clearn.png
Sunday May 31st, 2020 12:58AM

Georgia high court upholds canceling of judicial election

By The Associated Press

ATLANTA (AP) — Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger cannot be forced to hold an election that was scheduled for a seat on the state Supreme Court that will become vacant with the resignation of a current justice, the Georgia Supreme Court ruled on Thursday.

Justice Keith Blackwell was up for reelection in May, but announced before the election that he would resign in November.

His decision to resign was irrevocable once accepted by Gov. Brian Kemp, and under Georgia’s Constitution, such vacancies on the state’s high court are filled by the governor, not by voters in an election, the state Supreme Court said in a 6-2 ruling.

An election for a new six-year term of office for Blackwell's seat would be “legally meaningless” and “misleading to voters and the public” because when Blackwell resigns in November, that six-year term will go with him, state Supreme Court Presiding Justice David E. Nahmias said for the majority. Instead, Kemp will get to appoint someone for a new, shortened term before that justice goes before voters.

“To the extent that the judicial selection system is subject to the possibility of manipulation by the relevant officials (as almost all government systems are), the checks against such machinations come in forms other than courts altering the Constitution by judicial fiat," Nahmias wrote.

Blackwell in February submitted a letter to Kemp saying he was resigning from the court on November 18. Kemp, a Republican, accepted his resignation and told Raffensperger he would appoint a replacement, prompting the secretary of state to cancel the election for Blackwell's seat.

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Brenda Holbert Trammell said the majority was ruling that the “appointment power of the Governor trumps the voting power of the public.” She noted that the election would have preceded Blackwell’s resignation in November and that the court was in agreement that the governor could not appoint a new justice until Blackwell officially resigned.

“This ruling means that even were the election to go forward and a winner be declared, the appointee defeats the electee,” she said.

John Barrow, a former Democratic congressman from Athens, and former Republican state lawmaker Beth Beskin of Atlanta had both planned to challenge Blackwell in the election. After they were denied the opportunity to qualify for the election, they each filed separate lawsuits saying the cancellation was illegal and asking a judge to order Raffensperger to put the election back on the calendar and allow candidates to qualify.

In a statement Thursday, Barrow accused the majority of misinterpreting the state Constitution and said Kemp and Blackwell had “manipulated” the election.

Beskin has since qualified to challenge another sitting justice after her attempt to challenge Blackwell was denied.

She said the state Supreme Court ruling validated some of her legal arguments.

“We now have much clearer guidance going forward about election law and the power of the governor to appoint in vacancies,” she said.

The ruling upheld a March decision by Fulton County Superior Court Judge Emily Richardson.

Five of the state Supreme Court’s justices recused themselves from participating in the case, and a seat vacated earlier this month by former Justice Robert Benham remains empty. Chief Justice Harold Melton, Nahmias and Justice Sarah Warren did not recuse themselves. Five judges from other courts were appointed to hear the cases in the place of the nonparticipating justices.

The failure of the three justices to recuse themselves tainted the ruling, Barrow in his statement.

“No judge should have an interest in deciding a case," he said.

  • Associated Categories: Local/State News, Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Online - Georgia News, AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: President vows to build health stockpile
President Donald Trump says he's intent on building the nation’s stockpile of ventilators, masks and other equipment to meet future health threats
4:07PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Stocks shake off some early stumbles and end broadly higher
The stock market ended a choppy day higher as a turnaround by banks and energy companies helped end a two-day losing streak
4:07PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Appeals court reinstates lawsuit over Trump's hotel profits
A federal appeals court has revived a lawsuit accusing President Donald Trump of illegally profiting off the presidency through his luxury Washington hotel
3:59PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Karen Pence: 'It's OK to not be OK' during pandemic
Karen Pence says it’s OK to not be OK during the coronavirus pandemic
3:30PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Virus tests hospitals in pockets of US as some states reopen
Coronavirus outbreaks are testing the public health networks in pockets of the U.S., while some states prepare to lift lockdown measures, seeing signs of progress
3:30PM ( 48 minutes ago )
3 million more US layoffs intensify fears of lasting damage
Nearly 3 million laid-off workers applied for U.S. unemployment benefits last week as the viral outbreak led more companies to slash jobs even though most states have begun to let some businesses reopen under certain restrictions
3:22PM ( 55 minutes ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Ex-judge asked to evaluate whether to hold Flynn in contempt
The judge presiding over Michael Flynn’s case has appointed a retired jurist to evaluate whether the former national security adviser should be held in criminal contempt
7:48PM ( 20 hours ago )
Supreme Court appears likely to reject Trump immunity claim
The Supreme Court appears likely to reject President Donald Trump’s claim that he is immune from criminal investigation while in office
3:56PM ( 2 days ago )
Supreme Court divided over Trump tax, bank records
The Supreme Court has concluded arguments over President Donald Trump’s bid to keep his tax, bank and financial records private
2:15PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Next up: Women's pole vaulters take turn in Garden Clash
Three of the leading women’s pole vaulters will compete in the second edition of the Ultimate Garden Clash
2:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
New refugees struggle to find footing in US during pandemic
Starting a new life in the U.S. is never easy for refugees, but doing it during a pandemic has created more struggles
3:57PM ( 1 day ago )
Georgia, Tech, Georgia State to meet in men's basketball
Georgia Tech and Georgia State have announced a three-game men’s basketball series between the city rivals
1:17PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online - Georgia News
The Latest: President vows to build health stockpile
President Donald Trump says he's intent on building the nation’s stockpile of ventilators, masks and other equipment to meet future health threats
4:07PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Appeals court reinstates lawsuit over Trump's hotel profits
A federal appeals court has revived a lawsuit accusing President Donald Trump of illegally profiting off the presidency through his luxury Washington hotel
3:59PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Reopening on track for swaths of central, northern New York
New York's governor says large swaths of central and northern the state are poised to reopen Friday, and he's urging businesses to prepare safety plans
3:53PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Atlanta zoo to reopen its outdoor exhibits amid virus crisis
Atlanta's zoo plans to reopen soon as more Georgia businesses attempt to get back to normal amid the coronavirus outbreak
3:51PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Men accused in coastal Georgia shooting hire attorneys
Attorneys for two white men accused in the shooting death of a black man they pursued through a subdivision in coastal Georgia city are asking for people not to rush to judgment
3:47PM ( 30 minutes ago )