Thursday April 15th, 2021 7:22AM

Taking a stand has new meaning in heavily litigated election

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

In the most litigious presidential election in memory, court fights are even happening over where poll watchers may stand as the votes are tallied.

Lawsuits by the hundreds already have been filed — with the prospect of many more before and after Tuesday's voting — as both Democrats and Republicans try to settle in court a process that is usually determined by citizens simply casting ballots.

The legal action runs along a broad spectrum, from a dispute over whether guns are allowed near polling places to more complicated matters that already have reached the Supreme Court.

"The level of litigation has just been so unprecedented," said Sophia Lin Lakin, deputy director of the American Civil Liberties Union's Voting Rights Project. “It does feel like there’s a desire to elevate any possible thing. Possible misunderstandings or just disagreements with what the rules are is somehow ending up in court. It feels very different."

Roughly 300 lawsuits have been filed over the election in dozens of states across the country, and still scores remain unsettled just days before Election Day. Many involve changes to normal procedures given the coronavirus pandemic, which has killed more than 227,000 people in the U.S. and sickened more than 8.8 million.

The campaigns of President Donald Trump and his Democratic rival, Joe Biden, have been quietly building armies of lawyers preparing for the possibility of a drawn-out legal fight that lands at the Supreme Court.

The latest focus for Republicans in some places is on poll watchers, who are volunteers for candidates or political parties long used in elections. They monitor voting places and local election offices and make note of potential problems as a way to challenge the voting or tabulating process.

The role of poll watchers or challengers has gained increased attention this year as Trump has pushed unfounded claims about the potential for voter fraud because of an increase in mailed-in ballots. Trump has been urging his supporters to go to the polls and “watch very carefully,” raising concerns about possible voter intimidation. He has also falsely stated that poll watchers were “thrown out” of a polling site in Philadelphia, where he has claimed without evidence that “bad things" are happening.

In Nevada, Trump's campaign and state Republicans went to court to try to stop the counting of Las Vegas-area mail-in ballots. Republicans say observers aren’t allowed close enough to workers and machines at the busy vote-counting center in suburban Las Vegas to challenge signatures in the state’s biggest and most Democratic-leaning county.

Jesse Binnall, an attorney for the Republican Party and Trump campaign, told a judge Wednesday that the counting process observed in Las Vegas prevents what he called a “meaningful opportunity” to challenge the validity of mailed ballots.

“People who vote in person can have their ballot challenged,” Binnall said. “People who vote by mail cannot.”

Nevada Democrats have called the lawsuit a “plain and simple” effort to suppress votes in the state’s most diverse county.

“Clark County is a blue county,” Gregory Zunino, deputy Nevada state solicitor general, told the judge. “They quite frankly would like to exclude as many ballots or signatures in Clark County as they can.”

Nevada Republicans and the Trump campaign filed another lawsuit this week demanding the county's registrar turn over names of Democrats, Republicans and nonpartisan ballot workers, election monitors and poll watchers along with details about their work instructions and shifts.

In Michigan, a candidate for the state House of Representatives sued this week, alleging coronavirus social distancing rules are preventing poll watchers from properly overseeing the election process. The lawsuit was quickly resolved with an agreement that poll watchers can look at election books and approach poll workers when necessary.

Meanwhile, New Mexico's highest court this week rejected a lawsuit brought by the state Republican Party alleging partisan poll challengers have been unfairly denied oversight of the initial ballot verification process. The lawsuit from Republicans including several state legislators and county clerks alleged partisan challengers are being shut out of the initial verification process unnecessarily, based on privacy regulations.

In Philadelphia, Trump’s campaign filed a lawsuit this month demanding its campaign representatives be allowed to monitor people registering to vote or filling out mail-in ballots in election offices in the battleground state. A judge ruled Pennsylvania law doesn't allow such representatives to observe in election offices, and that decision was upheld by an appeals court.

Other lawsuits across the country involve when to stop counting mail-in ballots if received after Tuesday, bans on curbside voting in the pandemic, issues over drop boxes for voters and enforcing strict witness requirements.

A judge recently overturned a ban in Michigan that prevented open-carry guns at the polls. And new lawsuits keep cropping up: A man in Maryland has sued the board of elections in Harford County following his arrest last week as he tried to vote without a face mask.

Pennsylvania officials have ordered ballots received after Tuesday to be segregated after a challenge pending before the Supreme Court on whether ballots can be counted after Election Day. The court on Wednesday turned away Republicans' plea to cut the deadline for receipt of absentee ballots in North Carolina, which means they can be received up until Nov. 12.

The lawsuits are adding to the confusion and uncertainty around the vote. And experts say legal challenges claiming the process was flawed will undoubtedly keep streaming in in the days after the election. But to have any chance of success, they'll have to show evidence of real legal violations.

"You know you're going to see those lawsuits in part because the president has been saying that the election has been fundamentally unfair since the last election," said Loyola Law School professor Justin Levitt, a former Justice Department elections official. But “the fact that you could file a lawsuit saying the election was fundamentally unfair because ‘fraud, maybe?!’ is not a thing that the courts will pay any attention to," he said.


Associated Press writers Colleen Long in Washington, Ken Ritter in Las Vegas, Maryclaire Dale in Philadelphia and Ed White in Detroit contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Political Conventions, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2021
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Trump, Biden to appeal to last-minute voters in Florida
President Donald Trump and Democratic rival Joe Biden are set to chase votes in Florida, a state all but essential to the Republican’s pathway to another term
12:46AM ( 6 minutes ago )
Taking a stand has new meaning in heavily litigated election
The United States is barreling toward Election Day in what is believed to be the most litigated race in American history
12:44AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Letters, texts, caravans, parades: Advocates mobilize voters
In the best of times, it’s a massive logistical challenge to get millions out to vote
12:42AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Pompeo, in Indonesia, renews China attacks as US vote looms
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is in Indonesia renewing the Trump administration's rhetorical onslaught against China as the American presidential election looms
11:46PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Explains: Trump pushes questions about Joe Biden's son
President Donald Trump’s campaign is pushing a familiar line of attack against Democrat Joe Biden in the final days of the presidential campaign: unverified allegations about Biden’s son and his foreign business ties
10:34PM ( 2 hours ago )
Former DHS official says he wrote 'Anonymous' Trump critique
A former Trump administration official who penned a scathing anti-Trump op-ed and book under the pen name “Anonymous” is making his identify public
10:06PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Feds issue coverage plan for COVID-19 vaccine and treatments
Federal health officials are issuing insurance coverage rules designed to deliver on the promise that every American will have access to free COVID-19 vaccines when they are approved
6:56PM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump calls 'Anonymous' critic a 'sleazebag'
President Donald Trump says a former administration official who penned a scathing anti-Trump op-ed and book under the pen name “Anonymous” was a “sleazebag.”
6:41PM ( 6 hours ago )
Social media CEOs rebuff bias claims, vow to defend election
The CEOs of Twitter, Facebook and Google rebuffed accusations of anti-conservative bias during testimony to a Senate hearing on Wednesday
6:28PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Asian shares lower, US futures up after S&P 500 sinks 3.5%
Asian shares have logged moderate losses after the S&P 500 dropped 3.5% as markets shuddered over surging coronavirus cases that are bringing fresh pandemic shutdown measures
11:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
Philadelphia pledges better response after Black man's death
Philadelphia police pledged to release 911 tapes and footage from police body cameras “in the near future” in the shooting death of a Black man with a history of mental health problems
7:19PM ( 5 hours ago )
In Florida's Old South, a new political battleground emerges
The last time Florida's Duval County voted for a Democratic presidential contender, it was 1976 and the candidate was Jimmy Carter
6:34PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Elections
Millions of mailed ballots not yet returned in key states
Millions of mail ballots have yet to be returned in key battleground states just days before the presidential election
3:08PM ( 9 hours ago )
The Latest: Biden will tell world leaders 'America is back'
If he wins the presidency, one of Joe Biden’s first moves will be to call foreign leaders and tell them “America is back.”
3:01PM ( 9 hours ago )
Police: 7 taken to hospitals after Trump Omaha airport rally
Police in Omaha, Nebraska, say at least seven people who attended an airport rally for President Donald Trump were taken to hospitals
2:59PM ( 9 hours ago )
General Election News
Tanzania votes but 'widespread irregularities' are claimed
Tanzania’s leading opposition presidential candidate asserts that Wednesday's election saw “widespread irregularities" amid a massive internet slowdown
2:00PM ( 10 hours ago )
Ahead of the election, a landslide of documentaries
The election has unleashed an avalanche of documentaries like no season before it
12:10PM ( 12 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump supporters delayed in the cold after rally
Throngs of people who attended a campaign rally held by President Donald Trump at a Nebraska airport had to wait around in frigid weather for hours after it ended before they could get back to their cars
10:08AM ( 14 hours ago )
General Presidential Election News
Biden vows to unify and save country; Trump hits Midwest
Joe Biden has traveled to the hot springs town where Franklin Delano Roosevelt coped with polio to declare the U.S. is not too politically diseased to overcome its health and economic crises
11:17PM ( 1 day ago )
Collins votes against Barrett, heads home to save Senate job
Republican Sen. Susan Collins of Maine is back on the campaign trail after another controversial vote on another of President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominees
10:54PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Trump heaping attention on 1 Nebraska district
President Donald Trump is heaping attention on Nebraska’s 2nd Congressional District in the home stretch before Election Day
9:26PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Political Conventions
Change of plea scheduled in Rudy Giuliani-related case
A change-of-plea hearing is set for Thursday for a man charged with conspiring with associates of Rudy Giuliani to make illegal campaign contributions
11:38AM ( 13 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump says he's getting husbands back to work
President Donald Trump has a new message to suburban women as he campaigns in Michigan: “We’re getting your husbands back to work.”
5:57PM ( 1 day ago )
If Trump wanted people to avoid '60 Minutes,' it didn't work
Angry about his interview with Lesley Stahl of “60 Minutes,” President Donald Trump released an unedited version of the talk on Facebook three days before the broadcast
5:22PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
FBI warns ransomware assault threatens US healthcare system
Federal agencies say cybercriminals are unleashing a major ransomware assault against the U.S. healthcare system
12:50AM ( 3 minutes ago )
Trump, Biden to appeal to last-minute voters in Florida
President Donald Trump and Democratic rival Joe Biden are set to chase votes in Florida, a state all but essential to the Republican’s pathway to another term
12:46AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Letters, texts, caravans, parades: Advocates mobilize voters
In the best of times, it’s a massive logistical challenge to get millions out to vote
12:42AM ( 11 minutes ago )
The University of Pittsburgh acquires August Wilson trove
The University of Pittsburgh has acquired the archive of the late playwright and Pittsburgh native son August Wilson, a trove that contains recordings, letters, artwork, poetry, unpublished work and notebooks
12:16AM ( 36 minutes ago )
Samsung reports record sales amid questions about future
As Samsung Electronics mourns the death of its long-time chairman, Lee Kun-Hee, questions loom over what's next for South Korea's biggest company
12:14AM ( 38 minutes ago )