clearn.png
Monday January 20th, 2020 6:53PM

Poking and prodding: did CNN debate go too far?

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — CNN poked and prodded for fault lines among Democrats running for president during both nights of debates this week, and that wasn't to everyone's liking.

The network took a hit on social media and among some critics for baiting candidates and provoking conflict. Drawing out differences in policy prescriptions and records, and seeing how politicians aspiring for the nation's highest office handle pressure, is precisely the point of a debate, however.

"If we were doing the debate again tomorrow, we would do it exactly the same way," Sam Feist, CNN's Washington bureau chief, said Thursday.

CNN reached 10.7 million people for Wednesday's second night of the debate, up 2 million from what a different batch of candidates reached the night before. Both nights were well below what NBC News had for the first round of debates in June. They had one thing in common, though: for both debates, the presence of former Vice President Joe Biden meant for a larger audience.

At the beginning of Wednesday's debate, CNN headed straight toward a conflict between Biden and Kamala Harris, whose clash over segregation was the most memorable moment of NBC's debate.

Addressing Harris, moderator Dana Bash noted that Biden had criticized her health plan as a "have-it-every-which-way approach and says it's part of a continuing pattern of equivocating about your health care stance. What do you say to that?"

After the two candidates went back and forth, Bash told Biden that New York Mayor Bill de Blasio "said Democrats who wanted to keep the private insurance industry are defending a health care system that is not working. What do you say to that?"

That pattern was repeated throughout the debate, like when moderator Jake Tapper said to Biden, "Sen. (Cory) Booker called your new criminal justice reform plan, quote, 'an inadequate solution to what is a raging crisis in our country.' Why is Sen. Booker wrong?"

The New York Times' James Poniewozik wrote that discord that erupted during the debate was multiplied by CNN's "smackdown aesthetic. You fight or you die — the price of attention is combat." The Washington Post's Hank Stuever said CNN was "conflict-obsessed."

Caroline Franke wrote in Variety that CNN hit the candidates with leading questions aimed more at starting fights than shedding light, and were looking for clips that would attract attention online and in reruns.

"They chase explosive moments, not the kind of kind of insight that people actually need to understand where a candidate stands," Franke wrote.

Stephen Farnsworth, a political scientist and author of "Presidential Communication and Character: White House News Management from Clinton and Cable to Twitter and Trump," argued in favor of more open-ended questions.

"The effort to provoke conflict went far overboard," he said. "A more useful approach would be to focus more extensively on the range of issues that the next president has to contend with."

The critical comments were echoed by many expressions of disgust on social media, although that's a venue where the negative often dominates.

"What this shows is that there are a lot of people out there among the Democrats who don't want to see what President Obama once called a circular firing squad," said Frank Sesno, head of George Washington University's School of Media and Public Affairs.

Many Democrats want to focus on defeating President Donald Trump instead of seeing a bloodletting within the party, but "that's what's supposed to happen now," Sesno said.

Booker displayed exactly that attitude when immigration reform was discussed. "We are playing into Republican hands who have a very different view," he said, "and they're trying to divide us against each other."

It's worth noting, however, that much of the conflict was generated by the candidates, not CNN. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, for instance, came prepared to confront Biden on what he wrote in a newspaper column decades ago. De Blasio tried to goad Biden into denouncing immigration policies of the Obama administration.

CNN could be faulted for giving short shrift to issues like climate change, but the network said it listened closely to what its audience cited as the most important issues.

Besides testing the candidates, the debates offer the Democrats a chance to refine and test its messages before taking on Trump in an election that's more than 15 months away.

Sesno, author of "Ask More: The Power of Questions to Open Doors," is a former CNN Washington bureau chief but said he isn't afraid to criticize his old network when merited. In this case, he said CNN planners clearly spent a lot of time thinking through the issues and framed the questions to cause meaningful and strong exchanges between the candidates.

"In my view, that's what a debate should be," he said.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, AP Entertainment, AP Online TV News, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
APNewsbreak: FBI: Amazon drivers part of major theft ring
The FBI says a Washington state theft ring sold millions of dollars' worth of stolen goods on Amazon.com, and a pair of Amazon delivery drivers was involved
5:23PM ( 7 minutes ago )
8 bans in Reds-Bucs brawl; Kela 10 games, Garrett 8, Puig 3
Pittsburgh pitcher Keone Kela has been suspended for 10 games, Cincinnati reliever Amir Garrett for eight and Yasiel Puig for three after a furious brawl between the Pirates and Reds
5:17PM ( 12 minutes ago )
GOP-controlled Senate confirms 13 more judges named by Trump
Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is hailing Senate votes this week confirming 13 of President Donald Trump's judicial nominees
5:16PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump says he'd rather ralliers don't chant 'Send her back!'
President Donald Trump says he would "prefer" that his supporters a rally Thursday night don't engage in a "Send her back!" chant about a Somali-born congresswoman
4:52PM ( 38 minutes ago )
GOP pushes immigration bill, skirting rules as Dems protest
The Senate Judiciary Committee is engaged in a particularly heated battle over immigration policy as chairman Lindsey Graham upends the rules to advance a detention bill.
4:38PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Congress wants Capital One, Amazon to explain data breach
Leaders of House and Senate committees want Capital One and Amazon to explain to Congress how a hacker accessed personal information from more than 100 million Capital One credit applications
4:36PM ( 54 minutes ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Hard-won budget, debt deal clears Senate, advances to Trump
The Senate has approved a hard-won, bipartisan budget and debt deal by a 67-28 vote
3:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
Vexed with minority status and rancor, GOP lawmakers retire
Eight House Republicans say they won't seek reelection next year, reflecting GOP unease as they look ahead to next year's elections
3:46PM ( 1 hour ago )
Presidential hopefuls invited to gun control forum in Vegas
Democratic presidential candidates are invited to a gun control forum in Las Vegas just after the second anniversary of the deadliest mass shooting in modern U.S. history
3:37PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Elections
Jury weighs what Katy Perry owes for hit they say she stole
Jurors are deciding how much Katy Perry, her collaborators and her record label owe the writers of a Christian rap song over her hit "Dark Horse"
5:02PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Golden Globes group gives $3.8 million in grants
Arnold Schwarzenegger says he is not much of a fan of President Donald Trump when he hosted the Hollywood Foreign Press Association's annual grants dinner
4:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
CBS stands by 'Bull,' its star in wake of misconduct claim
CBS is standing behind "Bull" and its star and producer, who are getting leadership coaching in the wake of a sexual harassment claim
4:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Entertainment
John Dillinger relatives doubt body in grave is the gangster
Relatives of 1930s gangster John Dillinger want his body exhumed from an Indianapolis cemetery because they question whether he was actually the man FBI agents killed in Chicago in 1934
12:29PM ( 5 hours ago )
AJ Calloway exiting 'Extra' after sex misconduct allegations
A.J. Calloway is leaving the syndicated entertainment news show "Extra" in the wake of sexual misconduct allegations
9:59AM ( 7 hours ago )
CNN's Lemon doesn't back down after Trump criticism
CNN's Don Lemon is not backing down despite criticism from President Donald Trump
11:44PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Online TV News
Democrats' divisions test Biden's front-runner strength
The ideological divisions gripping the Democratic Party are intensifying as presidential candidates waged an acrimonious battle over health care, immigration and race that tested the strength of early front-runner Joe Biden's candidacy
5:26AM ( 12 hours ago )
APNewsBreak: Gun safety groups to host presidential forum
Two prominent gun safety organizations say they'll host a forum for Democratic presidential candidates in Las Vegas on Oct. 2, the day after the second anniversary of the deadliest mass shooting in modern U.S. history
5:00AM ( 12 hours ago )
The Latest: Democrats close debate by focusing on Trump
Democratic presidential candidates are closing their second primary debate by focusing on President Donald Trump
11:36PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
8 bans in Reds-Bucs brawl; Kela 10 games, Garrett 8, Puig 3
Pittsburgh pitcher Keone Kela has been suspended for 10 games, Cincinnati reliever Amir Garrett for eight and Yasiel Puig for three after a furious brawl between the Pirates and Reds
5:17PM ( 13 minutes ago )
GOP-controlled Senate confirms 13 more judges named by Trump
Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is hailing Senate votes this week confirming 13 of President Donald Trump's judicial nominees
5:16PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Center Ryan Kalil comes out of retirement to join Jets
Former Panthers Pro Bowl center Ryan Kalil comes out of retirement to join Jets
5:12PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Stocks fall as rally gives way to US-China trade war worries
Stocks slumped Thursday and bond prices spiked after President Donald Trump surprised markets with a new 10% tariff on $300 billion worth of goods from China beginning next month
5:11PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Garber's 20 years as MLS commissioner time of huge growth
Don Garber's 20th anniversary as Major League Soccer's commissioner is Sunday, and the league's challenge these days is growth and not survival, an upward trajectory that will be boosted when the U.S. co-hosts the World Cup in 2026
5:11PM ( 20 minutes ago )