sunny.png
Monday April 6th, 2020 12:33PM

Utah lawmaker proposes warning label for pornography

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — A Utah lawmaker has unveiled a proposal to require pornography to carry warning labels or be subject to a possible $2,500 penalty, though an adult-entertainment industry group warned the idea would violate the First Amendment.

The label about the potential harm to minors would have to appear on both print and digital material that appears in Utah if the bill proposed by Republican Rep. Brady Brammer passes the Legislature.

If the label doesn’t appear, the producer could be sued for $2,500 per violation, either by the Utah Attorney General’s Office or a private group. The enforcement process would be similar to warning labels about toxic substances that are required in California, Brammer said Tuesday.

“We continue to have people complain about the prevalence of obscene materials and the impact on their children,” Brammer said. The 15-second digital warnings, for example, would allow people to navigate away quickly if something obscene comes up online accidentally, he said.

The bill doesn’t contain a specific definition of pornography. Instead, that would be decided in court if a lawsuit is filed under the law, Brammer said. The law wouldn’t regulate the content itself, so doesn’t violate free-speech rights, he said.

“It’s not censorship because it doesn’t stop anything from being said or printed or published,” he said.

Mike Stabile, a spokesman for the Free Speech Coalition, an adult-industry trade group, disagreed. Such a warning label would violate the First Amendment because it would require producers to communicate a specific message, he argued.

“You can’t force someone to say something,” he said, pointing to a U.S. Supreme Court ruling overturning a California law that would have required anti-abortion pregnancy crisis centers to post signs saying they are not medical facilities. Warning systems like those for rating movies with an R or PG-13 are different because they are voluntary, he said.

Meanwhile, the Utah bill is broad enough that it could cover everything from the TV show “Game of Thrones” to a partially nude selfie on Twitter, he argued.

Stabile also questioned the proposed language of the warning, which states that exposing minors to pornography is “known to the state of Utah” to negatively affect minors' emotional and brain development and their ability to maintain intimate relationships.

Unlike the effects of toxic substances, the research on pornography is not exhaustive or definitive, he said.

“This is the government coming in and trying to control something that should be handled by parents,” he said, adding that explicit material is intended for adults.

Brammer, though, said he drew the language of the warning from a resolution passed by Utah in 2016 that declared pornography a public-health crisis, citing its widespread availability online. Since then, more than a dozen states have advanced similar resolutions.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Entertainment, AP Business
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Hong Kong reports virus death as workers strike at hospitals
Hong Kong hospitals are cutting services as thousands of medical workers strike for a second day to demand that the border with mainland China be shut completely to ward off a virus that caused its first death in the territory
4:17PM ( 3 minutes ago )
White House excludes CNN from Trump session, with no protest
The White House excluded CNN from its annual off-the-record briefing with television news personalities prior to the State of the Union address
4:08PM ( 11 minutes ago )
On eve of impeachment verdict, Trump tees up State of Union
President Donald Trump will deliver his State of the Union address Tuesday night on the eve of his likely impeachment acquittal and in the aftermath of the chaotic first votes of the race to replace him
3:50PM ( 30 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Democratic convention host committee leaders put on leave
The two leaders of Milwaukee's host committee for the 2020 Democratic National Convention have been placed on leave pending an investigation into allegations that they oversaw a toxic work environment
3:40PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Tech companies lead US stock rally following global gains
Technology companies led a broad rally for U.S. stocks in afternoon trading Tuesday following solid gains overseas
3:37PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Official: 2nd student dies after truck hits Oklahoma runners
A school official says a second suburban Oklahoma City high school student has died after a group of cross-country runners was struck by a pickup
3:31PM ( 48 minutes ago )
AP National News
The Latest: Company behind caucus app regrets tech glitches
The company at the center of the Iowa caucus fiasco says it regrets that an app it designed had technical glitches that delayed the release of the results from the first nominating contest of 2020
3:14PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Iowa governor defends 1st-in-the-nation caucuses
Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds is defending the state's first-in-the-nation caucus status as Democrats struggle to get results released
2:58PM ( 1 hour ago )
US general slips into Iraq for talks to salvage relations
The top U.S. commander for the Middle East has slipped into Iraq as the Trump administration works to salvage relations with Iraqi leaders and shut down the government's push for an American troop withdrawal
2:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
McConnell blasts impeachment, will vote to acquit Trump
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is slamming the House Democrats' drive to impeach President Donald Trump as “the most rushed, least fair and least thorough" in history
12:02PM ( 4 hours ago )
Montana lawmaker rejects resigning over socialism comments
A Montana lawmaker has rejected legislative leaders' call for his resignation over his assertion that the U.S. Constitution allows socialists to be jailed or shot
11:27AM ( 4 hours ago )
Trump's envoy urges Kosovo to drop taxes on Serbian goods
U.S. President Donald Trump's special envoy for Kosovo has urged the new Kosovo government to abolish punitive tariffs on Serbian goods that have blocked negotiations between the two Balkan rivals
10:44AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Service set for members of family who died with Kobe Bryant
A public memorial has been announced for three members of a family who died along with Kobe Bryant and others when a helicopter crashed in foggy weather last month outside Los Angeles
3:40PM ( 40 minutes ago )
No good vibrations for Beach Boys, split by hunting concert
One of the co-founders of The Beach Boys has joined a boycott of his own music to protest it being used by another member at an animal hunting convention
3:36PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Hall of Fame voter who snubbed Jeter keeps ballot private
The lone baseball writer who did not vote for Derek Jeter for the Hall of Fame chose to keep his or her ballot private
3:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Entertainment
China's virus outbreak weighs on global business
China's virus outbreak is giving global business a chill
2:53PM ( 1 hour ago )
Knicks fire Steve Mills, begin search for new president
The New York Knicks have fired President Steve Mills
1:37PM ( 2 hours ago )
Abu Dhabi's long-troubled Etihad sells 38 planes for $1B
Abu Dhabi's long-troubled Etihad Airways says it is selling 38 aircraft to an investment firm and a leasing company in a deal valued at $1 billion
1:34PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Hong Kong reports virus death as workers strike at hospitals
Hong Kong hospitals are cutting services as thousands of medical workers strike for a second day to demand that the border with mainland China be shut completely to ward off a virus that caused its first death in the territory
4:17PM ( 3 minutes ago )
White House excludes CNN from Trump session, with no protest
The White House excluded CNN from its annual off-the-record briefing with television news personalities prior to the State of the Union address
4:08PM ( 11 minutes ago )
On eve of impeachment verdict, Trump tees up State of Union
President Donald Trump will deliver his State of the Union address Tuesday night on the eve of his likely impeachment acquittal and in the aftermath of the chaotic first votes of the race to replace him
3:50PM ( 30 minutes ago )
Michigan State coach Mark Dantonio retiring after 13 seasons
Michigan State football coach Mark Dantonio is retiring after a 13-year run
3:46PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Service set for members of family who died with Kobe Bryant
A public memorial has been announced for three members of a family who died along with Kobe Bryant and others when a helicopter crashed in foggy weather last month outside Los Angeles
3:40PM ( 40 minutes ago )