fog.png
Wednesday September 22nd, 2021 9:38AM

Beyond the Needle: Probability experts assess 2020 race

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — The one thing most likely to conjure nightmares of the 2016 election night for opponents of President Donald Trump is the Needle.

A graphic on The New York Times' website, the Needle measured in real time the probability of victory for Trump or Hillary Clinton as votes were counted. Its steady movement triggered anxiety for Clinton supporters, who repeatedly refreshed the page, and elation for Trump fans.

There’s no sign that the Needle will be making a reappearance on Nov. 3, which would be one change in the world of election probability gurus following the unexpected 2016 result. Nate Silver's influential FiveThirtyEight blog used a number, not a needle, for the same task four years ago but won't on election night 2020.

Silver said the change had more to do with uncertainties created by the high volume of early voting this year than any failures in 2016.

“I just think people need to be exceptionally careful,” he said.

Silver has been a pioneer in the specialized field of statistic experts who crunch the growing number of public opinion polls to put them in a broader context. Nate Cohn of the Times and his blog The Upshot, is also a leader.

They amplified the shock of 2016 by predicting a high probability of a Clinton victory. Samuel Wang of the Princeton Election Consortium said she had a 93% chance of victory — a call that later led him to eat a cricket live on CNN as penance.

Cohn went into election night saying Clinton had an 85% chance of winning, and that served as the Needle's baseline. The graphic was a meter, shaped like a half-clock, with outcomes that ranged from a “very likely” Clinton win to the same for Trump.

At 8:02 p.m. Eastern time on election night, the Needle pointed sharply to the left, and a “likely” Clinton win. It moved to the right as results came in. By 10 p.m., the pointer headed into the “toss-up” category and, less than two hours later, was “leaning Trump.”

You know how the story ended.

In later mea culpas, pollsters noted they weren't far off in predicting Clinton's advantage in the popular vote. Crucial state polls in Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin had been wrong, however, and that was enough for Trump to win the Electoral College.

Silver was more cautious heading into election night; his final forecast gave Clinton a 71% chance of winning and Trump a 29% likelihood. For that, he was criticized by those who couldn't conceive of a Trump win.

While a 29% chance may not seem like much, Silver notes that a .290 batting average is pretty decent for a Major League baseball player. That's where the probability experts acknowledge their weakness, in communicating that a Trump victory was not impossible.

Cohn later wrote, “We failed at explaining that an 85% chance is not 100%.”

“We think people should have been better prepared for it,” Silver wrote after the election. “There was a widespread complacency about Clinton's chances in a way that wasn't justified by careful analysis of the data and uncertainties surrounding it.”

When the Times announced before the 2020 Democratic primaries that the Needle would return, it provoked an anxious response encapsulated in a Rolling Stone magazine headline: “ The New York Times Needle and the Damage Done.”

But that response has a lot to do with perspective. The newspaper's readership, like the city itself, is heavily liberal.

“It performed exactly as we had hoped,” Cohn wrote in 2018, “and, frankly, if more readers and journalists were conservative, they would have seen it ... as the leading indicator of a thrilling upset.”

The Times didn’t make Cohn or any other editor available for an interview, so the Needle’s fate is shrouded in some mystery. Times media writer Ben Smith quoted a top editor in August as saying the paper was looking at a “range of tools” as alternatives to what Smith described as “the single, predictive needle that offered readers false confidence in 2016.”

The probability experts aren't shying away from predictions this year. Silver's site said Saturday its computers had simulated the election 40,000 times, and Democrat Joe Biden won in 87% of them.

The Upshot said Biden would win 357 electoral votes if the polls through Saturday were correct, while Princeton put him at 358 electoral votes — both enough for a comfortable victory.

FiveThirtyEight has consciously given its election forecast a less prominent spot on the website this year, Silver said. That's not to signal a lack of confidence, but is being done to make it harder for followers to obsess over it.

The election night probability estimate is being replaced by an interactive tool that will allow readers to click and see what it does for the final result if individual states go one way or another.

Wang's Princeton site has an intriguing “Moneyball” feature that calculates where a person's vote has the greatest value, based on a state's population and the closeness of the polls. Currently, he puts voters in Nevada, Arizona and Maine's 2nd Congressional District at the top.

“Looking back on polling errors is missing the point this year,” Wang said. “The point this year is whether we're going to have orderly and fair elections.”

Silver said the average person probably had too much confidence in the polls in 2016 and now it has shifted in the other direction. They may be going out of their way to take seriously the chances Trump can win.

“I can't control what people think,” he said. “I can only control that we're doing the best work that we possibly can.”

___

This story has been corrected to show that comments about alternatives to the Needle were in an August column, not a blog post last week, and that Times editors have stopped short of confirming the Needle will not return for the election.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top General short headlines, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Political Conventions
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Surging coronavirus colors White House race in closing days
President Donald Trump assured supporters packed shoulder to shoulder Saturday in North Carolina that “we’re rounding the turn” on the coronavirus and mocked his Democratic challenger, Joe Biden, for raising alarms
4:48PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Beyond the Needle: Probability experts assess 2020 race
Probability estimates for the 2020 U.S. presidential election are still being made, but one fixture of the 2016 cycle won’t make a return
4:41PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Murkowski's nod gives Barrett extra boost for Supreme Court
Sen. Lisa Murkowski has announced that she'll vote to confirm Amy Coney Barrett
4:38PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Opposition activist leaves embassy haven to flee Venezuela
The party of prominent opposition activist Leopoldo López has abandoned the Spanish ambassador’s residence in Caracas and left Venezuela after years of frustrated efforts to oust the nation’s socialist president
3:11PM ( 1 hour ago )
Cunningham keeps low in NC Senate race marked by his affair
North Carolina Democratic Senate candidate Cal Cunningham is bypassing uncomfortable questions about his extramarital activities in the final days of his race with GOP Sen. Thom Tillis
2:40PM ( 2 hours ago )
Attack in Kabul kills 18; al-Qaida leader killed in Ghazni
Afghanistan’s interior ministry says a suicide attack outside an educational center in the capital, Kabul, has killed at least 18 people and wounded 57 others, including students
1:50PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
Ethiopia blasts Trump remark that Egypt will 'blow up' dam
Ethiopia is denouncing “belligerent threats” over the huge dam it has nearly completed on the Nile, a day after U.S. President Donald Trump said downstream Egypt will “blow up” the project it calls an existential threat
9:56AM ( 7 hours ago )
Voter advocates hoping to stave off intimidation at polls
Election officials are on high alert over fears that U.S. polling stations could attract the same strain of partisan violence and civil unrest that erupted on American streets this year
9:38AM ( 7 hours ago )
'All talk, no action' defense likely in Michigan kidnap case
Defense lawyers for the men accused of trying to kidnap Michigan Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer are likely to argue that their clients were all talk and no action
9:13AM ( 7 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Alaska Sen. Murkowski to support Barrett for Supreme Court
Sen. Lisa Murkowski has announced that she'll vote to confirm Amy Coney Barrett
3:37PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Biden will work hard for Trump 'chumps' too
Vice President Joe Biden has called Trump supporters gathered outside his drive-in rally “chumps,” but said he’d work hard for them if he win’s next month’s presidential election
3:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Trump touts 'incredible' numbers as virus soars
President Donald Trump is continuing to criticize Joe Biden for saying during their debate that the country is headed for a dark winter because of the pandemic — something health experts have been warning for months
2:45PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Elections
Work already underway for presidential inauguration
While much of Washington is twisted in knots over the upcoming election, there’s another contingent already busy trying to figure out how to stage an inauguration for the next president during a pandemic
2:46AM ( 14 hours ago )
Work already underway for inauguration of TBD president
While much of Washington is twisted in knots over the upcoming election, there’s another contingent already busy trying to figure out how to stage an inauguration for the next president during a pandemic
12:47AM ( 16 hours ago )
Trump to vote in Fla., hold 3 rallies; Biden focuses on Pa.
President Donald Trump is set to cast his own ballot in his adopted home state of Florida Saturday before rallying supporters in three other critical battleground states
12:18AM ( 16 hours ago )
General Election News
Parties' late spending on Senate races shows GOP's jeopardy
Republicans and Democrats are unleashing millions in eleventh-hour spending in Senate races
5:21PM ( 23 hours ago )
Trump: Sudan to join UAE, Bahrain in recognizing Israel
President Donald Trump says Sudan will start to normalize ties with Israel, making it the third Arab state to do so in the run-up to Election Day
4:24PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Biden accuses Trump of encouraging virus spread
Joe Biden has long accused the Trump administration of giving up on the coronavirus pandemic, but he is getting more aggressive, arguing that the president actively encouraged its spread
3:57PM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
The Latest: Trump says he will vote in person
President Donald Trump is taking his own advice and plans to vote in person in the presidential election on Saturday in Florida
1:32AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Biden clarifies debate answer on fossil fuels
Democrat Joe Biden says his pledge to gradually move the country away from fossil fuels to combat climate change doesn’t mean he will impose bans that could effectively shut down the oil and gas industry
12:01AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Final debate ends on different tone than 1st one
The second and final debate between President Donald Trump and Democratic nominee Joe Biden has ended, with a remarkably different tone than their first meeting
10:59PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Political Conventions
Surging coronavirus colors White House race in closing days
President Donald Trump assured supporters packed shoulder to shoulder Saturday in North Carolina that “we’re rounding the turn” on the coronavirus and mocked his Democratic challenger, Joe Biden, for raising alarms
4:48PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Murkowski's nod gives Barrett extra boost for Supreme Court
Sen. Lisa Murkowski has announced that she'll vote to confirm Amy Coney Barrett
4:38PM ( 22 minutes ago )
No. 1 Clemson wakes up late to beat Syracuse 47-21
No. 1 Clemson needed a second-half surge to put away pesky Syracuse 47-21 and win its 27th straight game against Atlantic Coast Conference competition
4:33PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Crews vacuum 'murder hornets' out of Washington nest
Heavily protected crews in Washington state have worked to destroy the first nest of so-called murder hornets discovered in the United States
4:24PM ( 36 minutes ago )
France reacts after Erdogan questions Macron's mental health
France has recalled its ambassador to Turkey after Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said President Emmanuel Macron needed mental health treatment and made other comments that the French government described as unacceptably rude
4:09PM ( 51 minutes ago )