cloudy.png
Tuesday March 31st, 2020 6:29PM

Harris health plan stops short of overhaul Sanders envisions

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Kamala Harris insists she still backs "Medicare for All," but the health care proposal she released on Monday stops short of the full-scale health care system overhaul that her more liberal 2020 Democratic presidential rivals are advocating.

In a split with Bernie Sanders, Medicare for All's chief architect and a fellow White House hopeful, Harris said she envisions a role for private insurers as long as they follow the government's rules. She would slow the transition to a so-called single-payer system to 10 years from the four Sanders has proposed. And she has ruled out tax increases on middle-income Americans, an idea to which Sanders has expressed openness in exchange for lowering the price of health coverage.

Medicare for All has become a defining issue in the Democratic primary, with the most progressive candidates calling for a revolutionary approach to providing insurance coverage for all Americans at a lower price. Harris' proposal, released a day before the second round of presidential debates begins, essentially seeks to thread the Democratic Party's disparate camps, nodding to the demands of the progressive base while acknowledging that some voters are nervous at the prospect of losing private coverage provided by their employers.

But it also could open Harris to criticism that she's trying to appease all corners while doing little to stake out a position of her own. She's already had to repeatedly clarify her positions on fundamental aspects of the Democratic Party's health care battle, including the role of private insurers.

A top adviser to Joe Biden, with whom Harris memorably clashed during the first debate, blasted the California senator's plan as a failed attempt to please all sides in the debate and warned that her decision to push a 10-year transition obscures the full cost of her approach.

"This new, have-it-every-which-way approach pushes the extremely challenging implementation of the Medicare for All part of this plan ten years into the future, meaning it would not occur on the watch of even a two-term administration," said Biden's deputy campaign manager, Kate Bedingfield. "The result? A Bernie Sanders-lite Medicare for All and a refusal to be straight with the American middle class, who would have a large tax increase forced on them with this plan."

Harris also got hit from the left over her health care tightrope walk. Sanders campaign manager Faiz Shakir accused her of "continuing her gradual backdown from Medicare for All" and suggested that she had been inconsistent on the issue of health care.

Although Harris signed onto Sanders' Medicare for All legislation in Congress and credited the Vermont senator on Monday for "making sure this is a front and center topic," she distanced herself from his strategy.

"I have a vision of what it should be, and the existing plans that are being offered did not express what I wanted," Harris told reporters while campaigning in Detroit.

Topher Spiro, vice president for health policy at the left-leaning think tank Center for American Progress, lauded Harris for trying to assuage "concerns that people have about disruption and about an abrupt transition" away from a largely employer-based health insurance system.

Spiro likened Harris' plan to the current design of Medicare and Medicaid, which he said "shows it's possible to have a government program that provides benefits through private options that is very cost-efficient." He declined to say whether he consulted with the campaign on its plan beyond providing information on Medicare Extra, his group's proposed alternative to Sanders' Medicare for All.

Advocates of Sanders' single-payer insurance plan were quick to criticize the Harris proposal. Adam Gaffney, the president of Physicians for a National Health Program, said Harris' plan has "several major shortcomings," including the continuation of private insurance and the longer transition period.

"This plan continues to give private insurance a very central role in the health care system," he said. "We have seen for decades that that does not work."

Harris has repeatedly been forced to clear up her stance on Medicare for All. She has previously appeared to suggest that she supported abolishing private insurance, later clarifying that she does not.

Sanders and Harris will debate on different nights during this week's second primary debates, so they won't clash directly on health care. But liberals who will share the stage with Harris, including New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, could press the issue.

Sanders said this month that the sweeping overhaul of the U.S. health system he envisions could cost up to $40 trillion over a decade, and he has said that one option for paying for part of that hefty price would be a 4% tax hike on families making more than $29,000 each year.

Harris is calling for exempting households making less than $100,000 each year from that 4% tax, with "a higher income threshold for middle-class families living in high-cost areas." While Sanders estimated that his proposed tax increase would raise $3.5 trillion over 10 years, Harris did not specify how much revenue would be raised in the scenario she's proposing.

To pay for the difference, Harris wants to tax stock trades at 0.2% of the value of the transaction, 0.1% for bonds and 0.002% for derivatives.

___

Associated Press writers Hunter Woodall in Detroit and Elana Schor in Washington contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Elections - Campaigns, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Harris health plan stops short of overhaul Sanders envisions
Kamala Harris is filling in the details of how she would move 330 million Americans onto a single government health insurance system, but her plan stops short of the full-scale overhaul Bernie Sanders has envisioned
7:43AM ( 6 minutes ago )
Russian opposition leader Navalny discharged from hospital
Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny has been discharged from hospital even though his physician raised suspicions of a possible poisoning
7:42AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Sailing to America: Teen to bring her climate activism to US
Greta Thunberg, whose social media-savvy activism has inspired tens of thousands of students in Europe to skip classes and protest against climate change, plans to take her message across the Atlantic the old-fashioned way: by boat
7:40AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Kamala Harris releases new details of her health care plan
Kamala Harris is filling in the details of how she would move 330 million Americans onto a single government health insurance system
6:02AM ( 1 hour ago )
Biden's full embrace of Obama health law has political risks
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden is placing a big bet on expanding the Affordable Care Act, but the approach leaves him subject to attacks from the left, right and middle
12:40PM ( 19 hours ago )
Biden's full embrace of Obama's health poses political risks
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden is placing a big bet on expanding the Affordable Care Act, but the approach leaves him subject to attacks from the left, right and middle
12:33PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Health
Vulnerable House Dems amass cash, adding to GOP challenge
Some of the most vulnerable Democratic incumbents are in strong financial shape for their 2020 campaigns, but there's a long way to go
6:29AM ( 1 hour ago )
Coats out as national intel director, clashed with Trump
Coats resigning next month as national intelligence director, often clashed with Trump over Russian election interference
5:59AM ( 1 hour ago )
Death toll in attack at Afghan political office rises to 20
Death toll from attack against Kabul party offices of Afghan president's VP candidate climbs to at least 20
3:33AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Elections
Judge could order Georgia to make interim voting system fix
A federal judge says Georgia allowed its election system to grow "way too old and archaic" and now has a deep hole to dig out of to ensure that the right to vote is protected
11:41AM ( 1 day ago )
Judge could order Georgia to use paper ballots this fall
A federal judge says Georgia allowed its election system to grow "way too old and archaic" and now has a deep hole to dig out of to ensure that the right to vote is protected
8:08AM ( 1 day ago )
Myriad election systems complicate efforts to stop hackers
Senate report highlights state role in overseeing elections, but should the federal government have more responsibility in securing elections?
7:59AM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Tunisians, world leaders bury president who died in office
Tunisians and visiting dignitaries are bidding adieu to the country's first democratically elected president, Beji Caid Essebsi, who died in office at 92
7:21AM ( 2 days ago )
Strike by Alaska ferry workers snarls travel plans
The first strike by Alaska ferry workers in over 40 years has snarled travel plans for thousands of people during the busy tourist and fishing season
10:19PM ( 2 days ago )
Young black voters vital to Democrats' multiracial coalition
The 2020 presidential campaign offers a critical test for Democrats of whether they can again rely on the multiracial coalition that helped Barack Obama win the White House twice
11:03AM ( 2 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
Global shares fall as market eyes US-China trade talks
Global shares are mostly lower as investors watch for developments in the trade conflict between the U.S. and China, with more talks this week
4:09AM ( 3 hours ago )
Asian shares mostly fall as market eyes US-China trade talks
Asian shares are mostly lower as investors watch for developments in the trade conflict between the U.S. and China, with more talks this week
2:25AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Band member recounts exchange with shooter
Member of the band Tin Man recounts exchange between shooter, witness
12:30AM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Business
Ready to fight: Biden leans into racial debate with Dems
Ready to fight: Biden leans into racial debate among own party
5:55PM ( 3 days ago )
Google crushes second quarter earnings expectations
Google parent Alphabet beat analyst expectations for its second quarter financials Thursday, pleasing investors and sending its stock price up
4:56PM ( 3 days ago )
Booker takes on Biden in bid to break through crowded field
As Cory Booker prepares for a pivotal turn in the spotlight at next week's Democratic presidential debate, he's trying on a new role: Joe Biden's chief antagonist
2:30PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Trump steps up attack on black lawmaker, calls him 'racist'
Facing growing accusations of racism for his incendiary tweets, President Donald Trump is seeking to deflect the criticism by labeling a leading black congressman as himself racist
7:35AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Trump touts economy, but not everyone in Michigan feeling it
Contrasting views of the economy under President Donald Trump are at the heart of the battle for Michigan, a state that helped Trump win the White House in 2016 and that both the Republican president and Democrats agree he must hold to win a 2nd term
7:16AM ( 34 minutes ago )
Boy, 8, dies in Germany after being pushed onto train tracks
German police say an 8-year-old boy has been killed by a train at Frankfurt's main station after a man pushed him and his mother onto the tracks
7:12AM ( 38 minutes ago )
New video from Iran shows Guard warning away UK warship
Iran's Revolutionary Guard releases new video showing seizure of British-flagged tanker earlier in July
7:04AM ( 46 minutes ago )
Freshmen House Democrats raise more money than GOP opponents
Some of the most vulnerable Democratic House incumbents are in strong financial shape for their 2020 campaigns, but there's a long way to go
6:59AM ( 51 minutes ago )