Sunday September 20th, 2020 11:12PM

Hoping for clarity, NCAA adjusts transfer waiver guidelines

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Following fresh concerns about the handling of athletes switching schools, the NCAA approved several adjustments Wednesday to the guidelines used to determine when waivers can be granted to transfers seeking immediate eligibility to play.

The adjustments approved by the Division I council will require schools requesting a waiver for an incoming transfer to provide more documentation to support the argument — and more detailed verification of athletes' claims about why they are leaving the original school.

"The overall goal of these adjustments was to provide the membership with as much information and knowledge and education as to what they need to be including in their waiver requests," said Brandy Hataway, NCAA director of academic and membership affairs. "I don't know if I'd say it's extra (information). A lot of it is information that was already being requested in the process. It's just now letting schools know on the front end rather than them submitting their requests and staff going back to them and saying we need x, y, z."

The move comes 14 months after a directive helped clear the way for immediate eligibility for all approved requests. Previously, the legislative relief available to athletes requesting a transfer waiver was a sixth year of eligibility. Only in cases where the student was a victim of egregious behavior by a school could immediate eligibility be granted.

Since the change, high-profile cases involving quarterbacks Shea Patterson of Michigan and Justin Fields of Ohio State have been decided in favor of the players. But the overall rate of approval of waiver requests during that time has been about the same as previous years.

What has gone up significantly is the number of waiver requests.

Attorney Tom Mars, who has worked on waivers for Patterson, Fields and other college athletes, said "massive, widespread confusion" about why waivers are granted has caused the uptick in requests. He said he gets two or three calls and email a day from parents and head coaches seeking assistance.

"More often than not, the parents and coaches asking for my help have already convinced themselves that the student-athlete they want me to represent should get a waiver just because some other player they read about was given one," Mars told AP in an email. "On top of that, some head coaches have been putting undue pressure on their compliance staff to pursue waiver requests that don't stand a chance of being granted."

The waiver process affects football and basketball players more often because those sports do not allow students to transfer without having to sit out a season at their new school. In most of the so-called Olympic sports, athletes are allowed to use a one-time exception to the so-called year-in-residence rule and play right away.

The year-in-residence rule was debated and examined anew by college sports administrators in 2017 and '18. A package of transfer rules reforms passed last year by the NCAA — separate from the change to the waiver process — left the status quo in place. Sitting out a season was still required for most transfers in high-profile sports.

Changing the waiver rules to allow the opportunity for more athletes to become immediately eligible seemed like a compromise move, but it has only led to more complaints about how the waivers are granted. There was recent criticism of the NCAA after the denial of a waiver to Illinois tight end Luke Ford, who says he transferred from Georgia to be closer to home because of ailing grandparents.

The latest changes focus on the four guidelines (out of 13) most frequently cited in waiver cases: Claims of athletes being run off a team by a coach; claims of egregious behavior by the original school; injured or ill immediate family member; and injury or illness to the athlete.

The changes could lead to fewer requests being granted since it appears to raise the bar on what is required by a school to make a case for immediate eligibility for an athlete. Hataway said the measure approved by the council was not meant to curb the number of approvals and a review of the guidelines is annually done by the committee.

"Most of what's in here is what was already being done," she said. "It's just putting it in writing so that way the members would have better clarification on the front end."


Follow Ralph D. Russo at and listen at


More AP college football: and

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, College Sports, AP Sports - College Football
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Breakouts, burns and zingers: What to watch in Dem debates
Breakouts, burns and zingers: What to watch for in the 1st 2020 Democratic presidential debates
12:12PM ( 1 minute ago )
Trump headlines faith community conference in Washington
President Donald Trump is delivering remarks in Washington to kick off a four-day faith conference that highlights top issues for evangelical voters, who are among his most loyal supporters and vital to his 2020 reelection bid
11:59AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Esper: Turkey faces sanctions if it buys Russian system
Acting U.S. Defense Secretary Mark Esper is making it clear to Turkey that it will face economic sanctions if it goes ahead with the purchase of a Russian missile defense system
11:59AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Athletic trainers: Coaches still influence health decisions
College athletic trainers: Coaches still influence player health decisions
11:19AM ( 54 minutes ago )
WIMBLEDON '19: How well do you know the grass-court major?
WIMBLEDON '19: See how much you know about the year's third Grand Slam tennis tournament by taking this AP quiz
10:39AM ( 1 hour ago )
Former UCLA gymnast Ohashi to make pro debut at Aurora Games
Former UCLA gymnast Katelyn Ohashi to perform in inaugural Aurora Games, a 6-day women's sports festival in Albany, NY
10:25AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
Longtime AP sports writer Ed Shearer dies at 82
Longtime Associated Press sports writer Ed Shearer has died at 82; covered Olympics, Super Bowl, World Series and Hank Aaron's 715th homer but best known as "SEC Seer"
6:12PM ( 1 day ago )
Jagger appears healthy as Rolling Stones rock Soldier Field
Mick Jagger appeared healthy and energetic as he ran and skipped along a narrow stage that jutted out into the crowd at Chicago's Soldier Field
1:47AM ( 4 days ago )
Patriots owner pledges $20 million to fight anti-Semitism
Israel honored New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft with the 2019 Genesis Prize for his philanthropy and commitment to combatting anti-Semitism
4:48PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Football
UConn board expected to finalize switch from AAC to Big East
The University of Connecticut's Board of Trustees is expected to accept an invitation to move most of the school's athletic teams from the American Athletic Conference to the Big East
2:03AM ( 10 hours ago )
Vandy rides Rocker to 4-1 win, forces a Game 3 vs. Michigan
Vanderbilt rides Kumar Rocker to 4-1 win, forces a Game 3 against Michigan in College World Series finals
12:05AM ( 12 hours ago )
UCLA's Rachel Garcia wins Collegiate Woman Athlete of Year
UCLA softball player Rachel Garcia earns Collegiate Woman Athlete of the Year; pitcher led team to NCAA title
9:08AM ( 1 day ago )
College Sports
'This isn't for everyone': A labor of love for football refs
Being a college football official has never been more difficult. How they do the job and why.
11:48AM ( 2 weeks ago )
Ex-Florida player charged with murder in wife's 2016 death
Authorities say a former University of Florida football player, Earl "Tony" Joiner, has been arrested and charged with killing his wife in a case dating to 2016
9:57PM ( 2 weeks ago )
APNewsBreak: Emails show chaos before Kansas player's death
Newly released emails show the chaos surrounding the heatstroke death of a 300-pound football player after practice at a Kansas community college
3:48PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Sports - College Football
Breakouts, burns and zingers: What to watch in Dem debates
Breakouts, burns and zingers: What to watch for in the 1st 2020 Democratic presidential debates
12:12PM ( 1 minute ago )
Judge accused of aiding wanted immigrant seeks pay restored
A lawyer for a judge charged with helping a defendant evade an immigration enforcement agent says it's unfair to take away her salary while she's fighting to clear her name in court
11:58AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Opposition leader: Ethiopia, AU join forces in Sudan efforts
Sudanese opposition figure: African Union, Ethiopia join forces to mediate between Sudan protesters, ruling generals
11:47AM ( 26 minutes ago )
US military says 2 service members killed in Afghanistan
Day after Pompeo visit to Kabul, US military says 2 service members killed in Afghanistan
11:43AM ( 30 minutes ago )
Democrats hope Mueller testimony will have 'profound impact'
The chairman of the House Judiciary Committee says he expects special counsel Robert Mueller to have "a profound impact" when he testifies before Congress on July 17
11:43AM ( 31 minutes ago )