sunny.png
Wednesday June 3rd, 2020 8:28AM

Justices fear 'chaos' if states can't bind electors' votes

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — Supreme Court justices invoked fears of bribery and chaos Wednesday to suggest they think states can require presidential electors to back their states’ popular vote winner in the Electoral College.

The justices heard arguments on an unusual voting issue that could have important consequences for the 2020 presidential election in an era of intense political polarization.

A focus of the questions was whether states can replace electors who decide to vote for someone other than the state popular vote winner. If they can't, “it would lead to chaos," Justice Samuel Alito said, “where the popular vote is close and changing just a few votes would alter the outcome."

Justice Clarence Thomas asked, “Can a state remove someone, for example, who openly solicits payments for his or her vote?”

Wednesday was the court's final day of arguments by telephone in May, with livestreamed audio, and dealt with whether presidential electors are bound to support popular-vote winners in their states or can opt for someone else. Arguments had been scheduled for the courtroom in April but were postponed because of the coronavirus pandemic.

So-called faithless electors have not been critical to the outcome of a presidential election, but that could change in a contest with a razor-thin margin.

Thirty-two states and the District of Columbia require presidential electors to vote for the popular-vote winner, and electors almost always do so anyway. Under the Constitution, the country elects the president indirectly, with voters choosing people who actually cast an Electoral College ballot for president. It takes 270 votes to win.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said people become electors by pledging to support a candidate. What troubled her, Ginsburg said, was, “I made a promise to do something, but that promise is unenforceable."

The issue arose in lawsuits filed by three Hillary Clinton electors in Washington state and one in Colorado who refused to vote for her despite her popular vote win in both states. In so doing, they hoped to persuade enough electors in states won by Donald Trump to choose someone else and deny Trump the presidency.

The federal appeals court in Denver ruled that electors can vote as they please, rejecting arguments that they must choose the popular-vote winner. In Washington, the state Supreme Court upheld a $1,000 fine against the three electors and rejected their claims.

In all, there were 10 faithless electors in 2016, including a fourth in Washington, a Democratic elector in Hawaii and two Republican electors in Texas. In addition, Democratic electors who said they would not vote for Clinton were replaced in Maine and Minnesota.

Harvard Law School professor Lawrence Lessig, who favors broad reforms to voting, redistricting and the way campaigns are funded, represented the Washington electors at the Supreme Court. Lessig briefly sought the 2016 Democratic nomination and called for presidential electors to support Clinton because she won the national popular vote four years ago.

Lessig warned that binding electors could open the door to other restrictions, including denying electoral votes to candidates who don’t visit their states or fail to release their tax returns.

The Campaign Legal Center, which also supports campaign finance and redistricting reforms, warned in a legal filing that a high court ruling that electors are free agents creates the “possibility that presidential campaigns and outside groups could direct large sums of money to crucial or wavering electors."

The closest Electoral College margin in recent years was in 2000, when Republican George W. Bush received 271 votes to 266 for Democrat Al Gore. One elector from Washington, D.C., left her ballot blank.

The Supreme Court played a decisive role in that election, ending a recount in Florida, where Bush held a 537-vote margin out of 6 million ballots cast.

The justices scheduled separate arguments in the Washington and Colorado cases after Justice Sonia Sotomayor belatedly removed herself from the Colorado case because she knows one of the plaintiffs.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Political Conventions, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Justices fear 'chaos' if states can't bind electors' votes
Supreme Court justices invoked fears of bribery and chaos to suggest they think states can require presidential electors to back their states’ popular vote winner in the Electoral College
1:30PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Nassar-related case dismissed against ex-university chief
A judge has dismissed criminal charges against former Michigan State University President Lou Anna Simon arising from the Larry Nassar sexual assault scandal
1:25PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Justices hear election year cases over 'faithless electors'
Supreme Court justices are invoking fears of bribery and chaos to suggest they think states can require presidential electors to back their states’ popular vote winner in the Electoral College
1:20PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
AP Courtside: Supreme Court hangs up on phone arguments
The Supreme Court has hung up the phone
12:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
California GOP dream: Party poised to win US House seat
A former Navy combat pilot has a double-digit lead in the fight for an open U.S. House seat north of Los Angeles, positioning Republicans to capture a Democratic-held congressional district in California for the first time in over two decades
12:19PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Interview: Pelosi: Americans 'worth it' on $3T virus aid
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi defended the stunning $3 trillion price of tag of Democrats’ pandemic relief package Wednesday as what’s needed to confront the “villainous virus” and economic collapse
12:10PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
AP Courtside: Kavanaugh cites 'chaos' in electors case
Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh says he would apply the “avoid chaos principle of judging.”
11:59AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Courtside: Professor, solicitor general in phone argument
The attorneys speaking before the Supreme Court on its last scheduled day of phone arguments include a professor and a state solicitor general
11:04AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Courtside: Phone arguments on electors who shun Clinton
The Supreme Court has started the final day of arguments it has scheduled to hear by telephone because of the coronavirus pandemic
10:01AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Elections
Trump-backed Tiffany wins Wisconsin congressional race
A Republican endorsed by President Donald Trump has easily won a special congressional election in a heavily conservative rural Wisconsin district
10:57PM ( 14 hours ago )
Nebraska primary voters avoid polls, shatter mail-in record
Nebraska’s primary voters mostly steered clear of polling sites Tuesday while shattering the state record for absentee voting with nearly 400,000 mail-in ballots in the midst of the coronavirus pandemic
10:44PM ( 14 hours ago )
Biden plans to stay home, testing limits of virtual campaign
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden has no foreseeable plans to resume in-person campaigning amid a pandemic that is testing whether a national election can be won by a candidate communicating almost entirely from home
9:50PM ( 15 hours ago )
General Election News
Supreme Court divided over Trump tax, bank records
The Supreme Court has concluded arguments over President Donald Trump’s bid to keep his tax, bank and financial records private
2:15PM ( 23 hours ago )
Supreme Court hearing clash over Trump tax, bank records
The Supreme Court is taking up President Donald Trump’s bid to keep his tax, bank and financial records private
12:02PM ( 1 day ago )
Democrats set to take next steps toward virtual convention
Democrats are making new moves toward a virtual presidential nominating convention this August
10:24AM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
The Latest: Singapore loosens coronavirus restrictions
Singaporeans will be able to get a haircut at the barber or pop in to their favorite bakery as the government loosens coronavirus restrictions three weeks before a partial lockdown ends
1:14AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: South Korea reports 27 new coronavirus cases
South Korea has reported 27 new cases of the coronavirus in the past 24 hours
12:15AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: China reports 1 new coronavirus case
China reported just one new coronavirus case Tuesday as the government presses ahead with re-opening measures, including allowing Beijing middle school senior students to return to class and Shanghai Disneyland to open its gates again to a limited number of visitors
9:45PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Political Conventions
Trump casts doubt on mail voting. His campaign promotes it.
President Donald Trump's reelection campaign is helping Republican voters cast their ballots through the mail even as the president calls the process unreliable
12:15AM ( 1 day ago )
Pandemic creates electoral uncertainty for Trump, Democrats
President Donald Trump’s reelection is facing growing headwinds less than six months before Election Day
7:29AM ( 2 days ago )
Flynn dismissal a surprise? AG Barr in sync with Trump
President Donald Trump has made no secret that he thought former national security adviser Michael Flynn was treated unfairly by federal investigators
12:11AM ( 4 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Nassar-related case dismissed against ex-university chief
A judge has dismissed criminal charges against former Michigan State University President Lou Anna Simon arising from the Larry Nassar sexual assault scandal
1:25PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Justices hear election year cases over 'faithless electors'
Supreme Court justices are invoking fears of bribery and chaos to suggest they think states can require presidential electors to back their states’ popular vote winner in the Electoral College
1:20PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Dispute over reopening California Tesla factory may be over
A dispute between Tesla and San Francisco Bay Area authorities over the reopening of a factory in the face of coronavirus shutdown orders may be coming to an end
1:19PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Common's #WeMatterToo push urges jail releases amid virus
Grammy and Academy Award winning rapper Common and his criminal justice reform organization Imagine Justice has launched a campaign with dozens of advocacy and activist groups calling attention to the threat coronavirus poses on millions of people jailed or imprisoned in the U.S. The campaign is dubbed #WeMatterToo
1:14PM ( 20 minutes ago )
US says Chinese hackers might be targeting virus researchers
The FBI and the Department of Homeland Security’s cyber division are warning that hackers backed by the Chinese government may be attempting to steal the work of researchers dealing with the response to the coronavirus pandemic
1:06PM ( 28 minutes ago )