Friday October 30th, 2020 12:03AM

Politics has way of finding Supreme Court eager to avoid it

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court might prefer to avoid politics, but politics has a way of finding the court.

President Donald Trump wants the court to keep his taxes from being turned over to New York's top prosecutor and allow his administration to exclude non-citizens from the census count. He wants the justices to counteract an order making it easier for women to get abortion pill and rein in voting by mail.

And Trump is hoping to have his third high court nominee, Judge Amy Coney Barrett, installed before Election Day. That would forge a 6-3 conservative majority on a court that for decades has had a 5-4 conservative edge, which liberals could occasionally upend by attracting a vote from across the ideological divide.

“It is difficult for the court to avoid politics. Every issue of course has a very political angle and right now the politicization of the courts puts their decisions front and center,” Princeton University historian Julian Zelizer said in an email. “We are at a turning point moment, on the cusp of the entrenchment of a conservative 6-3 majority that will have huge implications on public policy. So at the most basic level, hard to ignore their connections to the events of the day.”

The court got back to work this week, hearing arguments by telephone over three days. Chief Justice John Roberts began Monday's session by paying tribute to Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died just over two weeks before the new term began.

But apart from that, it was hard to tell that anything had changed. The tone was upbeat as the eight justices took turns questioning lawyers in cases that did not appear destined to split the court's conservatives and liberals.

The business-as-usual approach is how the justices like it, part of their mantra that the court is above politics and that the public should not view it as just like the other two elected branches of government. That's especially true for Chief Justice John Roberts, the titular leader of the court who rebuked Trump in 2018 for the president's criticism of an “Obama judge.”

But despite their best efforts, the justices are facing a brewing political storm that could peak after Election Day if they are called upon to decide the election's outcome.

Issues related to the general election already have come to the court from four states, and more are expected.

The court's Republican-appointed conservative majority has typically rejected court-ordered changes close to an election. But the justices have been more accepting of changes when agreed to by a state's elected officials.

In the midst of the pandemic, Democrats have pushed for extending the deadline to receive and count mailed-in ballots, dropping witness requirements and easing rules for determining if the signature on a ballot matches the one on file. For their part, Republicans have fought efforts to mail ballots to all voters.

Pennsylvania Republicans want the court to rule out mailed ballots that are received after Election Day, or at least ballots that are not clearly postmarked as having been mailed on or before Nov. 3. A federal court ordered ballots to be counted if received by Nov. 6, unless there is evidence they were mailed after Election Day.

The justices on Monday agreed with Republicans and blocked a court order that allowed South Carolina voters to mail ballots without having a witness sign them. The next day, Justice Stephen Breyer rejected a Republican bid to stop the use of ranked-choice voting in Maine. On Thursday, Justice Elena Kagan turned away a Republican effort to limit the mailing of ballots to voters in Montana.

These pre-election issues would pale in comparison to a reprise of the court's 2000 Bush v. Gore case if the campaigns are fighting in court over the outcome in one or more states.

There might be a 6-3 conservative majority by that point, if Barrett is confirmed. And she would join two other Trump-appointed justices, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, in potentially deciding whether the president who appointed her would get another four years in office. In Bush v. Gore, in which the court's five conservatives prevailed over its four liberals, no justices were voting on the political future of the president who appointed them.

Not all the cases have electoral implications. But even those that don't are highly charged politically.

In the fight over Trump's taxes, the justices could decide before Election Day whether to allow the immediate enforcement of a subpoena issued by Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. or block it temporarily. The court in July rejected Trump's argument that he is effectively immune from the subpoena while serving as president, a decision Gorsuch and Kavanaugh joined.

The 2020 census also has been to the court previously. In 2019, Roberts joined Ginsburg and the other liberals in a 5-4 decision that rejected the administration's effort to include a citizenship question on the census for the first time since 1950.

Trump has since ordered the Census Bureau to provide him with a population count that excludes people who are in the country illegally so that their numbers would not be used for dividing the House of Representatives' 435 seats among the states, and the states' Electoral College vote, for the next 10 years.

A lower court has blocked the Trump policy as illegal. The administration is appealing and asking for speedy resolution in time for the population report the president must submit to Congress in January.

On an abortion-related issue, the court found a way Thursday to put off any definitive action for the time being.

The court had failed to act for nearly a month on the administration’s appeal to reinstate a requirement, temporarily suspended by lower court order because of the pandemic, that women make an in-person visit to obtain the abortion pull.

The matter is the first abortion-related action before the court since Ginsburg died.

On Thursday, the court said it would not act on the appeal for now, allowing women to continue to get the pill by mail and ordering the lower court to review its initial order.

Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas dissented, objecting that “there is no legally sound reason” for the court's refusal to rule.

It is unclear whether the long period of inaction owed to Ginsburg's death, Barrett’s nomination or some other factor.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Elections, General Election News, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Scalia 'heir' Barrett may be open to reversing Roe v. Wade
President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee has made clear in her academic writings that she's at least open to reversing some long-established precedents, possibly including the Roe v
12:31AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Politics has way of finding Supreme Court eager to avoid it
The Supreme Court might prefer to avoid politics, but politics has a way of finding the court
12:28AM ( 12 minutes ago )
In 25th Amendment bid, Pelosi mulls Trump's fitness to serve
The tensions between House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and President Donald Trump are getting even worse
12:24AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Teen charged in Kenosha shootings due back in Illinois court
A 17-year-old accused of killing two protesters days after Jacob Blake was shot by police in Kenosha, Wisconsin, is due back in court Friday as his attorneys fight efforts to send him to Wisconsin to stand trial on homicide charges
11:51PM ( 49 minutes ago )
13 charged in plots against Michigan governor, police
Six people have been charged in federal court with plotting to kidnap Michigan Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer at her vacation home
10:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
'This is not a bad dream': New hurricane menaces Louisiana
Louisiana residents are confronting the menace of a new hurricane weeks after one battered parts of the state
10:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Armenia says cathedral shelled in clashes with Azerbaijan
Armenia has accused Azerbaijan of shelling a historic cathedral in the separatist territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, where nearly two weeks of heavy fighting has killed hundreds of people
8:47PM ( 3 hours ago )
Protests against new labor law turn violent across Indonesia
Protests in many Indonesian cities have turned violent as thousands of enraged students and workers criticize a new law they say will cripple labor rights and harm the environment
8:41PM ( 3 hours ago )
Newspaper: Trump official ignored virus rules at wedding
An Atlanta newspaper is reporting that White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows hosted a large wedding for his daughter that appeared to violate a Georgia order and city of Atlanta guidelines aimed at stopping the spread of COVID-19
8:40PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
The Latest: Trump wants to hold rally in Florida on Saturday
President Donald Trump says he wants to try and hold a campaign rally in Florida on Saturday “if we have enough time to put it together.”
10:07PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Commission won't rethink shift to virtual debate
The chair of the Commission on Presidential Debates says it is not reconsidering shifting the second debate from virtual back to in-person, despite a request from President Donald Trump’s team
9:07PM ( 3 hours ago )
Feds sue Yale, allege discrimination against applicants
The Justice Department is suing Yale University after prosecutors found the university was illegally discriminating against Asian American and white applicants, in violation of federal civil rights law
7:59PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Biden won't divulge court expansion stance now
Joe Biden says he won’t reveal under after the Nov. 3 election whether he’d consider adding seats to the Supreme Court
4:33PM ( 8 hours ago )
VP Debate Takeaways: Pandemic looms over a more civil fight
Wednesday's vice presidential debate had sharp moments, some modest interruptions and violations of the debate clock
12:25AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Harris says Breonna Taylor didn't get justice
Democrat Kamala Harris says she doesn’t believe justice has been done in the case of Breonna Taylor, who was killed in a police drug raid that went bad
10:48PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
China joins COVAX coronavirus vaccine alliance
China is joining the world's coronavirus vaccine alliance known as COVAX
10:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: California governor tests negative for virus
California Gov. Gavin Newsom has tested negative for the coronavirus
10:25PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: China to join COVAX COVID-19 vaccine alliance
China, which has four coronavirus vaccine candidates in the last stage of clinical trials, says it is joining the COVID-19 vaccine alliance known as COVAX
10:05PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Health
Mali: 3 European hostages, 1 Malian politician freed
A prominent Malian politician and three European hostages freed by Islamic extremists in Mali this week have landed in the country’s capital where they held emotional reunions with family members and were greeted by government officials
8:58PM ( 3 hours ago )
Stocks climb again on Wall Street with hopes for stimulus
Stocks are closing higher on Wall Street Thursday as hope remains that Washington can approve more aid for the economy and after a report suggested the pace of layoffs is slowing a bit, though it remains incredibly high
4:35PM ( 8 hours ago )
The Latest: Biden calls on Trump to stop insulting Harris
Democrat Joe Biden is calling on President Donald Trump to stop insulting his running mate, Sen. Kamala Harris, after the president called her a “monster” during a TV appearance
4:17PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Elections
Trump, Biden teams debate debate: Virtual or not, next week?
It’s suddenly up in air when the next presidential debate, or maybe debates, may take place
12:55PM ( 11 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump seeks debate delay, wants in-person events
President Donald Trump’s campaign is proposing delaying the two remaining presidential debates by one week to ensure the debates can take place in-person, rather than virtually, after Trump’s coronavirus diagnosis
12:48PM ( 11 hours ago )
Trump says no after debate commission switches to 'virtual'
President Donald Trump says he will skip next week’s debate with Democratic nominee Joe Biden if it's virtual
12:15PM ( 12 hours ago )
General Election News
2 million stillbirths every year, pandemic might worsen toll
The World Health Organization and partners say there are about 2 million stillbirths every year, according to its first-ever global estimates
6:47PM ( 1 day ago )
Morgan awaits debut but Mewis, Heath make impact in England
Alex Morgan’s Tottenham debut has been delayed as she returns to action following pregnancy, with the American forward not fit enough to make the bench at Manchester City
9:57AM ( 4 days ago )
Doctors ask Supreme Court to strike down Trump abortion rule
The American Medical Association is asking the Supreme Court to strike down a Trump administration rule that's had a far-reaching impact on the nation’s family planning program
5:58PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Scalia 'heir' Barrett may be open to reversing Roe v. Wade
President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee has made clear in her academic writings that she's at least open to reversing some long-established precedents, possibly including the Roe v
12:31AM ( 9 minutes ago )
In 25th Amendment bid, Pelosi mulls Trump's fitness to serve
The tensions between House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and President Donald Trump are getting even worse
12:24AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Trump, Barr at odds over slow pace of Durham investigation
With time running out for pre-election action, President Donald Trump is increasingly airing his dissatisfaction with the Justice Department's investigation of the origins of the Russia probe in tweets and television appearances
12:20AM ( 20 minutes ago )
Trump says he's ready for rallies but details slim on health
President Donald Trump is eager to get back on the campaign trail
12:14AM ( 26 minutes ago )
Bang! Bang! Astros thump away vs Oakland, return to ALCS
Carlos Correa hit a go-ahead, three-run homer after Michael Brantley’s two-run shot in the fourth inning, helping the Houston Astros beat the Oakland Athletics 11-6 to end their home-run heavy AL Division Series in four games
12:12AM ( 28 minutes ago )