clearn.png
Tuesday October 22nd, 2019 10:22PM

Kentucky students lose appeal in chickenpox vaccination case

By The Associated Press

FRANKFORT, Ky. (AP) — More than two dozen Catholic school students and their parents have lost their initial appeal in challenging a Kentucky health department's efforts to control a chickenpox outbreak they claim infringed on their religious beliefs.

A three-judge panel of the Kentucky Court of Appeals sided with a trial court judge who ruled in April that the Northern Kentucky Health Department acted within its authority.

The health agency canceled extracurricular activities and later imposed a temporary ban on school attendance for unvaccinated students as the chickenpox outbreak spread.

"The commonwealth has a compelling interest in taking limited and temporary steps to control an outbreak of a vaccine-preventable disease," the appeals court panel said last Friday.

The ruling applied to the trial judge's refusal to impose a temporary injunction on behalf of the Catholic school students attending Our Lady of the Sacred Heart and Assumption Academy who — along with their parents — challenged the regional health department's actions.

Attorney Christopher Wiest, who represents the students and parents, said Monday he will appeal to the Kentucky Supreme Court. The appeals court ruling was "extraordinarily deferential to the trial court," he said, adding that the health department "targeted our clients for their religious beliefs and ... retaliated against protected First Amendment speech."

The health department's attorney, Jeff Mando, said Monday that the ruling "underscored the authority of local health departments to take reasonable measures to prevent the spread of infectious disease and protect public health." The appeals court "recognized that this case was never really about the exercise of religious freedom. It was about preventing and controlling the spread of a contagious disease," he said.

The students have cited religious objections to the chickenpox vaccine, claiming the original cells from which the vaccine was developed came from aborted fetus cells decades ago.

More than 80% of students at the two schools are not vaccinated against chickenpox. Their parents signed documents exercising their right to a religious exemption from vaccination.

When a chickenpox outbreak occurred earlier this year at the schools, the health department initially ordered that extracurricular activities be temporarily canceled. In March, as the illness spread, the health agency imposed the temporary ban on school attendance for unvaccinated students until 21 days after the onset of a rash for the last ill student or staff member.

The appeals court said there was no evidence that the health department required that parents have their children vaccinated.

The legal fight began when a student wasn't allowed to play basketball because he wasn't vaccinated for chickenpox. The other students and their parents joined the lawsuit.

Chickenpox is a contagious disease that causes a blister-like rash, itching, tiredness and fever, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. It recommends two doses of chickenpox vaccine for children, adolescents and adults who have never had chickenpox and were never vaccinated, according to its website.

Complications from chickenpox can include bacterial infections, pneumonia and encephalitis — inflammation of the brain, according to the CDC. Complications aren't common in healthy people with the disease, it says, but high risk groups for complications due to a serious case of chickenpox can include infants, adolescents, pregnant women and people with weakened immune systems.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Health, AP Health - Children's Health, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Hong Kong police clear protesters from legislature building
Hong Kong police carrying riot shields and firing tear gas have moved in to clear hundreds of pro-democracy protesters who had taken over the legislature's main building
1:50PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Naomi Osaka eliminated in 1st round at Wimbledon
After winning two straight Grand Slam titles, Naomi Osaka has now failed to reach the second week at the last two majors
1:40PM ( 22 minutes ago )
The Latest: AP Source: Avalanche land Donskoi on 4-year deal
The latest from NHL free agency
1:36PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Plane was sold months before it crashed in Texas, killing 10
Officials haven't released the identities of 10 people killed in a small plane crash at a suburban Dallas airport, but the aircraft's former owner says he sold it this year to a Texas-based company
1:19PM ( 42 minutes ago )
The Latest: Police begin clearing Hong Kong legislature
Police in Hong Kong have used tear gas to clear a crowd of protesters gathered outside the city's legislature after several hundred broke into the building and spray-painted pro-democracy slogans on the walls of the main chamber
1:17PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Iran breaches uranium stockpile limit set by nuclear deal
Iran has broken the limit set on its stockpile of low-enriched uranium by its 2015 nuclear deal with world powers
1:08PM ( 54 minutes ago )
AP National News
Closing arguments due in Navy SEAL court-martial
The court-martial of a Navy SEAL accused of committing murder and other crimes in Iraq has reached the closing arguments phase
11:03AM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Police say they will clear Hong Kong legislature
Hong Kong police have announced that they plan to clear Hong Kong's legislative building after it was taken over by protesters
11:02AM ( 2 hours ago )
Democrat Pete Buttigieg says he raised $24M in 2nd quarter
Democratic presidential hopeful Pete Buttigieg says he raised nearly $25 million in the second quarter, roughly quadrupling what he received in the first three months of this year
10:53AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Former Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder named Harvard fellow
Former Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder is headed to Harvard University to teach, study and write on subjects related to state and local government
12:08AM ( 13 hours ago )
Trump administration agrees to delay health care rule
Trump administration agrees to postpone implementing "conscience" rule that would protect health care workers who object to procedures on moral or religious grounds
6:08AM ( 1 day ago )
Flint hears from prosecutors who dropped water charges
Prosecutors who dropped charges against eight people in the Flint water scandal explain their decision in a public forum
9:05AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Health
Cold, cramped, filthy: Migrants describe border centers
Immigrant advocates are asking a federal judge to immediately require inspections and let doctors into border detention facilities where they say sleep-deprived, flu-stricken children are languishing in filthy conditions
8:15PM ( 3 days ago )
Child migrants decry illness, filth in border detention
Immigrant advocates are asking a federal judge to immediately require inspections and let doctors into border detention facilities where they say sleep-deprived, flu-stricken children are languishing in filthy conditions
5:02PM ( 3 days ago )
Doctors, lawyers portray dire conditions for child migrants
Immigrant advocates are asking a federal judge to immediately require inspections and let doctors into border detention facilities where they say sleep-deprived, flu-stricken children are languishing in filthy conditions
6:02AM ( 4 days ago )
AP Health - Children's Health
Iran's breach of uranium limits complicates nuclear deal
Efforts by world powers to preserve a 2015 landmark nuclear deal with Iran grew more complicated Monday with confirmation that Tehran had breached the pact's limitations on stockpiles of low-enriched uranium
1:01PM ( 1 hour ago )
Kaley Cuoco takes a dramatic turn after 'Big Bang Theory'
Kaley Cuoco is making a big move after wrapping 12 seasons with "The Big Bang Theory," with a production deal that includes a drama series
12:03PM ( 1 hour ago )
Stocks open July with a rally on US-China trade talks
Stocks rallied after the U.S. and China agree to another round of trade talks and a cease-fire on escalations
11:51AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Global shares rise on hopes for US-China trade negotiations
Global shares are higher on revived hopes for progress in trade negotiations between the U.S. and China after President Donald Trump met with China's Xi Jinping at the Group of 20 Summit in Japan
8:07AM ( 5 hours ago )
Japan resumes commercial whaling, seen as face-saving end
Japan is resuming commercial whaling for the first time in 31 years, meeting a long-cherished goal seen as a largely lost cause
2:48AM ( 11 hours ago )
Japan resumes commercial whaling, seen as face-saving end
Japan is resuming commercial whaling for the first time in 31 years, meeting a long-cherished goal seen as a largely lost cause
11:09PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Stocks mostly rise as investors push to break losing streak
Banks and health care companies are leading stocks broadly higher on Wall Street, placing the market on track to snap a four-day losing streak
3:09PM ( 3 days ago )
Future is in doubt for cheaper versions of biologic drugs
Sales of biosimilars, cheaper near-copies of pricey biologic drugs, have been so limited in the U.S. that their future is in doubt.
10:46AM ( 4 days ago )
AbbVie makes $63B bid for Botox maker Allergan
AbbVie is buying Botox maker Allergan in a deal valued around $63 billion
2:39PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Hong Kong police clear protesters from legislature building
Hong Kong police carrying riot shields and firing tear gas have moved in to clear hundreds of pro-democracy protesters who had taken over the legislature's main building
1:50PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Naomi Osaka eliminated in 1st round at Wimbledon
After winning two straight Grand Slam titles, Naomi Osaka has now failed to reach the second week at the last two majors
1:40PM ( 22 minutes ago )
The Latest: AP Source: Avalanche land Donskoi on 4-year deal
The latest from NHL free agency
1:36PM ( 26 minutes ago )
The Latest: Wizards deal Satoransky to Bulls, add Ish Smith
The Latest: Wizards deal Satoransky to Bulls, add Ish Smith, re-sign Bryant
1:33PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Ex-Cowboys player Brent arrested on assault, other charges
Former Dallas Cowboys player Josh Brent is being held on charges that include assaulting a public servant after authorities say officers found him intoxicated outside a Dallas-area fast food restaurant
1:23PM ( 38 minutes ago )