Friday December 6th, 2019 1:08AM

Scientists feel chill of crackdown on fetal tissue research

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — To save babies from brain-damaging birth defects, University of Pittsburgh scientist Carolyn Coyne studies placentas from fetuses that otherwise would be discarded — and she's worried this kind of research is headed for the chopping block.

The Trump administration is cracking down on fetal tissue research , with new hurdles for government-funded scientists around the country who call the special cells vital for fighting a range of health threats. Already, the administration has shut down one university's work using fetal tissue to test HIV treatments, and is ending other fetal tissue research at the National Institutes of Health.

"I knew this was something that's going to trickle down to the rest of us," said Coyne. She uses the placenta, which people may not think of as fetal tissue but technically is classified as such because the fetus produced it, to study how viruses such as Zika get past that protective barrier early in pregnancy.

"It seems to me what we're moving toward is a ban," she added. If so, when it comes to unraveling what happens in pregnancy and fetal development, "we're going to stay ignorant to a lot of things."

Different types of tissue left over from elective abortions have been used in scientific research for decades, and the work has been credited with leading to lifesaving vaccines and other advances. Under orders from President Donald Trump, the Health and Human Services Department abruptly announced on Wednesday the new restrictions on taxpayer-funded research, but not privately funded work.

Aside from the cancellation of an HIV-related project at the University of California, San Francisco, university-led projects that are funded by the NIH — estimated to be fewer than 200 — aren't affected right away.

But as researchers seek to renew their funding or propose new studies, HHS said it will have to pass an extra layer of review, beyond today's strict scientific scrutiny. Each project will have a federal ethics board appointed to recommend whether NIH should grant the money.

HHS hasn't offered details but under the law authorizing the review process, that board must include not just biomedical experts but a theologian, and the nation's health secretary can overrule its advice.

"I predict over time we will see a slow and steady elimination of federal funding for research that uses fetal tissue, regardless of how necessary it is," said University of Wisconsin law professor Alta Charo, a nationally recognized bioethics expert.

Necessity is the crux of a fierce debate between abortion foes and scientists about whether there are alternatives to fetal tissue for research.

Zika offers a glimpse at the difficulty. Somehow, the Zika virus can sneak from the mother's bloodstream across the placenta, which protects and nourishes the fetus, and target the fetus' brain. It's something researchers hope to learn to block.

Studying the placentas of small animals or even monkeys isn't a substitute because they differ from the human organ, said Emory University researcher Mehul Suthar. For example, the specific type of placental cell where Zika can lurk in humans isn't thought to be present in mouse placentas.

And because the placenta continually changes as the fetus that created it grows, first-trimester tissue may show a very different vulnerability than a placenta that's expelled during full-term birth, when it's no longer defined as fetal tissue but as medical waste.

Suthar recently submitted a new grant application to study first- and second-trimester placental tissue, and is worried about its fate under the still uncertain ethics provision.

It "sounds a bit murky as to what the impact could be," he said. It could be small, "or it could be an outright ban on what we're doing."

Anti-abortion groups argue there are alternatives, such as stem cells, growing organ-like clumps of cells in lab dishes, or using tissue taken from newborns as they have heart surgery.

Indeed, NIH is funding a $20 million program to research alternatives to fetal tissue and to prove whether they work as well.

"Taxpayer funding ought to go to promote alternatives that are already being used in the production of treatments, vaccines and medicines, and to expand approaches that do not depend on the destruction of unborn children," said Mallory Quigley of the Susan B. Anthony List, which works to elect anti-abortion candidates to public office.

But dozens of medical and science organizations have told HHS there is no substitute for fetal tissue in studying certain — not all — health disorders, such as HIV, Zika, Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, spinal cord injury, and a variety of eye diseases.

To Pittsburgh's Coyne, part of the political debate is a "completely unsubstantiated belief that not allowing research and science is going to prevent or stop abortions, which is not the case."

Medical research using fetal tissue won't stop but will move to other countries, said Charo, who advised the Obama administration. The United Kingdom, Australia, Singapore and China are among the countries using fetal tissue to seek breakthroughs.

"Other countries work with this in a regulated fashion and they will continue to outstrip us," she said. "We have allowed patients' interests to become collateral damage in the abortion wars."


Ritter reported from New York.


The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Scientists feel chill of crackdown on fetal tissue research
Scientists working to save children from devastating birth defects are feeling the chill of the Trump administration's new crackdown on fetal tissue research.
9:40AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Pomp, parade marks Queen Elizabeth II's official birthday
Queen Elizabeth II is marking her official birthday with the Trooping the Color parade, a grand occasion and demonstration of Britain's ability to deploy pomp and circumstance of the highest order
9:34AM ( 13 minutes ago )
The Latest: Thiem-Djokovic semifinal resumes after rain
The Latest on the French Open: The semifinal between Novak Djokovic and Dominic Thiem has resumed after a rain delay of about an hour
9:30AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
With Mexico deal done, US urges China to resume trade talks
One down, still others to go, as US urges China to resume trade talks where negotiations left off
7:41AM ( 2 hours ago )
Olivia Colman gets royal honor ahead of debut in 'The Crown'
Academy Award-winning actress Olivia Colman has been honored by Queen Elizabeth II _ the monarch she is about to play on television in "The Crown."
7:00AM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Pompeo hails Mexico's work to avert tariffs
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is thanking his Mexican counterpart for his "hard work" after the two nations reached an agreement Friday to try to stem the flow of Central American migrants into the United States
6:55AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Leonard, Raptors move within victory of first championship
Kawhi Leonard's hot hand is sending the Raptors home to Toronto on the cusp of a startling upset for Canada
12:39AM ( 9 hours ago )
Shipping from Mexico rushed before tariff threat lifted
Companies have been rushing to ship as many goods as possible out of Mexico to get ahead of possible tariffs threatened by President Donald Trump
12:19AM ( 9 hours ago )
Trump says US, Mexico reach agreement to prevent tariffs
President Donald Trump says he has suspended plans to impose tariffs on Mexico
12:13AM ( 9 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
FDA: 'Influencers' promoted vaping without suitable warnings
The Food and Drug Administration is sending warnings to companies that inappropriately pushed their e-cigarette formulas online through paid social media influencers on Facebook, Twitter and other websites
3:05PM ( 18 hours ago )
Joe Biden reverses position on federal dollars for abortions
Democratic presidential hopeful Joe Biden says he can no longer support a congressional ban on using federal health care money to pay for abortions
9:01AM ( 1 day ago )
Lack of abortion access troubles Guam's 1st female governor
The first female governor of Guam says she's concerned that a lack of abortion access in the U.S. territory means women will be forced to seek illegal or dangerous alternatives
1:03AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Health
Trump halts fetal tissue research by government scientists
The Trump administration will no longer allow government scientists to conduct medical research using human fetal tissue
9:03PM ( 2 days ago )
Missouri official stresses safety over abortion access
Access for women seeking an abortion is important, but patient safety takes priority, Missouri's health department director said Wednesday
6:26PM ( 2 days ago )
Trump ends fetal tissue research by federal scientists
In victory for abortion foes, White House ends fetal tissue research by federal scientists
3:07PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Pomp, parade marks Queen Elizabeth II's official birthday
Queen Elizabeth II is marking her official birthday with the Trooping the Color parade, a grand occasion and demonstration of Britain's ability to deploy pomp and circumstance of the highest order
9:34AM ( 13 minutes ago )
The Latest: Thiem-Djokovic semifinal resumes after rain
The Latest on the French Open: The semifinal between Novak Djokovic and Dominic Thiem has resumed after a rain delay of about an hour
9:30AM ( 17 minutes ago )
The Latest: Canada's Fernandez wins French Open girls' title
The Latest on the French Open: Leylah Annie Fernandez of Canada has won the girls singles title
9:19AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Russian journalist in Moscow police custody sent to hospital
A prominent investigative journalist who was detained on drug-dealing charges in Russia is being taken to the hospital after complaining of feeling poorly in police custody
8:58AM ( 50 minutes ago )
WWCup: Nearly 11 million TV viewers watch France's opener
World Cup fever has gripped the nation after nearly 11 million people tuned in for France's opening match South Korea on Friday night
8:57AM ( 50 minutes ago )