Friday February 28th, 2020 3:27AM

As trial nears, Trump keeps discredited Ukraine theory alive

By The Associated Press

The theory took root in vague form well before Donald Trump laid claim to the White House in 2016. The candidate’s close confidant tweeted about it. His campaign chairman apparently spoke about it with people close to him.

What if, the idea went, it was actually Ukraine — and not Russia — that was interfering in the 2016 election?

Never mind that the notion has since been amplified by the president of Russia, the country that U.S. intelligence agencies unequivocally blame for interfering in that year's presidential race. Or that Trump’s hand-picked FBI director and other American officials have said there’s no information pointing to Ukraine interference. Or that 25 Russians stand charged in U.S. courts with hacking into Democratic emails and waging a covert social media campaign to sway American public opinion.

The Ukraine theory lives on.

Now, Trump’s request for Ukraine to investigate the matter and a political rival, former Vice President Joe Biden, is at the heart of a congressional inquiry that produced Trump’s impeachment by the House of Representatives. A Senate trial is next.

The discredited theory, spread online by GOP allies in interviews and tweets, has been embraced by a president reluctant to acknowledge the reality of Russian election interference, and anxious to show he had reason to be suspicious of Ukraine as the U.S. withheld crucial military aid last year.

The effect: blurring the facts of the impeachment case for many Americans even before it reaches a trial that could begin with days.

Experts fear the strategy leaves the U.S. vulnerable to more misinformation campaigns in the 2020 election and signals to the Kremlin and other foreign actors that Americans are willing to cling to falsehoods.

A review by The Associated Press shows that the Ukraine conspiracy theory traces back to Trump’s 2016 campaign, was spread online and later advanced by Russian President Vladimir Putin weeks after his own country was blamed for election interference. Finally, some of America’s own elected leaders made it their truth.

“The ultimate victim is democracy, is the stability of our nation,” said Nina Jankowicz, a disinformation expert at the nonpartisan Wilson Center, a Washington, D.C. think tank.


As U.S. authorities collected evidence in 2016 that Russia had hacked and stolen years of internal emails from the Democratic National Committee, Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort, who had cultivated extensive business contacts in Ukraine and worked for pro-Russia politicians there, was privately pointing to another culprit.

Manafort, now serving more than seven years in prison for tax fraud and other crimes, suggested then that the attack was probably executed by Ukrainians, according to FBI notes from an April 2018 interview with Rick Gates, Manafort's former deputy. The idea parroted that of Konstantin Kilimnik, a Manafort business associate who U.S. authorities have assessed has ties to Russian intelligence — an accusation Kilimnik has denied.

Trump aide Michael Flynn, who later became Trump's first national security adviser, was also adamant within the campaign that Russia couldn't have carried out the attack and that U.S. intelligence wouldn't be able to figure out who had done it, Gates recalled.

That skepticism was adopted by Trump himself, who memorably said during a presidential debate that “it could also be China. It could also be lots of other people. It also could be somebody sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds, OK?"

All the while, U.S. officials were agreeing with a private cybersecurity firm's findings that Russia was responsible, collecting evidence over the next several months that tied individual Russian military intelligence officers to the hack.

Adding to the FBI's concern was the revelation that a Trump campaign official had been told Russia had damaging information about Democratic opponent Hillary Clinton. That July, the bureau opened an investigation into whether Russia and the Trump campaign were working together to sway the election in Trump's favor, a probe eventually taken over by special counsel Robert Mueller.


As the Democrats' stolen emails were published online and the U.S. prepared to publicly blame the Kremlin for the hack, assertions surfaced online that Ukraine had meddled — directly or indirectly — in America's presidential campaign.

In September 2016 Roger Stone, a Trump confidant later convicted of lying about his efforts to get inside information about the emails, tweeted: “The only interference in the U.S. election is from Hillary’s friends in Ukraine."

His tweet highlighted a Financial Times article that said some Kyiv leaders were determined “to intervene, however indirectly" in the U.S. election. The story detailed efforts by Serhiy Leshchenko, a former Ukrainian parliament member who opposed Trump's bid, to expose off-the-books payments Ukraine’s pro-Russia political party made to Manafort.

Leshchenko maintains his efforts don't amount to interference or compare to Russia's attack on the U.S. elections.

Still, some Republican legislators, including a few contacted by AP, pointed to the article as proof Ukraine interfered.

“I think both Russia and Ukraine meddled in the 2016 election,” Republican Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana said last month on NBC's “Meet the Press. He cited the Financial Times as evidence.

As Trump prepared to take office, news reports fueled doubts online over the conclusion that Russia had hacked the DNC and Clinton campaign.

“So how and why are they so sure about hacking if they never even requested an examination of the computer servers? What is going on?” Trump tweeted on Jan. 5, 2017, the day after a BuzzFeed News article reported that the FBI did not physically examine the Democrats’ servers to determine Russia infiltrated the system.

A Politico report days later documented a Democratic consultant’s opposition research in 2016 on Manafort's work in Ukraine — which included consulting on behalf of former leader Viktor Yanukovych, who fled to Russia after his 2014 ouster — and described efforts by some Ukraine leaders to support Clinton over Trump.

The article said there was not a top-down effort by Ukraine to push voters toward Clinton, but some Republicans now point to the reporting to support their allegations of meddling.

Citing the reports, anti-establishment conservative and liberal bloggers made misleading connections between Ukraine and CrowdStrike, the cybersecurity firm that traced the hack back to Russia.

This online speculation helped shape the Ukraine conspiracy theory, explained Thomas Rid, a Johns Hopkins University professor who has tracked disinformation campaigns and election interference.

“The landscape has made it so easy to find rabbit holes, and go down these rabbit holes, stay there, and find a community of like-minded amateur sleuths,” Rid said.

It is the nebulous nature of the Ukrainian theory, which leaves room for both direct and indirect interference, that has given the idea a shape-shifting, evolving form that has contributed to its staying power.

One online commentator misleadingly claimed CrowdStrike's co-founder Dmitri Alperovitch works for a think tank funded by a Ukrainian oligarch. Alperovitch is a fellow at the Atlantic Council, which is based in the U.S. and receives funding from a variety of sources. Donations from Ukrainian oligarch Victor Pinchuk’s foundation made up less than less than 1.6 percent of the group's funding in 2018.

“A great deal of misinformation relies upon serendipity or mere contacts,” said John Herbst, a former U.S. ambassador to Ukraine and director of the Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Center. “Then they draw egregious or conspiratorial conclusions based on those contacts.”

Putin himself weighed in days after Trump moved into the White House, publicly claiming that Ukraine’s entire government had favored Clinton during the election and now needed to “improve relations” with the new Trump administration.

“As we all know, during the presidential campaign in the United States, the Ukrainian government adopted a unilateral position in favor of one candidate,” Putin said in at a news conference that February with Hungary’s prime minister.

Russian media used the comments to suggest it was Ukraine that had actually interfered.

It was convenient for the Kremlin to point the finger at another offender: Just weeks earlier, U.S. intelligence agencies had released a detailed report accusing Russia of interfering in the election on Trump's behalf. And Ukraine was the perfect scapegoat, experts said. The Kremlin has been locked in a 5-year war with Ukraine that has killed more than 14,000 people.

“It’s in Russia’s interest to amplify this issue because it wants Ukraine to be undermined,” said Jankowicz, the disinformation expert.

By April 2017, the Ukraine conspiracy theory was being promoted by Trump himself.


Trump sat at the desk of the Oval Office, just shy of his first 100 days on the job, when he falsely suggested in an Associated Press interview that CrowdStrike had even stronger ties to Ukraine.

“I heard it’s owned by a very rich Ukrainian, that’s what I heard,” Trump said. “Why didn’t they allow the FBI in to investigate the server? I mean, there is so many things that nobody writes about. It’s incredible.”

In fact, CrowdStrike is a publicly held California company founded by two U.S. citizens — George Kurtz and Alperovitch, who was born in Russia but spent his adult life in America. The company has identified cyberattacks for major U.S. clients, including the U.S. government and the National Republican Congressional Committee.

And the FBI didn't need to physically take the DNC servers to confirm CrowdStrike's findings that Russia was behind the attack, said Eugene H. Spafford, a computer science professor at the Center for Education and Research in Information Assurance and Security at Purdue University who has assisted the bureau in cases.

Instead, CrowdStrike took digital images of the DNC system, capturing files, photos, emails, and browsing history to determine who had breached the system. Copies of those images were then handed over to the FBI, the company says.

The process is similar to how investigators at a crime scene take photos that are later analyzed for clues.

A physical review of the DNC's data, a cloud system comprised of at least 140 servers, would have disabled the Democrats’ computer systems for days or weeks amid a presidential election, Spafford noted.

But Trump took his suspicions about the servers directly to Volodymyr Zelenskiy, the newly elected Ukraine president in the now-infamous July 25 phone call that resulted in articles of impeachment against Trump.

“I would like you to find out what happened with this whole situation with Ukraine, they say CrowdStrike ... I guess you have one of your wealthy people...” Trump asked of Zelenskiy on the call, according to notes released by the White House in September. “The server, they say Ukraine has it.”

Dozens of news outlets debunked Trump’s comments and continue to do so. Finding itself at the center of the phone call, CrowdStrike then released a blog post rebuffing the president’s claims. The president's own national security advisers rebutted the theory to no avail, former White House aide Fiona Hill told impeachment investigators in November.

“We spent a lot of time ... trying to refute this one in the first year of the administration,” Hill said.


Still, Trump keeps the notion alive.

He insisted to Fox News viewers in November that he only withheld aid from Ukraine to investigate corruption in the country, hinting once again that the DNC’s servers are hidden there.

“You know, the FBI has never gotten that server,” Trump said “That’s a big part of this whole thing. Why did they give it to a Ukrainian company?”

Parts of the Ukraine election interference theory have since been echoed by a growing number of the president’s Republican allies — some of whom concede that Russia interfered but posit that Ukraine did too.

Days before the president was impeached, Sen. Ted Cruz told NBC’s “Meet the Press” that there’s “considerable evidence" that Ukraine had interfered.

His office later said in a statement: “Russia’s campaign to interfere in our election was real and systematic. It is also true that Ukrainian officials did not want...then-candidate Trump to win. The two are not mutually exclusive."

And as his Senate impeachment trial looms, Trump is pressing GOP senators to rally behind the discredited theory — asking his personal attorney Rudy Giuliani to brief them on his trip to eastern Europe, where he searched for witnesses and documents to back up the claims. Videos documenting his trip have aired on the pro-Trump television network, One America News, and have been viewed thousands of times online.

Hill, a Russia expert, told Congress in November that political leaders who spread such falsehoods about Ukraine are only polarizing the U.S. further and turning it into an easy target for misinformation campaigns by such foreign powers as Russia.

She warned: “These fictions are harmful even if they are deployed for purely domestic political purposes.”


Associated Press writers Mary Clare Jalonick in Washington and Yuras Karmanau in Kyiv contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Presidential Election News, AP World News, AP Elections - Campaigns, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Canadian province retracts alert of nuclear power incident
People throughout the Canadian  province of  Ontario awoke to an alarming alert of an “incident” at a nuclear plant just east of Toronto _ only to later be told the message was a mistake
1:19PM ( 3 minutes ago )
US seeking to amplify voices of protest in Iran amid turmoil
The Trump administration is trying to amplify voices of dissent in Iran following the downing of a Ukrainian civilian airliner
1:14PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Suit over Border Patrol detention conditions goes to trial
The trial for a years-old lawsuit challenging detention conditions in Border Patrol stations is set to begin
1:10PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Queen prepares for royal family summit over Harry and Meghan
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II  is preparing for a crisis family meeting to work out a future for Prince Harry and his wife, Meghan, after their dramatic decision to walk away from royal roles
12:34PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Patriots star Edelman arrested for vandalism in California
New England Patriots star Julian Edelman was arrested near LA on suspicion of misdemeanor vandalism after allegedly jumping on the hood of someone's car
12:31PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Alabama county to preserve jail remnant where MLK was held
An Alabama county is taking steps to preserve what's left of the lockup where officials say Martin Luther King Jr. served his final time behind bars
11:56AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Australia turns from defense to offense in wildfire battle
Crews battling Australia's wildfires say they have been able to turn from defense to offense for the first time in weeks thanks to a break in the weather
8:20AM ( 5 hours ago )
Titans stun Ravens, head to AFC title game with 28-12 win
Derrick Henry gained 195 yards rushing and threw a 3-yard touchdown pass in the Tennessee Titans' 28-12 victory over the Baltimore Ravens
12:50AM ( 12 hours ago )
Titans stun Ravens, head to AFC title game with xx-xx win
Derrick Henry gained 195 yards rushing and threw a 3-yard touchdown pass in the Tennessee Titans' 28-12 victory over the Baltimore Ravens
11:35PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Queen attends church on eve of meeting over Harry and Meghan
Queen Elizabeth II has attended church at her Sandringham estate ahead of a crisis meeting to work out a future for Prince Harry and his wife, Meghan, after their decision to walk away from royal roles
9:09AM ( 4 hours ago )
Esper: US does not expect more Iranian retaliatory attacks
Defense Secretary Mark Esper says he doesn't foresee further Iranian military attacks in retaliation for the U.S. strike that killed the Islamic Republic's most powerful general
9:03AM ( 4 hours ago )
Not on form, but brawl over citizenship question continues
There won't be a citizenship question on this spring's U.S. census form, but that doesn't mean the fight over it has ended in court
8:42AM ( 4 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Democratic 2020 candidates vie for unions, Latinos in Nevada
Democratic presidential candidates are in Nevada seeking to build relationships with Latino voters and win the coveted endorsement of a powerful casino workers union
9:30PM ( 15 hours ago )
Report: US, China reach agreement to resume economic talks
A published report says the United States and China have agreed to resume semiannual talks on economic and trade issues
6:57PM ( 18 hours ago )
Judges from across Europe march to defend Polish peers
Judges from across Europe have marched silently in Warsaw in a show of solidarity with peers in Poland
4:18PM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Pelosi to send impeachment to Senate for historic trial
The standoff over when to move the articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump to the Senate appears to be wrapping up
12:53AM ( 1 day ago )
White House considering dramatic expansion of travel ban
The Trump administration is considering dramatically expanding its much-litigated travel ban to additional countries
12:52AM ( 1 day ago )
Biden slams Trump on Iran policy, says he hurt US interests
Former Vice President Joe Biden is blaming President Donald Trump's withdrawal from a nuclear agreement with Iran in 2018 for the current instability in the Middle East. Biden used a rally in northern Nevada Friday night to tout his own foreign policy experience as a key reason he's the Democrat with the best chance to unseat Trump in November
12:25AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Congress News
Andrew Yang won the internet, but can he win a 2020 caucus?
After months of running on unconventional campaign strategies, Andrew Yang has arrived at a point in the 2020 campaign that is governed by the conventional rules of election
7:54AM ( 1 day ago )
Taiwan's independence-leaning president leading vote count
Taiwan's independence-leaning President Tsai Ing-wen appears headed for a landslide victory with more than 70% of precincts reporting election tallies
6:53AM ( 1 day ago )
Early tallies show Taiwan's president leading vote count
Early results from Taiwanese television networks and the Election Commission show President Tsai Ing-wen leading her closest challenger, possibly putting her on the way to winning a second term
5:26AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections
Pelosi: House moving to send impeachment to Senate next week
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says the House will take steps next week to send articles of impeachment to the Senate for President Donald Trump's trial
3:59PM ( 1 day ago )
White House considers expanding travel ban to more countries
The White House is considering expanding its much-litigated travel ban to additional countries amid a renewed election-year focus by President Donald Trump on immigration issues
2:50PM ( 1 day ago )
Spiritual guru Marianne Williamson ends 2020 White House bid
The Democratic presidential race has lost another candidate
1:00PM ( 2 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
China threat looms over presidential election in Taiwan
An expected victory for President Tsai Ing-wen in Taiwan's elections Saturday is likely to bring further deadlock and heightened pressure from Beijing
5:17AM ( 2 days ago )
Trump boasts Iranian general's death was 'American justice'
President Donald Trump is using his first campaign election rally of 2020 to argue that he served up “American justice" by ordering a drone strike to take out Iranian commander Qassem Soleimani
1:45AM ( 2 days ago )
Steyer is 6th candidate to qualify for next week's debate
Billionaire Tom Steyer has qualified for next week's Democratic presidential debate in Iowa
7:09PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Suit over Border Patrol detention conditions goes to trial
The trial for a years-old lawsuit challenging detention conditions in Border Patrol stations is set to begin
1:10PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Recovery begins after stormsthat kill 11 in Midwest, South
Thousands remain without electrical power from storms that ravaged parts of the South and Midwest, causing 11 deaths
1:03PM ( 19 minutes ago )
AP source: Browns hiring Vikings OC Stefanski as next coach
A person familiar with the decision tells The Associated Press that the Cleveland Browns are hiring Minnesota Vikings offensive coordinator Kevin Stefanski as their new coach
12:31PM ( 51 minutes ago )
'It feels good': Serena Williams ends 3-year title drought
Serena Williams ended a three-year title drought when she beat fellow American Jessica Pegula 6-3, 6-4 to win the singles final at the ASB Classic on Sunday
12:01PM ( 1 hour ago )
Canadian province retracts alert of nuclear power incident
People throughout the Canadian  province of  Ontario awoke to an alarming alert of an “incident” at a nuclear plant just east of Toronto _ only to later be told the message was a mistake
12:01PM ( 1 hour ago )