Thursday April 15th, 2021 10:41PM

Giuliani shows at Trump camp lawsuit hearing in Pennsylvania

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WILLIAMSPORT, Pa. (AP) — A hearing on the Trump campaign's federal lawsuit seeking to prevent Pennsylvania officials from certifying the vote results was set to begin Tuesday after a judge denied the campaign's new lawyer's request for a delay.

Rudy Giuliani, the former New York City mayor and the president’s personal attorney, entered the federal courthouse in Williamsport to cheers across the street from several dozen supporters of President Donald Trump.

U.S. District Judge Matthew Brann had told lawyers for Donald J. Trump for President Inc. and the counties and state election official it has sued that they must show up and “be prepared for argument and questioning" at the federal courthouse.

Giuliani filed Tuesday morning to represent Trump in the case. He has not entered an appearance in federal court since 1992, according to online court records. That was the year before he was elected mayor.

The Trump campaign wants to prevent certification of results that give President-elect Joe Biden the state's 20 electoral votes, suing over election procedures that were not uniform across the state. Giuliani has promised a raft of lawsuits and to provide Trump with evidence of voter fraud in the drive to overturn the election result.

Pennsylvania Secretary of State Kathy Boockvar, a Democrat, has asked to have the lawsuit thrown out, calling its allegations in court filings “at best, garden-variety irregularities.”

Brann scheduled the hearing to discuss the campaign's request for a temporary restraining order as well as the defendants' request to have the case dismissed.

After Pittsburgh lawyers dropped out of representing Trump's campaign on Friday, Philadelphia election lawyer Linda Kerns and two Texas lawyers also filed to withdraw Monday.

Camp Hill lawyer Mark Scaringi, a losing candidate in the 2012 Republican U.S. Senate primary, notified the judge he was stepping in but did not get the delay he sought.

The Associated Press has declared Biden the winner of the presidential contest, but Trump has refused to concede and is blocking Biden’s efforts toward a smoother transition of power. With Georgia the only uncalled state, Biden has collected at least 290 electoral votes — just enough that overturning Pennsylvania's result would not open an avenue to a second term for Trump.

Biden's margin in Pennsylvania is now more than 73,000 votes.

There is no evidence of widespread fraud in the 2020 election, and experts say Trump’s various lawsuits have no chance of reversing the outcome in a single state, let alone the election. In fact, election officials from both political parties have stated publicly that the election went well, and international observers confirmed there were no serious irregularities.

The issues Trump’s campaign and its allies have pointed to are typical in every election: problems with signatures, secrecy envelopes and postal marks on mail-in ballots, as well as the potential for a small number of ballots miscast or lost.

Trump’s campaign has also launched legal challenges complaining that its poll watchers were unable to scrutinize the voting process. Many of those challenges were tossed out by judges, some within hours.

Trump’s legal team has so far scored just two small victories. In one case, a court allowed their observers to stand a little closer to election workers processing mail-in ballots in Philadelphia. In another, Pennsylvania counties were ordered not to count mail-in or absentee ballots for which the voter didn’t submit valid identification within six days after the election, but that ruling is expected to affect no more than a few thousand ballots.

A slew of other legal challenges brought by Republicans have quickly been swatted down or withdrawn.

On Monday, a conservative group that has been pushing baseless claims that absentee voting is rife with fraud abruptly dropped lawsuits it had filed in Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania and Georgia with no explanation.

One Trump campaign case that is still pending seeks to block the certification of election results in Michigan, but the state appeals court on Monday denied another bid to stop the certification of Detroit-area votes.

In Pennsylvania, the Trump legal challenge being heard Tuesday centers on how some counties let voters fix, or “cure,” mail-in ballots that lacked secrecy envelopes or had other problems. The Trump campaign’s lawsuit claims counties’ inconsistent practices violated constitutional rights of due process and equal protection under the law and resulted in the “unlawful dilution or debasement” of properly cast votes.

“Democratic heavy counties,” the lawsuit alleges, notified voters about the lack of secrecy envelopes or other problems in time for some to fix them, but counties in Republican regions “followed the law and did not provide a notice and cure process, disenfranchising many.”

The lawsuit seeks to stop Boockvar and election boards in seven Biden-majority counties that are co-defendants from counting absentee and mail-in ballots that the Republican president’s campaign claims were “improperly permitted to be cured.”

Boockvar’s lawyers described Trump’s claims as generalized grievances and speculative injuries that would not warrant throwing out the election results.

They told Brann that other counties could have permitted their voters to fix problem mail-in ballots, but chose not to.

“Election practices need not cater to the lowest common denominator, and Plaintiffs’ arguments would improperly penalize those counties that are enfranchising voters by helping them avoid ballot disqualification,” they wrote.


Associated Press writer Alanna Durkin Richer in Boston contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Twitter, Facebook CEOs defend election actions, promise more
The CEOs of Twitter and Facebook have defended their safeguards against disinformation in the presidential election
1:49PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Amazon opens online pharmacy, shaking up another industry
Now sold on Amazon: insulin and inhalers
1:46PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Biden filling top White House team with campaign veterans
President-elect Joe Biden has announced top White House staff positions, drawing from the senior ranks of his campaign and some of his closest confidants
1:35PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Georgia elections chief battles fellow Republicans, Trump
Georgia’s top elections official is under attack from President Donald Trump and other fellow Republicans in the aftermath of the heated election season
1:15PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Play 'Thoughts of a Colored Man' to get a Broadway run
Playwright Keenan Scott II’s play “Thoughts of a Colored Man,” a work about the outer and inner lives of Black men, is heading to the bright lights of Broadway
1:04PM ( 47 minutes ago )
Hurricane Iota roars onto Nicaragua as 2nd blow in 2 weeks
Hurricane Iota is tearing across Nicaragua, hours after roaring ashore as a Category 4 storm along almost exactly the same stretch of the Caribbean coast that was recently devastated by an equally powerful hurricane
1:04PM ( 47 minutes ago )
AP National News
The Latest: British PM Johnson tests negative for virus
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has tested negative for the coronavirus, but will complete 14 days of self-isolation because of contact with an infected person
9:50AM ( 4 hours ago )
Twitter: 300,000 tweets flagged over election disinformation
The CEO of Twitter says the service flagged some 300,000 tweets as part of efforts to combat disinformation in the period around the 2020 election between President Donald Trump and Democrat Joe Biden
9:40AM ( 4 hours ago )
Bach issues gentle plea for Olympians to get vaccinated
IOC President Thomas Bach has issued a gentle plea to all competitors to get vaccinated before the Tokyo Olympics
8:58AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Georgia elections chief fights fellow Republicans, Trump
Georgia’s top elections official is under attack from President Donald Trump and other fellow Republicans in the aftermath of the heated election season
12:08AM ( 13 hours ago )
Georgia official says Graham asked him about tossing ballots
Georgia’s secretary of state said that U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham asked him whether he had the power to reject certain absentee ballots
11:13PM ( 14 hours ago )
The Latest: Iowa's governor orders statewide mask mandate
With Iowa hospitals filling up, Gov. Kim Reynolds has dropped her opposition to a statewide mandate for mask use to combat the spread of the coronavirus
9:08PM ( 16 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
House asks justices to put off case over Russia grand jury
The Democratic-controlled House of Representatives is asking the Supreme Court to put off upcoming arguments about whether Congress should have access to secret grand jury testimony from special counsel Robert Mueller’s Russia investigation
12:39PM ( 1 hour ago )
Thai protesters, police clash as MPs mull charter change
Pro-democracy protesters in Thailand have battled police who sought to keep them from entering the grounds of Parliament to press for constitutional changes as lawmakers debate whether to back proposed amendments
12:25PM ( 1 hour ago )
EU urges Poland, Hungary to sign up to big money budget
Germany is urging member states to put divergences aside in a bid to break a stalemate on the adoption of the bloc’s €1.8 trillion budget and coronavirus recovery package blocked by Poland and Hungary
12:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Trump attacks Vegas-area certification of Biden election win
As officials in Nevada certified results of the Nov. 3 election, President Donald Trump took to Twitter on Monday with a new attack on the vote that gave Democratic candidate Joe Biden a 33,596-vote statewide victory
9:54PM ( 15 hours ago )
Peru's Congress selects centrist lawmaker to be new leader
Peru’s Congress has chosen a new leader expected to become the nation’s third president in the span of a week, a hopeful sign that the political crisis is on the verge of resolution
9:18PM ( 16 hours ago )
Biden filling out top White House team with campaign vets
President-elect Joe Biden is drawing from the senior ranks of his campaign to fill out an increasingly diverse White House leadership team
9:04PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Elections
Facebook, Twitter CEOs to be pressed on election handling
The CEOs of Facebook and Twitter are being summoned before Congress to defend their handling of disinformation in the contest between President Donald Trump and Democrat Joe Biden
2:41PM ( 23 hours ago )
Hardening partisan map steepens Democrats' climb in Senate
Senate Democrats have been in the minority for six years, but that might soon change
12:29PM ( 1 day ago )
Americans across party lines, regions embrace marijuana
Recreational marijuana initiatives passed in four states this year, from liberal New Jersey to conservative Montana and South Dakota
9:20AM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Brazil voters ignore Bolsonaro's city election endorsements
Brazil’s President Jair Bolsonaro has suffered a setback as most of the dozens of candidates he backed for municipal elections failed to secure victories or spots in runoffs
12:30PM ( 1 day ago )
Pro-Western candidate wins Moldovan presidential election
Maia Sandu, a former World Bank economist who favors closer ties with the European Union, has won presidential runoff elections in Moldova, decisively defeating the staunchly pro-Russian incumbent
6:39AM ( 1 day ago )
Trump seems to acknowledge Biden win, but he won't concede
President Donald Trump tweeted the words “he won” early Sunday but quickly made clear he hadn't changed his tune about Joe Biden getting more votes in the 2020 presidential election
9:18PM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
Bloomberg's big spending struggles to sway election outcomes
After pouring more than $1.2 billion of his personal fortune into presidential politics this election, former New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg has little to show for it
12:39AM ( 3 days ago )
Republicans face court setbacks, Trump law firm steps down
Republicans suffered setbacks to court challenges over the presidential election in three battleground states on Friday as a national law firm that came under fire for its work for President Trump’s campaign withdrew from a major Pennsylvania case
6:37PM ( 3 days ago )
In Georgia, Trump's shadow looms over pair of Senate runoffs
President Donald Trump won’t be on the ballot in January as Georgia voters settle two Senate runoffs that will determine who controls the chamber at the start of Democratic President-elect Joe Biden’s tenure
4:22PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Biden filling top White House team with campaign veterans
President-elect Joe Biden has announced top White House staff positions, drawing from the senior ranks of his campaign and some of his closest confidants
1:35PM ( 18 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump ally Netanyahu calls Biden president-elect
Israel’s president and prime minister have spoken with Joe Biden for the first time since his victory in the U.S. election
1:28PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Turkish parliament approves peacekeepers for Azerbaijan
Turkey’s parliament has granted President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s government permission to deploy peacekeepers to Azerbaijan to monitor a cease-fire deal between Azerbaijan and Armenia that aims to end the conflict in the region
1:27PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Twitter launches disappearing tweets that vanish in a day
Twitter is launching tweets that disappear in 24 hours called “Fleets” globally, echoing social media sites like Snapchat, Facebook and Instagram that already have disappearing posts
1:20PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Wall Street taps the brakes following its record-setting run
U.S. stocks are taking a pause on Tuesday from their big rally this month that vaulted them back to record heights
1:20PM ( 34 minutes ago )