sunny.png
Friday September 20th, 2019 2:26PM

Big Tech faces a new set of foes: nearly all 50 US states

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Big tech companies have long rebuffed attempts by the U.S. federal government to scrutinize or scale back their market power. Now they face a scrappy new coalition as well: prosecutors from nearly all 50 states.

In a rare show of bipartisan force, attorneys general from 48 states along with Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia are investigating whether Google's huge online search and advertising business is engaging in monopolistic behavior. The Texas-led antitrust investigation of Google, announced Monday, follows a separate multistate investigation of Facebook's market dominance that was revealed Friday.

The state moves follow similar sweeping antitrust tech investigations launched by the Federal Trade Commission and the Trump administration's Department of Justice; the Democrat-led House Judiciary Committee is conducting a similar probe. But should federal officials tire of their work, the state-led efforts could keep them on their toes.

States have worked closely together on other matters, such as the fight to curb opioid abuse. But the sheer number participating in this kind of antitrust effort is unprecedented and gives it more weight, said Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes, a Republican.

"It's just an accumulation of public frustration, whether it's from consumers, other players in the market, regulators, lawmakers," Reyes said in an interview Monday.

Fiona Scott Morton, a Yale economics professor and former antitrust official at the Justice Department under the Obama administration, said it's important that states are taking the lead because the Trump administration is "not really enforcing antitrust law except against companies the president is upset with."

She noted the Trump administration's unsuccessful push to use antitrust law to block AT&T's acquisition of Time Warner, which owns CNN, a frequent target of Trump's criticism; and Friday's announcement that federal antitrust enforcers would investigate automakers that worked with California on tougher emissions limits.

"That's not what consumers want," she said. "Consumers want to be protected from anticompetitive conduct."

States haven't seriously taken up antitrust enforcement — using laws originally crafted to combat railroad and oil barons in the 19th century — since a major antitrust case against Microsoft about two decades ago. Then, state leadership helped propel federal action.

Back in 2016, Reyes and a Democratic counterpart, Washington, D.C. Attorney General Karl Racine, tried unsuccessfully to get the Federal Trade Commission to reopen an earlier investigation into Google for allegedly favoring its own products in search results.

The FTC declined, leaving European regulators to take the lead in similar probes overseas, Reyes said.

Google's parent company, Alphabet, has a market value of more than $820 billion and controls so many facets of the internet that it's almost impossible to surf the web for long without running into at least one of its services. Google's dominance in online search and advertising enables it to target millions of consumers for their personal data.

The company — and peers such as Amazon, Facebook and Apple — have long argued that although their businesses are large, they are useful and beneficial to consumers. Influenced by the popularity of the companies' ubiquitous tech products and their significant lobbying power, most American political leaders didn't challenge that view.

But the public debate over the tech industry has changed dramatically since Reyes and Racine sent their letter to the FTC at the end of the Obama administration three years ago. Culprits in that shift include Facebook's Cambridge Analytica privacy scandal, in which a political data mining firm affiliated with Donald Trump's presidential campaign improperly accessed the personal data of as many as 87 million users.

On Monday, Reyes and Racine joined forces again — this time flanked by nearly a dozen mostly Republican state attorneys general on the steps of the Supreme Court and dozens more from both parties who signed onto the formal investigation.

"Ignoring 50 AGs is a lot more difficult than ignoring two AGs," Reyes said. "DC and Utah had raised these issues but didn't feel we had enough firepower or resources on our own."

Scott Morton, the Yale professor, said most states have laws that mimic federal antitrust laws, but it can be harder for state attorneys general to enforce those laws because they don't usually have in-house antitrust experts. They can get around that, she added, by working together with other states and hiring shared experts.

Reyes emphasized that the state-led effort is not "anti-tech," and argued it is "actually for the benefit of the tech ecosystem to help level the playing field."

He said there's nothing wrong with Google being the dominant search player if it's done fairly, but the investigation will look into whether Google crosses the line "between aggressive business practices and illegal ones."

A tech trade association that has supported some antitrust measures expressed wariness about how states are proceeding.

"We hope the investigations will be law and evidence-based and will restrain from overly politicizing these inquiries, and that both companies and authorities will work together in good faith," said Ed Black, president and CEO of the Communications Computer and Communications Industry Association.

__

Associated Press writers Rachel Lerman in San Francisco and Marcy Gordon in Washington contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Big Tech faces a new set of foes: nearly all 50 US states
Big tech companies have long rebuffed attempts by the U.S. federal government to scrutinize or scale back their market power, but they have a scrappy new coalition to contend with: nearly all of the 50 states
1:18AM ( 6 minutes ago )
California governor signs vaccine bills he demanded
California Gov. Gavin Newsom has signed bills to crack down on doctors who write fraudulent medical exemptions for children's vaccinations
1:08AM ( 16 minutes ago )
NOAA chief to address forecasters amid Dorian flap
The head of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has a chance to weigh into the fray over President Donald Trump's mistaken claim that Hurricane Dorian was threatening Alabama
1:07AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Trump calls NC vote 1st step to removing Pelosi
President Donald Trump is urging North Carolina voters to "take the first steps" toward removing House Speaker Nancy Pelosi
12:26AM ( 58 minutes ago )
At rally, Trump paints bleak picture of Democratic control
President Donald Trump's rally in North Carolina was more than just a measure of his clout in trying to elect a Republican to a key House seat
12:25AM ( 59 minutes ago )
Trump says peace talks with Taliban are now 'dead'
President Donald Trump says that as far as he's concerned, Afghanistan peace talks with the Taliban are dead
12:23AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Democrats press Trump to intervene with GOP on gun bill
Congressional Democrats are pressing President Donald Trump to intervene with Senate Republicans and demand passage of a bipartisan bill to expand background checks for gun purchases
7:24PM ( 6 hours ago )
Air Force reviews hotel choices after Trump resort stay
The Air Force is reviewing how crews on international travel choose airports and hotels
7:17PM ( 6 hours ago )
Lawmakers eye stopgap spending bill to prevent a shutdown
House Democrats propose a government-wide temporary funding bill to prevent a federal shutdown at month's end, give Senate time to get moving on $1.4 trillion in spending bills
7:05PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Asian shares mixed as investors look ahead to rate decisions
Asian shares are mixed after a day of listless trading on Wall Street as investors awaited signs on global interest rates
11:37PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Ship owner thanks all for rescue of crew members
The South Korean company that owns a capsized cargo ship says it's grateful to everyone involved in the rescue of four trapped crew members
9:11PM ( 4 hours ago )
Asics employee's lawsuit highlights paternity leave in Japan
Asics employee's lawsuit highlights paternity leave issues in Japan, where corporate culture values loyalty
8:32PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Groups praise states for launching Google probe
A large group of states led by Texas is announcing an investigation of Google's market power and whether it unfairly squelches competition and hurts consumers.
3:25PM ( 9 hours ago )
States led by Texas target Google in new antitrust probe
A large group of states led by Texas announced an investigation into whether Google has gotten too big and effective at stomping or acquiring rivals.
3:01PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Calif., Ala. missing from group probing Google
A large group of states led by Texas is announcing an investigation of Google's market power and whether it unfairly squelches competition and hurts consumers.
2:54PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
California governor signs vaccine bills he demanded
California Gov. Gavin Newsom has signed bills to crack down on doctors who write fraudulent medical exemptions for children's vaccinations
1:08AM ( 17 minutes ago )
NOAA chief to address forecasters amid Dorian flap
The head of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has a chance to weigh into the fray over President Donald Trump's mistaken claim that Hurricane Dorian was threatening Alabama
1:07AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Apple expected to unveil iPhones echoing last year's models
Apple expected to reveal relatively minor changes to iPhone line-up amid sales slump that raises the stakes for an upcoming video service
1:06AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Climate change, trade woes reshape Frankfurt auto show
The headwinds buffeting the global auto industry are making themselves felt at the Frankfurt Motor Show as the industry confronts slowing global trade and auto sales, the U.S
1:06AM ( 18 minutes ago )
The Latest: UK govt formally suspends Parliament for 5 weeks
The British government has formally suspended Parliament, sending lawmakers home for five weeks amid a Brexit crisis
1:06AM ( 19 minutes ago )