Tuesday May 26th, 2020 9:45PM

Nebraska's AG is lone holdout in pursuing opioid cases

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LINCOLN, Neb. (AP) — Nebraska Attorney General Doug Peterson has fought prescription opioid abuse through public education campaigns, worked with lawmakers to tighten prescribing practices and even demanded documents from the maker of OxyContin. He has said the overdose crisis is ravaging families.

What Peterson hasn't done is pursued a lawsuit seeking to hold any opioid manufacturer, distributor or pharmaceutical company accountable. That leaves him standing alone among state attorneys general.

Every other state has sued, filed administrative charges or promised to sue the companies blamed for the national crisis, which played a role in the deaths of more than 390,000 Americans from 2000 through 2017. Peterson's decision to stand on the sidelines, at least so far, has frustrated some who want to make sure that Nebraska is in line to receive its fair share of money under any national settlement.

"We as a state have been great and our attorney general has been wonderful in recognizing the opioid problem," said state Sen. Sara Howard, of Omaha, whose sister died of an overdose in 2009. "It's really baffling to me why we haven't joined (the lawsuits)."

Howard sent a letter to Peterson last month urging him to join a group of some 1,500 opioid-related lawsuits from around the country that are consolidated under a federal judge in Ohio, but said she received no response. She said Nebraska has more work to do and that she would like to see the drug companies pay for treatment and prevention programs.

In a statement, Peterson spokeswoman Suzanne Gage said state lawyers talk regularly with private attorneys and other states that have filed opioid-related lawsuits. Gage would not rule out future legal action, but declined to say why the state has not yet proceeded with a claim of its own.

After a flurry of legal filings in recent weeks, 48 states have sued to recover damages they say are caused by the opioid crisis, while Michigan's attorney general has announced her intention to sue and has solicited bids from outside law firms to handle the case.

Nebraska stands out for another reason. Its opioid-related death rate in 2017 was the lowest of all states, with advocates saying addictions to alcohol and methamphetamine are more pervasive. Even so, tribal and local government officials say opioid abuse has led to a rise in law enforcement and public health costs.

That's among the reasons that led several of them to file their own lawsuits.

The Ponca Tribe last year sued Purdue Pharma, the Connecticut-based maker of OxyContin, and other pharmaceutical companies. The state's other three tribes quickly joined.

"We have a responsibility to make sure we're protecting the health of our citizens and being proactive wherever we can," said Larry Wright Jr., the Ponca tribe's chairman.

Five Nebraska counties — three rural and two in the Omaha area — also filed lawsuits, as did South Sioux City. Douglas County, which includes Omaha, claimed in its January lawsuit that the epidemic has saddled officials "with an enormous economic burden" and led to more crime and children in foster care.

Nationally, more than 2,000 state, local and tribal governments have sued Purdue.

Several Nebraska lawyers involved in the local opioid cases said they were surprised the attorney general's office hasn't yet filed a lawsuit to help the state recover the costs of health care, law enforcement and social services.

"From a lawyer's standpoint, it seems to me you'd be in a better position if you have a lawsuit on file and are engaged in the litigation process," said Ed Hotz, one of the attorneys representing Douglas County. "But maybe the attorney general has his reasons. I'm just not sure what they are."

The go-slow approach is in keeping with how Peterson, a Republican, handles his job. Now in his second term, the former assistant attorney general and deputy county counsel has always billed himself as a "workhorse, not a show horse."

While he has accepted campaign donations from pharmaceutical companies, including industry giants Pfizer and Eli Lilly, state campaign finance records show Peterson has received no money from Purdue Pharma or other major defendants in the opioid lawsuits.

Even without suing, Peterson has taken an active role in trying to address the problems caused by opioid addiction.

Last year, he worked with state lawmakers on new monitoring requirements for prescription drugs and restrictions on how much doctors could prescribe at one time. In 2017, he joined a coalition of 41 attorneys general that issued subpoenas to drugmakers and demanded Purdue turn over documents. His office helped launch a public awareness campaign that included television and internet ads.

"We are joining forces to work together in protecting Nebraskans from the harmful impacts of addiction and the ravages it can cause to families and futures," Peterson said at the time. "Nebraskans are not immune from this problem. We all need to work together and do something about it."

Peterson also played a major role on the Nebraska Coalition to Prevent Opioid Abuse, a working group that emphasized public awareness, increased training for health care providers and expanded use of naloxone, a potentially life-saving drug for opioid users who have overdosed.

But he also has tried to deter local governments from taking matters into their own hands. In an April 2018 letter to Nebraska's associations for cities and counties, Peterson said it was unnecessary for local governments to file their own lawsuits because the state would likely distribute settlement money to them if it received a share.

He did not elaborate on how Nebraska would collect the money, and Peterson's spokeswoman declined to comment further. In the letter, Peterson said his office was "actively engaged" in talks over how to hold opioid makers accountable and was still investigating the matter with other states.

It's not clear whether a government entity that does not sue could miss out on a nationwide settlement with the opioid industry or individual companies. States are being represented in the federal settlement talks in Ohio, regardless of whether they filed claims, but it's not certain that there eventually will be a settlement. How that money would be distributed also would be subject to negotiations.

Paul Hanly, whose firm represents about 250 local governments in opioid litigation, said many governments that initially were reluctant to sue now realize there is no downside to taking action. The number of court filings from states has surged since last year, and in March Purdue reached a $270 million settlement with Oklahoma.

"I think the Oklahoma settlement has got attorneys general saying, 'I'd better get on board here,'" he said.


Mulvihill reported from Cherry Hill, New Jersey.


Follow Grant Schulte at and Mulvihill at

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: David Ortiz making 'progress' after shooting
The wife of former Red Sox star David Ortiz says her husband is recuperating at a hospital in Boston after being shot at a bar in his native Dominican Republic
1:40PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Nebraska's AG is lone holdout in pursuing opioid cases
Nebraska's attorney general has taken a number of actions to combat the opioid addiction crisis, but so far has decided against suing the main players in the opioid industry
1:38PM ( 6 minutes ago )
The Latest: Merkel urges 'peaceful solutions' in Gulf crisis
The Latest: Merkel urges 'peaceful solutions' in Gulf crisis, discusses Iran with Abu Dhabi crown prince
1:38PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
White House asserts executive privilege in census fight
Justice Department says Trump is asserting executive privilege over documents in fight over census question
1:16PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Japan premier warns US, Iran 'accidental conflict' possible
Japan's premier in Tehran warns an 'accidental conflict' possible between Iran and US
1:10PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Watchdog: Abuse and neglect in nursing facilities unreported
Watchdog: Nursing facilities have failed to report serious cases of potential abuse and neglect of Medicare patients
1:09PM ( 35 minutes ago )
AP National News
The Latest: Saudi coalition hits back at Iran-allied Houthis
The Latest: Yemeni officials say that the Saudi-led coalition has launched airstrikes against a Houthi rebel stronghold in the country's north
12:30PM ( 1 hour ago )
Tessa Thompson is OK with the 'Men in Black' title, for now
The "Men in Black" franchise has a new recruit who isn't a man, but actress Tessa Thompson is fine with keeping the masculine-centered film title _ for now
12:24PM ( 1 hour ago )
Hundreds detained in Moscow protest over journalist's case
Hundreds were detained in Moscow as they marched to protest actions by police who arrested an investigative journalist on drug charges that later were dropped when the government admitted there was no evidence he committed a crime
12:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
Top General short headlines
GOP pushes back on cash governor seeks for voting machines
Republican lawmakers aren't committing to the money sought by Democratic Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf to back up his demand that counties replace their voting machines by 2020
12:57PM ( 47 minutes ago )
UK House of Commons rejects bid to rule out no-deal Brexit
British lawmakers have failed in their latest attempt to ensure the U.K. can't leave the European Union without a divorce deal
12:40PM ( 1 hour ago )
Kamala Harris proposes executive orders on immigration
California Sen. Kamala Harris says if elected president, she will pursue a series of executive actions to make it easier for immigrants brought to the United States illegally as children to apply for green cards
11:57AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Hong Kong restaurant owner strikes to support protests
'Hoping to find a breath of freedom': Hong Kong restaurant owner strikes to support protests
9:37AM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: HK leader doesn't say if she will withdraw bill
Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam has spoken tearfully about the sacrifices she has made for the city in response to questions about whether she is "selling out" the territory by trying to push through a controversial extradition bill
9:17AM ( 4 hours ago )
In opioid lawsuits, 1 state opts to stay on the sidelines
The nation's opioid addiction crisis has prompted every state except one to file claims or promise to sue drugmakers, distributors or pharmaceutical companies
9:08AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
EU asks Italy to better explain debt or face legal action
European Economy Commissioner Pierre Moscovici is urging Italy to quickly provide any new information it might have to explain its high debt levels and or face the prospect of imminent legal action
1:13PM ( 31 minutes ago )
France pledges to reform economy, boost competitiveness
France's prime minister says the government of President Emmanuel Macron plans to keep reforming the economy and will look at unemployment benefits, the pension system and tax cuts for middle-class workers
12:28PM ( 1 hour ago )
Agency: Safeguards failed in fire that killed 5 at gas well
A federal report says an explosion and fire that killed five workers at a southeastern Oklahoma natural gas well last year was caused by the failure of blowout prevention devices and other factors
12:25PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Proxy companies advise shareholders against Nissan's Saikawa
Proxy companies advise shareholders against re-appointment of Nissan CEO Saikawa
4:48AM ( 8 hours ago )
Building materials helped spread Grenfell fire, US suit says
A lawsuit filed in the United States says faulty building materials helped spread a devastating fire at London's Grenfell Tower in 2017
9:28PM ( 16 hours ago )
Trump orders simpler path for genetically engineered food
President Trump has signed an executive order directing federal agencies to simplify the regulatory process for genetically engineered plants and animals
7:13PM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
The Latest: David Ortiz making 'progress' after shooting
The wife of former Red Sox star David Ortiz says her husband is recuperating at a hospital in Boston after being shot at a bar in his native Dominican Republic
1:40PM ( 4 minutes ago )
The Latest: Merkel urges 'peaceful solutions' in Gulf crisis
The Latest: Merkel urges 'peaceful solutions' in Gulf crisis, discusses Iran with Abu Dhabi crown prince
1:38PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Hong Kong protesters vow to keep fighting extradition law
Hong Kong students and civil rights activists vowed to keep protesting a proposed extradition bill that has become a lightning rod for concerns over greater Chinese control and erosion of civil liberties in the former British colony
1:31PM ( 13 minutes ago )
5-year-old dies of Ebola as outbreak crosses Congo border
5-year-old boy dies of Ebola as 2nd deadliest outbreak in history spreads out of Congo
1:30PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Federal prosecutors detail Chinese scholar's brutal death
Federal prosecutors detail Chinese scholar's brutal death in opening statements of a federal death-penalty trial of a former University of Illinois graduate student
1:25PM ( 19 minutes ago )