Thursday September 24th, 2020 5:08PM

San Francisco to paint over historic George Washington mural

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — San Francisco will spend up to $600,000 to paint over historical artwork at a public school depicting the life of George Washington, a mural once seen as educational and innovative but now criticized as racist and degrading for its depiction of black and Native American people.

The "Life of Washington" was painted by Victor Arnautoff, one of the foremost muralists in the San Francisco area during the Depression. The San Francisco School Board's decision to paint over the 83-year-old mural is prompting some to worry that other artwork from the so-called New Deal era could face a similar fate because of changing sensitivities.

In addition to depicting Washington as a soldier, surveyor and statesman, the 13-panel, 1,600-sqaure foot mural at George Washington High School contains images of white pioneers standing over the body of a Native American and slaves working at Washington's Mount Vernon estate in Virginia.

The board's decision last week comes at a time when the legacies of Washington and other historical figures who owned slaves are being re-examined. Some cities have changed the names of streets and buildings named after slave owners.

Richard Walker, a professor emeritus of geography at the University of California, Berkeley and director of the history project, Living New Deal, said the Washington mural is meant to show the "uncomfortable facts" about America's first president. For that, it was among many New Deal works of art considered radical when created.

"We on the left ought to welcome the honest portrayal," Walker said, adding that destroying a piece of art "is the worst way we can deal with historic malfeasance, historic evils."

Mark Sanchez, vice president of the school board and a third-grade teacher, said students who must walk past the mural during the school day don't have a choice about seeing the harmful images. "Painting it over represents not only a symbolic fresh start, but a real fresh start," he said.

Lope Yap, Jr., vice president of the Washington High School Alumni Association and a 1970 graduates, disagreed, saying when he was a student and saw the mural he was "awed by the subtle ways Arnautoff was able to critique American history." He said the depictions are "treasures, priceless art" and painting it over is tantamount to pretending the history depicted never happened.

"I'm not into censorship," Yap said. "I would want to deal with history so we can prevent this from ever happening again."

The mural is a fresco, which means it's painted on the wall and can't easily be removed. Painting it over won't happen immediately. Should a lawsuit or other delay arise, it will be covered up until the issues are resolved. The board plans to digitally archive the mural.

Most of the $600,000 earmarked for the project will go toward a required environmental review and to cover expected legal challenges.

George Washington High School has about 2,000 students. Nearly all are people of color and many come from low-income families. As early as the 1960s, some students argued the mural's imagery is offensive and racist. Renewed opposition emerged in recent years amid protests in the South and elsewhere over statues honoring Confederate heroes.

Arnautoff, a Russian-born communist and social critic, was hired with Federal Art Project funds as part of President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal, a series of government programs meant to help lift the country out of the Great Depression of the 1930s.

He was one of a group of artists to paint murals at San Francisco's Coit Tower that prompted anti-communists to delay the tower's opening. Arnautoff's piece, called "City Life," shows urban workers crowding around a newsstand of socialist newspapers and magazines. The piece faced criticism for failing to include the conservative-leaning San Francisco Chronicle.

"Victor Arnautoff was far ahead of his time, and we have yet to catch up with him in terms of making school curriculum more inclusive and historically accurate," said Harvey Smith, president of the National New Deal Preservation Association.

Walker and other supporters of the mural worry that painting over it may signal that it's acceptable to destroy the thousands of other New Deal murals across the country. Activists have been successful in getting a series of New Deal murals at the University of New Mexico covered up. Other New Deal murals in New York and Iowa have been vandalized, as well as painted over and subsequently restored.

"The mural is an immense public treasure during one of the few periods of American history where you had the federal government supporting public art, public spaces, public goods," Walker said. "It's been the right that has always attacked the New Deal with its social programs."

Walker suggested rather than destroying the Washington mural, school officials should simply cover it and require freshmen to take a course on slavery and California's role in subjugating Native Americans.

To Sanchez, that's not enough.

"I understand the importance of art, and it should be the last thing we do, to attempt to cover any kind of art up," he said. "The starting point has to be from those who feel they are harmed and how that is unacceptable, especially given the history of this country. When we don't listen, we don't learn."

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Local/State News, Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Business, AP Business - Economy
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
San Francisco to paint over historic George Washington mural
San Francisco School Board decides to paint over a Depression-era mural of George Washington for its depiction of black and Native American people; critics worry the move allows modern sensitivities to censor a critical portrayal of American history.
5:23PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Florida's most famous cheerleader, Mr. Two Bits, dies at 97
University of Florida's most famous cheerleader, the man better known as Mr. Two Bits, has died at age 97
5:00PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Gibraltar detains Syria-bound supertanker with Iranian oil
Authorities in Gibraltar say they have intercepted an Iranian supertanker believed to be breaching European Union sanctions by carrying a shipment of Tehran's crude oil to war-ravaged Syria
4:53PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Drenched Trump supporters, protesters mark July 4 in DC
Soggy scene and polarized opinion as people gather for Trump's 'Salute to America' July 4 event
4:31PM ( 55 minutes ago )
Pregnant teens especially vulnerable in border centers
Teen moms and pregnant girls are among the most vulnerable migrants
4:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump, protesters gear up for an untraditional July Fourth
Sweltering capital hosts traditional July Fourth parade, prelude to Trump's untraditional event at the Lincoln Memorial as storms threaten
4:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
The Latest: Joey 'Jaws' Chestnut eats 71 hot dogs to win
Joey "Jaws" Chestnut ate 71 wieners and buns to secure his 12th title at Nathan's Famous annual July Fourth hot dog eating contest
1:15PM ( 4 hours ago )
Miki Sudo eats 31 hot dogs to win 6th women's title
Reigning women's champion Miki Sudo devoured 31 hot dogs to win the women's division of the annual Nathan's Famous Fourth of July hot dog eating contest on New York City's Coney Island boardwalk on Thursday
12:41PM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Protesters show off diapered baby Trump balloon
An anti-war organization has put up a 20-foot-tall diaper-clad balloon of an infant Donald Trump in the shadow of the Washington Monument to protest what it calls the president's co-opting of Independence Day
12:31PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
North Carolina proposes smokable hemp ban as demand grows
A proposed ban on smokable hemp is making its way through North Carolina's General Assembly after the product's popularity surged in the six months since the passage of the federal Hemp Farming Act of 2018.
11:49AM ( 5 hours ago )
Push to posthumously give black soldier D-Day Medal of Honor
A new push is under way to posthumously award an African American soldier the Medal of Honor for actions on D-Day
9:15AM ( 8 hours ago )
Appeals court: Trump can't use Pentagon cash for border wall
An appeals court has upheld a freeze on Pentagon money to build a border wall with Mexico, casting doubt on President Donald Trump's ability to make good on a signature campaign promise before the 2020 election
7:24AM ( 10 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
The Latest: Europe talking with Iran, dispute tool an option
A European diplomatic official says that talks at all levels with Iran are in progress
3:55PM ( 1 hour ago )
Christie's goes ahead with contested King Tut statue auction
Christie's auctions off 3,000-year-old King Tut sculpture for 4.7 million pounds, or $5.9 million, despite protests from the Egyptian government
2:21PM ( 3 hours ago )
Server image mystery in Georgia election security case
A lawyer for the Georgia's Secretary of State has told plaintiffs in a closely watched Georgia election integrity lawsuit that it never did subpoena the FBI _ despite telling a judge it would.
1:10PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
World shares steady after US benchmarks hit record highs
World shares steady after Wall Street rally pushes benchmarks to record highs
7:36AM ( 9 hours ago )
Greek election front runner keeps campaign unusually low-key
The AP has followed Kyriakos Mitsotakis on an exhaustive campaign tour ahead of Sunday's general election in Greece, as the conservative front runner avoids mass rallies that have been a staple of the country's politics for decades
7:18AM ( 10 hours ago )
Japan export curbs take effect as SKorean officials protest
Japanese controls on exports of key materials used to make semiconductors and displays have taken effect, as South Korean officials vow to fight back
6:41AM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Florida's most famous cheerleader, Mr. Two Bits, dies at 97
University of Florida's most famous cheerleader, the man better known as Mr. Two Bits, has died at age 97
5:00PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Gibraltar detains Syria-bound supertanker with Iranian oil
Authorities in Gibraltar say they have intercepted an Iranian supertanker believed to be breaching European Union sanctions by carrying a shipment of Tehran's crude oil to war-ravaged Syria
4:53PM ( 32 minutes ago )
We have a wiener! Joey Chestnut eats 71 hot dogs for title
It wasn't a year for records at Nathan's Famous annual July Fourth hot dog eating contest
4:52PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Harris clarifies stance on federally mandated school busing
Sen. Kamala Harris is clarifying her position on federally mandated school busing, saying it's only necessary in cases where local governments are actively opposing integration
4:50PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Putin asks Italy to help restoring ties with EU, meets Pope
Russian President Vladimir Putin has asked Italian Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte for help in improving relations between the European Union and Russia and stop sanctions on Moscow
4:40PM ( 45 minutes ago )