicans and conservative Democrats in the Senate. Thornberry never got a vote either, once it became clear Fortas wasn't moving up.

When Richard Nixon won the 1968 election, he got a bonus, the opportunity to select a chief justice who would be nothing like the liberal Warren. The outgoing chief justice served another year, until Warren Burger took the oath of office in June 1969.

The only other vacancy that has occurred in an election year since was in 2016, when Justice Antonin Scalia died. President Barack Obama named Merrick Garland to fill the seat and Senate Republicans refused to act on the nomination.

When Trump shocked the nation by winning the presidency, he too had a seat to fill and quickly named Justice Neil Gorsuch.

___

Enough of things that are not likely to happen.

For the first time in 24 years, the court's work is almost certain to extend into July, mainly a product of the court's response to the coronavirus pandemic.

The justices heard arguments by telephone in 10 cases in May, after closing the building to the public in mid-March and abandoning most in-person activities for a court in which 6 of the 9 justices are 65 and older, and most at risk of serious complications from COVID-19.

None of those cases has been decided yet, and the justices still have pending three earlier cases, including one dealing with abortion clinic regulations in Louisiana. More opinions are expected Monday and Tuesday, the last day in June.

Thomas, Ginsburg and Breyer were the only three justices who were on the court the last time it didn't finish issuing opinions in June. That was in 1996, when the court held on July 1 that the government could be sued by once-healthy savings and loans that were forced into the red as part as the congressional response to the S&L crisis of the 1980s.

Charles Cooper, who argued the S&Ls' case at the Supreme Court, recalled that a resolution was urgently needed “because scores of copy-cat cases had been clogging" court dockets for years.

The court also issued opinions in July a few years earlier, in 1989. That July, the court struck down a nativity display inside a government building in Pittsburgh, while upholding a menorah erected outside a different public building in Pittsburgh. The next day, the justices upheld or allowed to take effect several abortion restrictions in Missouri.

When Burger was chief justice, from 1969 to 1986, the court routinely kept working into July, even past Independence Day.

Adam Feldman, the creator of the Empirical Scotus blog, provided the data cited above.

___

Another reason there is no special urgency to finishing up by the end of June is that the justices have nowhere to go this year.

The last decisions of the term typically are followed closely by flights to very desirable locations, in the Alps, the Rockies, European capitals, even “an island fortress" in the Mediterranean, as Chief Justice John Roberts described Malta before heading there on the heels of his opinion saving the heart of the Affordable Care Act in 2012.

The law schools that usually are thrilled to snag a justice to teach for a week or two in a study-abroad program all canceled their summer sessions this year because of the coronavirus outbreak.

“I think we have reason to believe no one needs to jet off to Europe,” Supreme Court lawyer Paul Clement said, joking that the term could last to August 10 at the current pace of decisions.

___

Associated Press writer Jessica Gresko contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Governors who quickly reopened backpedal as virus surges
An alarming resurgence of coronavirus infections across the country has some governors retreating to measures they previously resisted
9:09AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Spacewalking astronaut loses mirror, newest space junk
A spacewalking astronaut has added to the millions of pieces of junk orbiting the Earth
9:08AM ( 6 minutes ago )
The Latest: Germany's Merkel calls city leader with outbreak
Chancellor Angela Merkel’s spokesman is calling on Germans to show “respect and sympathy” to people in areas where there have been new coronavirus outbreaks
8:52AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Pentagon chief seeks to reassure NATO over US troop plans
U.S. Defense Secretary Mark Esper is trying to reassure NATO allies that Washington will consult them on any future troop movements, after President Donald Trump surprised his partners by announcing the withdrawal of thousands of personnel from Germany
8:14AM ( 1 hour ago )
US police registry would fail without changes in states
Without major changes in almost every state, a national police misconduct database like what the White House and Congress have proposed after George Floyd’s death would fail to account for thousands of problem officers
8:13AM ( 1 hour ago )
Nebraska Democrats struggle with 'dumpster fire' reputation
Democrats in Nebraska are struggling for relevance in their Republican-dominated state, and a series of high-profile embarrassments is only making it harder
7:50AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
House passes sweeping police overhaul after Floyd's death
The House has approved a far-reaching policing overhaul from Democrats
12:14AM ( 9 hours ago )
Despite pandemic, Trump administration urges end to ACA
The Trump administration is urging the Supreme Court to overturn the Affordable Care Act in the midst of the coronavirus pandemic
11:02PM ( 10 hours ago )
Ex-UN human rights chief calls for Hong Kong special envoy
The United Nations’ former human rights chief and eight former U.N. special envoys have urged the body’s secretary-general to appoint a special envoy on Hong Kong
9:28PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Justices rule for Trump administration in deportation case
The Supreme Court has ruled that the Trump administration can deport some people seeking asylum without allowing them to make their case to a federal judge
11:03AM ( 22 hours ago )
Senate approves 200th federal judge nominated by Trump
The Senate has approved the nomination of a Mississippi judge to a federal appeals court
5:52PM ( 1 day ago )
2 Republicans opposed by Trump win in N. Carolina, Kentucky
Voters have rebuffed President Donald Trump and nominated two Republicans he opposed to House seats from North Carolina and Kentucky
11:17AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Biden, Trump stage rare dueling events in pandemic era
Both President Donald Trump and Democrat Joe Biden are swinging through key battleground states on Thursday
2:50PM ( 18 hours ago )
Campaigning finds a new normal as door-knocking resumes
The coronavirus pandemic isn't going away anytime soon, but political campaigns are forging ahead with in-person organizing
2:43PM ( 18 hours ago )
House Democrats push toward policing vote, challenge Senate
With a policing overhaul stalled in the Senate, House Democrats have returned to Washington for a daylong debate and vote on their package of law enforcement changes
1:38PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Elections
Q&A: Harris says Democrats need to listen to young voters
California Sen. Kamala Harris says Democrats “need to listen" to young black and Latino voters demanding change
1:47PM ( 1 day ago )
Populist Polish president faces tough reelection challenge
Poland's populist President Andrzej Duda is facing a tough challenge as he seeks reelection Sunday despite the devoted support of many Poles in conservative rural regions
7:55AM ( 2 days ago )
Populist Polish president faces tough re-election challenge
Poland's populist President Andrzej Duda is facing a tough challenge as he seeks re-election Sunday despite the devoted support of many Poles in conservative rural regions
5:21AM ( 2 days ago )
General Election News
Democrats confirm plans for nearly all-virtual convention
Democrats plan to hold an almost entirely virtual presidential nominating convention Aug. 17-20 in Milwaukee using live broadcasts and online streaming
6:16PM ( 1 day ago )
Icons of 1960s civil rights movement voice cautious optimism
Bob Moses says America is at “a lurching moment” for racial change, potentially as transforming as the Civil War era and the 1960s civil rights movement that he helped lead
11:54AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Gade wins Virginia Republican Senate primary
Virginia Republicans have picked Daniel Gade to be their nominee and face off against incumbent Mark Warner for a Senate seat later this year
7:31PM ( 2 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
Governors who quickly reopened backpedal as virus surges
An alarming resurgence of coronavirus infections across the country has some governors retreating to measures they previously resisted
9:09AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Spacewalking astronaut loses mirror, newest space junk
A spacewalking astronaut has added to the millions of pieces of junk orbiting the Earth
9:08AM ( 6 minutes ago )
The Latest: Germany's Merkel calls city leader with outbreak
Chancellor Angela Merkel’s spokesman is calling on Germans to show “respect and sympathy” to people in areas where there have been new coronavirus outbreaks
8:52AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Asia Today: India's cases spike again to near half-million
India has neared half a million coronavirus cases with its biggest 24-hour spike of 17,296 new infections
8:43AM ( 32 minutes ago )
US consumer spending up 8.2%, partly erasing record plunge
American consumers increased their spending by a sharp 8.2% in May, partly erasing record plunges the previous two months, against the backdrop of an economy that’s likely shrinking by its steepest pace on record this quarter
8:38AM ( 36 minutes ago )