clearn.png
Thursday October 1st, 2020 3:53AM

Facebook's influencers nod shows murky side of campaign ads

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Facebook's green light for political campaigns to pay prominent social media users to spread their messages is highlighting the difficulties around setting rules for the fast-changing world of online political campaigning.

The company's rule change comes days after Democratic presidential candidate Mike Bloomberg exposed a loophole in Facebook's political advertising guidelines by promoting his campaign through popular Instagram personalities followed by millions of younger people.

The Bloomberg posts weren’t much more than using self-deprecating humor to sell the candidate’s old guy appeal, using a tactic that until now was largely used to sell skin care products or clothing-subscription services on social media. But the lack of oversight and clear rules around influencer marketing, along with their effectiveness in reaching younger audiences, makes them ripe for misuse.

Even with Friday's change, Facebook's policies leave plenty of loopholes, which campaigns and candidates will likely find ways to exploit until Election Day, said Dipayan Ghosh, a former Facebook employee who is currently co-director of Harvard's digital platforms and democracy project. And if campaigns can do it, he said, so can grifters and foreign governments.

“We’re in for quite a lot of turmoil and trouble,” Ghosh said.

Bloomberg easily skirted many of the rules that tech companies have imposed over the years to safeguard U.S. elections from interference and misinformation. After Russia used social media ads in an attempt to influence the 2016 presidential election, Facebook began to require campaigns to verify their identity with a U.S. ID or mailing address and disclose how much they spent running each ad.

Before the explosion of social media, it was clearer what's an ad and what isn't — and thus what's subject to disclosures and other rules. With social media, a campaign can pay influential users to spread a message on their behalf, without ever buying an ad and being subject to its rules.

“This is a new kind of activity that simply didn’t exist when the rules for internet political communications were last updated,” said Commissioner Ellen L. Weintraub of the Federal Election Commission.

Friday's policy change involves what Facebook calls “branded content” — sponsored items posted by ordinary users who are typically paid by companies or organizations. Advertisers pay the influential users directly to post about their brand. Because Facebook doesn't make money directly, such posts weren't governed by Facebook's advertising policies,

Until Friday, Facebook tried to deter campaigns from using such branded content by barring them from using a tool designed to help advertisers run such posts on Facebook and Instagram, which is owned by Facebook. The rule change now allows campaigns in the U.S. to use this tool, provided they've been authorized by Facebook to run political ads and disclose who paid for the sponsored posts. Campaigns that avoid using the tool, as Bloomberg had, now risk having their accounts suspended.

“After hearing from multiple campaigns, we agree that there’s a place for branded content in political discussion on our platforms,” Facebook said.

Politicians still won’t be required to disclose how much they paid the influencers to run the posts. And the posts won't appear in Facebook's online catalog of political ads, which lets other campaigns, journalists and watchdog groups view the type of messages politicians are pushing.

Facebook's new rules won't apply to someone merely creating or sharing a post about a politician without getting paid.

Facebook said it is asking the influencer accounts that posted the Bloomberg memes to retroactively use the tool meant for such posts. After this happens, the posts will be labeled as a “paid partnership” with Bloomberg.

Google says it doesn't allow political messages using its main tools for connecting with influencers, but campaigns can make individual arrangements with YouTube influencers. These videos would be covered under general disclosure rules, but would not be added to Google's political advertising database. Twitter bans all political ads, but “organic content” such as influencers' posts aren't covered.

The Bloomberg campaign had taken the unconventional step of paying more than a dozen influencers on Instagram — individuals with huge followings — to post memes of Bloomberg. The memes showed the 78-year-old candidate, in a tongue-in-cheek awkward fashion, asking influencers with names like “Tank Sinatra" to help raise his profile among younger people.

“Can you post a meme that lets everyone know I’m the cool candidate?” Bloomberg wrote in one of the exchanges posted by an Instagram account with nearly 15 million followers. The candidate then sent a photo of him wearing baggy chino shorts, an orange polo and a zip-up vest. The reply: “Ooof that will cost like a billion dollars.” The billionaire candidate responded by asking where to send the money.

Bloomberg’s campaign said it was reaching those who might not be normally interested in day-to-day politics and make them "feel like they're not just getting a canned generic statement,” campaign spokeswoman Sabrina Singh said.

The Bloomberg campaign declined to say how much it paid for the sponsored posts, or if it had more in the works.

Ghosh, the Harvard critic, said the sponsored posts should be treated like any other ad, so people can see how much was paid and how wide an audience a post received. Ghosh said voters don’t distinguish between ads, in which campaigns pay Facebook directly, and sponsored posts, in which campaigns pay influencers.

“It is incredulous to think that Facebook cannot provide greater transparency,” Ghosh said. “Facebook simply doesn’t want to wade into those waters. Doing so would provide a level of responsibility that this company at every possible turn shirks.”

___

Seitz reported from Chicago. AP Technology Writer Rachel Lerman in San Francisco contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Elections - Political Conventions, AP Elections - Campaigns, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
National Black News Channel makes debut
The nation's only black news network is on the air
5:23PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Facebook's influencers nod shows murky side of campaign ads
Facebook's green light for political campaigns to pay prominent social media users to spread their messages is highlighting the difficulties around setting rules for the fast-changing world of online political campaigning
5:19PM ( 19 minutes ago )
US won't charge ex-FBI official McCabe, a Trump target
Federal prosecutors have declined to charge former FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe, closing an investigation into whether he lied to federal officials about his involvement in a news media disclosure
5:18PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Go West: 2020 Democrats seek their fortunes in Nevada
As the Democratic presidential race hurtles toward Nevada, candidates in the still-crowded field are facing their first test in a racially diverse state with solid union muscle and shaky plans for a presidential caucus
4:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
In interview, Klobuchar, Steyer can't name Mexican president
Democratic presidential hopefuls Amy Klobuchar and Tom Steyer were stumped when asked during a televised interview in Nevada to name the Mexican president
4:30PM ( 1 hour ago )
Bernie Sanders pranked by Russians posing as Greta Thunberg
Russian pranksters claim they called U.S. Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders pretending to be climate activist Greta Thunberg and offered Thunberg's support to his campaign
3:38PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Elections
Warren has raised $6M since Iowa, says race is 'wide open'
Elizabeth Warren says she's raised about $6 million from online donors since last week's Iowa caucuses, fueled by people who want to see her stay in the Democratic presidential primary despite an underwhelming performance there and in New Hampshire
9:40PM ( 19 hours ago )
Democrats step up attacks to blunt Michael Bloomberg's rise
Democratic presidential candidates hoping to revive their flagging campaigns are increasingly taking aim at Michael Bloomberg
8:12PM ( 21 hours ago )
Smollett case could complicate reelection of top prosecutor
The decision by a grand jury to restore charges against Jussie Smollett could bedevil the reelection bid of the first black woman to hold Chicago's top law enforcement job
7:56PM ( 21 hours ago )
General Election News
Limbaugh draws bipartisan criticism for Buttigieg remarks
Conservative talk show host Rush Limbaugh is drawing bipartisan criticism for saying the country won't elect openly gay Democrat Pete Buttigieg because it's not ready for a president who 'loves to kiss his husband on the debate stage
10:34PM ( 19 hours ago )
Trump says he might keep others from listening in on calls
President Donald Trump says he might end the long-running White House practice of letting administration officials and staffers listen in on presidential calls with foreign leaders
7:12PM ( 22 hours ago )
Limbaugh draws bipartisan condemnation for Buttigieg remarks
Conservative talk show host Rush Limbaugh is drawing bipartisan criticism for saying the country won't elect openly gay Democrat Pete Buttigieg because it's not ready for a president who 'loves to kiss his husband on the debate stage
4:53PM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
Delta says it will invest $1 billion to cut carbon emissions
Delta Air Lines says it will invest $1 billion over the next 10 years to offset climate-warming emissions from its planes
5:00PM ( 38 minutes ago )
AP Exclusive: MLB raises salaries for minor leaguers in 2021
Major League Baseball is raising the minimum salary for minor league players in 2021, according to a memo sent from the commissioner’s office to all 30 teams obtained by The Associated Press
4:52PM ( 45 minutes ago )
3 employees suspended in $4M Puerto Rico online scam
Puerto Rico’s government says it suspended three employees as federal agents investigate an online scam that attempted to steal more than $4 million from the U.S. territory
4:38PM ( 59 minutes ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Bloomberg says he's prepared to take on Trump
Michael Bloomberg says none of the other candidates in the Democratic primary field had answers when asked in last week’s debate why they’re better prepared than he is to take on President Donald Trump
8:53PM ( 1 day ago )
AP VoteCast: Democrats still seeking candidate to unite them
Democrats are still searching for a presidential front-runner
7:57PM ( 1 day ago )
Gospel of Matthew's message rings loudly for some 2020 Dems
As Democrats running for president this year display increasing fluency with faith in their courtship of religious voters, one particular biblical passage is getting name-checked often: Matthew 25 and its exhortation to treat “the least of these" with kindness
2:48PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections - Political Conventions
Nevada union might not endorse, but it isn't staying quiet
Nevada's most politically powerful union, the casino workers' Culinary Union, is so far staying quiet on whether it will endorse a candidate as the Democratic presidential race swings west, but Joe Biden isn't counting on the labor group's help
8:03PM ( 1 day ago )
Iowa Democratic Party chairman resigns after caucus chaos
The chairman of the Iowa Democratic Party has resigned after a disastrous caucus process beset by technical glitches led to a dayslong delay in reporting the results, inconsistencies in the numbers and no clear winner
7:02PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Biden team not expecting pre-caucus endorsements
Joe Biden's campaign has told top donors that it doesn't expect the powerful Culinary Union or former Democratic Senate leader Harry Reid to endorse any Democratic presidential candidate ahead of the Nevada caucuses on Feb. 22
6:39PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
US's Pelosi urges countries to steer clear of Huawei for 5G
U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has appealed to an audience in Germany for countries to steer clear of Chinese tech giant Huawei as they build their next-generation cellular networks
10:39AM ( 6 hours ago )
Zuckerberg accepts that Facebook may have to pay more tax
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg plans to throw his support behind international reforms that would require Silicon Valley tech giants to pay more tax in Europe
8:35AM ( 9 hours ago )
US brings new charges against Chinese tech giant Huawei
The Justice Department has added new criminal charges against Chinese tech giant Huawei and two of its U.S. subsidiaries
7:25AM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Technology News
National Black News Channel makes debut
The nation's only black news network is on the air
5:23PM ( 15 minutes ago )
US won't charge ex-FBI official McCabe, a Trump target
Federal prosecutors have declined to charge former FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe, closing an investigation into whether he lied to federal officials about his involvement in a news media disclosure
5:18PM ( 19 minutes ago )
United and American push back expected return of Boeing Max
United Airlines won’t use the Boeing 737 Max at all this summer, while American Airlines is still holding out hope for a late August return
5:13PM ( 25 minutes ago )
UEFA bans Man City from Champions League for 2 seasons
UEFA has banned Manchester City from the Champions League for two seasons for “serious breaches” of financial regulations
5:10PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Parkland widow renovates home, preserves memories
It was a bittersweet moment when representatives of the TV show “Military Makeover" surprised Parkland, Florida, shooting widow Debbi Hixon to let her know they were going to renovate her entire home
5:04PM ( 33 minutes ago )