Tuesday April 7th, 2020 4:26AM

Impeachment loses its constitutional gravity in Trump case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Years from now, will you remember where you were and what you were doing when President Donald Trump was impeached? Have you forgotten already?

The country has been on a constitutional bullet train that took off with a whistleblower's highly detailed account of wrongdoing, roared ahead through a cascade of tweets and lurched to a halt after more than four months of inquiry, angst and debate with Trump's acquittal on Wednesday. So can you point to Ukraine on a map?

American children learn almost by rote that impeachment is a gravely serious proposition, the constitutional means for removing a president from office who commits “high crimes and misdemeanors."

The words of founders like Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and George Mason are invoked from more than two centuries ago to remind everyone why they thought the federal government needed to have a means to undo an election.

Long before anyone split an atom, the founders created the political equivalent of a nuclear weapon, with the fate of the nation in the balance.

This time, it just didn't feel like it.

We were witness to history in a way few generations have been. But it was a chapter of history laced with artifice.

The roughly half of the country that wanted Trump to be impeached and begone knew his acquittal was all but preordained in the Republican-controlled Senate. Just as Trump loyalists thought the matter was a hoax inflicted by the Democratic-controlled House.

The Senate impeachment trial delivered eloquence without persuasiveness, a mystery without suspense. It delivered argument without the anguish that accompanied the other impeachment episodes in anyone's lifetime today.

In the past they wept.

In 1974, Republican Rep. M. Caldwell Butler of Virginia wept after he cast a committee vote to impeach fellow Republican Richard Nixon. "For years we Republicans have campaigned against corruption and misconduct,” he said. “But Watergate is our shame.”

A quarter-century later, California Republican Rep. Tom Campbell verged on tears from the weight of the moment when he announced in favor of Clinton's impeachment in a near whisper.

As partisan and poisonous as that era was, too, Democrats gave their president a tongue-lashing to remember before saving his presidency. ''He's not the best Democrat any of us have seen," snapped Rep. Louise Slaughter of New York.

Trump commanded fealty from his party like others also stained by impeachment or its threat never did. Only one in Congress broke with the president, and for him the anguish was plain on his face and in his voice. "The president is guilty of an appalling abuse of public trust,” Utah Sen. Mitt Romney said on the Senate floor as he explained why he would vote for conviction.

The founders were never big on specifics. In essence, they told the House to handle impeachment and the Senate to manage conviction or acquittal as each chamber sees fit. Their atomic bomb from the ages came without a detailed instruction manual or FAQ.

As the Senate sat as both judge and jury to assess the impeachment charges against Trump -- for only the third time in history and the first time for a president seeking reelection — the limits of the proceedings for addressing misconduct were clear and the artifice became ever more apparent.

It was a trial in name only.

Senators on both sides openly prejudged the case. Questions were not spontaneous. The lawyers knew them in advance and were prepared with answers that even included slideshows.

The senators, muzzled in the chamber for much of the time, rushed to TV cameras to deliver their opinions on what they had just heard, unlike a jury that would be sequestered and forbidden to discuss the case.

New facts or documents were not introduced into evidence. No witnesses were called, unlike in the Andrew Johnson and Clinton impeachment trials.

Questions of fact and law were put to the prosecutors and defense lawyers, who gave self-serving answers, rather than to the person in the room most suited to the task, Chief Justice John Roberts.

Roberts had only limited say in the proceeding's substantive matters and little appetite for more, in deference to the elected representatives. Though not a supplicant, he was more of a moderator than a jurist.

The president chose his lawyers in part for how he thought they would look on television, an acknowledgment that the audience that mattered to him — his base — was outside the room.

There was ringing rhetoric about the meaning of words on sepia-toned parchment from the 1700s and in 2019 text messages from the smartphones of all the president's men.

The Federalist Papers and the contemporary record of a president pressing another country for a political favor were all part of this continuum.

Yet those arguments were in the realm of theater rather than of justice.

In the parlance of Washington and these times, everyone was “playing a role.”

With Alexander Hamilton taking a star turn again, like on Broadway.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Impeachment loses its constitutional gravity in Trump case
President Donald Trump's acquittal in the Senate impeachment trial leaves his political fate in the hands of voters and his place in history to be judged in the passage of time
12:15AM ( 6 minutes ago )
Biden reaches for 'Comeback Kid' mantle in New Hampshire
Former Vice President Joe Biden is acknowledging his campaign “took a gut punch” in Iowa but says he isn't going anywhere as he tries to position himself in New Hampshire as the new "Comeback Kid
12:11AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Trump courts black voters, but opposition remains deep
President Donald Trump used part of his State of the Union speech to court black voters, but opposition to him remains deep
12:09AM ( 12 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Buttigieg clings to narrow lead as Iowa results trickle in
Pete Buttigieg is clinging to a slight lead over Bernie Sanders in a new batch of votes released by the Iowa Democratic Party
11:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump barrels into 2020 campaign, emboldened after acquittal
The Senate's impeachment trial has ended, and now President Donald Trump is barreling into his reelection fight with a united Republican Party behind him
10:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
Videos show fatal stabbing on California subway platform
Jurors in the trial of a man accused of fatally stabbing a young woman on a California subway platform were shown video Wednesday of the stabbing that also injured her sister
9:23PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Weinstein accuser says he trapped her during hotel assault
A final accuser at Harvey Weinstein’s rape trial says he told her having him grope her is what actresses had to do to make it in Hollywood
7:24PM ( 4 hours ago )
Snowfall blankets Texas, Oklahoma; Deep South to see storms
A winter storm is bringing snowfall as far south as El Paso, Texas, while areas of the Deep South are at risk of severe weather including tornadoes and torrential rains
7:17PM ( 5 hours ago )
Madoff seeks prison release, citing terminal kidney failure
Ponzi schemer Bernard Madoff says he has less than 18 months to live and has asked a federal judge to grant him a compassionate release from his 150-year prison sentence
7:07PM ( 5 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Venezuelan opposition head meets Trump in show of US support
Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaidó has achieved a long-sought goal, a White House meeting with President Donald Trump
10:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
Black lawmakers demand Biden disavow surrogate's comments
Black lawmakers in South Carolina are calling on former Vice President Joe Biden to disavow statements from a longtime friend and campaign surrogate that they say are racist
9:11PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Biden dismayed Limbaugh awarded Medal of Freedom
The awarding of the Presidential Medal of Freedom to Rush Limbaugh has left Joe Biden almost speechless
8:34PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
No sanctions for Montana lawmaker over socialism comments
The speaker of the Montana House is conceding the Legislature will likely do nothing to sanction a state representative for his comments about socialism
4:29PM ( 7 hours ago )
Trump cleared of abuse, impeachment acquittal on track
President Donald Trump has been found not guilty of the first article of impeachment, abuse of power, by the Senate
4:20PM ( 8 hours ago )
Parkland dad apologizes for State of the Union outburst
The father of a student killed in the 2018 Florida high school massacre has apologized for interrupting President Donald Trump's State of the Union address
4:18PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Asian economies cut rates, move to blunt impact of virus
Thailand's central bank cut its benchmark interest rate and other Asian countries look set to follow suit as they seek ways to soften the impact of the outbreak of a virus in China that has killed more than 560 people
11:44PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Raptors beat Pacers for team-record 12th straight win
Serge Ibaka hit a go-ahead 3-pointer with 30 seconds remaining and the Toronto Raptors rallied from 19 down to beat the Indiana Pacers 119-118, setting a franchise record with their 12th consecutive victory
11:39PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Vandy snaps 26-game SEC skid by upsetting No. 18 LSU 99-90
Saben Lee scored a career-high 33 points and Vanderbilt upset No. 18 LSU 99-90 to end the Southeastern Conference's longest regular-season skid at 26 straight
11:38PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Asia stocks surge after Trump acquitted, China virus aid
Asian stock markets have surged after President Donald Trump was acquitted in an impeachment trial and China promised tax cuts and other help to businesses reeling from a virus outbreak
11:36PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Yankees lefty James Paxton has back surgery, out 3-4 months
New York Yankees left-hander James Paxton has had back surgery and is expected to be sidelined until May or June
11:33PM ( 49 minutes ago )