Monday November 23rd, 2020 11:57AM

Barrett tells doubtful Dems she'd keep open mind on court

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett presented herself in Wednesday's final round of Senate confirmation questioning as a judge committed to a strict reading of the Constitution, holding deep personal and religious beliefs but vowing to keep an open mind on what would be a 6-3 conservative-majority court.

Senate Republicans are championing President Donald Trump's pick, an appeals court judge who adheres to an "originalist" constitutional approach. Doubtful Democrats are digging deeper into the judge’s views on health care, abortion, racial equity and voting rights, but they are running out of time to stop her quick confirmation.

The conservative late Justice Antonin Scalia was her mentor, but Barrett said when confronted with his rulings and outspoken comments that she is her own judge.

“When I said that Justice Scalia’s philosophy is mine, too, I certainly didn’t mean to say that every sentence that came out of Justice Scalia’s mouth or every sentence that he wrote is one that I would agree with,” Barrett told the Senate Judiciary Committee,

The 48-year-old Indiana judge was being asked about several of Scalia's decisions, some controversial. She did not respond directly to Sen. Dianne Feinstein, the top Democrat on the panel, who asked whether Barrett agreed with Scalia's view that the civil rights era Voting Rights Act was a “perpetuation of racial entitlement.”

Barrett said Scalia's approach — “originalism and texturalism” — is hers as well. But without discussing the specifics of that case, she called the Voting Rights Act a "triumph in the civil rights movement.”

When Democratic Sen. Chris Coons of Delaware ran through several of Scalia's opinions including his dissent in the landmark 2105 Obergefell v. Hodges gay marriage case he wanted to know just “how closely” she stood by his views.

“I hope you're not suggesting I don't have my own mind,” Barrett said.

Her nomination to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has ground other legislative business to a halt as Republicans excited by the prospect of tipping the court balance to conservatives race to confirm her over Democratic objections before Election Day.

Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., opened the final day of her testimony praising Trump’s nominee as an “unashamedly pro-life” conservative who is making history as a role model for other women.

“She’s going to the court,” Graham said. “This is the first time in American history that we’ve nominated a woman who’s unashamedly pro-life and embraces her faith without apology.”

Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois agreed Barrett is making history — but as the first nominee considered so close to a presidential election, tapped to fulfill the president's public quest to install a ninth justice in time to undo the Affordable Care Act in a case heading to the court Nov. 10.

Durbin called Trump's intent to dismantle the health care law a cloud — “an orange cloud” — over her nomination, a political slam at the president's tan.

“They need that ninth justice, that’s why it has to be hurried,” Durbin said.

Barrett's nomination has been the focus at a Capitol mostly shut down by COVID-19 protocols, as Americans struggle during the pandemic, and Congress is delayed by bickering over differences in providing more aid. The virus has hung over the proceedings after Trump introduced Barrett at a Rose Garden event that apparently spread COVID. Two senators on the panel who attended have been stricken.

The former law school professor, who had little trial court experience before being confirmed to the appellate court in 2017, did not stray from her disciplined refusal to disclose her views on specific issues, saying it's not appropriate without consideration of the actual facts of any given case.

“I would of course keep an open mind,” she told senators at various points, including on whether to allow cameras in the courtroom.

As Democrats probed Barrett's views, Durbin asked Wednesday if her strict adherence to originalism means a president could not “unilaterally deny the right to vote” based on race, noting restrictions on mail-in ballots being erected in several states before Nov. 3.

She agreed there are "many laws" that protect the right to vote, including the 14th and 15th Amendments to the Constitution, but stopped short of a blanket statement: "I really can't say anything more."

Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., asked what she thinks of Trump's view that he can pardon himself.

Barrett said a president's ability to pardon himself has never been tested in court and the question calls out for “legal analysis.” She said, “It's not one that I can offer a view.”

At one point, she even brushed back a question on whether she agrees with a strict originalist view that Medicare, the senior health care program, may be unconstitutional. “I can't answer that question in the abstract,” she said.

In some ways it was an extension of Tuesday’s long and lively session as she declined to say whether she would recuse herself from the upcoming health care case or any election-related disputes involving the heated race between Trump and Democratic nominee Joe Biden.

Along with trying to undo the health care law, Trump has publicly stated he wants a justice seated for any disputes arising from the election, and particularly the surge of mail-in ballots expected during the pandemic, as voters prefer to vote by mail.

Barrett testified she has not spoken to Trump or his team about election cases, but skipped past Democrats' pressing questions about ensuring the date of the election or preventing voter intimidation, both set in federal law, and the peaceful transfer of presidential power. She declined to commit to recusing herself from any post-election cases without first consulting the other justices.

“I can’t offer an opinion on recusal without short-circuiting that entire process,” she said during the nearly 12-hour session.

Democrats had no such reticence.

"Let’s not make any mistake about it,” said California Sen. Kamala Harris, the Democratic vice presidential nominee, appearing remotely due to COVID concerns.

Allowing Trump to fill the seat with Barrett “poses a threat to safe and legal abortion in our country," Harris said.

Underscoring the Republicans’ confidence, Graham set an initial committee vote on the nomination for Thursday, the last day of hearings, which would allow final approval by the full Senate by the end of the month.


Associated Press writers Mary Clare Jalonick, Matthew Daly and Jessica Gresko in Washington, and Elana Schor in New York contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Jets' Flacco to start again for injured Darnold vs. Dolphins
Joe Flacco will get his second straight start at quarterback for the New York Jets in place of the injured Sam Darnold
12:54PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Laila Ali salutes social activism of athletes with awards
Laila Ali is applauding athletes who speak out about social issues
12:45PM ( 12 minutes ago )
UK's COVID-19 strategy unraveling as regions choose own path
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s new strategy for combating COVID-19 appears to have unraveled as regional leaders chose their own paths and the mayors of the cities facing the toughest restrictions accused Johnson of using the crisis to divide them for political advantage
12:33PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
As virus surges anew, Milan hospitals under pressure again
Coronavirus infections are surging anew in the northern Italian region where the pandemic first took hold in Europe, putting pressure again on hospitals and health care workers
12:11PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Industrial nations consider extending debt relief over virus
The world’s major economies are considering a proposal to extend for six months a moratorium on debt payments by poor nations as a way to provide support during the worst global recession since the 1930s
12:04PM ( 53 minutes ago )
St. Louis couple who waved guns at protest plead not guilty
A St. Louis couple celebrated in some circles and vilified in others for waving guns at protesters near their home have pleaded not guilty to two felony charges
12:04PM ( 53 minutes ago )
AP National News
The Latest: Barrett keeping 'open mind' on cameras in court
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett says she’ll “keep an open mind” on allowing cameras to broadcast proceedings of the high court
10:37AM ( 2 hours ago )
Called 'unashamedly pro-life,' Barrett faces senators anew
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett has returned to Capitol Hill for a third day of confirmation hearings by the Senate Judiciary Committee
10:22AM ( 2 hours ago )
Northern Ireland shuts schools; Liverpool slams revelers
Northern Ireland introduced the tightest COVID-19 restrictions in the United Kingdom on Wednesday, closing schools, pubs and restaurants in a effort to slow the spread of the virus
10:02AM ( 2 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
The Latest: Trump pushes claims on vaccine, infrastructure
President Donald Trump is describing the choice for voters in the Nov_ 3 election as a “choice between the socialist nightmare and the American dream.”
12:07PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Kyrgyzstan president weighs resignation in talks with new PM
Kyrgyzstan’s embattled president has discussed his possible resignation with his newly appointed prime minister in a bid to end the political crisis in the Central Asian country after a disputed parliamentary election
11:48AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Durbin says 'orange cloud' over Barrett's pick
Sen. Dick Durbin says there’s an “orange cloud” hanging over the nomination of Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court
11:06AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Supreme Court halts census in latest twist of 2020 count
The Supreme Court has ruled that the Trump administration can end census field operations early, in a blow to efforts to make sure minorities are properly counted in the crucial once-a-decade tally
6:31AM ( 6 hours ago )
Barrett bats away tough Democratic confirmation probing
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett spent a long day and evening batting back Democrats' tough questioning at her Senate confirmation hearings
10:51PM ( 14 hours ago )
Cut cable shuts down Virginia voter portal; lawsuit filed
A severed fiber optic cable that shut down Virginia's online voter registration system has prompted a lawsuit from a civil rights organization
8:37PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
The Latest: Barrett steers clear of transfer of power issue
President Donald Trump’s nominee for the Supreme Court is declining to get involved in the question of whether the president should commit to a peaceful transfer of power if the election doesn’t go his way
6:13PM ( 18 hours ago )
Takeaways: Barrett is reticent as Dems focus on health care
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett is facing her first day’s worth of questions from the Senate Judiciary Committee
6:02PM ( 18 hours ago )
The Latest: Barrett clarifies her use of 'sexual preference'
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett is clarifying her use of the phrase “sexual preference,” apologizing to those who interpreted her word choice as suggesting hostility toward LGBT rights
5:27PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Thai democracy protesters march despite police, rival groups
Thai activists hoping to keep up the momentum in their campaign for democratic change are marching in Bangkok amid concerns about a possible confrontation with police or rival groups supporting the government
9:07AM ( 3 hours ago )
Thai protest rally plans complicated by king's itinerary
Thai activists hoping to keep up the momentum in their campaign for democratic change have launched a third major rally in Bangkok, amid concerns about possible confrontation with police or rival government supporters
3:03AM ( 9 hours ago )
Trump, Biden zero in on swing states that are key to victory
With Election Day just three weeks away, President Donald Trump and Democratic challenger Joe Biden are concentrating on battleground states both see as critical to clinching an Electoral College victory
8:53PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Elections
Bloomberg gives $500,000 to spur Dem turnout in Miami-Dade
Billionaire former New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg is donating $500,000 to juice Democratic turnout in Miami-Dade County
3:29PM ( 21 hours ago )
Trump lawyers ask Supreme Court to halt tax record turnover
President Donald Trump is asking the Supreme Court to put on hold an appeals court ruling that Trump’s accountant must immediately turn over tax records to a New York state prosecutor
3:07PM ( 21 hours ago )
Bloomberg gives $500,000 to juice Dem turnout in Miami-Dade
Billionaire former New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg is donating $500,000 to juice Democratic turnout in Miami-Dade County
2:57PM ( 22 hours ago )
General Election News
Belarus opposition leader threatens nationwide strike
Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya, top opposition challenger in the Belarusian presidential election, has threatened to call a nationwide strike unless the country’s authoritarian president announces his resignation, releases political prisoners and stops violent crackdown on protesters by Oct. 25
1:08PM ( 23 hours ago )
Barrett refuses to commit to recusal of election cases
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett is testifying that she cannot commit to recusing herself from any cases involving the upcoming election
11:05AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Barrett says she can't answer on election delay
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett says she can’t answer whether President Donald Trump has the power to delay the general election
10:20AM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
A taste for travel? Finnair to sell plane food in shops
Finnish carrier Finnair says it will start selling business class-style airline meals in a nationwide supermarket chain in a move to both keep its catering staff employed and also to offer the airline experience to those missing flying in the COVID-19 times
12:08PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Pilgrim's Pride reaches plea deal on chicken price-fixing
Pilgrim’s Pride Corp. has reached a plea agreement with the U.S. government over charges of price-fixing in the chicken industry
11:38AM ( 1 hour ago )
UnitedHealth tops profit forecast, finally hikes outlook
UnitedHealth Group beat third-quarter forecasts, and the nation’s largest health insurance provider finally hiked its 2020 earnings outlook after holding off while trying to sort out COVID-19’s impact
11:29AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
UK's COVID-19 strategy unraveling as regions choose own path
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s new strategy for combating COVID-19 appears to have unraveled as regional leaders chose their own paths and the mayors of the cities facing the toughest restrictions accused Johnson of using the crisis to divide them for political advantage
12:33PM ( 25 minutes ago )
G-20 suspends poor nations' debt payments for 6 more months
The Group of 20  nations, representing the world’s biggest economies, say they have  agreed to extend the suspension of debt payments by an additional six months to support the most vulnerable countries in their fight against the coronavirus pandemic
12:23PM ( 35 minutes ago )
The Latest: Barrett won’t say if a president can pardon self
Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett won’t say whether a president can pardon himself but says she agrees no one is above the law
12:21PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Mullen apologizes, awaits word on COVID-19 tests, LSU game
Florida coach Dan Mullen apologized Wednesday “if I offended people or anybody out there” with his comments about wanting to pack Florida Field with 90,000 fans during the coronavirus pandemic
12:17PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Europe Today: Closing schools is latest front in virus fight
European countries are lurching for solutions to stem the resurgence of the coronavirus in hopes of avoiding another round of total lockdowns
12:16PM ( 42 minutes ago )