cloudy.png
Wednesday September 22nd, 2021 10:25AM

Despite rhetoric, GOP has supported packing state courts

By The Associated Press

Republican claims that Democrats would expand the U.S. Supreme Court to undercut the conservative majority if they win the presidency and control of Congress has a familiar ring.

It's a tactic the GOP already has employed in recent years with state supreme courts when they have controlled all levers of state political power.

Republican governors in Arizona and Georgia have signed bills passed by GOP-dominated legislatures to expand the number of seats on their states’ respective high courts. In Iowa, the Republican governor gained greater leverage over the commission that names judicial nominees.

“The arguments being advanced now by Republican leaders — that this is an affront to separation of powers, that this is a way of delegitimizing courts — those don’t seem to be holding at the state level,” said Marin Levy, a law professor at Duke University who has written about efforts to expand state high courts.

President Donald Trump and the GOP have seized on the issue in the final weeks of the presidential race, arguing that Democratic nominee Joe Biden would push a Democratic Congress to increase the number of seats on the Supreme Court and fill those with liberal justices.

Some on the left have floated the idea in the wake of Republicans' rush to confirm Amy Coney Barrett to fill the seat of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a liberal icon who died last month.

Biden, for his part, has said he's not a fan of so-called “court packing,” and it's far from certain that Democrats can win back the majority in the U.S. Senate.

Arizona's governor, Republican Doug Ducey, said he opposes adding seats to the U.S. Supreme Court.

"We shouldn’t be changing our institutions,” he told reporters recently.

Yet Ducey signed a bill that did just that at the state level in 2016, expanding the Arizona Supreme Court from five seats to seven. As a result, Ducey has appointed more judges than any other governor in the state's history.

Ducey said the situations are not the same because Arizona’s system for selecting judges allows him to appoint them only from a list sent to him by a commission that interviews and vets candidates.

Arizona judges also face “retention” elections, a process that is essentially a formality. No state supreme court justice has ever lost a retention election.

“It’s apples and oranges,” Ducey said, comparing the state and federal high courts. “We have a merit selection process in Arizona, and I’m not the one who selects the judges that are put in front of me.”

That same year in Georgia, then-Gov. Nathan Deal signed similar legislation expanding that state's supreme court from seven to nine seats. Supporters said the move was needed because of the state's growing population and economy.

But the expansion allowed Deal to leave his conservative mark on the court by appointing a majority of its justices by the time he left office.

Democrats, including then-House Minority Leader Stacey Abrams, opposed the expansion. She questioned the need for adding seats without seeing the effects of other changes the Legislature made to the court’s responsibilities.

“To simultaneously increase the size of the court without really understanding the necessity, I find problematic,” Abrams, who two years later narrowly lost a bid for governor, said at the time. “There are political concerns, always, about appointments to the court and the positions that those new justices would take."

Some of the court-packing efforts at the state level have come in response to controversial court rulings. In 2007, a Republican state senator in the majority-Republican Florida Legislature proposed and later withdrew a proposal to more than double the number of seats on the state Supreme Court after the court struck down a school voucher bill. The legislation said the court's decision “betrays a lack of respect on the part of the majority for the separation of state powers."

A Republican lawmaker in Iowa's Legislature, then controlled by Democrats, proposed expanding the state's high court in 2009 following a ruling legalizing gay marriage in the state.

That effort was unsuccessful, but conservatives in the now majority GOP Iowa Legislature last year upended the way justices are chosen for the court. Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds signed into law legislation that effectively gave her a majority on the commission that names potential judges and justices.

The change had the backing of the Judicial Crisis Network, a conservative group in Washington that has spent millions on ads urging Barrett's confirmation.

“The people of Iowa want fair justice, so why do trial lawyers carry more weight than you?” the group said in a video backing the changes in Iowa.

The state-level moves are part of a broader, longer-term effort by conservatives to reshape the judiciary. Outside groups have been playing an increasing role in state judicial races in recent years. They accounted for a quarter of all spending in the 2018 state supreme court elections, and in some states outspent the candidates, according to figures compiled by the Brennan Center for Justice.

“There are just so many stories to point to from so many different states of legislators using every tool they have to give themselves and their allies an upper hand in the state’s most important courts," said Douglas Keith, counsel at the Brennan Center.

___

DeMillo reported from Little Rock, Ark. Associated Press writer Jonathan J. Cooper in Phoenix contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Online - Georgia News, AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
© Copyright 2021 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
'All talk, no action' defense likely in Michigan kidnap case
Defense lawyers for the men accused of trying to kidnap Michigan Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer are likely to argue that their clients were all talk and no action
9:13AM ( 1 hour ago )
US sets coronavirus infection record; deaths near 224,000
The U.S. coronavirus caseload has reached record heights with more than 83,000 infections reported in a single day
6:46AM ( 3 hours ago )
California prosecutors again seek death for Scott Peterson
California prosecutors say they will again seek the death penalty for Scott Peterson even as a county judge considers throwing out his conviction for murdering his pregnant wife because of juror misconduct during a trial that riveted the nation
12:27AM ( 9 hours ago )
U.S. News
Ethiopia blasts Trump remark that Egypt will 'blow up' dam
Ethiopia is denouncing “belligerent threats” over the huge dam it has nearly completed on the Nile, a day after U.S. President Donald Trump said downstream Egypt will “blow up” the project it calls an existential threat
9:56AM ( 19 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump voting in Florida; Bon Jovi joining Biden
President Donald Trump is casting his ballot Saturday morning, taking advantage of Florida’s early voting system
9:43AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Voter advocates hoping to stave off intimidation at polls
Election officials are on high alert over fears that U.S. polling stations could attract the same strain of partisan violence and civil unrest that erupted on American streets this year
9:38AM ( 36 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Needle goes away as probability experts assess 2020 race
Probability estimates for the 2020 U.S. presidential election are still being made, but one fixture of the 2016 cycle won’t make a return
8:40AM ( 1 hour ago )
As Trump casts doubt on election, new agency contradicts him
As President Donald Trump sows doubts about the election, an obscure government agency he created is working behind the scenes to inspire confidence in the vote amid unprecedented challenges
8:19AM ( 1 hour ago )
Fighting over Nagorno-Karabakh goes on despite US mediation
Rocket and artillery barrage have hit residential areas hours in the disputed region of Nagorno-Karabakh after the United States hosted top diplomats from Armenia and Azerbaijan for talks on settling their decades-long conflict
8:18AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Trump campaign sues in Nevada to stop Vegas-area vote count
The Trump campaign and Nevada Republicans want a judge to stop the counting of Las Vegas-area mail-in ballots
11:20PM ( 10 hours ago )
Some hospitals in crisis as US nears high for COVID-19 cases
The United States is approaching a record for the number of new daily coronavirus cases in the latest ominous sign of the disease’s grip on the nation
8:20PM ( 13 hours ago )
Washington state discovers first 'murder hornet' nest in US
Scientists in Washington state have discovered the first nest of so-called murder hornets in the United States and plan to wipe it out Saturday to protect native honeybees
7:08PM ( 15 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Work already underway for presidential inauguration
While much of Washington is twisted in knots over the upcoming election, there’s another contingent already busy trying to figure out how to stage an inauguration for the next president during a pandemic
2:46AM ( 7 hours ago )
California utility cuts power to 1 million over fire threat
Pacific Gas & Electric says it will cut power to some 1 million people this weekend in central and Northern California, which could see the most dangerous fire weather of the season
1:01AM ( 9 hours ago )
Buehler leads Dodgers over Rays 6-2 for 2-1 Series lead
Los Angeles ace Walker Buehler set down the Tampa Bay Rays with dominance and ease that brought flashbacks of Orel Hershiser during the Dodgers' last title run
12:52AM ( 9 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Egypt's parliamentary vote likely to tighten leader's grip
Egyptians have begun voting in the first stage of a parliamentary election, in a vote that is highly likely to produce a toothless lower chamber packed with supporters of President Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi
7:14AM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump calls 'Borat' star an unfunny 'creep'
President Donald Trump says he thinks Sacha Baron Cohen, the comedian behind the “Borat” films, is “a creep.”
11:24PM ( 10 hours ago )
Trump, Biden scrap on oil, virus with just over a week to go
President Donald Trump and his allies are fighting for momentum in the nation’s leading battleground states following a debate performance that gave new hope to anxious Republicans
9:48PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Nebraska, Maine could play pivotal role in presidential race
Nebraska and Maine aren’t exactly swing states in the race to pick the next president, but each one has something to offer next month that could give them a huge amount of sway: a single electoral vote
6:22PM ( 15 hours ago )
Problems with his health? McConnell says 'of course not'
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says there’s nothing the public needs to know about his health after photos showed what appears to be bruising on his hands and around his mouth
6:01PM ( 16 hours ago )
Parties' late spending on Senate races shows GOP's jeopardy
Republicans and Democrats are unleashing millions in eleventh-hour spending in Senate races
5:21PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
The Latest: Trump, Biden argue over their tax returns
Joe Biden and Donald Trump are arguing over their tax returns
9:52PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Biden: Nations that meddle in elections will pay
Former Vice President Joe Biden says any country that interferes in American elections will pay a price if he's elected, saying, “They are interfering with American sovereignty.”
9:43PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Final Trump-Biden presidential debate begins
The second and final presidential debate of the 2020 election has begun
9:05PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
'All talk, no action' defense likely in Michigan kidnap case
Defense lawyers for the men accused of trying to kidnap Michigan Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer are likely to argue that their clients were all talk and no action
9:13AM ( 1 hour ago )
US sets coronavirus infection record; deaths near 224,000
The U.S. coronavirus caseload has reached record heights with more than 83,000 infections reported in a single day
6:46AM ( 3 hours ago )
California prosecutors again seek death for Scott Peterson
California prosecutors say they will again seek the death penalty for Scott Peterson even as a county judge considers throwing out his conviction for murdering his pregnant wife because of juror misconduct during a trial that riveted the nation
12:27AM ( 9 hours ago )
Trump campaign sues in Nevada to stop Vegas-area vote count
The Trump campaign and Nevada Republicans want a judge to stop the counting of Las Vegas-area mail-in ballots
11:20PM ( 10 hours ago )
Some hospitals in crisis as US nears high for COVID-19 cases
The United States is approaching a record for the number of new daily coronavirus cases in the latest ominous sign of the disease’s grip on the nation
8:20PM ( 13 hours ago )