clearn.png
Thursday June 27th, 2019 4:54AM

Tech on trial: House mulls antitrust help for news industry

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Members of both parties on Tuesday suggested legislation may be necessary for the financially-struggling U.S. news industry as lawmakers began a bipartisan investigation into the market dominance of Silicon Valley companies.

At a hearing of the House Judiciary Committee's antitrust panel, news media associations accused the tech companies of jeopardizing the news industry's economic survival by putting out news content on their platforms without fairly compensating them for it.

"This is the first significant antitrust investigation undertaken by Congress in decades," Rep. David Cicilline, D-R.I., the subcommittee's chairman, said at the start of the hearing. The investigation is long overdue, he said, and Congress must determine whether the antitrust laws "are equipped for the competition problems of our modern economy."

Cicilline noted the steep layoffs in the news industry in recent years, saying the dominant position of the online platforms in the advertising market has created "an economic catastrophe for news publishers, forcing them to cut back on their investments in quality journalism." At the same time, he said, tech platforms that are gateways to news online "have operated with virtual immunity from the antitrust laws."

As a partial solution, Cicilline proposed legislation to establish an antitrust exemption that would allow news companies to band together to negotiate revenue rates with big tech platforms. He called it "a life support measure, not the remedy for long-term health" of the news business.

The senior Republican on the full committee, Rep. Doug Collins of Georgia, said he backs Cicilline's proposal. Addressing the broader question of antitrust, however, he said, "Big is not necessarily bad," adding that lawmakers need to proceed cautiously.

The head of an association that represents technology and telecom companies said the government scrutiny of successful companies is appropriate. However, an antitrust exemption for the news industry wouldn't solve the problem, said Matt Schruer, vice president of the Computer and Communications Industry Association.

Before the internet, "news publishers received an exemption to deal with previous competitors like radio and TV news (and they) have not worked," Schruer said. "The results were fewer choices for readers and less competition among news outlets."

Stepping ahead of the criticism, Google's vice president of news Richard Gringas said the company has "worked for many years to be a collaborative and supportive technology and advertising partner to the news industry."

"Every month, Google News and Google Search drive over 10 billion clicks to publishers' websites, which drive subscriptions and significant ad revenue," he said in a statement Tuesday.

In a Capitol steeped in partisanship, inflamed by special counsel Robert Mueller's report and Democrats' intensifying probes of President Donald Trump, Congress' new investigation of tech market power stands out. Not only is it bipartisan, but it's also the first such review by Congress of a sector that for more than a decade has enjoyed haloed status and a light touch from federal regulators.

With regulators at the Justice Department and Federal Trade Commission apparently pursuing antitrust investigations of Facebook, Google, Apple and Amazon, and several state attorneys general exploring bipartisan action of their own, the tech industry finds itself in a precarious moment — with the dreaded M-word increasingly used to describe their way of doing business. Cicilline has flatly called them monopolies.

Politicians on the left and right have differing gripes about the tech giants. Some complain of aggressive conduct that squashes competition. Others perceive a political bias or tolerance of extremist content. Still others are upset by the industry's harvesting of personal data.

Several Democratic presidential candidates think they have the solution: breaking up the companies on antitrust grounds. Cicilline has called that "a last resort," but the idea has currency with both major political parties, including at the White House.

Trump noted the huge fines imposed by European regulators on the biggest tech companies.

"We are going to be looking at them differently," he said in an interview Monday on CNBC.

"We should be doing what (the Europeans) are doing," Trump said. "Obviously, there is something going on in terms of monopoly."

The tech giants have mostly declined to comment on the antitrust investigations.

Google has said that scrutiny from lawmakers and regulators "often improves our products and the policies that govern them," and that in some areas, such as data protection, laws need to be updated.

Facebook executives have been calling broadly for regulation while explicitly rejecting the idea of breaking up "a successful American company." CEO Mark Zuckerberg has called for new rules in four areas: harmful content, election integrity, privacy and data portability.

When Democratic presidential contender Sen. Elizabeth Warren tweeted in April that tech giants like Amazon should be broken up, Amazon tweeted back, "Walmart is much larger."

And Apple has countered a legal challenge to its management of the App Store by saying it "will prevail when the facts are presented and the App Store is not a monopoly by any metric."

In hearings and closed-door work over coming months, lawmakers in the House aim to unpeel the complex onion of the tech industry's dominance. They are expected to summon the chief executives of the major companies to appear before the panel. Not showing up, as some CEOs have done in the past, is unlikely to be tolerated.

"There could be something really useful" to emerge as legislation, said Allen Grunes, who led merger investigations at the Justice Department as an antitrust attorney.

Lawmakers could address, for example, the galloping acquisition of small companies by the tech giants or craft an update of antitrust laws to apply better to complex tech behemoths, suggested Grunes, a co-founder and attorney at the Konkurrenz Group in Washington.

"It's not illegal to be a monopoly," he said. "But it's wrong for someone at the top of the hill to kick the people off who are trying to climb it."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Tariff deal gives momentum to 'Remain-in-Mexico' policy
Centerpiece of U.S.-Mexico deal on immigration calls for rapid expansion of a new policy that makes Central American asylum seekers wait in Mexico while their cases wind through U.S. immigration courts.
4:46PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Tech on trial: House mulls antitrust help for news industry
A key House committee on Tuesday launched its bipartisan investigation into the market dominance of Silicon Valley's biggest names, with a look at the impact of the tech giants' platforms on the news industry
4:42PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Ex-slugger David Ortiz had counted on fans to protect him
Beloved in his hometown in the Dominican Republic, former Boston Red Sox David Ortíz traveled the dangerous streets of Santo Domingo with little or no security, trusting in his fans to protect him
4:36PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Mom of slain children asks mercy for ex-husband in his trial
The mother of five children who were killed by their father has stunned a South Carolina courtroom by asking the jury to not sentence her ex-husband to death
4:15PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Pilot killed in crash wasn't certified to fly in bad weather
Investigators are working to determine what caused a helicopter to crash into the roof of a midtown Manhattan skyscraper
4:02PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Holocaust Museum digitizing letters from Anne Frank's father
A Massachusetts man who struck a friendship with Anne Frank's father has donated a trove of letters and mementos he received from Otto Frank to the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum for the 90th anniversary of the young Holocaust victim's birth
3:52PM ( 56 minutes ago )
AP National News
Building materials helped spread Grenfell fire, US suit says
A lawsuit filed in the U.S. says faulty building materials helped spread a devastating fire at London's Grenfell Tower in 2017
2:58PM ( 1 hour ago )
As bishops gather, prosecutors step up scrutiny of church
Attorneys general eyeing U.S. church authorities in growing clergy abuse investigations
2:42PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Biden calls Trump a 'threat to our core values'
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden is blasting President Trump for his behavior during the D-Day commemoration in Europe last week, including a tweet attacking singer and Broadway star Bette Midler
2:36PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Rep. Omar filed joint tax returns before she married husband
Minnesota campaign finance officials say that U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar filed joint tax returns with her current husband years before they were legally married and at a time when she was married to another man
3:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump, Biden trade insults during dueling Iowa visits
Biden, Trump swap insults in dueling visits to Iowa
3:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
Former Bush, Reagan EPA heads caution on Trump rollbacks
Former Environmental Protection Agency heads from three Republican administrations are telling lawmakers they're concerned about the way the Trump administration is rolling back environmental protections
2:53PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Hong Kong political strife continues with protests, strikes
Protesters opposed to legislation in Hong Kong that would allow criminal suspects to be extradited to mainland China are gathering outside the Chinese territory's legislature amid plans for further demonstrations and strike actions
11:53AM ( 4 hours ago )
Tech on trial: House panel begins review of market power
The House Judiciary Committee is set to launch its probe into the market dominance of Silicon Valley's biggest names, starting with a look at the impact of the giants' platforms on news outlets.
11:42AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Protesters against Hong Kong legislation gather
Protesters in Hong Kong opposed to legislation that would allow criminal suspects to be extradited to mainland China are gathering outside the territory's legislature amid plans for further demonstrations and strike actions
11:38AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Ratings show no need to about HBO post-'Game of Thrones'
Ratings for 'Big Little Lies' and 'Chernobyl' show there's no need to worry about HBO post-'Game of Thrones'
4:21PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Don't worry about HBO post-'Game of Thrones'
HBO always faces questions about what it will do when a popular series ends, and it happened again this year following 'Game of Thrones.'
4:16PM ( 32 minutes ago )
AP source: Grizzlies hire Taylor Jenkins as new head coach
Person with knowledge of the decision says the Memphis Grizzlies have hired Milwaukee Bucks assistant Taylor Jenkins to be the team's next head coach
3:33PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
States sue to stop $26.5 billion Sprint-T-Mobile deal
A group of state attorneys general led by New York and California are filing a lawsuit to block T-Mobile's $26.5 billion bid for Sprint, citing consumer harm.
12:44PM ( 4 hours ago )
10 states sue to stop $26.5 billion Sprint-T-Mobile deal
A group of 10 state attorneys general led by New York and California are filing a lawsuit to block T-Mobile's $26.5 billion bid for Sprint, citing consumer harm.
12:37PM ( 4 hours ago )
Stocks fizzle and flatten out at midday after early gains
U.S. stocks gave up early gains and fizzled in midday trading after technology and industrial companies headed lower
12:31PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
US says Egypt, Jordan and Morocco to attend peace workshop
A White House official says that Egypt, Jordan and Morocco have confirmed their attendance at U.S. conference this month in Bahrain, where the administration will unveil the economic portion of its plan for Mideast peace
12:52PM ( 3 hours ago )
Biden assailing Trump on trade as both come to Iowa
Biden is assailing Trump on trade and branding him an 'existential threat to America' as both come to Iowa
12:08PM ( 4 hours ago )
Trump and Biden head to Iowa in a potential 2020 preview
President Donald Trump and Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden to visit Iowa, where Biden plans to criticize Trump's economic policy
10:08AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Ex-slugger David Ortiz had counted on fans to protect him
Beloved in his hometown in the Dominican Republic, former Boston Red Sox David Ortíz traveled the dangerous streets of Santo Domingo with little or no security, trusting in his fans to protect him
4:36PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Student convicted of campus attack accused in 2 more cases
A student who remained at West Virginia's Marshall University despite a conviction for a 2016 attack against a female student on campus is now facing charges of assaulting two more women
4:35PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Southern Baptists meet; sex abuse crisis tops agenda
The Southern Baptist Convention opens a national meeting expected to be dominated by discussion of a large-scale sex-abuse crisis
4:33PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Unanimous vote OKs security deal for men's-only retreat
A secretive men's-only retreat hosted by an elite club will pay for security protection from a Northern California county after a majority of women on the board of supervisors reluctantly approved a $151,000 contract.
4:33PM ( 15 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump briefed on Nebraska flood damage
President Donald Trump is getting briefed on Midwestern flood damage as he visits Nebraska prior to participating in political events in Iowa
4:31PM ( 17 minutes ago )