Sunday May 31st, 2020 12:45AM

Judge rules that Oregon virus restrictions are invalid

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SALEM, Ore. (AP) — A judge in rural Oregon on Monday tossed out statewide coronavirus restrictions imposed by Democratic Gov. Kate Brown, saying she didn’t seek the Legislature's approval to extend the stay-at-home orders beyond a 28-day limit.

Baker County Circuit Judge Matthew Shirtcliff issued his opinion in response to a lawsuit filed earlier this month by 10 churches around Oregon that argued the state's social-distancing directives were unconstitutional.

Brown filed paperwork within hours seeking an emergency review by the Oregon Supreme Court and a hold on the ruling until the high court could take it up. Her attorneys had asked the judge to stay his ruling until that time, but he declined.

In a statement, Brown said: “The science behind these executive orders hasn’t changed one bit. Ongoing physical distancing, staying home as much as possible, and wearing face coverings will save lives across Oregon."

Scott Erickson, chief pastor of one of the churches behind the lawsuit, is waiting to see what the Supreme Court does before making any move to open the doors. Currently, his Peoples Church in Salem, Oregon, has drive-in church, with worshippers tuning in service on their radios from the parking lot, and livestreaming.

“We're going to wait until there's finality,” he said in a phone interview.

If the judge's ruling stands, Erickson's church, which 3,700 people normally attend regularly, will change its ways, the pastor said. It will adhere to 6-foot (2-meter) distancing, every other row would be empty and anything that people touch, like chairs and pews, would be wiped down before each service.

"It would certainly impact our capacity, but that’s where we’re at on this,” Erickson said.

In a seven-page opinion, Shirtcliff wrote that the damage to Oregonians and their livelihood was greater than the dangers presented by the coronavirus. He also noted that other businesses deemed essential, such as grocery stores, had been allowed to remain open even with large numbers of people present and have relied on masks, social distancing and other measures to protect the public.

“The governor’s orders are not required for public safety when plaintiffs can continue to utilize social distancing and safety protocols at larger gatherings involving spiritual worship,” he wrote.

Courts in other states have ruled against similar orders. The Wisconsin Supreme Court struck down Gov. Tony Evers’ stay-at-home order last week, ruling that his administration overstepped its authority when it extended the order for another month without consulting legislators.

A federal judge in North Carolina on Saturday sided with conservative Christian leaders and blocked the enforcement of restrictions that Gov. Roy Cooper ordered affecting indoor religious services during the pandemic.

The order from Judge James C. Dever III came days after two churches, a minister and a Christian revival group filed a federal lawsuit seeking to immediately block enforcement of rules covering religious services within the Democratic governor’s executive orders.

In Louisiana, however, a federal judge refused a minister’s request to temporarily halt Gov. John Bel Edwards’ stay-at-home order, which expired that same day.

The ruling in Oregon turns on the legal mechanism Brown used to issue her orders. The plaintiffs allege — and the judge agreed — that they were issued under a statute pertaining to public health emergencies, not an older provision that addresses natural disasters such as storms, earthquakes or floods.

The public health statute contains the 28-day time limit, while the other would give Brown broader powers but is not relevant in the current situation, said Kevin Mannix, who is representing business owners in the case.

California, Washington state and New York — other states where governors have repeatedly extended coronavirus restrictions — give their governors more power in public health emergencies, but Oregon law puts a specific clock on those “extraordinary powers,” he said.

“Maybe other states will take a lesson from us in the future about what to do about public health emergencies,” Mannix said. “We've thought about it, we've balanced the powers of the governor with the powers of the people and their representatives.”

Brown declared a statewide state of emergency due to the virus on March 8 and has issued multiple executive orders since then, including the closure of all schools, non-essential businesses and a ban on dine-in service at restaurants and bars.

Earlier this month, Brown extended the order another 60 days until July 6. All but a handful of Oregon counties, however, got the state's approval to begin loosening those restrictions last Friday.

Oregon Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum urged residents to abide by the stay-at-home orders while the ruling is appealed.

“We will argue that the judge erred in his construction of the relevant statutes and that he abused his discretion in issuing the preliminary injunction,” she said in a statement.

The top Republican in the Oregon House applauded the judge’s ruling but cautioned people to continue to follow federal guidelines so as not to undo the progress the state has made against the virus.

“This ruling will be appealed but the need for the governor to create the least possible harm in the exercise of extraordinary power remains, "she said.

Attorney Ray Hacke, who represented the plaintiffs in the case, said the ruling was a vindication not just for freedom of religion, but for all freedoms of people in the state.

“Praise God. I’m excited, and I’m glad that the judge saw that there are limitations on the governor’s power, even in the midst of emergencies,” he said. “If people want to get their haircut, they can. They can leave their home for any reason whether it’s deemed essential in the eye of the state or not.”


Flaccus reported from Portland, Oregon.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Judge rules that Oregon virus restrictions are invalid
A judge in rural Oregon has declared Gov. Kate Brown’s coronavirus restrictions “null and void” statewide because she didn’t have her emergency orders approved by the Legislature
5:04PM ( 20 minutes ago )
California relaxes some county criteria for reopening
California is relaxing some of its reopening criteria and that could mean most of the state may soon be offering services such as dining at restaurants
4:52PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Outside judge named to preside over cases in Arbery slaying
An outside judge has been appointed to oversee the cases of a Georgia father and son charged in the fatal shooting of Ahmad Arbery
4:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
U.S. News
Who got what? Details scant on small-business relief effort
A small, overlooked federal agency is shouldering a massive relief effort for the nation’s small businesses and their workers punched by the pandemic
5:06PM ( 18 minutes ago )
The Latest: NASCAR’s Pocono races might be run without fans
Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf says NASCAR can hold its races at Pocono Raceway in late June if the coronavirus situation improves in the area, but the races might have to go off without fans
5:06PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Devils' Schneider: NHL players concerned as pause lingers
Veteran NHL goaltender Cory Schneider says a growing number of players are concerned the league will announce a “drop-dead” deadline for returning to play
4:56PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US autoworkers return, while possible vaccine shows promise
More than 130,000 autoworkers returned to factories across the U.S. in one of the biggest steps yet to restart American industry, while an experimental vaccine against the coronavirus showed encouraging results in an extremely small and preliminary study
4:36PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Local leaders resist Mexico president's push for reopening
Local governments across Mexico pushed back against President Andrés Manuel López Obrador’s call to reopen the economy in some 300 townships that do not have active cases of coronavirus
4:26PM ( 59 minutes ago )
Ken Osmond, Eddie Haskell on 'Leave It to Beaver,' dies
Ken Osmond, who played the two-faced teenage scoundrel Eddie Haskell on TV’s “Leave it to Beaver,” has died
4:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
High court allows bigger award in 1998 embassy bombings case
The Supreme Court is allowing a bigger award of money to victims of the 1998 bombings by al-Qaida of the U.S. embassies in Nairobi, Kenya, and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
4:01PM ( 1 hour ago )
Barr says he doesn't envision investigations of Biden, Obama
Attorney General William Barr says he does not expect investigations into the origins of the FBI’s Russia investigation to lead to criminal probes into either President Donald Trump’s Democratic opponent, Joe Biden, or former President Barack Obama
3:37PM ( 1 hour ago )
Sweeping federal lawsuit seeks election changes in Wisconsin
Advocates for people with disabilities and minority voters in Wisconsin have filed a sweeping federal lawsuit seeking changes to ensure the August primary and November presidential election can be held safely amid the coronavirus pandemic
3:33PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Hong Kong lawmakers clash as pro-Beijing camp elects chair
Clashes have broken out in Hong Kong’s legislature for a second time this month as a pro-Beijing lawmaker was elected as chair of a key committee that scrutinizes bills
7:31AM ( 9 hours ago )
With no leader, commission overseeing virus relief struggles
It's been seven weeks since Congress unleashed more than $2 trillion to help deal with the coronavirus crisis, and seven weeks since lawmakers created an oversight commission that's supposed to keep track of how all that money is spent
8:12AM ( 1 day ago )
Israel finally set to swear in government after 3 elections
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is finally swearing in his new government after three deadlocked and divisive elections, a year and a half of political paralysis and another three-day delay because of political infighting in his Likud party over coveted Cabinet posts
7:35AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Congress News
California relaxes some county criteria for reopening
California is relaxing some of its reopening criteria and that could mean most of the state may soon be offering services such as dining at restaurants
4:52PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Outside judge named to preside over cases in Arbery slaying
An outside judge has been appointed to oversee the cases of a Georgia father and son charged in the fatal shooting of Ahmad Arbery
4:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
Feds urge 'extreme caution' for reopening nursing homes
Federal authorities aren’t setting any hard dates for when nursing homes can allow family members to visit again but are urging governors to use “extreme caution” in making that decision
4:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
Missouri officers accused of assaulting black woman, son
A lawsuit accuses four white suburban St. Louis police officers of brutalizing a 68-year-old black woman and her adult son after wrongly accusing them of stealing a television
4:14PM ( 1 hour ago )
Tropical Storm Arthur hits North Carolina coast with rain
Tropical Storm Arthur began moving away from the North Carolina coast Monday after dumping heavy rain as forecasters warned that the first named storm of the Atlantic hurricane season could also bring life-threatening surf and rip currents along the U.S. East Coast
2:58PM ( 2 hours ago )