clearn.png
Thursday June 27th, 2019 4:44AM

States sue to stop $26.5 billion Sprint-T-Mobile deal

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — A group of state attorneys general led by New York and California filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday to block T-Mobile's $26.5 billion bid for Sprint, citing consumer harm.

The state attorneys general said the promised benefits, such as better networks in rural areas and faster service overall, cannot be verified, while eliminating a major wireless company will immediately harm consumers by reducing competition and driving up prices for cellphone service.

New York Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement that combining the two companies would reduce access to affordable, reliable wireless service nationwide and would particularly affect lower-income and minority communities in New York and other urban areas.

Other attorneys general joining Tuesday's lawsuit are from Colorado, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Maryland, Michigan, Mississippi, Virginia and Wisconsin. All 10 attorneys general are Democrats. The lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in New York.

The lawsuit is an unusual step by state officials ahead of a decision by federal antitrust authorities. The Justice Department's decision is pending. The Republican majority of the Federal Communications Commission supports the deal , though the agency has yet to vote.

Too many "mega mergers have sailed through the governmental approval process," so it's up to the states to "step up," James said at a news conference.

"There's no rule or regulation that we have to wait for the DOJ," she said. She added the attorneys general will "continue to litigate whether the DOJ approves the merger or not."

Diana Moss, the president of the American Antitrust Institute and an advocate for tougher antitrust enforcement, said the states' lawsuit could signal to other potential merger partners that there would be tougher enforcement from states even if the federal government permitted deals to go through.

James said Tuesday that her office's renewed focus on mergers and anti-competitiveness goes beyond the tech industry, though she did not elaborate.

T-Mobile and Sprint have argued that they need to bulk up to upgrade to a fast, powerful "5G" mobile network that competes with Verizon and AT&T. The companies are appealing to President Donald Trump's desire for the U.S. to "win" a global 5G race.

Consumer advocates, labor unions and many Democratic lawmakers worry that the deal could mean job cuts, higher wireless prices and a hit to the rural cellphone market.

Amanda Wait, an antitrust lawyer and former Federal Trade Commission lawyer, said states are acting because they disagree with what they have seen the federal government doing.

"They see the FCC accepting certain remedies and concessions that don't, in their minds, solve the problem," she said.

T-Mobile declined comment. Sprint and the Justice Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

One famous example of when the states and federal government diverged on a big antitrust case was in the fight against Microsoft, although that was not a merger case. Several states dissented from the Justice Department's settlement roughly 20 years ago, pushing for tougher sanctions to curtail Microsoft's ability to use its dominance in the Windows operating system to thwart competition in other technologies.

More recently, in the Bayer-Monsanto agribusiness merger, five states last year criticized the federal government's approval.

T-Mobile and Sprint previously tried to combine during the Obama administration but regulators rebuffed them. They resumed talks on combining once Trump took office, hoping for more industry-friendly regulators.

T-Mobile has a reputation for consumer-friendly changes to the cellphone industry. T-Mobile and Sprint led the return of unlimited-data cellphone plans, for example.

T-Mobile, trying to reassure critics, promised the FCC it would build out a 5G network and invest in rural broadband on a specific timeframe or pay penalties. It also promised to sell off Sprint's prepaid Boost Mobile brand and keep price increases on hold for three years.

That was enough for FCC Chairman Ajit Pai to back the deal. The other two Republican commissioners indicated they would join him.

But public-interest advocates said these conditions did not address concerns about higher prices and reduced competition— and would be difficult for regulators to enforce.

The Justice Department evaluates deals using stricter criteria than the FCC's "public interest" standard — namely whether they harm competition and raise prices for consumers. Staff attorneys at DOJ have reportedly told the companies they won't approve the deal as proposed, but the ultimate decision lies with Makan Delrahim, the top antitrust official who is a political appointee.

The state attorneys general said in Tuesday's lawsuit that combining Sprint and T-Mobile would make the industry as a whole — Verizon and AT&T, too — less likely to offer plans and services that consumers like. And they say the companies have already been working to roll out 5G and don't need to combine to do so.

Japanese tech conglomerate SoftBank owns Sprint, while Germany's Deutsche Telekom owns T-Mobile.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
GOP's Amash, impeachment supporter, quits conservative group
Lone Republican calling for President Donald Trump's impeachment has quit an influential caucus of House conservatives
12:44PM ( 13 minutes ago )
States sue to stop $26.5 billion Sprint-T-Mobile deal
A group of state attorneys general led by New York and California are filing a lawsuit to block T-Mobile's $26.5 billion bid for Sprint, citing consumer harm.
12:44PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Feisty Virginia primaries closely watched for national trend
Virginia's highly charged legislative primary elections are being closely watched as a possible political barometer for 2020 presidential election year
12:39PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Biden assailing Trump on trade as both come to Iowa
Biden is assailing Trump on trade and branding him an 'existential threat to America' as both come to Iowa
12:08PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Building materials helped spread Grenfell fire, US suit says
A lawsuit filed in the U.S. says faulty building materials helped spread a devastating fire at London's Grenfell Tower in 2017
12:04PM ( 53 minutes ago )
Amazon to shut down US restaurant delivery service
Amazon is closing its U.S. restaurant delivery service, a 4-year-old business that failed to take off amid fierce competition from Uber Eats, Door Dash and others
11:55AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Detained US resident freed by Iran arrives in native Lebanon
Beirut official: US resident and Lebanese businessman imprisoned for years in Iran freed, on his way back to his native Lebanon
10:41AM ( 2 hours ago )
China telecom giant Huawei hints US pressure hurting sales
China telecom giant Huawei hints US pressure hurting global expansion
1:51AM ( 11 hours ago )
US stocks climb after US suspends tariffs on Mexican goods
Technology companies and banks helped power stocks higher on Wall Street Monday as investors welcomed news that the U.S. and Mexico averted a trade war and potentially damaging tariffs
5:05PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
GOP's Amash, impeachment supporter, quits conservative group
Lone Republican calling for President Donald Trump's impeachment has quit an influential caucus of House conservatives
12:44PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Feisty Virginia primaries closely watched for national trend
Virginia's highly charged legislative primary elections are being closely watched as a possible political barometer for 2020 presidential election year
12:39PM ( 18 minutes ago )
David Ortiz undergoes more surgery in Boston after shooting
Former Red Sox slugger David Ortiz is recovering from exploratory surgery in Boston as investigators in his native Dominican Republic try to figure out who shot him and why
12:39PM ( 18 minutes ago )
10 states sue to stop $26.5 billion Sprint-T-Mobile deal
A group of 10 state attorneys general led by New York and California are filing a lawsuit to block T-Mobile's $26.5 billion bid for Sprint, citing consumer harm.
12:37PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Stocks fizzle and flatten out at midday after early gains
U.S. stocks gave up early gains and fizzled in midday trading after technology and industrial companies headed lower
12:31PM ( 26 minutes ago )