pcloudy.png
Thursday July 16th, 2020 1:43PM

Owner of dive boat where 34 died seeks to head off lawsuits

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LOS ANGELES (AP) — The owners of the dive boat where 34 people perished in a fire off Southern California filed a lawsuit Thursday to head off potentially costly litigation, a move condemned by some observers as disrespectful to the families of the dead.

Truth Aquatics Inc., which owned the Conception, filed the action in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles under a pre-Civil War provision of maritime law that allows it to limit its liability.

Investigators are still searching for what caused the blaze that wrecked the boat, which remains upside down at the bottom of the sea near the Channel Islands.

The time-tested legal maneuver has been successfully employed by owners of the Titanic and countless other crafts — some as small as Jet Skis — and was widely anticipated by maritime law experts. Still, the fact it was filed just three days after the deadly inferno Monday came as a surprise to legal observers.

Families of the deceased, who are not named in the complaint, will be served with notice that they have a limited time to challenge the company's effort to clear itself of negligence or limit its liability to the value of the remains of the boat, which is a total loss.

"They're forcing these people to bring their claims and bring them now," said attorney Charles Naylor, who represents victims in maritime law cases. "They have six months to do this. They could let these people bury their kids. This is shocking."

Professor Martin J. Davies, the maritime law director at Tulane University, said the cases always follow accidents at sea and always look bad, but they are usually initiated by insurance companies to limit losses.

"It seems like a pretty heartless thing to do, but that's what always happens. They're just protecting their position," Davies said. "It produces very unpleasant results in dramatic cases like this one. ... The optics are awful."

The U.S. law dates to 1851, but it has its origins in 18th century England, Davies said. It was designed to encourage the shipping business. Every country with a shipping industry has something similar on the books.

In order to prevail, the company and owners Glen and Dana Fritzler have to show they were not at fault in the disaster.

They asserted in the lawsuit that they "used reasonable care to make the Conception seaworthy, and she was, at all relevant times, tight, staunch, and strong, fully and properly manned, equipped and supplied and in all respects seaworthy and fit for the service in which she was engaged."

Even if the captain or crew are found at fault, the Fritzler's and their insurance company could avoid paying a dime under the law, experts said.

All of those who died were in a bunkroom below the main deck. Officials have said the 33 passengers and one crewmember had no ability to escape the flames.

Crew members told investigators they made several attempts to rescue the people who were trapped before abandoning ship, the National Transportation Safety Board said. None of the survivors has spoken publicly.

The court filing not only seeks to protect the boat owners from legal exposure, but also will require any lawsuits to be filed in the same federal court.

A judge will hold a non-jury trial to see if the company can successfully show it wasn't at fault. If that's the case, any claimants would only be entitled to the value of the remains of the ship, which the suit said is a total loss with zero value.

There's a long history of ship owners successfully asserting this protection. The case involving the White Star Line, the owners of the Titanic, went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, which held that a foreign owner could assert protection of the Limitation Act, attorney James Mercante said.

In that case, plaintiffs eventually withdrew their lawsuits and filed them in England, where the company was based. British law, even though it also limited damages, provided a bigger payout than the value of the remaining lifeboats.

While the law can shield owners from damages, over 90% of cases where injury and death are involved are settled before trial, Mercante said.

Attorney A. Barry Cappello, who is in discussions with another firm to represent family members of the Conception victims in court, said there's a strong case to show negligence in the boat fire and that good lawyers can find a way around the admiralty law in federal court.

"The law is so antiquated and so skewed in favor of the ship owners that damages for wrongful death type cases is very limited unless one can prove exceptions," Cappello said.

Cappello recently prevailed in a case in which a company that rented a paddleboard to a man who drowned in Santa Barbara Harbor had asserted the liability protection. A judge ruled the admiralty law didn't extend to such crafts, though the company has appealed.

Davies said from what he's heard of the disaster, there's a realistic prospect the owner might prevail if the boat was properly equipped and the cause of the fire remains mysterious.

If the owner loses, there's the potential of unlimited liability.

"That's why the fight is always about limitation because if you've got unlimited liability, well, ... 30 dead people is a whole lot of money," Davies said.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Newly hired scientist for California among boat fire victims
The 33 people killed on Labor Day when a dive boat off Southern California caught fire and sank included a water conservationist dubbed 'water princess' and an environmental scientist recently hired to lead marine management for the state of California
7:31PM ( 1 minute ago )
Dorian further dampens enthusiasm for NC congressional race
Hurricane Dorian has created new challenges in the final days of campaigning for a North Carolina congressional seat already getting scant attention
7:28PM ( 4 minutes ago )
1 acquitted in deadly warehouse fire; jury deadlocks on 2nd
A jury has acquitted one man of involuntary manslaughter but couldn't reach a verdict for the leader of an artists' commune accused of turning a California warehouse into a cluttered maze that trapped 36 partygoers during a fast-moving fire
7:27PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Dorian grazes Carolina coast, aims for Outer Banks
Hurricane Dorian is sideswiping the Carolina coast with shrieking winds and sideways rain, threatening a direct hit on the dangerously exposed Outer Banks overnight
6:52PM ( 39 minutes ago )
The Latest: Dive boat owners seek to head off lawsuits
The owners of the California dive boat where 34 people perished in a fire have filed suit in federal court to avoid liability in the case
6:49PM ( 43 minutes ago )
The Latest: Defense points to high rents in warehouse fire
An attorney for the leader of an artists' commune has broken down in tears after a jury said they couldn't agree whether to convict or acquit his client in a California warehouse fire that killed 36 partygoers
6:47PM ( 45 minutes ago )
AP National News
In Arizona, Pentagon-funded border fence already underway
Construction on a Pentagon-funded portion of the border wall began in Yuma, Arizona, this week, just as a federal authorities announced they are diverting even more defense funds for wall projects
6:38PM ( 54 minutes ago )
Taliban attacks test Trump as he seeks to end Afghan war
Relentless, deadly attacks by the Taliban, including one Thursday that killed a U.S. service member, are testing President Donald Trump's resolve to withdraw troops from Afghanistan and
6:11PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump presents Medal of Freedom to NBA's Jerry West
President Donald Trump has awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom to pro basketball great Jerry West
5:16PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
This time it's Boris Johnson's younger brother jumping ship
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson's bad week got even worse Thursday when younger brother Jo Johnson walked away from his government post to protest his big brother's Brexit policy
2:28PM ( 5 hours ago )
Manafort's lawyers: State charges are double jeopardy
Paul Manafort's lawyers say his New York mortgage fraud case should be dismissed on double jeopardy grounds
1:54PM ( 5 hours ago )
This time it's Boris Johnson's younger brother to jump ship
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson's bad week got even worse Thursday when younger brother Jo Johnson walked away from his government post to protest his big brother's Brexit policy
1:18PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
The Latest: Dorian advancing to Carolinas, weakens slightly
Forecasters say Hurricane Dorian is expected to slowly weaken as it travels near and along the coasts of South and North Carolina
5:06PM ( 2 hours ago )
Families, engineers, free spirits among boat fire victims
California boat fire claimed lives of engineers, free spirits, parents with teenage and adult children brought together over a passion for scuba diving
4:20PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Flights canceled as Dorian approaches Southeast
Much of southeastern Virginia is shutting down as Hurricane Dorian churns up the Atlantic Coast
4:16PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
Newly hired scientist for California among boat fire victims
The 33 people killed on Labor Day when a dive boat off Southern California caught fire and sank included a water conservationist dubbed 'water princess' and an environmental scientist recently hired to lead marine management for the state of California
7:31PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Dorian further dampens enthusiasm for NC congressional race
Hurricane Dorian has created new challenges in the final days of campaigning for a North Carolina congressional seat already getting scant attention
7:28PM ( 5 minutes ago )
1 acquitted in deadly warehouse fire; jury deadlocks on 2nd
A jury has acquitted one man of involuntary manslaughter but couldn't reach a verdict for the leader of an artists' commune accused of turning a California warehouse into a cluttered maze that trapped 36 partygoers during a fast-moving fire
7:27PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Official: Trump to challenge California authority on mileage
A government official says the Trump administration is moving forward with a proposal to revoke part of California's authority to set its own automotive emissions and fuel economy standards
7:18PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Crew reports multiple attempts to save 34 boat passengers
Investigators say the crew of the dive ship that sank off the Southern California coast made several attempts to save the 34 people who were trapped by fire and died
7:13PM ( 20 minutes ago )