sunny.png
Saturday March 28th, 2020 8:01PM

As outbreak blows up finances, a limit to EU solidarity

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BRUSSELS (AP) — The European Union is taking unprecedented action to help member countries endure the massive economic shock of the virus outbreak, but some nations are resisting the idea of shared borrowing to cover the heavy costs - suggesting that even during this crisis there are limits to solidarity in a bloc that is trying to reaffirm itself after Brexit.

As governments scramble to put together hundreds of billions of euros (dollars) to save lives as well as companies and families from going bankrupt, many of the worst-hit countries in Europe are also those that can least afford the costs, like Italy.

The EU's executive has temporarily set aside its strict rules on spending to give governments the leeway they need to keep their economies afloat. That will only go so far, however, as it would leave the most affected countries managing their own worsened finances once the crisis has abated.

Its governments have so far stopped short of bigger action involving breaking a longstanding taboo: joint borrowing among countries that share the euro currency. Leaders are expected to discuss the question in a teleconferenced summit on Thursday.

“To which extent Europeans help each other in this acute emergency can shape popular perceptions of what Europe stands for – and for a long time to come,” said Holger Schmieding, the chief economist at Berenberg bank.

Finance ministers from the 19 EU countries that use the bloc's common currency, the euro, have agreed on letting countries borrow up to 2% of GDP from the European Stability Mechanism, a bailout fund set up during the debt crisis a decade ago.

The fund took part in the rescue of indebted countries such as Greece and Ireland in the last decade. It is backed by all 19 eurozone countries, and in a sense would represent shared finances in another form. It has lending firepower of 410 billion euros. ($444 billion).

The credit line may be enough to keep indebted countries such as Italy from going bankrupt in coming months, but could still leave them with longer-term debt trouble. Money from the rescue fund might not even cover Italy's additional spending, whose deficit is estimated to run as high as 10% of GDP this year, from under 3% currently. It would send its huge public debt pile of 132% of GDP even higher.

That jump in debt and deficits would, in normal times, violate EU rules, but the bloc loosened them. It has also lifted bans on state aid, which aim to keep countries from favoring home industries, so that they can now support companies suffocated by lock-downs.

“In a couple of weeks, we took measures that only a few months ago were impossible to imagine,” Europe's economic and monetary commissioner, Paulo Gentiloni said.

Yet the eurozone finance ministers who met Tuesday to lay the groundwork for the leaders' meeting couldn't overcome resistance to so-called “coronabonds,” shared debt backed by all 19 member countries. The idea would be to ensure even the hardest-hit member nations can borrow at sustainably low interest rates as their spending balloons on hospitals and measures to keep businesses from going bankrupt due to the shutdowns.

Italy, for one, could spend without having to worry down the road that international investors would worry about the country defaulting. That is what happened in 2010-2012, when investors began demanding unsustainably high interest rates to lend to Italy, spawning a financial crisis that almost broke up the eurozone.

Long rejected by northern European countries, that the shared bonds idea is even being considered shows how serious the situation is.

Germany and the Netherlands have long objected to common borrowing because it would put them on the hook for the finances of shakier countries and reduce incentives for other countries to control their deficits. German Chancellor Angela Merkel was reported to have told legislators in 2012 that there would be no common borrowing “as long as I live.”

But right now, Merkel herself is in isolation after coming into contact with someone who tested positive for the new coronavirus, and few things can be ruled out.

The debate apparently isn't over, judging by a letter calling for a “common debt instrument” signed by French President Emmanuel Macron and eight other eurozone heads of government: Belgium, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Portugal, Slovenia and Spain. “The case for such a common instrument is strong, since we are all facing a symmetric external shock, for which no country bears responsibility, but whose negative consequences are endured by all,” they wrote to EU Council President Charles Michel.

“We will explore all possibilities to tackle the huge challenges that we still have ahead of us," said Mario Centeno, the president of the Eurogroup of finance ministers, when asked whether “coronabonds” remained an option. "No possible solution has been set apart.”

The argument against shared bonds has long been based on moral hazard, the idea that bailouts only encourage more bad behavior. But that wouldn't seem to apply now as the virus outbreak isn't the result of economic mismanagement, and because the borrowing would be a one-off, not a permanent feature of the eurozone economy.

In economic terms the conditional credit line “is probably good enough,” said Schmieding, the economist at Berenberg bank. “In political terms, the deal outlined but not finalized by Eurogroup finance ministers falls short of the required signal of unique solidarity in a unique crisis.”

“It contains a risk of a backlash in popular opinion in Southern Europe against the North which could significantly complicate future cooperation within the EU-Eurozone.”

___

McHugh reported from Frankfurt, Germany.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Financial Markets
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Washington agrees on unrivaled $2 trillion virus rescue bill
The White House and Senate leaders of both political parties have reached agreement on a $2 trillion measure to rush aid to businesses, workers and a health care system slammed by the coronavirus pandemic
12:57PM ( 10 minutes ago )
As outbreak blows up finances, a limit to EU solidarity
The European Union is taking unprecedented action to help member countries endure the massive cost of to keeping people and businesses alive through the virus outbreak
12:51PM ( 17 minutes ago )
The Latest: Russia reports its first coronavirus deaths
Russia has reported its first deaths from the novel coronavirus infection, two elderly patients who also had underlying conditions
12:48PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Cuomo: 3,800 hospitalized in New York, 285 dead
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo says the number of people hospitalized with COVID-19 in the state has climbed to 3,800, with close to 900 in intensive care
12:29PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Chicago uses hotels for quarantine to ease hospital demand
Chicago's plan to reserve at least 1,000 hotel rooms for coronavirus patients through partnerships with five hotels is the first such strategy unveiled in the U.S. But it's unlikely to be the last
12:24PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Spain's coronavirus deaths leap; Prince Charles now infected
The coronavirus outbreak hit home Wednesday among the well-born and the desperately poor alike
12:17PM ( 50 minutes ago )
AP Business
US big-ticket factory orders up 1.2% in February
Orders to US factories for big-ticket manufactured goods rose 1.2% in February before coronavirus struck with force.
9:37AM ( 3 hours ago )
As outbreak blows up finances, EU nations balk at solidarity
The European Union is taking unprecedented action to help member countries endure the massive cost of to keeping people and businesses alive through the virus outbreak
9:34AM ( 3 hours ago )
China lifting last controls in province at outbreak's center
China has started lifting the last controls that confined tens of millions of people to their homes in the province at the center of its virus outbreak
7:49AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
The Latest: Putin postpones vote on amendments
Russian President Vladimir Putin has postponed a nationwide vote on proposed constitutional amendments that include allowing him to seek another term in power
10:42AM ( 2 hours ago )
Stocks drift up and down in tentative trading on Wall Street
Stocks are limping along in tentative trading early Wednesday, as a historic, worldwide rally downshifts dramatically after just a day
10:15AM ( 2 hours ago )
Of America and sacrifice: Is the country ready to step up?
For most Americans alive today, the idea of a shared national sacrifice is a collective abstraction
10:00AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Tokyo soars 8% as US stimulus deal lifts world markets
Japan's Nikkei 225 has surged 8% and other world markets also jumped after Congress and the White House reached a deal to inject nearly $2 trillion of aid into an economy ravaged by the coronavirus
6:04AM ( 7 hours ago )
Asian shares jump after Dow's biggest gain since '33
Shares have advanced in Asia after the Dow Jones Industrial Average surged to its best day since 1933
3:33AM ( 9 hours ago )
Asian shares jump after Dow sees biggest gain since 1933
Shares have advanced in Asia after the Dow Jones Industrial Average surged to its best day since 1933
12:20AM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Business - Financial Markets
Washington agrees on unrivaled $2 trillion virus rescue bill
The White House and Senate leaders of both political parties have reached agreement on a $2 trillion measure to rush aid to businesses, workers and a health care system slammed by the coronavirus pandemic
12:57PM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Russia reports its first coronavirus deaths
Russia has reported its first deaths from the novel coronavirus infection, two elderly patients who also had underlying conditions
12:48PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Wall Street looks for first back-to-back gain in six weeks
Stocks are higher in another day of bumpy trading Wednesday as Congress moves closer to passing a $2 trillion package to help the economy deal with damage caused by the coronavirus
12:41PM ( 27 minutes ago )
The Latest: Cuomo: 3,800 hospitalized in New York, 285 dead
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo says the number of people hospitalized with COVID-19 in the state has climbed to 3,800, with close to 900 in intensive care
12:29PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Chicago uses hotels for quarantine to ease hospital demand
Chicago's plan to reserve at least 1,000 hotel rooms for coronavirus patients through partnerships with five hotels is the first such strategy unveiled in the U.S. But it's unlikely to be the last
12:24PM ( 44 minutes ago )