Monday July 13th, 2020 6:24AM

UK court rules Johnson's suspension of Parliament unlawful

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LONDON (AP) — A Scottish court dealt another blow to Prime Minister Boris Johnson's Brexit plans Wednesday, ruling that his decision to suspend Parliament less than two months before the U.K. is due to leave the European Union was an unlawful attempt to avoid democratic scrutiny.

The government immediately said it would appeal, as the political opposition demanded Johnson reverse the suspension and recall lawmakers to Parliament.

With Brexit due in 50 days, the court ruling deepened Britain's political deadlock. Johnson insists the country must leave the EU on Oct. 31, with or without a divorce deal to smooth the way. But many lawmakers fear a no-deal Brexit would be economically devastating, and are determined to stop him.

Their case got a boost late Wednesday as the government gave in to a demand from lawmakers and published a classified document sketching out the potential impact of leaving the EU without a divorce deal. The expected consequences included logjams for freight, shortages of some fresh foods, major travel disruptions and possible rioting.

Earlier, justices at Scotland's highest civil court said in a surprise judgment that the government's action was illegal "because it had the purpose of stymieing Parliament."

Johnson claims he shut down the legislature this week so that he can start afresh on his domestic agenda at a new session of Parliament next month. But the five-week suspension also gives him a respite from rebellious lawmakers as he plots his next move to break the political impasse over Brexit and lead Britain out of the EU by Oct. 31, "do or die."

But a panel of three Court of Session judges in Edinburgh said "the only inference that could be drawn was that the U.K. government and the prime minister wished to restrict Parliament."

One of the judges, Philip Brodie, said it appeared the suspension was intended "to allow the executive to pursue a policy of a no-deal Brexit without further parliamentary interference."

The judges declared the suspension "null and of no effect," but said Britain's Supreme Court must make the final decision at a hearing due to begin Tuesday.

Johnson denied he was being anti-democratic.

"If opposition members of Parliament disagree with our approach, then it is always open to them to take up the offer that I've made twice now — twice! — that we should have an election," he said in an online question-and-answer session. "There is nothing more democratic in this country than a general election."

Opposition politicians, however, insisted that the government must recall Parliament. Lawmakers were sent home this week despite the objections of House of Commons Speaker John Bercow and opposition lawmakers, who held up signs in the chamber saying "Silenced."

"He should do the right thing now, which is to reopen Parliament, let us back to do our job and to decide what to do next," said Labour Party Brexit spokesman Keir Starmer.

Dominic Grieve, one of 21 lawmakers kicked out of the Conservative group in Parliament by Johnson last week after voting against the government, said it was possible the prime minister had misled Queen Elizabeth II — whose formal approval is needed to suspend Parliament — about his motives.

He said if that turned out to be true, the prime minister would have to "resign — and very swiftly."

The court ruling came after more than 70 opposition lawmakers challenged the government's decision to shut down Parliament until Oct. 14 — just over two weeks before Britain is due to leave the EU.

Last week, a court in Edinburgh rejected the lawmakers' challenge, saying it was a matter for politicians, not the courts, to decide. But that was overturned Wednesday on appeal.

The British government said it was disappointed by the decision and would appeal to the Supreme Court.

It noted that another challenge to the suspension, brought by transparency campaigner Gina Miller, was rejected at the High Court in London last week by judges who said the decision was inherently political and "not a matter for the courts."

Catherine Haddon, a senior fellow at independent think-tank the Institute for Government, tweeted that the Scottish ruling "does not (yet) change the prorogation itself. Though of course will add to pressure."

Britain's 2016 decision to leave the European Union has left the country's politics gridlocked and tested to the limit the U.K.'s largely unwritten constitution.

With a no-deal Brexit looming, rebel members of the governing Conservatives joined with the opposition to deliver a series of blows to Johnson in the days before Parliament was suspended. They passed a law that orders the government to seek a three-month delay to Brexit if no agreement has been reached by late October, and twice rejected Johnson's call for a snap general election.

More than three years after Britain voted to leave the EU, voters of all stripes are fed up and both the Conservatives and main opposition Labour Party are divided.

Johnson, one of the leaders of the 2016 "leave" campaign, is trying to deliver Brexit and counter an electoral threat from the newly founded Brexit Party. Its leader Nigel Farage took out newspaper ads Wednesday, offering an electoral pact with the Conservatives if Johnson backed a "clean break" — a no-deal Brexit.

But Johnson's office said "the PM will not be doing a deal with Nigel Farage."

Johnson says he wants to strike a new deal with the bloc after the agreement made by his predecessor Theresa May was rejected three times by Britain's Parliament.

He said Wednesday that talks with the 27 other EU nations were making progress.

"The mood is changing, the ice floes are cracking," he said.

But EU officials say the U.K. has made no concrete new proposals.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel said Wednesday that "we still have a chance to achieve this in an orderly way," but that Germany was also prepared for a no-deal Brexit.


Frank Jordans in Berlin contributed to this story.


Follow AP's full coverage of Brexit and British politics at:

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, AP World News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Merkel says orderly Brexit still possible
German Chancellor Angela Merkel says an orderly departure of Britain from the European Union remains possible, less than two months before the deadline
5:27AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Inside Bolton's exit: Mongolia, a mustache, a tweet
It was a marriage that was never going to last: Trump and Bolton rarely saw eye to eye on the globe's growing hotspots
5:27AM ( 21 minutes ago )
UK court rules Johnson's suspension of Parliament unlawful
A Scottish court has ruled that Prime Minister Boris Johnson's decision to suspend Parliament was unlawful, but did not order it to be overturned
5:20AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
California Senate approves bill regulating gig economy
The California Senate has passed a bill that will give new wage and benefit protections to workers at so-called gig economy companies like Uber and Lyft
1:18AM ( 4 hours ago )
Trump ousts hawkish Bolton, dissenter on foreign policy
President Donald Trump has abruptly forced out John Bolton, his hawkish national security adviser
1:15AM ( 4 hours ago )
Democrats step on shaky political ground with fracking bans
Several Democratic presidential candidates are running on a promise to ban fracking and stepping on unstable political ground as they do so
12:41AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: GOP's Murphy wins seat of congressman who died
A Republican state legislator has won an eastern North Carolina congressional seat and will succeed the late GOP Rep. Walter Jones Jr.
8:30PM ( 9 hours ago )
Polls close in election for 2 N Carolina congressional seats
Polls close in special election for House seat from North Carolina that is testing Trump, GOP's 2020 prospects
7:55PM ( 9 hours ago )
Dems question Trump official on lands, Native Americans
Congressional Democrats are questioning a Trump administration official's commitment to public lands and his attitude toward Native Americans
7:43PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Merkel: Germany must engage in rights dialogue with China
German Chancellor Angela Merkel says it's important for her country to engage in dialogue with China, including on issues such as human rights
3:43AM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Netanyahu pledge dims hope for Palestinian state
The Latest: Israeli PM's pledge to annex heart of West Bank could extinguish all hope for Palestinian state
1:14AM ( 4 hours ago )
South Korea initiating WTO complaint over Japan trade curbs
South Korea is initiating a complaint to the World Trade Organization over Japan's tightened export controls on key materials South Korean companies use to make computer chips and displays
11:37PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP World News
Asian shares mostly higher after rise on Wall Street
Asian shares are mostly higher, cheered by a rise on Wall Street amid some signs of easing tensions between the US and China on trade issues
1:33AM ( 4 hours ago )
Apple takes on Netflix with a $5-a-month streaming service
Apple is finally taking on Netflix with its own streaming television service, offering it at the bargain price of $5 a month beginning on Nov. 1
12:13AM ( 5 hours ago )
Nielsen says it will include out-of-home viewing soon
The Nielsen company says that starting next season, it will start including people who watch programs outside of their homes in the weekly ratings
9:44PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Merkel says orderly Brexit still possible
German Chancellor Angela Merkel says an orderly departure of Britain from the European Union remains possible, less than two months before the deadline
5:27AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Inside Bolton's exit: Mongolia, a mustache, a tweet
It was a marriage that was never going to last: Trump and Bolton rarely saw eye to eye on the globe's growing hotspots
5:27AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Iran urges US to 'put warmongers aside' after Bolton firing
Iran's president says US should 'put warmongers aside' in reference to dismissal of Bolton, who was hawkish on Iran
5:09AM ( 39 minutes ago )
GOP holds NC House seat but shows weakness in suburbs
Conservative Republican Dan Bishop has won a special election for an open House seat in North Carolina
4:48AM ( 1 hour ago )
Balloon sent in memory of British dad lands in Polish field
Balloon released in England for father on anniversary of his death travels by land and sea to Poland
4:32AM ( 1 hour ago )