rain.png
Tuesday February 25th, 2020 4:23AM

Virginia transgender bathroom case: Judge favors ex-student

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NORFOLK, Va. (AP) — A federal judge in Virginia ruled Friday that a school board's transgender bathroom ban discriminated against a former student, Gavin Grimm, the latest in a string of decisions nationwide that favor transgender students who faced similar policies.

The order issued by U.S. District Judge Arenda Wright Allen in Norfolk is a major victory for the American Civil Liberties Union and for Grimm. His four-year lawsuit was once a federal test case and had come to embody the debate about transgender student rights.

The issue remains far from settled as a patchwork of differing policies governs schools across the nation. More court cases are making their way through the courts.

The Gloucester County School Board's policy required Grimm, a transgender male, to use girls' restrooms or private bathrooms. The judge wrote that Grimm's rights were violated under the U.S. Constitution's equal protection clause as well as under Title IX, the federal policy that protects against gender-based discrimination.

"(T)here is no question that the Board's policy discriminates against transgender students on the basis of their gender noncomformity," Allen wrote.

"Under the policy, all students except for transgender students may use restrooms corresponding with their gender identity," she continued. "Transgender students are singled out, subjected to discriminatory treatment, and excluded from spaces where similarly situated students are permitted to go."

Allen's ruling requires the school board to update the gender on Grimm's high school transcripts.

The judge also acknowledged that the board had the "unenviable responsibility" of navigating challenges that were unimaginable a generation ago.

"There can be no doubt that all involved in this case have the best interests of the students at heart," Allen added.

Grimm graduated in 2017 from Gloucester High School, located in a mostly rural area about 60 miles (95 kilometers) east of Richmond and near the Chesapeake Bay. Now 20 and living in California, he said by phone that the judge's order was "beautiful."

Grimm said he felt a sense of relief but would continue to fight the case if the school board appeals.

"My case has given me something of a platform that I intend to use, as long as I have it available to me, for trans education and advocacy," he added.

David Corrigan, the attorney for the Gloucester County School Board, declined to comment in an email to The Associated Press.

Corrigan had argued in court last month that Grimm remained female. He said gender is not a "societal construct" and that it doesn't matter that Grimm underwent chest reconstruction surgery and hormone therapy.

The judge's ruling will likely strengthen similar claims of discrimination made by students in eastern Virginia. It could have a greater impact if the case goes to an appeals court that oversees Maryland, West Virginia and the Carolinas.

Allen's ruling joins others that have been favorable to transgender students in states that include Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. But differing policies are still in place in schools across the country, said Harper Jean Tobin, policy director for the National Center for Transgender Equality, speaking last month with the AP.

Gary McCaleb, senior counsel for the conservative Christian group Alliance Defending Freedom, said last month that the issue is far from resolved.

McCaleb cited a federal discrimination complaint his organization filed in June that says a Connecticut policy on transgender athletes is unfair because it allows transgender girls to consistently win track and field events.

He also said a pending U.S. Supreme Court case involving a transgender woman who was fired by a Michigan funeral home could affect school bathroom policies.

Grimm's lawsuit became a federal test case when it was supported by the administration of then-President Barack Obama and scheduled to go before the U.S. Supreme Court in 2017.

But the high court hearing was canceled after President Donald Trump rescinded an Obama-era directive that students can choose bathrooms corresponding with their gender identity.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Walmart pulls violent game displays but will still sell guns
Walmart is removing displays or videos showing violence from stores nationwide in response to a mass shooting at one of its stores in Texas
5:33PM ( 50 seconds ago )
Mass shootings give rise to bullet-resistant backpacks
Mass shootings have led to the rise in bullet-resistant backpacks for children but critics question whether companies are using tragedy as a marketing opportunity
5:18PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Documents: Plant owners 'willfully' used ineligible workers
Court documents show six of seven Mississippi chicken processing plants raided Wednesday were "willfully and unlawfully" employing people who lacked authorization to work in the United States
5:14PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Charges filed against suspect in deadly California rampage
The suspect in a deadly Southern California stabbing rampage was charged with four counts of murder, one count of attempted murder and other counts
4:57PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Packed field of 2020 Dems descends on Iowa's 'Wing Ding'
Nearly all the Democrats running for president are descending on northern Iowa to make personal pitches to hundreds of would-be supporters
4:45PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Families gather to remember victims of El Paso shooting
Families of those killed when a gunman opened fire at an El Paso Walmart are gathering at funerals on each side of the U.S.-Mexico border to remember loved ones whose lives told the story of the vibrant region
4:39PM ( 55 minutes ago )
AP National News
Walmart pulls violent game displays but will still sell guns
Walmart is removing displays or videos showing violence from stores nationwide in response to a mass shooting at one of its stores in Texas
5:33PM ( 50 seconds ago )
Mass shootings give rise to bullet-resistant backpacks
Mass shootings have led to the rise in bullet-resistant backpacks for children but critics question whether companies are using tragedy as a marketing opportunity
5:18PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Documents: Plant owners 'willfully' used ineligible workers
Court documents show six of seven Mississippi chicken processing plants raided Wednesday were "willfully and unlawfully" employing people who lacked authorization to work in the United States
5:14PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Chaos of Dayton shooting echoes in 911 calls, radio traffic
Emergency calls and radio traffic from the mass shooting in Dayton, Ohio, last weekend provide a window into a chaotic scene as strangers sought help for the wounded and emergency responders tried to sort out whether there was a second shooter
5:10PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Stocks fall again on trade-war worries, capping a wild week
Stocks stumbled Friday as worries flared yet again that President Donald Trump's trade war with China may be worsening. It was a fitting end to a wild week
5:04PM ( 29 minutes ago )