pcloudy.png
Saturday June 6th, 2020 1:58PM

Trial highlights: Dershowitz backtracks, Paul thwarted

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — As senators wrapped up their questions in President Donald Trump's impeachment trial, one of Trump's attorneys tried to explain his controversial defense. Meanwhile, a Republican senator was dramatically thwarted in his questioning by Chief Justice John Roberts.

Throughout, senators heard urgent pleas either stop a president who Democrats say tried to cheat in the 2016 election or shut down impeachment proceedings that Republicans insist were a purely partisan attack.

The proceedings had an air of uncertainty as lawmakers faced a crucial vote on whether to call witnesses — a decision that could lead to an abrupt end of the trial or bring days or weeks of testimony from former national security adviser John Bolton and other witnesses.

Highlights of Thursday's session and what's ahead as senators conduct just the third impeachment trial of a president.

CLEAN-UP ON AISLE FIVE

Alan Dershowitz, one of Trump's lawyers and a renowned Harvard professor, delivered a stunning defense of Trump Wednesday night that essentially would make it impossible to impeach a president for anything he might do to boost his reelection prospects. The argument was quickly and forcefully denounced by legal scholars, historians and editorial boards who said there are clear limits on presidential authority.

Dershowitz seemed to backtrack Thursday, saying his remarks have been misinterpreted. But Democrats seized on them as they pressed their case for Trump's removal from office for tying the release of military aid to Ukraine to an investigation of his political rivals.

“I never said a president could do anything to get re-elected,'' Dershowitz said on Twitter. "A president seeking re-election cannot do anything he wants. He is not above the law.''

But Democrats said that is exactly what Dershowitz claimed on Wednesday: "If a president does something which he believes will help him get elected, in the public interest, that cannot be the kind of quid pro quo that results in impeachment,” he said on the Senate floor.

Rep. Adam Schiff, the lead Democratic prosecutor called Dershowitz's argument “a descent into constitutional madness," adding that if followed, it ”would lead this country down the most destructive path."

Democrats were so confident that Dershowitz had blundered they replayed his remarks several times Thursday as they made their case.

WHISTLEBLOWER NO-GO

Republican Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky roiled the trial briefly Thursday as he tried to ask about the intelligence community whistleblower whose complaint led to the investigation that resulted in impeachment. Paul has said he believes the whistleblower may have conspired with House staff aides in writing the August complaint.

Roberts, who has told senators the whistleblower's identity should be protected, refused to read the question aloud. He did not say what was on the card.

Paul left the impeachment proceeding to hold a news conference where he claimed his question was not aimed at outing the whistleblower.

“I don’t know who the whistleblower is. ... My question’s not about the whistleblower,” Paul said. “My question’s about two people who were friends who worked together at the National Security Council who have been overheard talking about impeaching the president years in advance."

U.S. law protects the identity and careers of people who bring forward accusations of wrongdoing by government officials. Lawmakers in both parties have historically backed those protections.

BIPARTISAN QUESTION

In a rare show of bipartisanship, two Democrats — Arizona Sen. Kyrsten Sinema and West Virginia's Joe Manchin — joined with two Republicans, Alaskan Lisa Murkowski and Susan Collins of Maine to ask a question.

The lawmakers wanted to be assured by the president that private citizens would not conduct foreign policy unless they've been specifically designated by the State Department to do so. The question referred to Trump's personal attorney, Rudy Giuliani, who played a key role in the Ukraine investigation.

White House lawyer Patrick Philbin said Giuliani was merely a "source of information" for Trump on Ukraine and was not conducting foreign policy. Even George Washington relied on trusted confidants, Philbin noted.

Schiff called the answer "breathtaking,'' saying the White House was admitting that Giuliani was not conducting official business when he was in Ukraine or working on Ukraine issues.

“They have just undermined their entire argument,'' Schiff said, adding that the White House had "acknowledged that the person in charge of this was not conducting policy'' but instead "was undergoing this domestic errand.”

The last comment referred to a remark by former Trump adviser Fiona Hill, who testified that Giuliani and his associates were on “a domestic political errand” while she and other professionals were engaged in foreign policy.

ECHOES OF WATERGATE

Rep. Zoe Lofgren of California, a congressional staffer during Watergate and now a House prosecutor, said Watergate also started as a partisan inquiry. A bipartisan consensus emerged only after Republicans — including staunch Nixon supporters — saw enough evidence to change their minds, she said.

“They couldn't turn away from the evidence that their president had committed abuse of power and they had to vote to impeach him,'' Lofgren said. While disappointed that House Republicans did not vote to impeach Trump, the Senate — "the greatest deliberative body on the planet'' — has a new opportunity, she said.

Unlike House investigators, the Senate can call first-hand witnesses like Bolton who can testify about what they heard Trump say and saw him do, Lofgren said. "I think we would all learn something. Let's see if that kind of information can help the senators come together as happened in the House Judiciary Committee so many years ago.''

WHAT'S AHEAD

Next steps for the trial were unclear late Thursday. A vote on witnesses, expected Friday, could lead to an abrupt end of the trial with an expected acquittal by Republican senators unconvinced of wrongdoing by Trump. A less likely, but still possible outcome was a deal that could bring testimony from Bolton and other witnesses.

Three Republican senators have indicated openness to calling witnesses, an outcome that could lead to a 50-50 tie on the question if no senator changes their vote. It was not clear if Roberts would attempt to break a tie.

  • Associated Categories: Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Political Conventions
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Estranged husband accused of killing Jennifer Dulos dies
A lawyer for a Connecticut man charged with murdering his missing wife amid a contentious divorce case says his client has died
8:53PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Mom fails to meet deadline to bring missing kids to Idaho
The mom of two children missing since September failed to meet a court-ordered deadline to bring the kids to authorities in Idaho on Thursday
8:35PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Trial highlights: Dershowitz backtracks, Paul thwarted
Senators continued asking questions at President Donald Trump's impeachment trial, as one of Trump's attorneys tried to explain his controversial defense and a Republican senator was thwarted in his bid to expose the whistleblower whose complaint launched the probe
8:34PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Voters' 2nd choices could be decisive in close Iowa caucuses
With overwhelming uncertainty looming over the the Iowa caucuses, presidential campaigns are scrambling to navigate an evolving playing field in which voters' second choices could matter almost as much as their first
7:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump to create post to focus on solely human trafficking
The Associated Press has learned that President Donald Trump plans to appoint an individual to focus exclusively on combating human trafficking
7:38PM ( 1 hour ago )
Testimony coming? Abrupt acquittal? Trump trial edges on
President Donald Trump's impeachment trial is lurching through a final day and night of questions and answers before a crucial vote on calling witnesses
7:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Tricky trade-offs for states in Trump's new Medicaid offer
The Trump administration is offering states a new Medicaid deal: more control over health care spending on certain low-income residents
5:52PM ( 3 hours ago )
Wary of irking China, Trump offers rosy take on virus threat
President Donald Trump says he hopes the outbreak caused by a new virus in China won't be as bad as some people think it could be
5:31PM ( 3 hours ago )
Experts on Dershowitz's impeachment defense: Quid pro whoa
Alan Dershowitz delivered a stunning defense of President Donald Trump in the Senate that would essentially make it impossible to impeach a president for anything he might do to boost his reelection prospects
5:17PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Postal workers union with 200,000 members endorses Sanders
Bernie Sanders has been endorsed by the 200,000-member American Postal Workers Union
3:45PM ( 5 hours ago )
Even with no major rival, Trump steps up early state effort
President Donald Trump is set to coast to victory in the first Republican primary contests of 2020, but that doesn't mean he's taking them for granted
2:49PM ( 6 hours ago )
Effort to expose whistleblower fails as Trump trial edges on
President Donald Trump's impeachment trial has lurched into a final day of questions and answers before a crucial vote on calling witnesses
2:36PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Elections
10 Things to Know for Today
Get ready for Thursday, January 30th with a few things to know about the day’s news from The Associated Press
6:01AM ( 14 hours ago )
Buttigieg endorsed by major California, Nevada LGBTQ group
Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg has won the endorsement of one of the nation's largest LGBTQ membership organizations
6:01AM ( 14 hours ago )
Asked and answered? Senators have their say in Trump trial
Fidgety senators had their first chance to do something other than sit in silence at President Donald Trump's impeachment trial
12:34AM ( 20 hours ago )
General Presidential Election News
Bloomberg creates a parallel presidential race. Can he win?
When the leading Democratic presidential candidates marked Martin Luther King Jr. Day by linking arms and marching through South Carolina, Michael Bloomberg was nowhere near the early primary state
9:39PM ( 1 day ago )
Collins expected to try ousting new GA senator in GOP battle
A Republican official says conservative Georgia Rep. Doug Collins is expected to challenge newly appointed Sen. Kelly Loeffler for her Senate seat this year
11:31PM ( 2 days ago )
Democrats struggle with how directly to knock Sanders
With Bernie Sanders rising in the polls and expressing confidence in his ability to win Iowa's Democratic caucuses, his opponents are grappling with the challenge of stopping him
8:48PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Elections - Political Conventions
Estranged husband accused of killing Jennifer Dulos dies
A lawyer for a Connecticut man charged with murdering his missing wife amid a contentious divorce case says his client has died
8:53PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Mom fails to meet deadline to bring missing kids to Idaho
The mom of two children missing since September failed to meet a court-ordered deadline to bring the kids to authorities in Idaho on Thursday
8:35PM ( 23 minutes ago )
2 moderates, Biden and Buttigieg, diverge on strategy to win
Democratic presidential candidates Joe Biden and Pete Buttigieg have the same goal: emerging from the Iowa caucuses as the moderate alternative to progressive rival Bernie Sanders
8:26PM ( 32 minutes ago )
China reports new cases, deaths as virus declared emergency
The World Health Organization has declared the outbreak sparked by a new virus in China that has spread to more than a dozen countries a global emergency after the number of cases spiked more than tenfold in a week, including the record number of deaths in 24 hours reported Friday
8:21PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Family of dead Mexican forest guardian say people are afraid
Relatives of a Mexican anti-logging activist who was found dead don’t know whether he was slain or died accidentally, but they say they are sure of one thing
8:14PM ( 44 minutes ago )