sunny.png
Friday November 27th, 2020 9:23AM

A-10 commissioner: NCAA penalties against UMass unfortunate

By The Associated Press

The NCAA is stripping Massachusetts of victories in men’s basketball and women’s tennis for overpaying 12 athletes about $9,100 in financial aid over three years, prompting criticism of the penalty from the Atlantic 10 Conference commissioner.

The NCAA announced Friday the Committee on Infractions had imposed a two-year probation on UMass that will end October 2022 in addition to vacating results involving athletes who received what were determined to be a total of 13 inappropriate payments.

The school will also pay a self-imposed fine of $5,000.

UMass plans to appeal the committee's decision to vacate results from 2014-17 that include 59 basketball wins and an Atlantic 10 Conference championship in women’s tennis.

A-10 Commissioner Bernadette McGlade and UMass athletic director Ryan Bamford both took issue with the vacation penalty for what the COI conceded was a “misunderstanding,” according to the NCAA’s news release.

McGlade said the decision was “unfortunate.”

“I think there's a misappropriation and maybe we are at a point in time where the association (NCAA) needs to have a reset, quite frankly,” McGlade said. “To have a set of student-athletes that had no involvement in a mistake/violation that has been acknowledged ... and yet to penalize them by the vacation of contests seems inordinately punitive and not in the spirit of what we do as an association.”

Bamford referred to the violations as mistakes that were “inadvertent and unintentional.”

Public criticism of a COI decision and NCAA enforcement by college administrators has become common in recent years. In cases involving football, both Notre Dame and Missouri loudly complained their cooperation with the NCAA and proactive compliance led to harsh penalties for violations uncovered by the schools.

Similarly, Bamford said the NCAA’s investigation was initiated by UMass. The school was looking into possible violations in basketball that occurred under former coach Derek Kellogg. Bamford said UMass was concerned players had inappropriately received free tickets to on-campus concerts, but it turned out to be a non-issue.

Instead, the financial aid problems were found.

The NCAA said four UMass athletes received a higher housing rate after they moved to less-expensive off-campus housing, and eight continued to receive a telecom fee for those who live in on-campus after they moved to off. One athlete received both.

The NCAA determined UMass officials, coaches and athletes were unaware of the overpayments at the time, but they still caused the athletes to compete while ineligible.

The committee said a former associate athletics director’s misunderstanding of financial aid rules and administrative error resulted in the violations. The committee did not find a failure to monitor infraction because 98% of the time during the period where the overpayments occurred, UMass appropriately doled out financial aid.

Dave Roberts, COI chief hearings officer and special assistant to the athletic director at Southern California, said previous case precedent based on ineligible competition by athletes led to the penalty of vacating results.

“We look at a multitude of factors, not just the dollar amount involved,” Roberts said. “The number of students involved. The number of competitions involved. The duration of detection. Many, many factors.”

Bamford said UMass could have easily restored the athletes' eligibility by having them pay back the excess aid if anyone had been aware of overpayments.

McGlade said the use of ineligible players does not have to automatically trigger a vacation of contests penalty from the COI. Discretion is allowable, she said.

“If it’s an administrative, institutional mistake then penalize the institution. If that's a higher dollar value (fine) or additional years of probation or whatever," she said. "That's where the penalty should fall. It shouldn't fall on the backs of student-athletes when there was no advantage that was gained and/or knowledge (of the violation).”

Bamford added: “There’s got to be some subjectivity to matters like this.”

According to the NCAA's report, UMass and NCAA enforcement had agreed to a negotiated resolution of the case. Because it did not include a penalty of vacated results, a COI panel rejected the agreement, sent the case back to enforcement and held a hearing to resolve the case and hand down penalties.

___

Follow Ralph D. Russo at https://twitter.com/ralphDrussoAP and listen at https://westwoodonepodcasts.com/pods/ap-top-25-college-football-podcast/

___

More AP college football: https://apnews.com/Collegefootball and https://twitter.com/AP_Top25

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Basketball, College Sports, AP Business, AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
French leader decries Islamist terror attack against teacher
French President Emmanuel Macron has denounced what he is calling an “Islamist terrorist attack” against a history teacher decapitated in a Paris suburb, urging the nation to stand united against extremism
4:43PM ( 3 minutes ago )
White House rejects Putin response to US arms control offer
The White House and the Kremlin are rejecting each other's ideas on extending the last major treaty governing their nuclear arsenals
4:41PM ( 5 minutes ago )
France: Teacher beheaded, police shoot dead suspected killer
A history teacher who opened a discussion with students on caricatures of Islam’s Prophet Muhammad was beheaded in a French street and police have shot the suspected killer dead, a police official says
4:25PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Scheuer, Philly sports media denizen for decades, dies at 88
The go-to guy at courtside, on the field and in the press box who covered Philadelphia sports from the days of Wilt Chamberlain to Bryce Harper for The Associated Press and other outlets has died
4:08PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Jones returns to practice as Falcons prepare to face Vikings
Seven-time Pro Bowl receiver Julio Jones returned to practice as a limited participant and hopes to play Sunday when the Atlanta Falcons visit the Minnesota Vikings
4:06PM ( 40 minutes ago )
On Football: Flames under coaching hot seats intensify
Bill O’Brien went first
3:03PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
General manager Daryl Morey leaving Rockets on Nov. 1
Houston Rockets general manager Daryl Morey is stepping down on his own accord
9:29PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP source: General manager Daryl Morey leaving Rockets
A person familiar with the deal tells The Associated Press that Houston Rockets general manager Daryl Morey is stepping down on his own accord
5:39PM ( 23 hours ago )
The Latest: Men's hoops back on the court at Purdue
The Purdue men’s basketball team is back on the court after workouts were paused briefly this week following two questionable COVID-19 tests
4:09PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Basketball
Cincinnati-Tulsa postponed due to Bearcats' COVID-19 issues
No. 8 Cincinnati's weekend game at Tulsa has been postponed because of positive COVID-19 tests among Bearcats players
11:27PM ( 17 hours ago )
Saban still asymptomatic, but sidelined for Alabama-Georgia
Nick Saban won’t be allowed to coach No. 2 Alabama from home against third-ranked Georgia per SEC and NCAA guidelines
8:55PM ( 19 hours ago )
No. 2 Alabama vs. No. 3 Georgia takes center stage in SEC
The mid-week news that Alabama coach Nick Saban tested positive for COVID-19 added a challenging backdrop for the season’s first top 5 matchup
3:57PM ( 1 day ago )
College Sports
The Latest: US report shows patterns of virus deaths shifted
A new U.S. government report shows that patterns of coronavirus deaths shifted over the summer, with rising percentages of the deaths in Hispanic people, and those living in the South and West
3:50PM ( 56 minutes ago )
GOP, Dems hope Supreme Court fight bolsters Senate prospects
Senate Democrats and Republicans both think the Amy Coney Barrett confirmation battle will help them in this fall's elections
3:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: North Dakota leads nation in per capita cases
North Dakota leads the nation with 978 new cases of coronavirus per capita in the last two weeks
3:10PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Pandemic-proof: Fall college football revived on West Coast
The Pac-12 has set a Nov. 6 start date for a seven-game football season, following the Big Ten in overturning its August decision to postpone until spring because of concerns about playing through the pandemic
2:12AM ( 3 weeks ago )
Pac-12 football to start Nov. 7; Mt. West targets Oct. 24
The Pac-12 has set a Nov. 6 start date for a seven-game football season, following the Big Ten in overturning its August decision to postpone until spring because of concerns about playing through the pandemic
10:42PM ( 3 weeks ago )
Pac-12 to kick off 7-game football season in early November
The Pac-12 has set a Nov. 6 start date for a seven-game football season, following the Big Ten in overturning its August decision to postpone until spring because of concerns about playing through the pandemic
10:13PM ( 3 weeks ago )
AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
France: Teacher beheaded, police shoot dead suspected killer
A history teacher who opened a discussion with students on caricatures of Islam’s Prophet Muhammad was beheaded in a French street and police have shot the suspected killer dead, a police official says
4:25PM ( 21 minutes ago )
The Latest: Virus knocks out 3 tennis tournaments in Canada
Tennis Canada has postponed three Challenger pro events because of the COVID-19 pandemic
4:23PM ( 23 minutes ago )
The Latest: Biden: US hasn't 'turned the corner' on virus
Joe Biden is mocking President Donald Trump for suggesting in a Thursday town hall that the U.S. has “turned the corner” in the fight against the coronavirus pandemic
4:23PM ( 23 minutes ago )
A late slide erases gains for US indexes, leaving them mixed
Stocks took a late stumble on Wall Street, erasing an early gain and leaving major indexes mixed on Friday
4:16PM ( 29 minutes ago )
The Latest: Biden praises Democratic leaders in Michigan
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden is heaping praise on leading Michigan Democrats as he tries to flip the state back his party’s presidential win column
4:10PM ( 36 minutes ago )