Saturday April 4th, 2020 5:39PM

FTC fines Facebook $5B, adds limited oversight on privacy

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Federal regulators have fined Facebook $5 billion for privacy violations and are instituting new oversight and restrictions on its business. But they are only holding CEO Mark Zuckerberg personally responsible in a limited fashion.

The fine is the largest the Federal Trade Commission has levied on a tech company, though it won't make much of a dent for a company that had nearly $56 billion in revenue last year. Two of the five commissioners opposed the settlement and said they would have preferred litigation to seek tougher penalties. Privacy advocates worry the settlement will do little to force Facebook to rein in its data-collection practices.

As part of the agency's settlement with Facebook, Zuckerberg will have to personally certify his company's compliance with its privacy programs. The FTC said that false certifications could expose him to civil or criminal penalties.

Some experts had thought the FTC might fine Zuckerberg directly or seriously limit his authority over the company.

Facebook isn't admitting any wrongdoing. The company's top lawyer, Colin Stretch, said the company's FTC settlement will lead to more rigorous management of user privacy — including more technical controls to better automate privacy safeguards.

FTC Chairman Joe Simons said the settlement is "unprecedented in the history of the FTC" and is designed "to change Facebook's entire privacy culture to decrease the likelihood of continued violations."

The FTC opened an investigation into Facebook last year after revelations that data mining firm Cambridge Analytica had gathered details on as many as 87 million Facebook users without their permission. The agency said Wednesday that following its yearlong investigation of the company, the Department of Justice will file a complaint alleging that Facebook "repeatedly used deceptive disclosures and settings to undermine users' privacy preferences."

The agency is also suing Cambridge Analytica over the privacy violations and has settled with its former CEO Alexander Nix and an outside researcher, Aleksandr Kogan, who developed the Facebook app that harvested people's personal information. Cambridge Analytica filed for bankruptcy and hasn't settled the allegations, but Kogan and Nix have agreed to restrictions on how they conduct business in the future. The settlement requires them to delete or destroy all personal information gathered.

Facebook will also pay a separate $100 million fine to the Securities and Exchange Commission to settle charges it made misleading disclosures about the risk of misuse of Facebook user data. The SEC said Facebook presented misuse of data as a hypothetical for two years even though it knew since 2015 that the third-party developer had actually misused user data.

Stretch said Facebook's handling of the Cambridge Analytica affair was "a breach of trust between Facebook and the people who depend on us to protect their data."

Three Republican commissioners voted for the fine while two Democrats opposed it, a clear sign that the restrictions on Facebook don't go as far as critics and privacy advocates had hoped. That wish list included specific punishment for Zuckerberg, strict limits on what data Facebook can collect and possibly even breaking off subsidiaries such as WhatsApp and Instagram.

"The proposed settlement does little to change the business model or practices that led to the recidivism," Commissioner Rohit Chopra wrote in his dissenting statement. He noted that the settlement lacks "any restrictions on the company's mass surveillance or advertising tactics."

Ashkan Soltani, a former FTC chief technologist, said the settlement "amounts to essentially a get-out-of-jail free card for Facebook," by indemnifying the company from government prosecution for all claims prior to June 12.

Simons, the FTC's chairman, said in a news conference Wednesday that the agency has limited legal powers to enforce privacy rules. For stiffer penalties, he said, the agency would have faced long odds in drawn-out litigation.

Commissioner Noah Phillips, a Republican, said the purpose of the action isn't "to vindicate every concern that the world has about Facebook," but it sends important messages that the price of privacy violations is getting higher and "paying attention to privacy issues is something that companies ought to consider whether to elevate to the board level."

But despite the record fine and all the public flogging triggered by the Cambridge Analytica scandal, Facebook is worth more than it was before the blowback began. The company's stock had slipped by less than 1% to $201.51 in Wednesday's midday trading, a few hours after the settlement announcement. The company's market value was hovering around $575 billion — roughly $40 billion above where it stood before the news of the Cambridge abuses broke. Those gains make the $5 billion fine easier to swallow for Facebook and its shareholders.

The FTC had been examining whether that massive breakdown violated a settlement that Facebook reached in 2012 after government regulators concluded the company repeatedly broke its privacy promises to users. That settlement had required that Facebook get user consent to share personal data in ways that override their privacy settings.

The FTC said Facebook's deceptive disclosures about privacy settings allowed it to share users' personal information with third-party apps that their friends downloaded but the users themselves did not give permissions to.

The agency also found that Facebook misrepresented the extent to which users could decline, or opt out of, facial recognition technology used to identify people in pictures and videos and that it failed to disclose that phone numbers collected for a security feature known as two-factor authentication could also be used for targeted advertising.

Privacy advocates have pushed for the FTC to limit how Facebook can track users — something that would likely cut into its advertising revenue, which relies on businesses being able to show users targeted ads based on their interests and behavior. The FTC did not specify such restrictions on Facebook.

The fine is well above the agency's previous record for privacy violations — $22.5 million — which it dealt to Google in 2012 for bypassing the privacy controls in Apple's Safari browser. There have been even larger fines against non-tech companies, including a $14.7 billion penalty against Volkswagen to settle allegations of cheating on emissions tests and deceiving customers. Equifax will pay at least $700 million to settle lawsuits and investigations over a 2017 data breach; the FTC was one of the parties. The money will likely go to the U.S. Treasury.

The FTC's new 20-year settlement with Facebook establishes an "independent privacy committee" of Facebook directors. The committee's members must be independent, will be appointed by an independent nominating committee and can only be fired by a "supermajority" of Facebook's board of directors. The idea is to remove "unfettered control" by Zuckerberg, the FTC said.

Since the Cambridge Analytica debacle erupted more than a year ago, Facebook has vowed to do a better job corralling its users' data. Nevertheless, other missteps have come up since then.

In December, for example, the Menlo Park, California, company acknowledged a software flaw had exposed the photos of about 7 million users to a wider audience than they had intended. It also acknowledged giving big tech companies like Amazon and Yahoo extensive access to users' personal data, in effect exempting them from its usual privacy rules. And it collected call and text logs from phones running Google's Android system in 2015.

Amid all that, Zuckerberg and his chief lieutenant, Sheryl Sandberg, apologized repeatedly. In March, Zuckerberg unveiled a new, "privacy-focused" vision for the social network that emphasizes private messaging and groups based on users' interests.

The fine does not spell closure for Facebook, although the company's investors — and executives — have been eager to put it behind them. Facebook is still under various investigations in the U.S. and elsewhere in the world, including the European Union, Germany and Canada. There are also broader antitrust concerns that have been the subject of congressional hearings and led the Justice Department this week to announce that it has opened an investigation into major tech companies.


Ortutay reported from San Francisco. Associated Press writers Michael Liedtke and Samantha Maldonado in San Francisco, Mae Anderson in New York, Matt O'Brien in Providence, Rhode Island, and Frank Bajak in Boston contributed to this story.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
FTC fines Facebook $5B, adds limited oversight on privacy
Federal regulators are fining Facebook $5 billion for privacy violations and instituting new oversight and restrictions on its business
9:14AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Treasury secretary, trade rep headed to China for more talks
Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin is heading back to China next week to further talks aimed at resolving a trade war between the Washington and Beijing
9:11AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Boeing post loss of nearly $3 billion in 2Q
Boeing posts nearly $3 billion in losses for the second quarter
9:09AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Cooling energy sector pings Caterpillar
Slowing global economy, energy sector, a drag for Caterpillar in 2Q
8:42AM ( 37 minutes ago )
Judge temporarily blocks new Arkansas anti-abortion laws
A federal judge has temporarily stopped three new abortion restrictions from taking effect in Arkansas
8:35AM ( 44 minutes ago )
Boris Johnson to become UK PM, aiming to win over doubters
Boris Johnson was due to become Britain's new prime minister, vowing to lead the UK out of the European Union, and unite a country deeply divided over Brexit
8:33AM ( 46 minutes ago )
AP Business
Dining reservation app OpenTable moves into delivery
Dining reservation app OpenTable is partnering with Uber Eats and others to offer delivery
6:09AM ( 3 hours ago )
Did Facebook data help Trump? 'Great Hack' explores scandal
The documentary "The Great Hack" synthesizes the threat to democracy from Facebook's cavalier handling of user data exposed in the Cambridge Analytica scandal, but it doesn't prove the data helped Donald Trump get elected.
1:27AM ( 7 hours ago )
Justice Dept. puts Big Tech under the antitrust microscope
Justice Dept. puts Big Tech under the antitrust microscope
12:06AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Technology News
Treasury secretary, trade rep headed to China for more talks
Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin is heading back to China next week to further talks aimed at resolving a trade war between the Washington and Beijing
9:11AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Boeing post loss of nearly $3 billion in 2Q
Boeing posts nearly $3 billion in losses for the second quarter
9:09AM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Mueller dismisses Trump's claim of 'exoneration'
Special counsel Robert Mueller is dismissing President Donald Trump's claim of "total exoneration," saying it's not what his Russia report said
9:02AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Norfolk Southern 2Q profit up 2% despite weaker volume
Norfolk Southern's 2Q earnings chugged ahead 2% even though the railroad hauled 4% less freight because it was able to raise its shipping rates
9:00AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Mueller: Russian interference serious challenge to democracy
Former Trump-Russia special counsel Robert Mueller faces congressional interrogators in televised hearings.
8:59AM ( 20 minutes ago )