clearn.png
Wednesday September 18th, 2019 10:24PM

AP Interview: Gorsuch rues loss of civility in public life

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Justice Neil Gorsuch is following the path of Supreme Court colleagues-turned-authors in a new book in which he laments the loss of civility in public discourse.

The 52-year-old justice wrote "A Republic, If You Can Keep It" because Americans should remember that their political opponents "love this country as much as we do," Gorsuch said in an interview with The Associated Press in his Supreme Court office. The book is being published Tuesday.

But Gorsuch had little to say about President Donald Trump, who appointed him to the Supreme Court and who routinely brands his opponents dopes, losers, liars and worse.

"If you're asking me about politics, I'm not going to touch that," Gorsuch said.

All Gorsuch would say about Trump is that during the nomination process in 2017, the president "was very gracious to my family."

Penguin Random House gave Gorsuch a $225,000 advance for the book, a collection of speeches, essays and judicial decisions. Gorsuch also sets forth his view of the proper role of each branch of the federal government — the presidency, Congress and the courts — and defends his originalist approach to interpreting laws and the Constitution according to their meaning when written.

He is the latest justice, following Sonia Sotomayor, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Clarence Thomas and Stephen Breyer, to write a book while on the court.

Seated in his corner office a little over a month before the Oct. 7 start of the new Supreme Court term, Gorsuch appeared relaxed and upbeat. He showed off a plaque he brought back from his summer teaching sojourn in Padua, Italy, signed by "the boys" of the local police station. He'll travel to California and Texas to speak about his book at the Richard Nixon library and George W. Bush presidential center before the term begins, in addition to speaking at the National Archives in Washington.

One theme of the book is a common refrain among the justices when they speak in public, especially in the aftermath of Justice Brett Kavanaugh's tumultuous Senate confirmation hearings: Judges are not politicians in robes, even if their decisions in high-profile cases often can be predicted based on the president who appointed them.

"It's one thing to think that judges occasionally, mistakenly, wrongly decide cases based on who they like and who they dislike as parties. It's another thing to think that judges are just politicians who are supposed to do that. And I saw a lot of that thinking" during his own confirmation hearings in 2017, Gorsuch recalled.

In November, Chief Justice John Roberts offered a plain-spoken rebuke to Trump after the president described a judge who ruled against his asylum policy as an "Obama judge." ''We do not have Obama judges or Trump judges, Bush judges or Clinton judges. What we have is an extraordinary group of dedicated judges doing their level best to do equal right to those appearing before them," Roberts said in response to a question from the AP.

While Gorsuch avoids personal attacks, he takes aim at judges and legal scholars who prefer a "living Constitution" that adapts to the times over the originalist view.

Among the criticisms of originalism is that the Constitution, as Breyer has said, uses broad language that the founders knew would have to be flexible to changes in society. Another is that originalism almost always leads to outcomes preferred by conservatives. "Baloney. Rubbish," Gorsuch said. "You know, the living Constitution is going to take your rights away and it's going to add ones that aren't there. ... We have a written Constitution. It's about honoring the words the people chose to adopt. What are the first three words of the Constitution? It's 'We the people,' not 'We the states,' not 'We the nine old judges.'"

It's the same sentiment he expressed in a speech to the conservative Federalist Society in 2017. "Originalism has regained its place at the table of constitutional interpretation, and textualism in the reading of statutes has triumphed. And neither one is going anywhere on my watch," he said then to thunderous applause.

In his book, Gorsuch makes a plea for kindness and manners, recounting advice from the English grandmother of his wife, Louise, who told him that he would regret things he did and things left undone, but that he would never be sorry for being kind.

And he notes that George Washington had to copy by hand all 110 rules of civility that were written by the Jesuits in 1595. In the interview, Gorsuch paraphrased one rule that he particularly liked.

"Do not speak so closely to another person with such enthusiasm that you bedew the other man with your spittle," he said, from a safe distance. "It's a good rule. It's a good rule."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
AP Interview: Gorsuch rues loss of civility in public life
Justice Neil Gorsuch is following the path of Supreme Court colleagues-turned-authors in a new book in which he laments the loss of civility in public discourse
3:41PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Mugabe dies; liberated Zimbabwe, then held it for 37 years
Robert Mugabe, the longtime leader of Zimbabwe who was forced to resign in 2017 after a military takeover, has died at 95, his successor says
3:31PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Ex-drug company CEO Martin Shkreli sues former investor
The former drug company executive known as Pharma Bro has sued the son of one of his investors over losses from a failed hedge fund
3:25PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Kansas' Pompeo could swing Senate race, but will he run?
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo didn't address speculation that he might run for the Senate in Kansas during a college lecture in his home state, and some in his audience were convinced that it's still possible
2:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump challenges California power to control auto pollution
Trump administration begins all-out assault on California's authority to regulate auto tailpipe emissions
2:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
Moving beyond Mueller, Democrats focus on Trump's properties
House Democrats are demanding information on the use of taxpayer money at President Trump's hotels and properties, including during Vice President Pence's trip this week to Ireland
2:06PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Biden tells Colbert his 'gaffes' aren't 'substantive'
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden says verbal missteps and factual errors he's made while campaigning aren't "substantive"
12:48AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Texas executes man for killing 2 women
A Texas death row inmate has been executed for fatally stabbing an 89-year-old woman and her daughter more than 16 years ago
7:54PM ( 1 day ago )
Larger US sports betting market races for (online) end zone
As the second NFL season following a U.S. Supreme Court ruling clearing the way for legal sports betting begins, nearly three times as many states are in the game, and nearly three dozen others are considering jumping in
6:09PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Mugabe dies; liberated Zimbabwe, then held it for 37 years
Robert Mugabe, the longtime leader of Zimbabwe who was forced to resign in 2017 after a military takeover, has died at 95, his successor says
3:31PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Ex-drug company CEO Martin Shkreli sues former investor
The former drug company executive known as Pharma Bro has sued the son of one of his investors over losses from a failed hedge fund
3:25PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Chiefs sign Tyreek Hill to 3-year, $54 million extension
Chiefs sign wide receiver Tyreek Hill to 3-year, $54 million contract extension
3:24PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Pelosi calms allies, talks climate at G7 meet _ unlike Trump
It was a different atmosphere at this G-7 meeting
3:21PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Caps' Ovechkin leaner if not lighter going into 14th season
Capitals' Alex Ovechkin leaner if not lighter going into 14th NHL season at 34
3:03PM ( 48 minutes ago )