Saturday January 23rd, 2021 7:06AM

Facebook to allow paid political messages that aren't ads

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Facebook decided Friday to allow a type of paid political message that had sidestepped many of the social network's rules governing political ads.

Its policy change comes days after presidential candidate Mike Bloomberg exploited a loophole to run such humorous messages promoting his campaign on the accounts of popular Instagram personalities followed by millions of younger people.

Bloomberg's use of the loophole and Facebook's policy change in response underscore difficulties tech companies and regulators have in keeping up with the changing nature of paid political messages. It used to be clearer what's an ad and what isn't — and thus what's subject to disclosures and other rules. With social media, a campaign can pay can pay celebrities and other influential users to spread a message on their behalf, without ever buying an ad and be subject to its rules.

“This is a new kind of activity that simply didn’t exist when the rules for internet political communications were last updated,” said Commissioner Ellen L. Weintraub of the Federal Election Commission.

The change involves what Facebook calls “branded content” — sponsored items posted by ordinary users who are typically paid by companies or organizations. Advertisers pay the influential users directly to post about their brand.

Facebook makes no money from such posts and does not consider them advertising. As a result, branded content isn't governed by Facebook's advertising policies, which require candidates and campaigns to verify their identity with a U.S. ID or mailing address and disclose how much they spent running each ad.

Until Friday, Facebook tried to deter campaigns from using such branded content by barring them from using a tool designed to help advertisers run such posts on Facebook and Instagram, which is owned by Facebook. Friday's rule change will now allow campaigns in the U.S. to use this tool, provided they've been authorized by Facebook to run political ads and disclose who paid for the sponsored posts.

The Bloomberg campaign took the unconventional step of paying social media influencers — individuals with huge followings — to post Bloomberg memes using their Instagram accounts. Different versions of the sponsored posts from the Bloomberg campaign ran on more than a dozen influential Instagram accounts, each of which have millions of followers.

That effort skirted many of the rules that tech companies have imposed on political ads to safeguard U.S. elections from malicious foreign and domestic interference and misinformation. Online political ads have been controversial, especially after it was revealed Russia used them in an attempt to influence the 2016 presidential election. In response, Facebook has rolled out a number of rules to prevent a repeat of that, though it has declined to fact-check political ads and refuses to ban even blatently false messages.

The Bloomberg campaign's memes showed the 78-year-old candidate, in a tongue-in-cheek awkward fashion, chatting with popular social media influencers with names like “Tank Sinatra," asking them to help him raise his profile among younger folk.

“Can you post a meme that lets everyone know I’m the cool candidate?” Bloomberg wrote in one of the exchanges posted by an account called F(asterisk)(asterisk)(asterisk) Jerry, which has nearly 15 million followers on Instagram. The candidate then sent a photo of him wearing baggy chino shorts, an orange polo and a zip-up vest.

F(asterisk)(asterisk)(asterisk) Jerry’s account then replied, “Ooof that will cost like a billion dollars.” Bloomberg responded by asking where to send the money.

With the sponsored posts, Bloomberg’s campaign said it was reaching those who might not be normally interested in the day-to-day of politics.

"You want to engage people at every platform and you want them to feel like they're not just getting a canned generic statement,” campaign spokeswoman Sabrina Singh said of the campaign's strategy.

The Bloomberg posts weren’t much more than self-deprecating humor used to sell a candidate’s old guy appeal, using a tactic that until now was largely used to sell skin care products or clothing-subscription services. But the lack of oversight and clear rules around influencer marketing, not to mention their effectiveness in reaching younger audiences, makes them ripe for misuse.

It's not yet clear if Facebook's sudden policy change will close all the loopholes, though the company says the issue represents a new territory and its approach could change over time. The same goes for regulation, too, which is even further behind than the tech companies.

The Bloomberg campaign declined to say how much it paid for the sponsored posts, or if it had more of them in the works. The posts did not appear in Facebook’s ad transparency library, which catalogs the political ads that campaigns buy directly from Facebook or Instagram, and tells users how much was spent on them. Bloomberg’s campaign told The Associated Press on Thursday that Instagram does not currently require the campaign to disclose that information on the sponsored posts it ran earlier this week.


Seitz reported from Chicago.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Elections - Political Conventions, AP Elections - Campaigns, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Facebook to allow paid political messages that aren't ads
Facebook has decided to allow a type of paid political message that had sidestepped many of the social network's rules governing political ads
9:31AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Cyprus struggles to ease problem of bad loans
Defaulted loans are a prime economic issue for Cyprus, which since a 2013 financial crisis has seen overdue payments weighing on consumers and banks
9:28AM ( 13 minutes ago )
Florida 'red flag' gun law used 3,500 times since Parkland
A Florida law that allows judges to bar anyone deemed dangerous from possessing firearms has been used 3,500 times since its enactment after a 2018 high school massacre
9:24AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Montenegro PM, Serbian church bishop meet on religious law
Montenegro's prime minister has met with the top Serbian Orthodox Church bishop in the country in a bid to defuse tensions over a contentious law on religious rights
8:07AM ( 1 hour ago )
Rep. Dan Crenshaw to combine memoir, advice in upcoming book
Rep. Dan Crenshaw of Texas has a book deal
8:05AM ( 1 hour ago )
2020 Democrats step up attacks to blunt Bloomberg's rise
Democratic presidential candidates hoping to revive their flagging campaigns are increasingly taking aim at Mike Bloomberg
7:30AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Warren has raised $6M since Iowa, says race is 'wide open'
Elizabeth Warren says she's raised about $6 million from online donors since last week's Iowa caucuses, fueled by people who want to see her stay in the Democratic presidential primary despite an underwhelming performance there and in New Hampshire
9:40PM ( 12 hours ago )
New Mexico bid for recreational marijuana is all but doomed
New Mexico's bid to become the 12th U.S. state to legalize recreational use of marijuana abruptly fell flat after state senators in a legislature dominated by Democrats rejected a bill that would have forced permission for sales in all of the state's cities and towns
7:49PM ( 13 hours ago )
Barr: Trump tweets on cases make it 'impossible' to do job
Attorney General William Barr took a public swipe at President Donald Trump, saying that the president’s tweets about Justice Department prosecutors and cases “make it impossible for me to do my job
7:16PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Nevada's Culinary Union will not endorse in Democratic race
The Culinary Union, the most influential union in Nevada politics, has decided to stay out of the state's Democratic presidential caucuses
10:34PM ( 11 hours ago )
Limbaugh draws bipartisan criticism for Buttigieg remarks
Conservative talk show host Rush Limbaugh is drawing bipartisan criticism for saying the country won't elect openly gay Democrat Pete Buttigieg because it's not ready for a president who 'loves to kiss his husband on the debate stage
10:34PM ( 11 hours ago )
Democrats step up attacks to blunt Michael Bloomberg's rise
Democratic presidential candidates hoping to revive their flagging campaigns are increasingly taking aim at Michael Bloomberg
8:12PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Elections
AP Exclusive: Pro-Trump effort raises over $60M in January
Pro-Donald Trump groups raised more than $60 million in January and have more than $200 million on hand for this year's general election
2:52PM ( 18 hours ago )
In South, Bloomberg aims to move past stop-and-frisk remarks
Michael Bloomberg is on a two-day campaign swing through the South
6:03AM ( 1 day ago )
2020 hopefuls eye Super Tuesday even as 2 other states loom
Nevada votes next, then South Carolina
5:53AM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Bloomberg once blamed end of 'redlining' for 2008 collapse
At the height of the 2008 economic collapse, then-New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg said that elimination of the discriminatory housing practice known as “redlining” was an instigator of the meltdown
11:59AM ( 21 hours ago )
Wanted: Texas Republicans need new voters in 2020, and fast
Big Republican donors in Texas are spending millions of dollars in 2020 looking for new votes
11:59AM ( 21 hours ago )
Nevada union might not endorse, but it isn't staying quiet
Nevada's most politically powerful union, the casino workers' Culinary Union, is so far staying quiet on whether it will endorse a candidate as the Democratic presidential race swings west, but Joe Biden isn't counting on the labor group's help
8:03PM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
With virus, shops in China suffer a star-crossed Valentines
In virus-stricken China, couples can celebrate Valentine's Day with a roast beef salad, hot chocolate, a rose and a note, all delivered to their door
8:42AM ( 58 minutes ago )
US retail sales up a modest 0.3% in January
US retail sales up modest 0.3% in January, boosted by strong sales at furniture and hardware stores
8:36AM ( 1 hour ago )
Zuckerberg accepts that Facebook may have to pay more tax
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg plans to throw his support behind international reforms that would require Silicon Valley tech giants to pay more tax in Europe
8:35AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Gospel of Matthew's message rings loudly for some 2020 Dems
As Democrats running for president this year display increasing fluency with faith in their courtship of religious voters, one particular biblical passage is getting name-checked often: Matthew 25 and its exhortation to treat “the least of these" with kindness
2:48PM ( 1 day ago )
AP VoteCast: NH Democrats angry, seek alternative to Trump
Democratic voters in the New Hampshire primary were angry at President Donald Trump's administration and eager to pick the candidate most likely to oust him from office
12:40PM ( 1 day ago )
AP VoteCast: Young, liberal voters key to Sanders’ NH win
AP VoteCast shows Bernie Sanders won the young, the liberal and the disaffected in New Hampshire
12:33PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Political Conventions
Iowa Democratic Party chairman resigns after caucus chaos
The chairman of the Iowa Democratic Party has resigned after a disastrous caucus process beset by technical glitches led to a dayslong delay in reporting the results, inconsistencies in the numbers and no clear winner
7:02PM ( 1 day ago )
Joe Biden looks to South Carolina to resurrect his campaign
Joe Biden has brought his wounded presidential campaign to South Carolina, staking his hopes for a comeback on the loyalty of black voters after a dismal finish in the New Hampshire primary magnified his disappointing finish in Iowa
2:50PM ( 1 day ago )
Klobuchar surged in New Hampshire. Can she make it count?
Democratic presidential hopeful Amy Klobuchar is hoping her strong third-place finish in New Hampshire will provide enough momentum to be competitive in Nevada and the states that come next in the nominating contest
2:21PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Ex-Waymo driver accused of deliberately causing crash
A man described by Waymo as a disgruntled former driver has been arrested on suspicion of deliberately crashing a passenger car into one of the company’s vans with self-driving capabilities
6:28PM ( 15 hours ago )
In win for Amazon, judge freezes work on Pentagon contract
A federal court has ordered the Pentagon to temporarily halt work with Microsoft on a $10 billion military cloud contract that Amazon was initially favored to win
6:04PM ( 15 hours ago )
Nevada Democrats unveil new caucus plan after Iowa chaos
Nevada Democrats have released a revamped plan for the Feb. 22 presidential caucuses, adding measures intended to avoid a repeat of problems that ensnared Iowa's vote
5:56PM ( 15 hours ago )
AP Technology News
Cyprus struggles to ease problem of bad loans
Defaulted loans are a prime economic issue for Cyprus, which since a 2013 financial crisis has seen overdue payments weighing on consumers and banks
9:28AM ( 13 minutes ago )
Florida 'red flag' gun law used 3,500 times since Parkland
A Florida law that allows judges to bar anyone deemed dangerous from possessing firearms has been used 3,500 times since its enactment after a 2018 high school massacre
9:24AM ( 17 minutes ago )
The Latest: Hong Kong announces anti-virus funds
Hong Kong’s leader has unveiled a 25 billion Hong Kong dollar ($3.2 billion) fund to bolster efforts to fight the virus outbreak, as the city announced three new cases, bringing its total to 56
9:23AM ( 17 minutes ago )
US manufacturing output hit by Boeing troubles, slips 0.1%
U.S. manufacturing output fell slightly in January, driven lower by Boeing's decision to halt production of its troubled 737 MAX aircraft
9:20AM ( 20 minutes ago )
Trump wants $1.5B over 10 years to revive US uranium mining
The Trump administration wants to spend $1.5 billion over 10 years to create a U.S. uranium reserve, claiming that reliance on cheaper uranium imports threatens the country's energy security
9:07AM ( 34 minutes ago )