sunny.png
Friday April 3rd, 2020 7:51PM

US appeals judges hear Down syndrome abortion arguments

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

CINCINNATI (AP) — Federal judges on Wednesday sharply questioned attorneys on both sides of an Ohio law that faces doctors with a felony charge if they perform abortions aimed at preventing the birth of a baby with Down syndrome.

Jessie Hill, an attorney for the ACLU of Ohio, argued that the law seeks unconstitutionally to take “the ultimate decision” on abortion away from the woman. Benjamin Flowers, Ohio's solicitor general, said it seeks to prevent abortions that target and discriminate against those with Down syndrome, which would send them a message that people including some medical providers “do not think people like you are as valuable as others.”

The case is viewed as pivotal in the national debate over the procedure. The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard the arguments in a rare full-court hearing before 15 judges on a court that has moved rightward in recent years with Republican President Donald Trump making six appointments.

Attorneys for the government contend in legal filings that the sidelined 2017 law does not infringe on a woman's constitutional rights — because it “does not prohibit any abortions at all.”

Judge Raymond Kethledge, an appointee of Republican President George W. Bush, indicated agreement with the government in his questions, suggesting that the Ohio law “strikes a balance between two extremes.” Other judges questioned whether it stands up under existing law on abortion and whether it encourages women to mislead their doctors.

The Ohio law prohibits physicians from performing an abortion if they're aware that a diagnosis of Down syndrome, or the possibility, is influencing the decision. They could face a fourth-degree felony charge, be stripped of their medical license, and be held liable for legal damages. The pregnant woman faces no criminal liability under the law.

This and similar proposals around the country have triggered emotional debate over women’s rights, parental love, and the trust between doctor and patient.

Hill said the law would “cut off communication between a woman and her doctor."

Judge Jeffrey Sutton, another George W. Bush appointee, countered: “We don't want our doctors knowingly doing selective abortions.”

The Trump Justice Department took the state of Ohio's side in the case in January, writing, “Nothing in Ohio’s law creates a substantial obstacle to women obtaining an abortion."

Justice Department attorney Alexander Maugeri told the judges Wednesday that the “Ohio law serves an important purpose” and lets people with Down syndrome know they “have lives that are worth living.”

Opponents call the law an illegal “reason ban.” They say it undercuts the woman's independent decision-making by attempting to get into her mind, or prevent her from speaking freely with her doctor, as she makes an abortion decision.

Wednesday's high-stakes hearing follows two earlier decisions in which a federal judge and a three-judge panel ruled the law is likely unconstitutional. It has been on hold since it was enacted.

In another of the Ohio case's legal twists, a group of mothers whose children have Down syndrome has sided with the ACLU of Ohio, Preterm-Cleveland and other abortion providers who brought the suit. They argue the law — dubbed the “Ohio Down Syndrome Non-Discrimination Act" — actually perpetuates discrimination against their children by singling out their genetic anomaly over others.

Down syndrome is a genetic disorder that can cause a variety of physical and mental disabilities. It occurs in about one in 700 babies born in the U.S. each year, or about 6,000 annually.

Mike Gonidakis, president of Ohio Right to Life, the state's oldest and largest anti-abortion group, said earlier that, legally, the Down syndrome law is not an outright ban on abortion — since the prohibition depends on the doctor's knowledge of the diagnosis.

It's unclear whether, if that argument should prevail and the law is upheld, what would be the effect of an abortion ban that “bans no abortions.”

A legislative backer said the idea is to make it impossible for a woman to find a doctor willing to abort a pregnancy in which Down syndrome is a possibility.

“I'm of the mind that it certainly does prevent abortions,” said state Rep. Candice Keller, a Republican abortion opponent from Middletown.

The appellate judges didn't give a timetable for a ruling.

"We believe that the court is going to identify that this did not indeed fall outside the bounds of what we can and cannot do under the current Roe structure,” Gonidakis said, referring to the landmark 1973 Roe v. Wade case, which legalized abortion.

___

Carr Smyth reported from Columbus.

___

On Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/jcarrsmyth and https://www.twitter.com/dansewell

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Big events banned in Seattle, San Francisco over coronavirus
Undertaking the most sweeping efforts yet to contain the nation’s coronavirus outbreak, authorities have banned large gatherings in the hard-hit Seattle area and San Francisco and closed Seattle schools
5:34PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Weariness hits residents in New York's 'containment area'
Residents are describing anxiety and weariness in a New York community that is home to one of nation's biggest clusters of coronavirus cases
5:30PM ( 11 minutes ago )
WHO declares virus crisis a pandemic, U.S. stocks plunge
The World Health Organization has declared that the global coronavirus crisis is now a pandemic
5:30PM ( 12 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Congress, White House move swiftly on new virus efforts
Congress is quickly unveiling a coronavirus aid package while President Donald Trump is considering a national disaster declaration and new travel advisories as Washington races to confront the outbreak
5:34PM ( 7 minutes ago )
The Latest: Baylor's Drew 'sad' about NCAA tourney fan ban
Baylor men's basketball coach Scott Drew says it's “sad” that college coaches and players in the NCAA Tournament won’t experience the excitement that a fan presence adds to the games and related events
5:32PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Dow tumbles into bear market as coronavirus fears intensify
Stocks fell sharply on Wall Street, shaving 5.9% off the Dow Jones Industrial Average and bringing the index into a bear market
5:19PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Mariners, Sounders, XFL shut out in Seattle because of virus
The Seattle Mariners are seeking alternative options for their season-opening series after Washington Gov. Jay Inslee announced a ban on all large gatherings in the three counties of the Seattle metro area because of the virus outbreak
4:55PM ( 47 minutes ago )
'Very much alive': Biden victorious in 4 more primary states
Joe Biden has had another big night in the Democratic presidential primary, capturing four more states, including Michigan
4:44PM ( 57 minutes ago )
The Latest: Only staff, limited family at NCAA Tourney games
NCAA President Mark Emmert says NCAA Division I basketball tournament games will be played without fans in the arenas because of concerns about the spread of coronavirus
4:43PM ( 59 minutes ago )
AP National News
Big events banned in Seattle, San Fran as virus toll mounts
Authorities are banning large gatherings in the hard-hit Seattle area and in San Francisco _ including pro baseball and basketball games _ in the most sweeping efforts yet to control the coronavirus outbreak in the U.S. And experts on the epidemic are warning that the worst is yet to come
2:58PM ( 2 hours ago )
Weinstein sentenced to 23 years for sexual assaults
Harvey Weinstein has been sentenced to 23 years in prison after he pleaded for mercy in the landmark #MeToo rape case
2:56PM ( 2 hours ago )
Loughlin, Giannulli lawyer is prosecutors' 'worst nightmare'
The lawyer leading the defense for “Full House” star Lori Loughlin and her fashion designer husband Mossimo Giannulli has a reputation for being fearless yet cool-headed and a master at navigating complex cases
2:23PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Mariners moving games, Warriors going fanless
Golden State will play Brooklyn in an empty arena, and the Seattle Mariners are looking for a temporary home as sports teams try to slow the coronavirus outbreak
4:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
Senate panel postpones subpoena vote in Hunter Biden probe
A Republican-led Senate committee has postponed a vote on a subpoena as part of its investigation into former Vice President Joe Biden’s son, but the chairman of the panel says the probe will move forward
3:52PM ( 1 hour ago )
Congress poised to tighten oversight of federal surveillance
Congress is taking a first step toward addressing errors made by the FBI during its investigation of the Trump campaign and Russia
3:23PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Court: House entitled to Mueller probe grand jury testimony
A federal appeals court has ruled that the Justice Department must give Congress secret grand jury testimony from special counsel Robert Mueller's Russia investigation
9:48PM ( 19 hours ago )
Lawsuits: Georgia illegally canceled election to high court
Lawsuits by two would-be candidates accuse Georgia officials of illegally canceling an election for a seat on the state's highest court
12:42PM ( 5 days ago )
Alabama executes inmate convicted in killing of 3 officers
A man convicted in the 2004 shooting deaths of three police officers in which another man pulled the trigger has been executed in Alabama
10:35PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Trump order expected on medical supplies amid virus outbreak
President Donald Trump is expected to announce an executive order insisting on American-made medical supplies and pharmaceuticals in response to the coronavirus outbreak
4:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Seattle shuts down schools for 53K students
The Seattle Public School system will close due to the ongoing coronavirus outbreak in Washington state, which prompted the governor to ban all events and gatherings of more than 250 people in Seattle's metro area
3:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: India suspends some visas over coronavirus
India has suspended some visas until April 15 to try to contain the spread of the new coronavirus
3:06PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Health
Market swings and a wave of cancellations as virus spreads
A wild start to the month on U.S. markets is becoming the new normal due to uncertainty over the coronavirus outbreak which is now being classified as a pandemic
4:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
WHO declares virus crisis a pandemic, urges global fight
The World Health Organization has declared that the global coronavirus crisis is now a pandemic
4:33PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Iran reports 62 more deaths from virus
The Seattle Public School system will close due to the ongoing coronavirus outbreak in Washington state, which prompted the governor to ban all events and gatherings of more than 250 people in Seattle's metro area
4:14PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Down syndrome abortion fight in Ohio takes legal twists
A federal court in Cincinnati will hear complex legal arguments for and against Ohio's Down syndrome abortion ban Wednesday
9:38AM ( 8 hours ago )
Supreme Court divided in 1st big abortion case of Trump era
A seemingly divided Supreme Court struggled with its first major abortion case of the Trump era, leaving Chief Justice John Roberts as the likely deciding vote
2:28PM ( 1 week ago )
Supreme Court takes up 1st big abortion case of Trump era
The Supreme Court is taking up the first major abortion case of the Trump era, an election year look at a Louisiana dispute that could reveal how willing the more conservative court is to roll back abortion rights
8:38AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Big events banned in Seattle, San Francisco over coronavirus
Undertaking the most sweeping efforts yet to contain the nation’s coronavirus outbreak, authorities have banned large gatherings in the hard-hit Seattle area and San Francisco and closed Seattle schools
5:34PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Weariness hits residents in New York's 'containment area'
Residents are describing anxiety and weariness in a New York community that is home to one of nation's biggest clusters of coronavirus cases
5:30PM ( 11 minutes ago )
WHO declares virus crisis a pandemic, U.S. stocks plunge
The World Health Organization has declared that the global coronavirus crisis is now a pandemic
5:30PM ( 12 minutes ago )
States shuffle poll locations to protect seniors from virus
The coronavirus threat to senior citizens is forcing counties to remove polling places from nursing homes for their safety
5:29PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Scientist links 2 state outbreaks with genetic fingerprints
A scientist in Seattle is helping public health authorities understand and track the new coronavirus, turning up clues about how it arrived and spread through Washington state and beyond
5:12PM ( 30 minutes ago )