Sunday November 29th, 2020 3:14PM

In blistering ruling, judge throws out Trump suit in Pa.

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — A federal judge issued a scathing order Saturday dismissing the Trump campaign's futile effort to block the certification of votes in Pennsylvania, shooting down claims of widespread irregularities with mail-in ballots.

The case was always a long shot to stop President-elect Joe Biden's inauguration, but it was President Donald Trump’s best hope to affect the election results through the courts, mostly because of the number of electoral votes, 20, at stake in Pennsylvania. His personal attorney, Rudy Giuliani, stepped into a courtroom for the first time in decades to argue the case this past week.

U.S. District Court Judge Matthew Brann wrote in his order that Trump had asked the court to disenfranchise almost 7 million voters.

“One might expect that when seeking such a startling outcome, a plaintiff would come formidably armed with compelling legal arguments and factual proof of rampant corruption," Brann wrote, so much that the court would have no option but to stop the certification even though it would impact so many people. “That has not happened.”

Even if he'd won the Pennsylvania case, Trump would have needed to win other lawsuits in other states where he'd also asked to delay certification. The campaign peppered battlegrounds states with litigation in the days after the election alleging widespread election fraud without proof, but the majority of those cases have already been dismissed.

The president has taken his effort to subvert the results of the 2020 election beyond the courtroom in recent days, straight to local lawmakers. Some Trump allies have expressed hope that state lawmakers could intervene in selecting Republican electors.

With that in mind Trump invited Michigan legislators to the White House on Friday, hoping that an Oval Office meeting would persuade them to set aside the popular vote favoring Biden by more than 154,000. But the lawmakers issued a statement after the meeting that they would follow the law and “normal process” on electors. Trump was said to be considering extending a similar invitation to lawmakers from Pennsylvania.

Time is running out for Trump and his campaign, as states certify their results one after another showing that Biden won the requisite 270 Electoral College votes to take office.

Brann ruled that Pennsylvania officials can certify election results that currently show Biden winning the state by more than 80,000 votes. He said the Trump campaign presented “strained legal arguments without merit and speculative accusations ... unsupported by evidence."

“In the United States of America, this cannot justify the disenfranchisement of a single voter, let alone all the voters of its sixth most populated state,” the opinion said. “Our people, laws, and institutions demand more."

Trump tweeted after the ruling that he couldn’t understand why Biden was forming a Cabinet when the president's investigators had found “hundreds of thousands of fraudulent votes,” a baseless claim for which Trump has supplied no evidence.

Giuliani and a Trump campaign lawyer said in a statement that they welcomed the dismissal because it would allow them to appeal up to the U.S. Supreme Court faster, where Trump has repeatedly said he feels he has sympathetic justices. But, the justices heard a case from the state before the election, over a three-day extension on mail-in ballots, and allowed the extension over the objections of the GOP.

Sen. Pat Toomey, a Pennsylvania Republican who had a hand in placing Brann on the bench during the Obama administration, said the ruling showed Trump had exhausted all possible legal avenues in the state and went on to congratulate Biden on his victory. He called Brann “a longtime conservative Republican whom I know to be a fair and unbiased jurist.”

Giuliani, a former federal prosecutor and New York mayor, showed his rustiness during the hearing this week by tripping himself up over the meaning of “opacity,” mistaking the judge for a federal judge in a separate district and provoking an opposing lawyer.

Giuliani repeatedly contended in court that it was illegal for counties to help people vote. Opposing lawyer Mark Aronchick suggested Giuliani must not know the Pennsylvania election code.

The Trump-aligned attorneys had argued that the U.S. Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection under the law was violated when Pennsylvania counties took different approaches to notifying voters before the election about technical problems with their submitted mail-in ballots.

The judge dismissed the argument entirely.

Pennsylvania Secretary of State Kathy Boockvar and the seven Biden-majority counties that the campaign sued had argued throwing out the popular vote over isolated allegations of mail-in fraud was far too extreme, particularly after most of them have been tallied.

“There is no justification on any level for the radical disenfranchisement they seek,” Boockvar’s lawyers wrote in a brief filed Thursday.

Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, tweeted shortly after Brann's ruling that “another one bites the dust.”

“These claims were meritless from the start and for an audience of one,” Shapiro said in a statement. “The will of the people will prevail. These baseless lawsuits need to end.”

Counties must certify their results to Boockvar by Monday, after which she will make her own certification. Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf will notify the winning candidate’s electors they should appear to vote in the Capitol on Dec. 14.


Long reported from Washington.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
AP source: VanVleet staying with Raptors; Hayward to Hornets
A person with direct knowledge of the discussions tells The Associated Press that guard Fred VanVleet has agreed to a four-year, $85 million contract to remain with the Toronto Raptors
9:59PM ( 17 minutes ago )
In blistering ruling, judge throws out Trump suit in Pa.
A federal judge has dismissed the Trump campaign’s longshot effort to block the certification of votes in Pennsylvania
9:54PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Asia Today: Cases in Japan hit record amid holiday travel
The daily tally of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Japan has hit a record for the fourth day at 2,508
9:23PM ( 53 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Protesters burn part of Guatemala's Congress building
Hundreds of protesters have broken into Guatemala’s Congress and burned part of the building amid growing demonstrations against President Alejandro Giammattei and the legislature for approving a budget that cut educational and health spending
7:50PM ( 2 hours ago )
Carson says he's 'out of the woods' after battling COVID-19
Housing Secretary Ben Carson is crediting unapproved, experimental treatments with saving his life after saying he became “desperately ill” following his infection with the coronavirus
7:13PM ( 3 hours ago )
G-20 summit opens as leaders urge united response to virus
The Group of 20 summit has begun with appeals by the world’s most powerful leaders to collectively chart a way forward as the coronavirus pandemic overshadows this year’s gathering, transforming it from in-person meetings to a virtual gathering of speeches and declarations
7:02PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
In cities across US, voters support more police oversight
Voters in communities across the country have approved measures toughening civilian oversight of law enforcement agencies
9:01AM ( 13 hours ago )
In cities across US, voters sanction more police oversight
Voters in communities across the country have approved measures toughening civilian oversight of law enforcement agencies
8:55AM ( 13 hours ago )
California enacts nighttime curfew as COVID-19 cases spike
California is enacting a nighttime curfew Saturday as spiking coronavirus cases threaten to swamp health care systems
12:49AM ( 21 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
The Latest: Donald Trump Jr. doing 'very well' with virus
President Donald Trump says his eldest son, Donald Trump Jr., is doing “very well” in quarantine after becoming infected with the coronavirus
1:15PM ( 9 hours ago )
The Latest: Midwest governors: Stay home for Thanksgiving
Coronavirus infections are ravaging South Dakota, where more than half of tests have come back positive for weeks
12:17PM ( 10 hours ago )
Bodies of man and his slave unearthed from ashes at Pompeii
Italian archaeological officials say the skeletal remains of two people believed to be those of a rich man and his male slave have been discovered at the site of ancient Pompeii
12:15PM ( 10 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
France: Bill on publishing police images sparks protests
Thousands of people in France have protested a proposed security law that would make it a criminal offense to publish images of police officers with the intent to cause them harm
3:03PM ( 7 hours ago )
Protests staged across France against bill on police images
Thousands of people took to the streets in Paris and other French cities Saturday to protest a proposed security law they say would impinge on freedom of information and media rights
12:27PM ( 9 hours ago )
White House Rose Garden adds Japanese American's sculpture
The White House Rose Garden has a new addition, but it isn't a floral variety
9:33AM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Japan's confirmed COVID-19 cases hit new record
Japans health ministry says the number of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Japan reached a record for the third day straight, at 2,418 cases
11:25PM ( 22 hours ago )
The Latest: SKorea's virus surge could bring more measures
South Korea has reported 386 new cases of the coronavirus, its fourth straight day of over 300, a viral resurgence that could force authorities to reimpose stronger social distancing restrictions after easing them in October to spur a faltering economy
10:32PM ( 23 hours ago )
The Latest: Texas tops 8,000 hospitalized virus patients
Texas has surpassed 8,000 hospitalized coronavirus patients for the first time since a deadly summer surge, and doctors are amplifying pleas to keep Thanksgiving gatherings small
7:00PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Congress News
Who needs Russia? Loudest attacks on US vote are from Trump
In the weeks before the presidential election, federal authorities warned that foreign countries could spread false information about the results to discredit the legitimacy of the outcome
12:24AM ( 21 hours ago )
US Rep. Mike Garcia claims win in swing district north of LA
Republican U.S. Rep. Mike Garcia claimed victory Friday in his back-and-forth contest with Democrat Christy Smith in the 25th District north of Los Angeles
10:31PM ( 23 hours ago )
Georgia governor certifies presidential electors for Biden
Georgia’s Republican governor and top elections official have certified results showing Joe Biden won the presidential race over Republican President Donald Trump
7:06PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections
Trump to meet Michigan leaders in bid to subvert election
Michigan state legislators are headed to the White House as President Donald Trump makes an extraordinary and sure-to-be futile attempt to block Joe Biden’s victory in the battleground state and subvert the results of the 2020 presidential election
2:07PM ( 1 day ago )
Trump objects to counting thousands of Wisconsin ballots
The recount of the presidential election in Wisconsin’s two most heavily Democratic counties has begun with President Donald Trump’s campaign seeking to discard tens of thousands of absentee ballots
1:27PM ( 1 day ago )
VP Mike Pence comes to Georgia ahead of Senate runoffs
Vice President Mike Pence is campaigning Friday in Georgia in support of the state’s two Republican senators
12:20PM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Death toll at 37 in Uganda unrest after Bobi Wine's arrest
The death toll from protests over the arrest of Ugandan opposition presidential hopeful and musician Bobi Wine has risen to 37, police said Friday
7:40AM ( 1 day ago )
Burkina Faso to vote amid escalating violence
Burkina Faso citizens will vote in presidential and legislative elections on Sunday, amid escalating extremist violence that’s killed more than 2,000 people this year and displaced some one million people from their homes
7:25AM ( 1 day ago )
Sanders, Warren under scrutiny as Biden weighs Cabinet picks
Democratic Party left wing leaders Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren are at risk of being excluded from the senior ranks of President-elect Joe Biden’s administration as Biden balances the demands of his party’s progressive base against the political realities of a narrowly divided Senate
5:48AM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
AP source: VanVleet staying with Raptors; Hayward to Hornets
A person with direct knowledge of the discussions tells The Associated Press that guard Fred VanVleet has agreed to a four-year, $85 million contract to remain with the Toronto Raptors
9:59PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Asia Today: Cases in Japan hit record amid holiday travel
The daily tally of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Japan has hit a record for the fourth day at 2,508
9:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
EXPLAINER: Trump's election challenges falling flat in court
While President Donald Trump vows to press ahead with efforts to overturn the election, judges across the country have consistently swatted down his legal challenges
8:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
Ramsey, No. 19 Northwestern top No. 10 Wisconsin 17-7
Peyton Ramsey threw two touchdown passes and No. 19 Northwestern shut down Graham Mertz and No. 10 Wisconsin for a 17-7 victory that put the undefeated Wildcats in control of the Big Ten West
8:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
Judge throws out Trump bid to stop PA vote certification
A federal judge in Pennsylvania says he won’t stop officials from certifying election results that show Democrat Joe Biden winning the state by more than 80,000 votes
8:43PM ( 1 hour ago )