cloudyn.png
Wednesday August 4th, 2021 12:06AM

Nestle, Cargill at high court in child labor case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court seemed concerned Tuesday about the impact of siding with food giants Nestle and Cargill and ending a lawsuit that claims they knowingly bought cocoa beans from farms in Africa that used child slave labor.

The court was hearing arguments in the case by phone because of the coronavirus pandemic. If the court were to accept Nestle and Cargill's arguments, that could further limit the ability of victims of human rights abuses abroad to use U.S. courts to sue. But both liberal and conservative justices asked questions that were skeptical of arguments made by the companies' attorney.

“Many of your arguments lead to results that are pretty hard to take,” conservative Justice Samuel Alito told attorney Neal Katyal, who was arguing on behalf of Nestle and Cargill. The court's three liberal justices were particularly critical of Katyal's position, with Justice Sonia Sotomayor at one point saying it “boggles my mind.”

The case before the justices has been going on for more than 15 years. It involves six adult citizens of Mali, referred to only as John Does, who say that as children they were taken from their country and forced to work on cocoa farms in neighboring Ivory Coast. They say they worked 12 to 14 hours a day, were given little food and were beaten if their work was seen as slow.

The group says that Minneapolis-based Cargill and the American arm of Switzerland-based Nestle “aided and abetted” their slavery by, among other things, buying cocoa beans from farms that used child labor. The group is seeking to bring a class action lawsuit on behalf of themselves and what they say are thousands of other former child slaves.

Both Nestle and Cargill say they have taken steps to combat child slavery and have denied any wrongdoing.

The case involves a law enacted by the very first Congress in 1789, the Alien Tort Statute, which permits foreign citizens to sue in U.S. courts for human rights abuses. The justices are being asked to rule on whether it permits lawsuits against American companies.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh was among the justices with tough questions for Nestle and Cargill's attorney. “The Alien Tort Statute was once an engine of international human rights protection,” Kavanaugh said before quoting a brief that argued that the companies' position would “gut the statute.” “So why should we do that?” he asked.

Alito, for his part, was also skeptical about this particular case against Nestle and Cargill. “You don't even allege that they actually knew about forced child labor,” Alito told attorney Paul Hoffman.

“We do contend that these defendants knew exactly what they were doing in that supply chain,” Hoffman responded.

The case had previously been dismissed twice at an early stage, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit revived it. The Trump administration is backing Nestle and Cargill.

The high court in recent years has limited the use of the Alien Tort Statute. Most recently, in 2018, the court ruled that foreign businesses cannot be sued under the law. In that case, the court rejected an attempt by Israeli victims of attacks in the West Bank and Gaza to use U.S. courts to sue Jordan-based Arab Bank, which they said helped finance the attacks. Cargill and Nestle are asking the court to take another step and rule out suits against U.S. companies.

A decision is expected by the end of June.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Agriculture
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Nestle, Cargill at high court in child labor case
The Supreme Court seemed concerned Tuesday about the impact of siding with food giants Nestle and Cargill and ending a lawsuit that claims they knowingly bought cocoa beans from farms in Africa that used child slave labor
2:42PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Stocks rise; S&P 500 approaches another all-time high
U.S. stocks rose broadly in afternoon trading Tuesday and the S&P 500 pushed toward another record high as investors focus on the possibility that coronavirus vaccines could soon help usher in a fuller global economic recovery
2:30PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Ex-Penn St. president's Sandusky-related conviction restored
A federal appeals court is reinstating former Penn State President Graham Spanier’s conviction for child endangerment over his handling of a report that former assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky sexually abused a child
2:24PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Harris warns of 'hunger crisis in America now'
Vice President-elect Kamala Harris says there is a “hunger crisis in America now” due to the COVID-19 pandemic but promised quick action to address the challenge when in office
2:03PM ( 47 minutes ago )
FDA chief called to White House as Trump pushes for vaccine
The head of the agency responsible for approving any COVID-19 vaccine has been summoned to the White House as an increasingly frustrated President Donald Trump complains approval isn't coming faster
2:00PM ( 49 minutes ago )
The Latest: Yellen warns quick action needed on virus impact
Treasury Secretary nominee Janet Yellen is describing the economic crisis brought on by the COVID pandemic as an “American tragedy” and warning that without quick action to address it, the damage will get worse
1:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Mnuchin defends shut down of Fed emergency loan programs
Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin is defending his decision to close down a number of emergency Federal Reserve loan programs at a time when coronavirus cases are surging
1:19PM ( 1 hour ago )
Biden unveils economic team at critical moment for recovery
President-elect Joe Biden is set to unveil his economic team Tuesday amid growing concerns about the pace of the nation’s economic recovery as governments reimpose restrictions to curtail the surging coronavirus pandemic
1:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump raises $170 million as he looks to future
President Donald Trump has raised roughly $170 million since his Election Day defeat, a sum garnered through a nonstop stream of solicitations that have falsely claimed the election was stolen while requesting contributions for an “election defense fund.”
12:58PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Congress News
Cosby's sex assault conviction goes before high-level court
An appeals court has questioned whether Bill Cosby’s alleged history of intoxicating and sexually assaulting young woman amounted to a “signature” crime pattern
2:11PM ( 39 minutes ago )
China spacecraft lands on moon to bring rocks back to Earth
The Chinese government says it has landed a spacecraft on the moon to bring rocks back to Earth
1:53PM ( 57 minutes ago )
Airbnb hopes to raise up to $2.6B in mid-December IPO
Airbnb hopes to raise as much as $2.6 billion in its initial public stock offering this month, betting investors will see its home-sharing model as the future of travel
1:52PM ( 58 minutes ago )
AP Business
European regulator could OK 1st COVID-19 vaccine on Dec. 29
European regulators say they may approve a coronavirus vaccine developed by drugmakers Pfizer and BioNTech within four weeks
11:15AM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Madrid to open hospital for coronavirus patients
Madrid officials held a ceremony to open part of a 1,000-bed hospital for emergencies
10:31AM ( 4 hours ago )
Without patients or staff, Madrid opens new $119M hospital
Authorities in Spain's capital have held a ceremony to open part of a 1,000-bed emergency hospital for COVID-19 patients
10:15AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
49ers to play 2 upcoming home games in Arizona
The San Francisco 49ers will play two home games in Arizona after new coronavirus regulations put in place by officials in Northern California forced the team to find a temporary new home
9:28PM ( 17 hours ago )
Suspected extremists kill at least 40 farmers in Nigeria
Nigerian officials say suspected members of the Islamic militant group Boko Haram have killed at least 40 rice farmers and fishermen while they were harvesting crops in northern Borno State
1:21PM ( 2 days ago )
India farmers press on with protest despite offer to talk
Thousands of farmers in and around the Indian capital are pressing on with their protest against agricultural legislation they say could devastate crop prices, while the government seeks talks with their leaders
3:40AM ( 3 days ago )
AP Business - Agriculture
Stocks rise; S&P 500 approaches another all-time high
U.S. stocks rose broadly in afternoon trading Tuesday and the S&P 500 pushed toward another record high as investors focus on the possibility that coronavirus vaccines could soon help usher in a fuller global economic recovery
2:30PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Ex-Penn St. president's Sandusky-related conviction restored
A federal appeals court is reinstating former Penn State President Graham Spanier’s conviction for child endangerment over his handling of a report that former assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky sexually abused a child
2:24PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Biden unveils economic team declaring, 'Help is on the way'
President-elect Joe Biden has introduced top advisers he says will help his administration rebuild an economy hammered by the coronavirus pandemic
2:23PM ( 28 minutes ago )
4 killed, 15 injured after German man drives car into crowd
German officials say a man zig-zagged an SUV at high speed through a pedestrian zone in the southwestern German city of Trier, killing four people, including a 9-month-old child, and seriously injuring 15
2:19PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Virus, fan eagerness may spur sports bet, casino expansion
Huge holes in state budgets due to the coronavirus pandemic and the demonstrated eagerness of fans to bet on sports are likely to spur a further expansion of sports betting and online casino gambling
2:18PM ( 33 minutes ago )