Tuesday November 24th, 2020 3:57PM

Precedent, recusal, Roe: A court nomination viewer's guide

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — A scant two weeks after her nomination, Judge Amy Coney Barrett goes before a Senate committee that's bitterly split along partisan lines over whether the Supreme Court vacancy created by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death should be filled now or should await the winner of the Nov. 3 presidential election. The Senate Judiciary Committee's hearings are taking place on an accelerated timeline because President Donald Trump and Senate Republicans want her on the bench by Election Day. Adding to the swirl of politics around the nomination is the coronavirus pandemic and the role it might play. Barrett was introduced as the nominee at a Rose Garden ceremony linked to a cluster of virus cases, including those of Trump and his wife, Melania.

Viewers should expect to see the 48-year-old Barrett portrayed by Republicans as a principled jurist and person of faith in the mode of her mentor, conservative Justice Antonin Scalia, and someone who will decide cases based on the law, not her policy preferences. Democrats will spend a lot of time talking about the unseemly rush to fill Ginsburg's seat. But they also will label Barrett a results-oriented conservative whose ascension to the high court would entrench a conservative majority bent on undoing abortion rights, loosening gun restrictions and turning back the clock on environmental regulations and anti-discrimination laws.

Lawmakers know the public is watching, but as the hearing gets going and lawmakers seek to probe the nominee’s views, they often slip into using legal jargon and refer to past Supreme Court cases in shorthand. It can sound as though they’re talking in code. Expect senators to use these terms at Barrett’s hearing, starting Monday:



These cases from 1973 and 1992, respectively, are the two main decisions on abortion rights. Barrett is the most open anti-abortion nominee to the Supreme Court in decades. She is certain to be asked repeatedly whether the cases were decided correctly, and whether they should be overturned, She’s not likely to answer either question during the hearings. Barrett signed an anti-abortion newspaper ad in 2006, was a member of Notre Dame's Faculty for Life and has cast two anti-abortion votes as an appellate judge.



In Latin, it means to stand by things decided. It’s the legal principle that judges use to base decisions on earlier ones. When it comes up at confirmation hearings, it’s often in reference to abortion rights and it’s usually a way of asking if a nominee will overturn certain decisions such as Roe. Nominees invariably invoke stare decisis, or refer to something as settled law, to try to reassure senators that they have great respect for Supreme Court precedents, without committing to preserve any specific one. Respect for precedent, however, has its limits. Almost every court opinion raising the issue of abiding by precedents or getting rid of them invokes a line from a 1991 Supreme Court opinion: “Stare decisis is not an inexorable command.”



The court's 2015 decision declared a nationwide constitutional right of same-sex couples to marry. Barrett has spoken approvingly of the conservative dissenting voices in the case who argued that states should set the rules on marriage, not unelected judges. The issue became newly prominent last week when Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, wrote that the 2015 decision “enables courts and governments to brand religious adherents who believe that marriage is between one man and one woman as bigots.” Thomas suggested the court needs to revisit the issue because it has “created a problem that only it can fix.” Until then, he said, the case will continue to have “ruinous consequences for religious liberty.”



That's the shorthanded reference to the Obama-era health law, the Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as “Obamacare.” The Supreme Court will hear a Trump administration-backed challenge to get rid of the law a week after the election. A lot of talk will focus on the law's now-toothless mandate to require people to have health insurance or pay a penalty. In 2017, Congress got rid of the penalty, a decision that gave rise to the latest court challenge. The bigger concern is that if the court says the mandate as it now stands is unconstitutional, it will strike down the rest of the law with it. So Democratic senators in all likelihood will talk a lot about the threat to another provision of the law prohibiting discrimination against people with preexisting health conditions. Barrett has been critical of Chief Justice John Roberts' 2012 opinion upholding the law and his 2015 opinion that preserved subsidies for millions of people to pay for health insurance. “I think the dissent has the better of the legal argument,” she said in 2015.



It refers to a judge’s decision to not take part in a case, usually because that judge participated in it at an earlier stage, or has a financial or personal conflict. Democrats are going to press Barrett to pledge to withdraw from any election-related cases, and perhaps from any involving abortion. She is not likely to commit to do so.



A 1984 Supreme Court ruling, in a case involving the Chevron oil company, says that when laws aren’t crystal clear, federal agencies should be allowed to fill in the details. That’s what agencies do — on environmental regulations, workplace standards, consumer protections and even immigration law. But a growing conservative legal movement has questioned the Chevron decision. Several conservative justices have expressed some support for limiting agencies’ discretion. If a future Supreme Court were to limit the Chevron ruling, it would mark a big change in the law that would potentially make it harder to sustain governmental regulations.



OK, that’s not a legal term, but it will come up anyway. Roberts famously compared judges to umpires during his 2005 confirmation hearing, saying neither makes the rules, but rather both just apply them. He said he would remember, if confirmed, that his job is “to call balls and strikes.” Lawmakers love to ask nominees about this analogy.



Again, it's not a legal term. Expect the committee chairman, Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., or the Republican sitting in his place, to interject when Democrats’ questioning of Barrett gets especially heated or they try to cut in if they feel Barrett is trying to filibuster. Question time is limited and senators often feel free to jump in to move the questioning along.


Associated Press writer Jessica Gresko contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, General Senate Election News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Babos, Mladenovic defend doubles title
Timea Babos and Kristina Mladenovic have defended their French Open title in women’s doubles
7:41AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Azerbaijan, Armenia report shelling of cities despite truce
Azerbaijan has accused Armenia of attacking large cities overnight in violation of the cease-fire brokered by Russia to end to the worst outbreak of hostilities in the separatist Nagorno-Karabakh region
7:40AM ( 12 minutes ago )
The Latest: Lebanon orders lockdown for 169 towns, villages
Lebanon’s Interior Ministry has ordered a lockdown in 169 villages and towns as well as ordering all night clubs and pubs to close around the country amid a sharp increase of coronavirus cases
7:34AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Graham, Harris share spotlight as Barrett hearings begin
Senate Republicans are vowing a quick confirmation for President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee
12:11AM ( 7 hours ago )
Doctor says Trump won’t transmit virus, stays mum on tests
President Donald Trump’s doctor says the president is no longer at risk of transmitting the coronavirus, but he does not say explicitly whether Trump has tested negative for it
11:01PM ( 8 hours ago )
Whitmer plot could affect fight for battleground Michigan
The arrest of a group of anti-government vigilantes in a kidnapping plot against Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer presents a new twist in the 2020 political fight for the battleground state
10:55PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Five things to know about court nominee Amy Coney Barrett
Confirmation hearings begin Monday for President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, Amy Coney Barrett
4:16PM ( 15 hours ago )
White House virus aid offer is panned by Pelosi, Senate GOP
A new White House coronavirus aid has gotten bad reviews from both ends of the political spectrum
3:29PM ( 16 hours ago )
Judge orders ex-Colombian president freed from house arrest
Colombia's powerful ex-President Álvaro Uribe has been ordered freed from house arrest while he is investigated for possible witness tampering
3:01PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
The Latest: Trump makes speech from White House balcony
President Donald Trump spoke from a White House balcony in his first public appearance since returning to the residence after being treated for the coronavirus
4:10PM ( 15 hours ago )
The Latest: Rome site of 2 anti-mask protests despite surge
Rome was the site of two anti-mask protests on Saturday, even as Italy undergoes a resurgence of coronavirus infections
3:34PM ( 16 hours ago )
The Latest: Milan site of 2 anti-mask protests despite surge
Milan was the site of two anti-mask protests on Saturday, even as Italy undergoes a resurgence of coronavirus infections
2:26PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
North Korea unveils new weapons at military parade
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un has warned that his country would fully mobilize its nuclear force if threatened as he took center stage at a military parade that unveiled what appeared to be a new intercontinental ballistic missile and other weapons
10:49PM ( 9 hours ago )
Belarus' authoritarian leader visits his foes in prison
Belarus’ authoritarian president has visited a prison to talk to opposition activists, who have been jailed for protesting his re-election they saw as rigged
1:53PM ( 18 hours ago )
After coronavirus, Trump aims to get campaign back on track
President Donald Trump is making his first public appearance  ince returning to the White House after his hospitalization for the coronavirus, welcoming supporters to the South Lawn for an event that marks the return of political activities in the final stretch of the 2020 campaign
1:49PM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Elections
Trump has events Saturday at White House, Monday in Florida
President Donald Trump is looking to get his campaign back on track, a week after he was sidelined with the coronavirus that has killed more than 210,000 Americans
5:27PM ( 1 day ago )
Ohio county says nearly 50,000 voters received wrong ballots
Ohio's Republican secretary of state is assuring residents that the election will be secure and accurate after a county sent wrong ballots to 50,000 voters
5:11PM ( 1 day ago )
Denver will stream a live 24-hour video of ballot processing
Strengthening efforts to counter the Trump administration’s baseless narrative that mail balloting is rife with fraud, elections officials in Denver, Seattle and a growing number of cities are giving voters live video of their ballot processing in a symbolic effort to assure voter trust in the November election
5:06PM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Belarus' leader claims he saved opposition challenger's life
Belarus’ authoritarian president, whose re-election has triggered two months of protests, is maintaining that he saved his main opponent’s life by getting her out of the country — a claim rejected by her spokeswoman
12:39PM ( 1 day ago )
US, Russia said close to deal on nuclear warhead freeze
U.S. and Russian negotiators have agreed in principle to freeze their nuclear warhead stockpiles in a bid to salvage their last remaining arms control pact before it expires next year
11:54AM ( 1 day ago )
Judge denies motion to extend Florida's voter registration
A federal judge has denied a motion to extend voter registration in Florida even though a computer meltdown might have prevented thousands of potential voters from taking part in November’s presidential election
11:22AM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
Republicans see 'grim' Senate map and edge away from Trump
Vulnerable Republicans are increasingly taking careful but clear steps away from President Donald Trump in the final stretch of the 2020 election
9:09PM ( 3 days ago )
Democrat's personal scandal roils N. Carolina Senate race
A race in North Carolina critical to control of the U.S. Senate has been thrown into turmoil over allegations of personal misconduct by Democrat Cal Cunningham, a married man who had an extramarital relationship this summer with a consultant
9:04PM ( 4 days ago )
N. Carolina Senate race upended by sexting, virus diagnosis
North Carolina's intensely competitive and expensive U.S. Senate race has been upended by personal and health disruptions that sent sharp tremors and uncertainty through the campaigns and an electorate already casting ballots
10:50PM ( 1 week ago )
General Senate Election News
The Latest: India's virus cases top 7 million; soon past US
 India’s confirmed coronavirus toll has crossed 7 million with a number of new cases dipping in recent weeks, even as health experts warn of mask and distancing fatigue setting in
6:27AM ( 1 hour ago )
Utility tells state equipment might have caused deadly fire
Fire investigators looking into what caused a wildfire that killed four people in far Northern California have taken possession of equipment belonging to Pacific Gas and Electric
1:14AM ( 6 hours ago )
Report: Iowa’s derecho crop losses increase by more than 50%
Crop loss estimates from a rare wind storm that slammed Iowa in August have increased by more than 50%
12:31PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Business
Azerbaijan, Armenia report shelling of cities despite truce
Azerbaijan has accused Armenia of attacking large cities overnight in violation of the cease-fire brokered by Russia to end to the worst outbreak of hostilities in the separatist Nagorno-Karabakh region
7:40AM ( 15 minutes ago )
The Latest: Lebanon orders lockdown for 169 towns, villages
Lebanon’s Interior Ministry has ordered a lockdown in 169 villages and towns as well as ordering all night clubs and pubs to close around the country amid a sharp increase of coronavirus cases
7:34AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Asia Today: Australian state warns non-complying public
The premier of Australia’s Victoria state is stepping up his fight with members of the public who don’t comply with pandemic regulations, saying close contacts of those infected who refuse a test will have to spend 21 days in quarantine
7:24AM ( 31 minutes ago )
The Latest: Tournament boss says Nadal's record untouchable
Regardless of whether Rafael Nadal beats Novak Djokovic in Sunday’s final to win a 13th French Open, the tournament director believes that the 12 titles already held by the Spaniard will never be equalled
6:55AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: UK told it's at 'tipping point' in virus fight
One of the main medical advisers to the British government has warned that the country is at a “tipping point” in its battle against the coronavirus pandemic
6:43AM ( 1 hour ago )